Chapter 40 Exercises — Watching Football Like a Coordinator

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension (film study and research)

The Outlaws, Sentinels, Pioneers, Forge, Stallions, and every player and game named here are fictional composites. Situations marked hypothetical are invented for practice. Selected answers are in Appendix J.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Name the four questions of the coordinator's viewing loop, in order. Why does "did it work?" come last, and inside the fourth question rather than as its own?

A2. List the seven items of the pre-snap checklist (situation plus six). Which one does Lyle count before the box, and why does the order matter?

A3. Define MOFO and MOFC. Then explain, in one sentence, what "the shell is not the coverage" means for a viewer.

A4. What does the offensive line's first step tell you? Give the first-step signature of zone, gap, dropback pass, play-action, and screen.

A5. Name the four freeze-frames and the question you ask at each. Which one does Lyle say "almost nobody uses," and what would it have shown on the Game 3 interception?

A6. Match each question to the camera angle that answers it best (broadcast, All-22, or end zone): (a) the score and the down; (b) whether the 3-technique slanted; (c) whether the boundary corner bailed at the snap; (d) where the quarterback's eyes went at the mesh; (e) how deep the safeties were.

A7. Define resulting and hindsight bias. Then describe the 34-second fence and the three things you write at it.

A8. What do the result-column letters C, R, and X stand for? Give one example of each from the Outlaws' season.

A9. State Marisol's threshold for calling something a "tell," and the two other rules that go with it before you write a tendency on a page.

A10. Lyle says film from the outside is a "hypothesis generator." Name four things you can't see from the outside, and say what you write instead of a verdict for each.

A11. Explain the "two receipts" rule in your own words, and say why a viewer who grades one play at a time can't see it.

A12. What are the four boxes of the process/result grid? Which two does Lyle say teach the most, and why does the broadcast rarely put a play in either of them?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Pre-snap: 11 personnel, 2x2, the tight end attached right. The defense shows two high safeties at twelve yards, a nickel over the left slot with outside leverage, four down linemen, and two linebackers, the weak-side one stacked over the left B gap. Count the box. Name the defender most likely to be in conflict on an inside-zone RPO with a slant by the left slot, and say why.

B2. The line's first step: the right guard and right tackle block down to their left; the left guard pulls to the right and turns up through the hole; the fullback kicks out the end man on the right. Name the family and the play. Which block would you check first if it lost a yard?

B3. Read this diagram and name the coverage, the box count, and the likely offensive answer the Outlaws had ready for it.

PRE-SNAP: 3rd-and-6, 11 personnel vs. a walked-down defense

         --- nobody deep ---

   C           *     $    M     W    F               C
                   E    T    N    T    E
   X           H     O    O    O    O    O   Y        Z
                               Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): An offense in 2x2 with one back faces a defense with no deep safety. Both safeties have walked down near the line with the two linebackers; both corners are pressed on the outside receivers, and a nickel is over the slot. A note at the top says "nobody deep."

B4. On a broadcast, the receiver in jet motion is followed by the camera, and you never see the safeties. On the replay from the overhead camera, you see the strong safety coming down toward the jet at the snap and the free safety running to the deep middle. Fill in the "shell before → after" field of the twelve-field chart for this snap, and say what you'd write if you'd never seen the replay.

B5. Pre-snap, two high safeties at thirteen yards. At the quarterback's back foot (freeze-frame 2), the strong safety is at eight yards and coming down, and the free safety is turning toward the middle. What is the coverage family now? Which of these throws does it hurt most: a post between the safeties, a dig at twelve, or a checkdown to the back?

B6. Pre-snap: a Cover 2 look, corners rolled up with outside leverage, safeties on the hashes. Post-snap: the left corner comes forward on the No. 1 receiver's six-yard hitch, and the slot runs a corner route that breaks toward the pylon at about eighteen. Name the concept, the conflict defender, and the throw. Then say how the picture would change against Cover 3.

B7. Twelve personnel, under center. The run fake goes left; the quarterback keeps the ball and rolls right; the right guard pulls toward the boot side; the tight end who started on the left crosses the formation. What has to be true of the backside defensive end for this play to work, and what in the drive's previous snaps would tell you it's true?

B8. On the broadcast, a running back is tackled for no gain on inside zone. The analyst blames the back for "missing the hole." On the end-zone film, the back aimed at the right guard's outside leg, the double-team on the nose never came off to the Mike, and the Mike filled the front-side A gap unblocked. Who failed, which "key block" does this chapter tell you to check first, and what does the analyst's call tell you about which angle he was watching?

Short answer

The double-team failed to climb to the Mike: the guard or center never came off the combo. That's the key block on inside zone, and it's where this chapter says to start. The back's aiming point was correct, and he had nowhere to go. The analyst was almost certainly watching the broadcast's tight shot, which shows the back and the pile but not the second level.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Make the call (grading). Hypothetical. 3rd-and-12 at the opponent's 27, up 10 with 4:40 left, opponent with two timeouts. Your kicker's range is about 50 yards. The defense has played Tampa 2 on 12 of its last 14 third-and-10-plus snaps. A coordinator calls a running back screen into the middle of the field, and it gains 8. A fan on the couch calls it "a give-up." Grade it: the process, the result by success rate, and your verdict.

Short answer

Process: A. Against Tampa 2 on third-and-long, the Mike runs to the deep middle, and a middle screen goes under him. The real job here is to improve a field-goal try and avoid a sack or turnover while protecting a 10-point lead: a try from the 27 is about 44 yards, from the 19 about 36. Result by success rate: failure (8 of 12). Verdict: a good call that fails a metric built for a different goal. This is Snap 3 of the self-test in a new uniform.

C2. Draw it up. Draw the PRE-SNAP and POST-SNAP of Anchor A, snap 2 ("Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant," 1st-and-10 at the Austin 49, Game 1), in which Ames sits rather than triggers. Label the three looks in order (line, key, ball), and write the described line.

Short answer

Same pre-snap as snap 1. Post-snap: the line steps right (zone), Harlan arcs to the alley safety, Ames drops toward the slant window instead of filling, so the box is five blockers on five. Vance reads Ames sitting and hands to Ruffin, who gains 7. The ball look is the handoff. The described line should say that the run went into the box the Will just left.

C3. Make the call (the 34-second fence). Hypothetical. You're watching a game. 3rd-and-7 at the offense's 45, tied, 6:30 left in the third quarter. Earlier today, on third-and-long, this defense has shown two high safeties four times: it stayed two-high three times and rotated once. Pause at the snap and write your three fence notes (purpose, likely looks, the call's answer to each) for this call: a post-dig concept with no tag, the quarterback's first read the post.

Short answer

Purpose: convert. Likely looks: two-high holds (about 3 in 4 on today's tiny sample) or rotates to one-high (about 1 in 4). Answers: against two-high, the post splits the safeties, good. Against a rotation, the post runs into the middle safety, and with no tag the quarterback has no built-in second answer. Fence grade: B−, a good bet with a known hole. If it's intercepted on a rotation, you already wrote down why, before the replay.

C4. Make the call (as a coordinator). Week 12-style situation, hypothetical: 2nd-and-8 at midfield, tied 7–7, against a single-high defense that has played Cover 3 on most early downs. Your call sheet's early-down box has Smash, Stick, and Inside. You want a call with a built-in answer for Cover 3. Choose, justify, and name the defender you'll be reading.

Short answer

Several are defensible. Smash is fine if you read the corner: against Cover 3 he bails and the hitch is the throw (the Week 12 snap, +7). Stick reads the flat and hook defenders and is naturally strong against Cover 3. Inside against a seven-man box with one high safety may be a lean. Lyle's rule from Chapter 9 says "Seven or fewer, run it; eight, take the throw." What's graded is naming the defender and having an answer for the coverage, not which call you pick.

C5. Whose fault? Game 3, first quarter, 3rd-and-3 at the Sacramento 38: a slant to Gaines against press, the corner wins the release, Vance holds the ball, and Rollins sacks him at about 2.9 seconds for −7. Assign responsibility across the call, the quarterback, the receiver, and the left tackle, with a C / R / X mark for each piece, and name the fix that showed up later in the same game.

Short answer

Call: C, in the sense that the third-and-short box had one answer to press, so the defense solved it on the first try. Quarterback: X: a quick-game ball held to 2.9; Rome's rule now is checkdown, dirt, or third row at 1.5. Receiver: credit Simmons, who won the rep; a partial X at most. Left tackle: no fault worth a letter; quick-game protection isn't built to hold to 2.9. Fix: a second answer in the box. On 3rd-and-2 at the SAC 29, Gaines came in zoom motion and caught a quick out for 5 against the same look.

C6. Draw it up. Draw the "freeze-frame 2" picture of the Game 3 Mills interception: where both safeties are at the quarterback's back foot, and where the post and the dig are. Then draw a second panel showing the same moment with the middle-read tag applied, and which throw the tag picks.

Short answer

Panel 1: at Vance's back foot, Holloway is at about eight yards on the left (the tight end's side) and coming down; Royce has turned from the right toward the deep middle. Gaines's post (from the right) is heading straight into the space Royce is filling; Powers's dig at twelve is crossing underneath Royce. Panel 2: the same frame with the tag's four beats. Both throws were named before the snap. The eyes went to the empty middle on step one, and on step three the middle reads closed. So it's never the post: the dig to Powers, then the flat (Harlan) or the back. Your described line should say the ball comes out at about the same time; only the read changed.

C7. Make the call (as the viewer). Hypothetical. 1st-and-goal at the 9, fourth quarter, down 7. The offense has run outside zone to its left on five of the drive's seven snaps, and the defensive end on the right has chased flat down the line every time. It now subs to two tight ends and lines up under center. Before the snap, predict the call, name the defender it attacks, and say what you'll watch at the snap to know whether it's working.

Short answer

Predict a play-action bootleg to the right off the outside-zone fake, with a tight end crossing from the left and a flat route to the right: the Game 3 Harlan touchdown pattern. The defender is the right end. Watch him on the first step. If he chases the fake, the quarterback has the edge and the crosser. If he stays home, look for the quarterback to throw the flat early or get rid of it.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Lyle grades Anchor A "A for the call, B for my management of it." Explain what "management" means here, using the shelf-life idea and the Inside Slant numbers from Game 2. When should a coordinator retire a call that's still producing positive yards?

D2. In the anchor grades, Anchor D gets an A with "an honest note about the gift." Some coaches would say a coordinator deserves full credit for exploiting a mistake, whoever made it. Argue both sides, then say which you'd write on your own self-scout and why.

D3. A broadcast analyst has about five seconds between plays to explain a call. Using this chapter's limits table, write the most useful honest thing he could say in five seconds about an interception thrown into a post-snap rotation, without resulting and without claiming knowledge he doesn't have.

D4. The self-test scores snap 10 with a "?" grade. Some readers will find that unsatisfying. Make the case that "?" is a better grade than a confident wrong one, using the idea that film is a hypothesis generator. Then name the cost of writing "?" too often.

D5. Teo's charting rules say a streak with no exceptions gets a question mark, not a bold. Using the 29-for-29 two-high streak, explain why a perfect streak can be less trustworthy than a 70 percent tendency against a smart defensive coordinator.

D6. You're a fan with a weekly podcast. After a loss, your audience wants a verdict on the coordinator. You've charted the game and found that his two worst results were good-process calls and his worst process call produced a touchdown. Write the opening two sentences of your segment so that it's honest, says what the film can and can't show, and still gives the audience a clear judgment. Then name the risk of saying it that way, and why it's worth the risk.

Short answer

One version: "The two plays everybody's angry about were the right calls that lost one-on-one matchups. The call I'd worry about is the touchdown, a forced throw into double coverage that worked this week and won't work twice." The risk is sounding contrarian, or seeming to excuse the loss. It's worth it because it's the only verdict that predicts next week. A result-based verdict predicts nothing.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. (Ch 40 + Chapter 7) Chapter 7's threshold concept is "the defense tells you where to go." Show how the pre-snap checklist and freeze-frame 2 together put that idea into practice. Use Anchor A as one example and the Mills call as the other.

M2. (Ch 40 + Chapter 13) Using the three-look viewing order (line, key, ball), explain how you'd tell from the end-zone film whether an RPO was a correct give, a correct throw, or a wrong decision. What would the quarterback's eyes and the key's first step look like in each case?

M3. (Ch 40 + Chapter 19) The "two receipts" rule says call play-action only after two same-look runs the defense has paid for. Design a twelve-field chart column that would let a fan detect two receipts on another team's film, and say what pattern in that column predicts a play-action shot.

M4. (Ch 40 + Chapter 25) Chapter 25 grades three Sacramento third downs by result and by process. Place each one in this chapter's process/result grid, and explain why two of them, run with the same concept, landed in opposite corners.

M5. (Ch 40 + Chapter 28) Self-test snap 3 (the Week 10 middle screen) is a "failure" by success rate. Explain how expected points (EPA) might grade it differently, and why neither metric knows the whole situation. What would Marisol say about grading it by either number alone?

M6. (Ch 40 + Chapter 38) Chapter 38 says an offense is a system of constraints. Pick one snap from the self-test whose grade depends on a snap that came before it, and explain why grading it alone would get it wrong.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. The two-copy experiment. Choose one drive from a game this season that you can watch on both the broadcast and coaches' film. Using the rules in Case Study 1, write your broadcast notes first, then mark each sentence confirmed, wrong, or couldn't-have-known. Report the three counts and describe what kind of claim the broadcast led you to get wrong. (If you have only the broadcast, use the live feed and the replays as your two copies, and expect a larger "couldn't have known" column.)

E2. One coordinator, ten snaps. Pick one offensive coordinator and one game. Choose ten snaps, including at least three third downs and one red-zone snap. Run the Film Grading Rubric from this chapter's Project Checkpoint on each one, writing your process grade at the snap. Then find every public comment the coordinator made about that game (press conferences, interviews) and note any call where his stated reasoning changed your grade. Report how many changed and in which direction.

E3. A season of motion answers. Chart one defense's reaction to pre-snap motion for four games using the motion table in 40.2 (travel, slide, rotate, nothing). Report the counts by down and by personnel, apply the 70-percent-on-ten-snaps threshold, and give every tendency a "since" date. Then watch the fifth game and record whether the tendencies held. What does the fifth game tell you about the half-life of a defensive tendency?