Chapter 11 — Instructor Notes

What this chapter is for

Chapters 9 and 10 taught runs where the defense decides the hole after the snap. Chapter 11 flips that: we pick the hole. Power, counter, and trap win with angles (down blocks that hit defenders from the side) and with an extra blocker the defense didn't count. The price is that the extra blocker is visible, and a visible puller is a key a linebacker can read.

That tension is the chapter's real subject, and the hook shows both halves. In the Week 12 four-minute drive against St. Louis, Austin, up 23–16 with 5:14 left, runs "Twenty-one, I Left, Power Left" six times while everybody in the building knows it's coming. The one snap that isn't Power is the lie: "Twenty-one, I Left, Counter Right," +14, because Stallions Mike Hollis Mabry was keying the fullback. Three kneels end the game. Students should leave able to say: a gap scheme is a promise, and the best gap offenses carry a play that makes each key lie.

The chapter also introduces the book's first explicit self-scout failure: Marisol's Monday-after-Game-2 finding that Ruffin offset toward Harlan in 2x2 on early downs meant counter or counter play-action on 14 of 19 snaps (74%). Sacramento had built a tag around it, and Case Study 1's counter was spilled for +1.

Teaching objectives

By the end of the session a student should be able to:

  1. Name the five parts of every gap play (play-side wall, back block, kick-out, wrap, backside) and identify the player doing each on Power Left and Counter Right.
  2. Assign Outlaws Power and Counter by rule: Lorusso pulls on Power Left with Fale kicking from Twenty-one; Moss kicks and Achterberg wraps on Counter Right; counter goes away from Harlan ("we flip the formation, not the linemen").
  3. Explain trap and the influence release, including why the play-side guard must "never touch the trap man."
  4. Apply Dre Whitaker's key rule (uncovered guard: read the guard; covered guard: read the back; both: read the triangle) to predict which gap run a given linebacker is vulnerable to.
  5. Pair each gap run with its key-breaker from the same look (the three-play test in §11.6).
  6. Explain the plus-one of QB Power and state its cost and Austin's usage rule.

Timing

In a 75-minute session: 10 minutes on the hook (six Power Lefts and one lie). 10 minutes on §11.1, the five parts. 15 minutes on §11.2 Power, including "Count it" and the ⚠️ banana pull. 15 minutes on §11.3 Counter from the gun, with the 🧩 productive struggle on the center's back block. 20 minutes on §11.6, pullers as keys: Dre Whitaker's rule, the three-play test, and the Sentinels' answer. 5 minutes to close on the self-scout lesson.

In a 150-minute block: add 20 minutes on §11.4 Trap and its 📋 "Whose fault?" drill (Lorusso chips the trap man), 15 minutes on §11.7's gap-or-zone trade-offs, 15 minutes on §11.8 QB Power and the 📋 "Make the call" on Game 1's 4th-and-goal at the SAC 3, and 25 minutes on Case Study 1.

What to cut when you are behind: §11.5 (Duo, Dart, pin-and-pull) goes to reading, except one sentence on Duo: two double teams, no puller, the line plays gap and the back plays zone. §11.7's trade-off table can be assigned. Do not cut §11.6. Without it, students learn three plays instead of one idea, and the next two chapters (option and RPOs) are built on the logic that a defender's key can be made to lie.

Where students get stuck

"Gap schemes win because they're more physical." Diagnostic: ask why Power gains yards against a bigger front. Students say "you knock them off the ball." Intervention: the §11.1 🔍 note. Power wins with angles and an uncounted blocker, not mass. Have students count the hook's box: eight defenders, and the offense chooses who's free (the defender farthest from the hole).

The back outruns the puller. Diagnostic: show the ⚠️ banana pull and ask whose fault the tackle-for-loss is. Students blame the guard alone. Intervention: timing is a pair skill. Lonnie Briggs times the back and the puller together with a stopwatch, and the back uses a bucket step. "Press the double, then go where the fullback says."

Trap means "hit the defender first." Diagnostic: the §11.4 Thursday team-period drill. Lorusso chips the 3-technique, who squeezes and meets Moss in the hole. Ask whose fault. Many students will blame Moss. Intervention: the rule is "never touch the trap man." The influence release is the whole play; a chip tells the 3-technique to stop.

"A good rule is always a good rule." Diagnostic: show Marisol's 14-of-19 counter tell and ask whether Austin's formation-flip rule was a mistake. Intervention: the rule was sound; never breaking it was the mistake. Sacramento's counter tag (Ames keying the guards when Ruffin aligned toward Harlan) turned Austin's own consistency into the defense's evidence. Key takeaway 9: your rules become their evidence.

Confusing who pulls on Power Right. Diagnostic: exercise C1 asks students to draw Power Right from Twenty-one. Many write "Lorusso pulls" because the chapter repeats it. Intervention: the backside guard always pulls; "Lorusso pulls" refers to Power Left. The rule beats the name.

Whiteboard / film-room activity

Board the center's problem on Counter Right. Draw the pre-snap picture and let the room solve §11.3's productive struggle before you draw the pullers.

PRE-SNAP (Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Counter Right vs. Nickel Over)

          $                                      F
   C                 W        M          *                  C
                E   T    N      E
   Z     H      Y   O   O   O   O   O        X
                      R   Q
POST-SNAP (Counter Right: LG kicks, LT wraps, C back-blocks the 3-tech)

                     W        M
                     |        ^
                E   T<--]    N  E
                    ^         ^  ^\
                Y   LT  LG   C  RG  RT
                 \__ __\___________\__> LG kicks EMOL
                     \___________\___> LT wraps to first backer
                       R <- jab, then cuts right inside the kick

📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap Harlan is attached on the left, Ruffin is offset left toward him, and the defense is in a nickel Over front with a 3-technique outside the left guard and two deep safeties. After the snap the right guard and right tackle block down, the center blocks back on the 3-technique the pullers leave behind, the left guard pulls flat across to kick out the end man on the right, and the left tackle pulls behind him and wraps up to the first linebacker. Ruffin jabs left toward Harlan, then cuts right inside the kick-out, following the wrapping tackle.

Ask, in order: Who has the hardest block? (The center, backing on a 3-technique who wants to chase the pullers.) What makes it possible? (The 3-technique's own rule pulls him upfield; the center's angle.) If your center can't make it, what do you change? (Run Counter Y, or call counter when the 3-technique is to the play side.) Then the punchline question: Which linebacker does the jab step fool, and which one is it useless against?

A strong answer sounds like: "The jab fools a back-reader. A guard-reader sees two pullers going right and goes with them, so against him I need the counter look with a different guard picture, like Counter Y or Power PA."

Assessment notes

Part A items A2, A6, and A7 check whether students can attach rules to names. Part B's B5 (counter from the I to fool a fullback reader) and B9 (charting the Will's key) are the best film items; B9 previews Chapter 23's scouting work. Grade C3 (four-minute, the Mike shooting Lorusso's pull) and C5 (Game 2, 2nd-and-5 at the SAC 42, the 74% tell) as the judgment items. On C5, full credit requires the student to refuse the telling alignment or change the guard picture; "call counter, it's our best run" earns little.

On the quiz, items 8, 9, and 18 test the chapter's central idea (keys and tells). Item 13 (the plus-one comes from the back becoming a blocker) is a good check on whether students understand the QB run arithmetic.

The Project Checkpoint is the Gap Scheme Sheet, one page per play for Power, Counter, and one Trap. Each page needs the call with your formation-flip rule; a rules table (pulls, kicks, wraps, back-blocks, hinges) against even and odd/tite fronts plus a bear line; the back's aiming point and read; the key it beats and the key it fears; its key-breaker partner; and the "call it when" trigger. A strong sheet fills the "Fears" and "Partner" rows honestly, the way the chapter's Counter Right model does ("Guard-readers who run with the pullers"; "Counter PA from the same look; Counter Y"). The common weak sheet has a beautiful rules table and blank or generic key rows. Those rows are the chapter. At the pro level, look for the self-scout line: what tell does your flip rule create?

Any-level adaptation

High school staff: Power and one trap from one formation family, one rule per position small enough for a wristband card, and low-block rules written at the top from your current state code. Case Study 2 (Lyle's fifth Ohio season, the "Power Fake, Fullback Trap" halftime fix and a 19–14 win) is your best teaching story; it shows a high school version of making a key lie.

College class: add GT counter and a QB version if the quarterback can carry it, and discuss how the wider college hash changes which way you run counter.

Analyst course: the film-room checkpoint (ten gap runs on All-22: who pulled, who kicked, what the play-side linebacker read) is a strong standalone assignment. Have students write the opponent's gap sheet from film.

Connections

Backward: Chapter 10 left the bear front unsolved; gap schemes and trap are part of the answer. Chapter 5 supplies the pulling technique and Moss and Lorusso's builds. Chapter 9 supplies Duo's zone half.

Forward: Chapter 12 leaves a defender unblocked to read him rather than trap him. Chapter 14 uses Power when everybody knows. Chapter 19 develops Power PA. Chapter 23 formalizes the self-scout that exposed the counter tell. Appendix B holds every gap rule by position.