Case Study 1 — Week 10 at Portland: The Second Half

A worked case: one defensive coordinator answers smash, and the offense answers him back. The Outlaws, the Portland Pioneers, and every person and number here are fictional.


Setup

The game: Week 10, at the Portland Pioneers. Austin was coming off its Week 9 bye, which gave Teo Arriaga two weeks with Portland's tape instead of one.

The defense: Leon Marchetti's Pioneers play the most disciplined two-deep zone in the league. Their philosophy fits on a wristband: keep it in front, rally, tackle. They don't blitz much and they don't disguise much. They don't need to. They make you complete twelve passes in a row to score, and they're betting you won't.

Teo's bye-week chart (Portland's last four games, about 260 defensive snaps):

Item Portland
Two-high shell before the snap 74%
Cover 2 (corners in the flat, two deep halves) 31%
Tampa 2 (Cover 2 with the Mike running the deep middle) 24%
Cover 3 18%
Quarters 10%
Cover 1 14%
Cover 0 3%
Five or more rushers 14%
Left corner Josh Kiel (#23) squatting on #1 against a hitch–corner pair 17 of 21
Tampa 2 on third-and-4 to 7 11 of 16
Third-and-medium pressure Mostly Sam plus nickel off the tight-end side

Personnel that mattered: Kiel at left corner; Darnell Price (#30) at the left safety; Owen Talbert (#52), the Mike, who runs the deep middle in Tampa 2; Nate Odegaard (#55), the Will.

First half: Austin scored a touchdown on its opening drive. The big snap was a zone-read play, "Eleven, Gun Wing Left, Inside Read Right, Arc," which gained 15 yards from the Portland 45 to the 30: 7–0. Portland answered with a touchdown drive late in the first quarter: 7–7. Early in the second quarter, a boot flood against single-high went to Harlan for 23 yards, from our 42 to the Portland 35. Two snaps later came Anchor B: 2nd-and-6 at the Portland 31, "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash," Kiel squatted, Powers 31-yard touchdown, 14–7. Portland kicked a field goal with four seconds left in the half: 14–10 at halftime.


What happens

Halftime

The offensive staff meeting at halftime is about eight minutes long. Lyle's sheet had three lines on it.

LYLE: One. Marchetti fixes Kiel. He's too good not to. He'll sink him on a vertical slot. When he does, the hitch is free, and we take it every time until he stops sinking.

TEO: He'll go Tampa on third down, too. Eleven of sixteen.

LYLE: That's two. Third-and-medium is Tampa. Talbert runs.

GUS: And three is their Sam coming off the tight end on third down. I want Harlan home if they show it.

LYLE: Three is Gus gets his tight end when they show it.

Lyle would say later that lines two and three were sitting on the same page and he never put them together.

Third quarter, the opening drive

Austin received the kickoff and started at its 25.

1st-and-10, AUS 25 — inside zone, Ruffin +5. 2nd-and-5, AUS 30 — Powers quick out, +7. 1st-and-10, AUS 37 — Wide right, Ruffin +9.

1st-and-10, AUS 46, 12:20, Austin leads 14–10 — "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash." The same call as the touchdown. Powers released vertical, and Kiel turned his hips and sank, exactly as Lyle had predicted. Vance saw Kiel's hips on his first step and threw the hitch on rhythm. Sutton +8, to the Portland 46.

TEO (booth): He sank. Hips at the snap. That's the halftime fix.

LYLE: Good. Now he's guessing the other way. Mark every smash from here, Teo. If he sinks three times, the hitch is ours all day.

2nd-and-2, POR 46 — inside zone, Ruffin +6. 1st-and-10, POR 40 — Bunch Right smash, hitch to Gaines, +7. (The right corner sank too. Marchetti had made the adjustment for both sides.) 2nd-and-3, POR 33 — duo, Odom +6. 1st-and-10, POR 27 — boot, incomplete. 2nd-and-10, POR 27 — Ruffin checkdown, +4.

3rd-and-6 at the POR 23, about 8:30 left in the quarter. Lyle had two pieces of information. Teo's chart said Portland played Tampa 2 on most third-and-mediums. Gus's note said the Sam came off the tight-end side on third down. Lyle called "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 70, Levels Left": Harlan home to block the Sam if he came, Sutton on the dig at twelve, Powers on the low in at five, Gaines on the right running a curl.

POST-SNAP: Levels Left with no vertical vs. TAMPA 2
           (Q3, 3rd-and-6 at the POR 23, Austin leads 14-10)

        F Price [DEEP 1/2]                       $ [DEEP 1/2]

                     ( M ) Talbert runs to ~14,
                       finds NOBODY vertical,
                       stops, eyes on the dig
                           v  PBU
       X dig 12  +------------------>  (ball arrives here)
                 |
                 |   ( W ) Odegaard jumps the low in
                 |       v
                 |   H in 5 +--------->
                 |          |
                 X          H     O  O  O  O  O  Y       Z
                                  (70: Y stays in)
                                        Q   R

📊 Diagram (described): Portland plays Tampa 2. Talbert, the middle linebacker, runs down the middle of the field to about fourteen yards, but no Austin receiver is running vertically inside, so he stops and looks at the dig window. Odegaard, the Will, jumps Powers's five-yard in. Sutton's twelve-yard dig crosses toward the middle, and Vance throws it, as his read says to, but Talbert breaks down on it from above and knocks it away. Harlan is blocking in seven-man protection, and the Sam did not rush.

Incomplete. The Sam didn't come. Harlan blocked nobody.

TEO (booth): Talbert ran to fourteen and stopped. He didn't have anybody.

LYLE: Because I didn't give him anybody.

WADE (on the sideline): Kick it.

Evan Dorsey's 41-yard field goal made it 17–10 with 7:48 left in the third quarter.

The answer

Portland kicked a field goal of its own late in the quarter: 17–13, 1:41 left in the third. Austin started its next drive at its own 30.

On the sideline, between series, Lyle drew the third-down play on the back of his call sheet, crossed out Harlan's block, and drew a seam. Then he moved the concept to Trips so that Harlan would be #3, inside the in-breakers.

LYLE: Teo. Talbert on the levels. Did he run, or did he read?

TEO: He ran. He's a Tampa Mike. Every vertical inside, he carries. He just didn't have one.

LYLE: Then we give him one.

The drive crossed into the fourth quarter. 2nd-and-8 at the POR 23, 12:05 left, Austin leads 17–13 — "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Levels." Marchetti called Tampa 2 again. Talbert ran with Harlan's seam, as his rules told him to. Odegaard jumped Powers's low in, as his rules told him to. Gaines's dig went into the window behind Odegaard and in front of the safeties, and Vance threw it on Gaines's break. Gaines caught it at about the 11 and scored. Twenty-three yards, 24–13. (The diagram is in 16.7.)

Austin added Dorsey's 36-yard field goal at 4:18. Final: Outlaws 27, Pioneers 13.


Analysis

Why the second smash worked. Lyle predicted the adjustment. A corner who gives up a touchdown on a hi-lo will be coached to take away the high route next time, and the only way to do that is to give up the low route. The hitch didn't beat Kiel's technique; it was the price of his technique. Notice that Marchetti applied the fix to both corners, so the bunch smash to the other side got the same hitch. When a coordinator makes a rule, the rule shows up everywhere.

Why the third-down levels failed. Not because of the read, the routes, or the throw. It failed because the concept was missing its vertical, and against Tampa 2 the vertical is not decoration — it's the thing that removes the middle linebacker from the dig window. Lyle's decision to keep Harlan home was reasonable in isolation: Gus had seen the Sam pressure on film. But Teo's chart had already said Portland played Tampa on most of those downs, and Tampa 2 and a Sam pressure are mostly different calls. Lyle protected against the less likely call by breaking his concept against the more likely one. That's a design error, not bad luck.

Why the fourth-quarter levels scored. The fix wasn't a new play. It was the same play, rebuilt so that it was whole again: a vertical inside the two in-breakers. Talbert and Odegaard both did their jobs correctly, which is what a good concept should make them do.

The conversation. Count the moves. Austin: smash (touchdown). Portland: sink the corners. Austin: take the hitches. Portland: Tampa 2 on third down. Austin: levels without a vertical (fails). Austin: levels with a vertical (touchdown). Marchetti never did anything wrong. He just ran out of ways to be right about everything at once.

💡 Coach's point: When a concept fails, ask whether it was complete before you ask whether it was the right call. Most "wrong calls" are right calls that were missing a piece.


Discussion questions

  1. Lyle's halftime sheet had "Talbert runs" and "Harlan home on third down" on the same page. How would you organize a halftime sheet so that two notes like that get checked against each other?
  2. Marchetti applied the sink rule to both corners. What did that tell Austin about how Portland coaches adjustments, and how could you use that in a later game against the same staff?
  3. Was keeping Harlan in on third-and-six a bad decision or a reasonable decision with a bad result? Use Teo's chart numbers in your answer.
  4. If Marchetti had stopped sinking his corners in the fourth quarter, what would you have called next, and why?
  5. Portland gave up 27 points while doing almost everything its rules asked. What does that suggest about playing a "keep it in front" defense against an offense with all three of these concepts?

Your turn

You are Leon Marchetti on Monday morning after this game. Write the three-line note you'd hand your defensive staff about Austin's smash and levels, including one rule you'll change and what that rule will cost you. Then switch sides: as Lyle, write the one-line call you'd use on the first third-and-medium the next time you face Portland, and say which of Marchetti's possible changes it's built to beat.