Chapter 14 Exercises — Short Yardage, Goal Line, and the Runs That MUST Work

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, and other team scenarios are fictional. Selected answers are in Appendix J; short answers to Part C appear below each item.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. Name the three things that change when the ball gets inside the opponent's 5, and explain in one sentence each why they make the run harder.

A2. On a handoff from Jumbo personnel (five linemen, three tight-end-sized players, a fullback), how many blockers do you have, and how many defenders are left unblocked against an eleven-man defense? Which unblocked defenders are acceptable?

A3. Define a gap charge. Why is a down block more effective against it than a straight-ahead base block?

A4. List the four "fixes" for goal-line arithmetic from this chapter (angles, gaps, the plus-one, the hold) and give one play that uses each.

A5. Why is the quarterback sneak, in public play-by-play data, one of the highest-percentage plays on third- or fourth-and-1? Give the mechanical reason and the selection caveat.

A6. In the NFL, what must a player wearing number 70 do before he can line up as an eligible receiver, and what does the referee do next? Why does that make the play a tell?

A7. What is the difference between a kick-out and a log block for the fullback on power, and what tells him which one to use?

A8. From which yard line is the two-point try snapped in the NFL? In college and high school? What happened to the NFL extra-point kick in 2015?

A9. Why does the ineligible-downfield rule matter more on a goal-line play-action pass than on the run it imitates?

A10. What is switch (in-out) coverage, and why does it defeat a rub concept that would beat straight man coverage?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Pre-snap: third-and-1 at midfield. The defense has a nose tackle head-up on the center, a defensive tackle in a 3 technique outside each guard, two ends outside the tackles, and three linebackers, the Mike about four yards deep over the center. Name the front, say whether the A gaps are filled by linemen, and say which run from this chapter it invites.

B2. Post-snap description: the offense is in Jumbo, under center. At the snap, the play-side tight end, tackle, and guard all step inside and block the defender on their inside shoulder. The backside guard pulls behind the center and turns up. The fullback runs at the end man on the line and pushes him outward. Identify the play and name which defender the pulling guard is responsible for.

B3. You're watching end-zone film of a goal-line run that fails. The offensive line converged toward the center and moved the pile forward a yard, but a linebacker who had stayed two yards deep over the center jumped over the pile and met the quarterback at the top. Name the play, name the defensive technique that beat it, and say what the offense should call next time this linebacker aligns there.

B4. Draw (or describe) a 6-2 goal-line front and a 5-3 goal-line front in this book's diagram notation. For each, say where the defensive linemen usually align and how many linebackers are behind them.

B5. PRE-SNAP: 3rd-and-goal at the 4

                       $                  F
      C          W          M                 *        C
                    E    T     T    E
      X              O    O    O    O    O     Y    H     Z
                              Q  R

📊 Diagram (described): The offense is in the gun with trips to the right: the tight end attached as #3, a slot (H) as #2, and the flanker (Z) as #1; the split end (X) is alone on the left. The defense shows four down linemen, two linebackers, a nickel over the slot, corners on both outside receivers, and two safeties near the goal line.

For B5: The defense plays man coverage, and at the snap the nickel and the right corner each take the first receiver who breaks into their area instead of following an assigned man. What coverage technique is this, and which kind of route combination will it defeat?

B6. Third-and-6 at the opponent's 9. The defense shows two safeties near the goal line and man coverage underneath, with the corner on the split end aligned inside and slightly under him. Name the coverage, describe the corner's technique, and name the throw that attacks it. What must another receiver do to make it work?

B7. Post-snap description: from Heavy, the left guard and center double-team a nose, the right guard and right tackle double-team a 3 technique, the tight ends block the ends man-on, and the wing blocks a walked-down safety. The back takes a handoff straight downhill and cuts right when the Mike fits to the left of the center. Name the play, name the defender the back is reading, and name the one front that makes this play a bad call.

B8. Describe what you'd look for on film to know whether a team's goal-line linemen play a gap charge or a read technique. Name two things to watch in the first half-second.


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Make the call. ⭐⭐ (Hypothetical, against the fictional Birmingham Forge.) Second quarter, third-and-1 at the Birmingham 44, tied. The Forge, a blitz-heavy Cover 1 / Cover 0 defense, show an eight-man box with both linebackers walked up into the A gaps and a single safety at ten yards. You have Heavy on the field with a Check menu of Sneak / Duo / Play-action to the tight end. Which do you check to, and why?

Answer

Play-action to the tight end is the best of the three. Both A gaps are filled (two mugged linebackers), so the sneak runs into defenders who start at the line. Duo's double teams have no free linebacker to climb to and eight defenders are already in the box. The mugged linebackers and Cover 1 mean the defense has sold out on the run: a play-action to the tight end in the flat or on a short drag gets the ball outside the pile against man coverage, with the linebackers triggering on the fake. If the defense instead shows the A gaps empty, check back to the sneak. The grading is on reasoning: you read the A gaps first, then the coverage.

C2. Draw it up. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw "Jumbo, Under I Wing Left, Power Left" against a 5-3 goal-line front (five down linemen: two ends outside the tight ends, two tackles in the B gaps, a nose on the center; three linebackers at two yards; three defensive backs: a corner on each side and a safety in the end zone). Assign every blocker and name the two unblocked defenders.

Answer

Kalu (left end, reported) blocks down on the left B-gap tackle with Achterberg (double, then Achterberg stays); Moss blocks down on the nose; Szabo blocks back on the right B-gap tackle; Lorusso pulls and wraps for the play-side (left) linebacker; Fitch hinges and climbs to the middle linebacker if he flows; Harlan cuts off the right end; Brandt (wing) blocks the left corner or the first defender outside Kalu who isn't the end; Fale kicks out the left end. Unblocked: the backside (right) linebacker if Fitch climbs to the Mike, and the safety in the end zone. Both are away from the hole. Against a 5-3, there are more linebackers to account for than against a 6-2, so the wrap block is critical and the back must press Fale's hip before cutting.

C3. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ (From the fictional Game 2 at Sacramento.) Fourth-and-1 at the Austin 36, early fourth quarter, Sentinels lead 20–13. Your head coach asks, "What's the call if we go?" Your runs against their big nickel have averaged under four yards; their edge rusher has beaten your left tackle repeatedly; you threw incomplete on your only third-and-1 of the first half. Give a call (or a short Check menu) and a one-paragraph case for going or punting.

Answer

A defensible menu: Heavy, Under Wing Right, Check — Sneak (vs. a bear or any look with empty A gaps) / Duo away from the edge rusher / Play-action to Harlan. Going is supported by most fourth-down models: fourth-and-1 at your own 36, down seven early in the fourth, generally favors going. Punting is supported by the day's evidence: the short-yardage run game against this front hasn't been league-average, and a failure gives a seven-point lead and a short field. The strongest answer names both sides and admits the chart assumes an average short-yardage play. In the actual game (fictional), the head coach punted and the opponent drove for a field goal.

C4. Draw it up. ⭐⭐⭐ Design a two-point play from the 2 for an offense whose quarterback is a good runner, against goal-line nickel in Cover 0. Show the formation, every route, the quarterback's path, and the one defender he reads.

Answer

One good answer is our "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, Sprint Right, Snag": #1 corner route to the back pylon, #2 snag settling two yards deep in the end zone, #3 (tight end) to the flat at the goal line. The back kicks out the edge rusher; the quarterback sprints right and reads the defender covering the flat receiver. If he stays with the flat, the quarterback runs; if he attacks the quarterback, throw the flat. The spy and a contain rusher are the play's enemies. In college or high school, snap it from the 3 and sprint to the wide side of the field.

C5. Make the call. ⭐⭐ First-and-goal at the 2. On first down you ran Power Left from Jumbo and gained one yard; the Mike filled the hole and met the back, and the backside linebacker flowed hard over the top. Second-and-goal at the 1, same personnel. What's your call?

Answer

"Jumbo, Under I Wing Left, Power Pass, Y Leak." The defense just showed you its answer to power: both linebackers fill hard. The leak looks identical for a count, then the backside tight end slips behind the flowing linebackers, with the fullback in the flat as the first read. Check that the defense has no deep safety sitting in the end zone; if it does, the sneak (if the A gaps are open) or a wedge is the safer second-and-1 call.

C6. Make the call. ⭐⭐ High school. Second-and-goal at the 1, ball on the left hash, your quarterback is your best athlete, and the opponent is in a 6-2 with tackles in both A gaps. What do you call, and which way do you run?

Answer

A QB wedge or power to the wide (right) side. With tackles in both A gaps, a sneak is a pile; the wedge closes the gaps they're charging into. If you prefer power, run to the wide side of the field: on a high school hash (53 feet 4 inches from the sideline) the boundary side is cramped and gives the edge defenders help from the sideline. Many high school coaches would also accept a QB sprint run-pass to the field on second-and-1, keeping a down in hand.

C7. Draw it up. ⭐⭐ Draw a QB wedge from a tight, two-tight-end, wing formation against a 6-2 with tackles in both A gaps and both B gaps. Give each lineman's rule in one line, name the apex, and say what the backs do.

Answer

Apex: the center. Every lineman and tight end puts his inside shoulder on the near hip of the man inside him and drives toward the center; the center drives straight ahead on the defender in front of him (or the A-gap tackle if he's covered). The two A-gap tackles and two B-gap tackles fire into gaps that are closing as they arrive. The quarterback takes the snap and follows the center's back, low, ball in both hands. The fullback and tailback fill behind him (whether they may push is a code question; check your rules). The ends outside the tight ends are unblocked and too far from the apex to matter. Splits are foot to foot.

C8. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Fourth-and-goal at the 3, first quarter, you lead 7–0. Your analyst's chart says "go, close." Your three snaps from inside the 6 — a duo, a back-shoulder from 3x1, and a bunch in-out — gained three yards total. You have one goal-line call you fully trust. Do you go or kick, and if you go, what do you call?

Answer

Both answers can be defended; the reasoning is graded. Go: the chart's expected-value case is real (even failure pins the opponent at its own 3), and three short gains against three different looks don't prove the next call fails. If you go, use the trusted call — saving it for a fourth quarter that may never need it is a guess about the future that costs real points now. Kick: a 10–0 lead has value; the defense has just stopped three looks; the trusted call might be worth more later in a close game. The deeper lesson is the one the chapter draws: if you have only one trusted goal-line call, the package is the problem. (In the fictional Game 1, the head coach kicked; the offensive coordinator would have gone.)


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Your head coach doesn't want your franchise quarterback sneaking. Make the best case for a written sneak rule (when you will and won't sneak) that addresses his concern. Include the A-gap read, ball-security coaching, and what you'd call instead when the sneak is off.

D2. The chapter argues that a goal-line package with one trusted play leads coaches to "save" the play. Is saving a play ever correct? Give one situation where you'd save a goal-line call and one where saving it costs you points. Use the Game 1 fourth-and-goal at the 3 as one of your examples.

D3. Jumbo personnel tells the defense you're running. Weigh the cost of that tell against the benefit of three extra big blockers. At what point does using Eleven at the goal line become a better choice? Consider personnel, the defense's goal-line package, and your quarterback.

D4. Your best short-yardage back is a 230-pound power runner who can't catch; your starter is a one-cut speed back who protects well. Build a rule for which one is on the field inside the 3, and explain how the defense's reaction to each should affect your call.

D5. Your line coach wants twelve Jumbo reps on Friday; your quarterbacks coach wants those reps for two-minute. Use a value-per-snap argument to decide, and say what you'd cut to make room.

D6. Your team trails by eight with four minutes left and scores a touchdown. Do you go for two now, or kick and plan to go for two after a later score? Lay out the information you'd want (your two-point play's expected conversion, your kicker's extra-point reliability, the opponent's likely possessions) and explain why the timing of the two-point attempt matters even if the odds are the same.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. (Ch 14 + Chapter 7, Understanding Defensive Structure.) "The defense tells you where to go." Apply this threshold idea to three goal-line fronts — a bear, a 6-2 with A-gap tackles, and Cover 0 nickel — and name the one place each front can't be and the play that goes there.

M2. (Ch 14 + Chapter 11, Gap Schemes.) Compare power in the open field (Chapter 11) with power from Jumbo at the 2. What changes in the splits, the fullback's read, the puller's target, and the back's aiming point?

M3. (Ch 14 + Chapter 12, The Option Game.) The Game 1 opening touchdown came from "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Read Bubble" at the 4. Explain why an option play from normal personnel can be a better goal-line call than a heavy-personnel run, using the plus-one arithmetic from both chapters.

M4. (Ch 14 + Chapter 4, Personnel Groupings.) Using Marisol's "kill the zeros" rule, audit our Heavy and Jumbo packages. What play type must appear on film from each, and how often?

M5. (Ch 14 + Chapter 5, The Offensive Line.) Gus's normal split rule is "two feet, toes to toes, inside-out." Explain why goal-line splits tighten, and what a tighter split costs you on a pulling play like power.

M6. (Ch 14 + Chapter 13, RPOs.) Can an RPO be used on the goal line? Discuss what changes about the ineligible-downfield rule, the conflict defender, and the throw's landing spot when the end zone is the back of the field.

M7. (Ch 14 + Chapter 9, Inside Zone.) Compare regular inside zone with inside zone "tight." What moves (aiming point, first step, the back's read), and against what kind of goal-line front is the tight version a better choice than power? Explain using the threshold idea that in zone, the hole is decided after the snap.

M8. (Ch 14 + Chapter 3, Formations.) In a Jumbo formation with a wing outside the left tight end, which players are eligible? What happens to eligibility if the wing steps up onto the line of scrimmage? Explain how the reported tackle fits the seven-on-the-line rule.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. Goal-to-go chart. Pick one NFL team and chart every goal-to-go snap inside the 5 from three of its games (or a full season if you have the time). For each snap, record personnel, formation, under center or gun, front (count the down linemen), coverage (man or zone; deep safety or none), the call family (sneak, wedge, power, duo, zone, toss, pass type), the defenders left unblocked, and the result. What does the team do on the first goal-to-go snap of a series? Does it pair runs and passes from the same picture?

E2. The sneak study. Using public play-by-play data (nflverse and similar sources), find quarterback sneaks on third- or fourth-and-1 over a season and compare their conversion rate with handoffs in the same situations. Then watch a sample of the sneaks on film and note how many came against empty A gaps. Write a paragraph on how much of the sneak's advantage might be selection.

E3. Two-point film. Find ten two-point tries from recent seasons (any level). For each, note whether the play forced one defender to choose (a run-pass read, a rub, a sprint), whether the quarterback was a run threat, and the result. What design features show up in the successful tries?