Chapter 3 — Instructor Notes
What this chapter is for
Chapter 3 teaches students to see the first thing the offense says on every snap: where eleven people stand. Its central distinction, which you should drill until it is automatic, is that personnel, formation, and play are three separate decisions (§3.1). Keeping them separate is what makes formationing, few plays from many pictures, possible. The chapter then asks what every formation does to a defense. §3.8 gives five answers: it forces a strength call, removes a defender from the box, creates leverage, isolates a receiver, or adds a run gap. "If it does none, cut it."
The hook carries the chapter's second lesson, and it is the one your high-school coaches will remember. Lyle's unbalanced line worked exactly as drawn, and the touchdown came back because a sophomore flanker, Danny Kostas, lined up on the ball and covered up the tight end. His father's line, "So the drawing was right and the boy was in the wrong place," is the reason §3.2 (legality, numbering, gaps, techniques) cannot be skipped. A formation is a question for the defense and a contract with the rulebook at the same time.
This is also the first chapter with a 🪞 Learning check-in and a ## Spaced Review. Use both in class rather than leaving them to the reader.
Teaching objectives
By the end of the session a student should be able to:
- Separate personnel, formation, and play in a full Outlaws call such as "Eleven, Gun Trey Right, Inside."
- Check a formation's legality: seven on the line, only the two ends and the backs eligible, ineligible numbers reported. Name who is covered up when a receiver aligns wrong.
- Number receivers outside-in (#1, #2, #3) on each side of Doubles, Trips, Trey, Nub, Bunch, and Empty, and name the gaps and technique numbers along the line.
- Distinguish the offense's strength word from the defense's strength call, and predict the light side against a field-strength or TE-strength rule.
- Name which of the five effects (§3.8) a given formation is after, and count the box in plain arithmetic.
- Identify a formation tell in a self-scout table and apply the chapter's fix: break it, spread it, or use it.
- Write formation cards that a backup could align from without being told.
Timing
In a 75-minute session: 5 minutes on the hook. Tell the Danny Kostas story yourself and stop at the flag. 15 minutes on §3.2: seven on the line, eligible ends, receiver numbering, gaps, and technique numbers (state once that some systems swap 6 and 7). 10 minutes on §3.4, strength: the offense's rule, the defense's rules, and the duo into the boundary. 20 minutes on §3.5, the families, built around the Nub 📋 Find the conflict (the activity below). 10 minutes on §3.8's box-count arithmetic. 15 minutes on §3.9, formationing and the Sentinels' tell table.
In a 150-minute block: add §3.6 (bunch chase vs. switch, stack, and Nasty splits, including the 🩺 crack-block note), §3.7 (Load, Wing, Empty), the 📋 Make the call on the left hash at the SAC 47, the 📋 Whose fault? (Jaylen Cross covers up Harlan), and ten minutes for the 🪞 Learning check-in done live: draw Doubles, Trey, and Nub from memory.
What to cut when you are behind: §3.3, backfield sets, can shrink to the 🧩 Productive struggle alone (the shotgun back's alignment as a tell). §3.7's Wing/Ace and Quads go to reading. Do not cut §3.2 or §3.9. Legality costs real touchdowns, and the tell table is the bridge to self-scouting in Chapters 23 and 25.
Where students get stuck
"The formation is the personnel." Diagnostic: quiz item 1. Which word in "Eleven, Gun Trey Right, Inside" is the formation? Students circle "Eleven." Intervention: the A1 sentences. Personnel is who, formation is where, play is what. Then show the Ch 3 📋 Make the call worked answer, where 12 personnel lined up with Harlan detached so the Sentinels matched with nickel. Same people, different question.
"Anybody on the line can catch it." Diagnostic: quiz item 3 (the Z steps onto the line outside an attached tight end). Intervention: the hook, then the 📋 Whose fault? with Jaylen Cross. The fault is assigned to the coaching, not the player. A backup who has never had an alignment rep at Z in Trey will eventually cover up Harlan. The fix is three-part: walk-through reps for backups at every spot, Vance checks the end man ("Off!"), and on/off-the-line marks on the formation card. Lyle calls it "the Danny Kostas rule."
"Our 'Right' is their strong side." Diagnostic: quiz item 11 (true/false: the offense's direction word and the defense's strength call always match). Intervention: §3.4's defensive strength rules (field, tight end, passing strength, back, linebacker's call) and the Sentinels' history. In Game 1 they set strength to the field. From Game 2 on, they set it to the attached TE. Every rule leaves a side light, and the job is to find it.
"A tell is only a problem if the play stops working." Diagnostic: quiz item 13. Intervention: the Sentinels' four-game chart in §3.9. All 9 of Austin's scissors calls came from a reduced split, and 19 of 21 empty snaps came after Ruffin motioned out. Russ showed Lyle the table in the spring. A tell is free information for the defense until the moment it chooses to use it, and you will not know which snap that is.
"Bunch means a free rub." Diagnostic: quiz item 7. Intervention: the ⚠️ in §3.6. Against a switching (in-out) man defense, there is no rub, and the first man out gets tackled short. §3.6's own Game 1 example shows it: on 3rd-and-goal at the SAC 4 from Gun Bunch Right, Simmons took the first receiver to break outside, nobody ran through traffic, and he tackled Powers at the 3. Austin kicked the field goal for 10–0.
Whiteboard / film-room activity
"Who connects the two halves?" Put up the §3.5 📋 Find the conflict picture:
GUN NUB RIGHT vs. NICKEL (front set to TE, coverage to trips)
F $
C * C W M
E N T E
X H Z O O O O O Y
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): The offense is in shotgun with three receivers on the left (the split end outside, the slot in the middle, the flanker inside) and the tight end attached alone on the right: Nub Right. The back is beside the quarterback. The defense has set its front toward the tight end, with the three-technique tackle on the right guard, while its coverage has shifted toward the three receivers: both corners and the nickel are on the left, with the linebackers inside and two deep safeties.
Ask: "The front is looking right. The coverage is looking left. Somebody has to connect the two halves. Who?" Let the room argue. Then: "Give me two plays from this exact picture that make that man wrong either way."
A strong answer: "The Will. His run fit is toward Harlan's side, and his pass job is the hook or #3 to the trips side. Pair inside zone right with a quick in-breaker to the #3 receiver on the left. If he fits the run, the throw is open. If he widens, the box is six on five." Push the best students one step further: "Is that two plays or one?" It is one play with a read, which is why Chapter 13 exists.
Assessment notes
Assign: A1, A2, A4, and A10 (legality and numbering, the non-negotiable base); B2 (what's wrong with this formation), B3 (Nub vs. a moving 3-technique), and B7 (a 3x1 third-and-medium tell); C1 (vs. a Game 1 field-strength defense), C4 (the self-scout two weeks later), and C6 (third-and-goal vs. man); D1 (six new formations this week) and D5 (the back's alignment predicts run direction 75% of the time). M3 ties the formation family back to the Chapter 1 never list. From the 20-item quiz, items 3, 11, 13, 18, and 20 discriminate best.
The Project Checkpoint — Formation Family. Six to eight formation cards, each with name and call words, alignment rules for every position (with splits, landmarks, and hash adjustments), the strength rule, a legality check, the defensive problem it creates (named from §3.8), and the tell to watch plus the play that keeps it honest. A strong family matches the worked "Gun Trey Right" card. Every card names the two eligible ends, every card names an effect, and the set as a whole includes at least one formation that attacks a different defensive strength rule (Trey and Nub together are the classic pair). Grade hardest on the legality line and the tell line. A card without them is a drawing, not a formation. The common failure is eight formations that all do the same thing, with "creates confusion" as the defensive problem. The chapter's answer: if it does none of the five things, cut it.
Any-level adaptation
High school staff: six formations, at least one under center or two-back (the 🏫 note in §3.3 makes the honest case). Every card must fit on an index card a sophomore can read. Spend real time on your state code's numbering and eligibility rules and on NFHS hash width, which makes field vs. boundary a much bigger decision than in the NFL.
College class: seven or eight formations, with the wide college hash written into every alignment rule. Exercise C7 (the Stallions learn to count Load) is a good graded item.
Analyst course: the film-room checkpoint (chart two quarters, tag every snap by family) plus Exercise E2, the strength-rule detective. Analysts often discover in this chapter that they never saw formations at all. That is the point of the 🪞 check-in.
Connections
Backward: Chapter 2 supplies the history of Wing, Load, Pistol, and Doubles; Chapter 1's never list should constrain the family. Forward: Chapter 4 puts people into these formations. Chapter 7 teaches the defensive side of strength and box count. Chapter 13 turns the Nub pairing into a single RPO. Chapter 23 and Chapter 27 build out self-scouting and motion. Reference: Appendix A for numbering, gaps, and technique numbers.