Wednesday of Week 6 was hot in a way that only Austin in October can be hot. We were in the
In This Chapter
- The Hook: "You Want Me to Let Ninety-Four Go?"
- 12.1 The Arithmetic of the Box: Why Somebody Goes Unblocked Anyway
- 12.2 The Zone Read: Anatomy of One Decision
- 12.3 The Mesh: Where the Option Is Won or Fumbled
- 12.4 The Defense Answers: Swap, Sit, Squeeze-and-Scrape, and the Mesh Charge
- 12.5 Counters: Arc, Bash, Slice, and the Third Option
- 12.6 Speed Option and the Pitch Phase
- 12.7 Power Read (Inverted Veer): Trade Who Goes Where
- 12.8 Where It Came From: Veer, Wishbone, Flexbone, and the Spread
- 12.9 The Cost: How Much Can Your Quarterback Run?
- Spaced Review
- Project Checkpoint: Option Package
- Chapter Summary
- What's Next
Chapter 12 — The Option Game: Zone Read, Speed Option, RPOs, and Putting Defenders in Conflict
The Hook: "You Want Me to Let Ninety-Four Go?"
Wednesday of Week 6 was hot in a way that only Austin in October can be hot. We were in the first-and-second-down walkthrough, helmets only, the scout defense in pinnies with numbers taped on the front so our guys could see who they were looking at. The scout end on the left side wore a strip of tape that said 94. That was DeShawn Rollins's number. On Sunday the real one would be lined up across from our left tackle, and he was the best edge rusher in the division.
I drew the play on the whiteboard we wheel out to the field: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Read Bubble." Inside zone to the right. Mekhi Powers on a bubble from the left slot. Devonte Sutton blocking the corner. And on the left edge, over Ben Achterberg, a circle around the end.
Ben looked at the board for a long time. He's six-foot-six, and when he tilts his head the whole offensive line tilts with him.
"Coach," he said. "You want me to let ninety-four go?"
Gus Ferrante, our line coach, had his arms folded and his sunglasses up on his cap. "Every year," he said to nobody. "Every year he draws this, and every year my tackle looks at me like I sold his dog."
"Ben, you're not letting him go," I said. "Darius is blocking him."
Ben looked at Darius Vance, who weighs about two hundred and twenty pounds and was holding a water bottle.
"With what?"
"With his eyes. You block the three-technique with Kendrick and climb. Ninety-four is Darius's man. If ninety-four chases Jalen, Darius keeps the ball and runs where ninety-four used to be standing. If ninety-four stays home to wait for Darius, Jalen runs right past him. Either way, the best pass rusher on their team spends the snap tackling nobody."
"And if he takes both?"
"Then he's the best football player who ever lived," I said, "and we should trade for him."
Gus snorted. Ben didn't laugh. Linemen don't laugh about being told not to block somebody. Their whole life is built on a promise: the man in front of me is mine. I was asking him to break it on purpose, and to trust that a quarterback ten yards behind him would keep it for him.
Four days later it was second-and-goal at the Sacramento 4, first quarter, no score, the seventh snap of our opening drive. Teo Arriaga's voice came down from the coaches' booth in the three words he's allowed in my quiet window: shell, box, one thing.
"Goal line, six, Ames is creeping."
Jordan Ames, their Will linebacker, number 45. We had made him wrong twice already on that drive. He had attacked our first run-pass option and Powers caught a slant behind him for 17 yards. On the next snap he sat back, and Jalen Ruffin ran through the space he'd left for 7. Now he was cheating toward the ball, a step tighter than his alignment rule, and I could feel him wanting to be right about the run.
I gave Darius the call. He gave it to the huddle. At the snap Achterberg stepped inside and never looked at Rollins. Rollins saw a tackle leave him, and he did what every great defensive end does when nobody blocks him: he went to make a play. He crashed down the line at Ruffin. Darius put the ball in Jalen's stomach, watched Rollins's shoulders turn, and pulled it. His second look was Kenny Vo, the nickel, who had Powers's bubble outside and had to honor it. Ames, the one man who could have saved them, had fit inside on the dive.
Darius walked into the end zone. Four yards. Outlaws 7, Sentinels 0.
When Ben came off the field he found me on the sideline. "I didn't touch him," he said, like he was confessing something.
Gus put a hand on his shoulder pad. "You blocked him fine," he said.
That exchange is the whole chapter. Our fictional Outlaws scored a touchdown against the best end in the division without blocking him. We didn't overpower him. We gave him a choice and then read his answer. This chapter is about how that works: the arithmetic, the mesh, the reads, and what a smart defense does about it. A smart defense always does something about it, and in our case that was Russ Kimbrough.
🏃 Fast Track: If you've coached the zone read and speed option, skim 12.1–12.3, then go to 12.4 (the defensive answers, with the Sentinels' Swap and Sit) and 12.5 (counters). Read the 🚪 threshold block in 12.1 even if you know the play. It frames Chapters 13 and 31.
🔬 Deep Dive: The full blocking rules for every option run are in Appendix B. Mesh, pitch, and read drills are in Appendix K. The pass becomes the third option in Chapter 13. The cost of running your quarterback gets its own treatment in Chapter 31.
📺 Film Watcher: This Sunday, when a shotgun team hands the ball off, look at the backside defensive end before the ball. If nobody touched him, it was an option, and the quarterback's eyes were on that end. Then watch the linebacker behind the end. He tells you whether the defense had an answer.
12.1 The Arithmetic of the Box: Why Somebody Goes Unblocked Anyway
Start with a fact that bothers every young line coach: on a normal handoff, the defense has one more man than you can block.
Count it. You have eleven players. One of them is the ball carrier, and he doesn't block. On a handoff from the shotgun, the quarterback hands the ball off and then watches, so he doesn't block either. That leaves nine potential blockers against eleven defenders. Some of your nine are wide receivers split out where they can't reach the box, and the defense keeps some of its eleven deep for the same reason. When you trim both sides down to the players who can actually affect a run up the middle, the offense usually comes out one short. The defense gets that extra man because your quarterback is a spectator.
The box is the area roughly from tight end to tight end and five to seven yards deep, where run defenders align. The box count is the number of defenders in it. Chapter 7 gave you our staff's words for it: light, neutral, loaded. We count an apex nickel as "half" because he's neither in the box nor out of it.
PRE-SNAP — Counting the box (Gun Doubles Right, 11 vs. Nickel Over)
F $
C * W M C
E T N E
X H O O O O O Y Z
R Q
DEFENDERS IN THE BOX: E T N E W M = 6 (* = "half")
OFFENSE CAN BLOCK: LT LG C RG RT Y = 6
SPECTATORS: Q (hands off), R (carries)
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in the shotgun with two receivers on each side and the tight end attached on the right; the back is beside the quarterback on his left. The defense shows two deep safeties, a nickel between the slot and the box on the left, and six box defenders: four linemen and two linebackers. The tally underneath is six box defenders against six blockers (five linemen and the tight end). The quarterback and the back don't block anyone, and the nickel is half in the box.
Six on six sounds even. It isn't, for two reasons. First, the defense doesn't have to block anyone. A defender only has to get off a block and touch the ball carrier, while a blocker has to stay on his man for two or three seconds. Second, the nickel and the safeties are coming. Against a two-high shell, a safety rotates down into the alley (the lane between the box and the sideline) at the snap, and the nickel fits inside or out. The defense's extra man is the player you never had a body for.
A coordinator has three ways to fix that math:
- Add a blocker. Bring in a fullback or a second tight end. (Chapter 4 showed what that costs: the defense matches with bigger people and now you're throwing against linebackers.)
- Remove a defender. Spread the formation so a box player has to leave and cover someone. That's the logic behind four- and five-wide formations.
- Make the quarterback count. Leave one defender unblocked on purpose, and let the quarterback handle him by reading him. The quarterback either hands the ball to the back or keeps it, depending on what that defender does.
The third way is the option. Any play where a ball carrier chooses after the snap, based on one defender's action, who gets the ball is an option play. The defender being read is the read key, also called the read defender or option key. He becomes a conflict defender: one man responsible for two things, the back and the quarterback, who can only take one of them.
Here is the same box with the backside end left unblocked and read:
| Box defender | Handoff (everyone blocked) | Zone read (end is read) |
|---|---|---|
| Backside end (E) | LT blocks him | Nobody. Vance reads him. |
| 3-technique (T) | LG | LT and LG (double, one climbs) |
| Nose (N) | C | C and RG |
| Play-side end (E) | RT | RT |
| Mike (M) | Y or a climbing lineman | Climbing lineman |
| Will (W) | Nobody, so he's the defense's extra man | Climbing lineman |
| Blockers per box defender | 6 on 6, and the alley player is free | 6 on 5, plus a decision on the 6th |
Count the bottom row. By reading one man instead of blocking him, the offense goes from even to plus-one: six blockers on five box defenders, plus a quarterback who handles the sixth with his eyes. The spare blocker becomes a double team that can climb to a linebacker. That's how the zone read "blocks" the Will without anyone running at him.
🚪 Threshold concept: You can "block" a defender with a decision.
Before: Every defender has to be blocked by somebody, and an unblocked defender is a mistake. If nobody touches the end, the line busted. If the end makes the tackle, someone missed his man. The quarterback is a ball-handler who isn't part of the blocking scheme.
After: An offense has three ways to take a defender out of a play: block him, read him, or run a route at him. A read defender is accounted for, as surely as one with a lineman on him. He is "blocked" by the fact that whatever he chooses, the ball goes to the other place. The quarterback is a blocker whose tool is a decision, and the hole is wherever the read defender isn't. When the end makes a tackle on a zone read, the question is no longer "who missed him?" It's "did the quarterback read him correctly, and did the defense have a second man assigned to the option we gave it?"
Once you see it, you can't stop seeing it. The RPO in Chapter 13 reads a linebacker instead of an end and uses a throw instead of a keep. The bubble on a triple option "blocks" the nickel with a receiver. Play-action "blocks" a safety with his own eyes. Every one of them is the same idea: a defender who has to choose can be beaten by whichever choice he doesn't make.
This is why I told Ben that Darius was blocking Rollins. That wasn't a pep talk. Rollins was accounted for, by a decision instead of by a body.
🔍 Why this works: A block is a bet that your man can hold his man long enough. A read is a bet that the defender can't be in two places at once, and that bet never loses on geometry. It can only lose on execution (a bad read or a fumbled mesh) or on a defense that assigns a second defender to the option you left open. That second defender is what the whole defensive half of this chapter is about. The read changes what the defense has to do. Instead of beating a block, it has to coordinate two players on one decision in about half a second.
🔄 Check your understanding: Against a six-man box, with the tight end attached, Austin runs inside zone and blocks everyone it can. Who is the defense's "extra man," and where does he come from? On the zone read, which defender is "blocked by a decision"?
Answer
On the plain handoff, six blockers take the six box defenders, but the defense still has the nickel and a rotating safety to fit the run, and they're free, so one of them is the extra man in the alley. On the zone read, the backside end is left unblocked and read by the quarterback. Whichever runner the end takes, the ball goes to the other one. That frees a lineman to double and climb to the Will, which gives the offense six blockers on five box defenders.
12.2 The Zone Read: Anatomy of One Decision
The zone read (our call is "Inside Read") is the most common option play in football at every level. It's inside zone (Chapter 9) with one change: the backside end isn't blocked, and the quarterback reads him at the mesh.
Two pieces of vocabulary for this chapter. Technique numbers describe where a defensive lineman aligns: 0 is head-up on the center; 1 is a shade of the center; 2i is the inside shade of the guard, 2 head-up, 3 the outside shade; 4i is the inside shade of the tackle, 4 head-up, 5 the outside shade; 7 is the inside shade of the tight end, 6 head-up, 9 the outside shade. (Some systems swap 6 and 7; we use 7 for the inside shade.) Gaps run A (center–guard), B (guard–tackle), C (tackle–tight end, or just outside the tackle with no tight end), and D (outside the tight end). A running quarterback effectively adds a gap. That's the option's plus-one, written in gap language.
Who does what
Here's Inside Read from our base look, "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right," with the zone going right (toward Brooks Harlan) and the read on the left end:
| Position | Assignment on Inside Read (zone right, read the left end) |
|---|---|
| LT (Achterberg) | Zone step inside. Block the 3-technique or B gap with the LG and climb to the backside linebacker. Never touch the end. |
| LG (Moss) | Zone step. Combo the 3-technique with the LT, or the nose with the C, depending on the front. |
| C (Szabo) | Zone right. Combo the nose; climb to the Mike. Makes the line call. |
| RG (Lorusso) | Zone right. Covered: base/reach his man. Uncovered: combo with the C and climb. |
| RT (Fitch) | Zone right. Down-step and reach the play-side end or climb. |
| Y (Harlan) | Zone right: reach the edge defender or the Sam/strong safety walked down. |
| R (Ruffin) | Aims at the play-side guard's outside leg on the inside-zone track. Reads the blocks like a normal inside zone: bang, bounce, or bend. Soft pocket at the mesh: don't clamp until Vance lets go. |
| Q (Vance) | Catch, ride the ball into Ruffin's pocket, eyes on the read end. Give or keep by the read rule. On a keep, run where the end was, then find the alley. |
| X / Z / H | Base: stalk-block the man over you. With a tag (Bubble, Glance, Slant), you're the third option (12.5, Chapter 13). |
Notice what the backside tackle does. Ben steps inside and blocks a defender who isn't the end. He doesn't arc out and he doesn't influence. He takes the gap inside the end away, which is what makes the end's decision so stark: if the end comes down, nobody is in his way, and nobody is behind him on the edge either.
The read
The rule is simple to say and hard to do at full speed:
| What the read end does | What it means | Vance's decision |
|---|---|---|
| Crashes down the line, shoulders turned in toward the back | He's taking the dive | Keep. Pull it, run where he was standing. |
| Squeezes but stays square, hips facing upfield, eyes on the QB | He's waiting for the quarterback | Give. He can't catch the back from there. |
| Widens or rushes upfield | He's taking the quarterback, or rushing the passer | Give. The back's lane is open. |
| Sits right at the line, feet chopping (slow-play) | He wants a give, so the linebacker can take the back | Give, and expect the back to meet a linebacker. (The defense's answer; see 12.4.) |
| Charges the mesh point flat and fast | He's trying to hit both and force a fumble | Keep, ball high and tight, around his back. (See the mesh charge in 12.4.) |
Rome Pettaway, our quarterbacks coach, compresses all of that into one sentence for Vance: "If he can tackle Jalen, he can't tackle you." The read isn't "did the end move inside?" It's "can the end, from where he is right now, make the tackle on the back?" If yes, keep. If no, give.
That phrasing matters, because ends lie. A good end shuffles inside a step with his shoulders square and his eyes on the quarterback. His feet moved inside, but he's still in position to take the quarterback. A young quarterback sees the feet and pulls the ball right into him. The shoulders tell the truth. The feet don't.
Back to the Sacramento 4
Here is the touchdown from the hook, in our notation. The Sentinels, we learned in the spring, had a call on that snap that Russ Kimbrough's staff named "Swap": a scrape exchange where the end crashes on the back and the linebacker behind him loops outside to take the quarterback. Their end did his job. Their linebacker didn't, and the bubble made sure nobody else could cover for him.
PRE-SNAP — 2nd-and-goal, SAC 4, Q1, 0-0, Game 1 (Week 6)
"Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Read Bubble"
========================= GOAL LINE ==========================
F $
C * W M C
(E) T N E
X H O O O O O Y Z
R Q
(E) = Rollins, #94: read, not blocked
📊 Diagram (described): On the Sacramento 4, Austin is in two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right, Gaines outside him, and Powers and Sutton on the left. Ruffin is beside Vance on his left. The Sentinels are in nickel near their goal line with Vo, the nickel, over Powers, Ames at Will on the left, Bell at Mike, and Rollins at left end, circled as the read.
POST-SNAP — Rollins crashes, Vo holds the bubble, Ames fits inside
========================= GOAL LINE ==========================
^ Vance keeps: 4-yd TD
|
* | W Ames fits inside on the dive
| holds | \
C <--H bubble | v
] | (E)===> Rollins crashes the dive
X blocks C | O O O O O Y-->]
\______ Q zone right ---> ---> --->
\ :
R ==> takes the fake, runs zone right
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the line zones right and Achterberg steps inside, leaving Rollins alone. Vance rides the ball into Ruffin's stomach while watching Rollins. Rollins crashes flat down the line toward Ruffin, so Vance pulls the ball. Powers runs a bubble toward the left sideline behind Sutton's block on the corner, and Vo widens to cover it. Ames, who should have looped outside to take the quarterback, has stepped inside toward the dive. Vance runs through the spot Rollins left, between Vo and Ames, for the touchdown.
Count the three options and who was assigned to each in the Sentinels' call:
| Option | Austin's threat | Sentinels' assignment (Swap) | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dive | Ruffin on inside zone | Rollins (crash) | Rollins took it, correctly |
| Quarterback | Vance's keep | Ames (scrape outside) | Ames fit inside, so nobody had the QB |
| Perimeter | Powers's bubble | Vo | Vo took it, correctly |
The Sentinels were one man away from stopping that play. Russ's call was sound. Two of his three players did exactly their jobs. This is why I never say a defensive coordinator was outschemed when an option works. Usually he wasn't. The option made one young linebacker solve a problem in half a second after two snaps of being punished for every answer he'd tried. That's sequence doing the work: the first two plays of the drive taught Ames to distrust his eyes.
🎙️ On the headset: Second-and-goal at the 4. I had three calls on the card for the goal-line zone: "Inside" (just run it), "Inside Read Bubble," and a fade to Sutton. Teo's "Ames is creeping" settled it. A creeping Will is a linebacker who wants to stop the dive. If he takes the dive, then on any scrape exchange the quarterback belongs to nobody. If they didn't have an exchange called, Rollins was going to crash or he wasn't, and Darius would read that. The bubble was there for Vo. Their nickel was the only player left who could rescue a busted exchange, and the bubble gave him something else to do. Eight seconds, and the call went in.
⚠️ Common mistake: reading the end's feet. Week 12 against St. Louis, first quarter, first-and-ten at our own 31, the Stallions' backside end took a hard inside step with his shoulders square. Vance, still a little amped from the opening kickoff, pulled the ball on the step. The end, who had never left the quarterback, tackled him for no gain. On Monday Rome froze the frame and drew a line through the end's shoulders: parallel to the line of scrimmage. The fix: read the near shoulder and the hips, not the feet, and use Rome's sentence. Could he tackle Jalen from there? No. Then give.
🔄 Check your understanding: On Inside Read, the backside end takes one quick step inside, but his shoulders stay square to the line and his eyes are on the quarterback. Give or keep? Why?
Answer
Give. He can't tackle the back from a square, upfield posture. He's in position to tackle the quarterback. The inside step is either a slow-play (the defense's "Sit" look) or just a squeeze. The read is the shoulders and whether he can make the tackle on the back, not which way his feet moved.
12.3 The Mesh: Where the Option Is Won or Fumbled
The mesh is the moment the quarterback and the back share the ball. On a zone read it lasts about half a second, from when the ball first touches the back's stomach to when the quarterback either lets go or pulls it out. Everything in the option happens there. If the read is right and the mesh is sloppy, you fumble. If the mesh is clean and the read is late, you hand the ball to a back who's already being tackled.
THE MESH (top view, Gun, back offset left, inside zone right)
(E) read end
\
\ Vance's eyes stay HERE, not on the ball
\
LT LG C RG RT
^
ride: Q ---.
back hip --> front hip decide by the FRONT hip
R ------>------> aim: outside leg of the RG
start (Ruffin's inside-zone track)
📊 Diagram (described): A close-up from above. Vance catches the shotgun snap and turns to place the ball in Ruffin's stomach as Ruffin crosses in front of him from the left, running his inside-zone track toward the right guard's outside leg. Vance's eyes aren't on the ball. They're on the unblocked end on the left. He rides the ball from Ruffin's back hip toward his front hip and must decide before it gets to the front hip.
Our mesh rules (Chapter 6 set them for every Outlaws back) are short:
- It's the quarterback's ball until he lets go. The back makes a soft pocket, top arm up, bottom arm across, and doesn't clamp until he feels the quarterback's hands leave. If the back clamps early, he "steals" the ball, and when the quarterback is trying to pull it, that's how fumbles happen.
- Same track, same speed. The back runs the exact inside-zone path at the exact inside-zone speed whether he gets the ball or not. If the back slows down at the mesh to "help," the read end sees it and knows.
- Ride, don't stab. The quarterback's arms move with the back, from his back hip toward his front hip. A stab-and-pull looks different from a handoff, and the end will learn it in two snaps.
- Decide by the front hip. If the ball reaches the back's front hip and the quarterback still hasn't decided, it's a give. A late pull is how quarterbacks get hit by the end and the linebacker at once.
- Carry out the fake. A give with no fake lets the end fall back inside on the back. Vance runs three hard steps after every give, every snap, in practice and games. A quarterback who stops running after the give gets the end to stop honoring him by the second quarter.
Rule 4 is where young quarterbacks struggle. The instinct is to keep reading as long as possible, because more information should mean a better decision. In the option it doesn't. Half a second is all the time you have. Past that, the back is too deep in the line to pull the ball from, and the end is close enough to hit whoever ends up with it. Rome runs a drill he calls "Front Hip": a manager holds a pad as the read end and moves on a coach's signal, sometimes before the mesh, sometimes right at the front hip, sometimes after. If the end moves late, the correct answer is give, every time. It's twenty reps a day in camp and eight a day in season.
Where the quarterback goes on a keep
A keep isn't "run left." Vance's keep path has rules:
- Replace the end's feet. Run first to the spot the end left. That's the window the read created.
- Find the second defender. On a keep, the next threat is the player assigned to the quarterback (12.4): a scraping linebacker, an alley safety, or a nickel. Vance reads him on the run. If the scraper comes outside, Vance cuts up inside him. If he comes inside, Vance bends it outside.
- With a bubble or pitch on, read the third man. On Inside Read Bubble, the nickel becomes a second read: if he takes the quarterback, throw the bubble; if he takes the bubble, run.
🩺 Player safety: the quarterback is a runner now. When your quarterback keeps the ball, he can be tackled like a running back. Under NFL rules as commonly interpreted, a quarterback carrying out an option action outside the pocket may be treated as a runner until it's clear he doesn't have the ball. That means the read end can legally hit him on a give if the fake was believable. Check the current rulebook each season; this area has been clarified more than once. Our rules for Vance on keeps: (1) get down or get out of bounds before the second defender arrives. A feet-first slide gives the runner the protection of being down, and defenders are expected to avoid hitting him, but the timing is the runner's job. (2) Never lower your head into a safety; take the yards and go down. (3) Inside the 10, you may finish forward. Outside it, the first down is enough. High school and college codes treat sliding and quarterback protection differently. Teach your code's version explicitly, and rep the slide in practice, because a slide nobody practiced won't happen on Sunday.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why does the mesh rule "decide by the front hip, otherwise give" exist, instead of "keep reading until you're sure"?
Answer
Because the option's advantage depends on time. After the front hip, the back is too far into the line for a clean pull, and the read end is close enough to hit both players. A late pull is a fumble risk and a quarterback-hit risk. Defaulting to the give means an unsure read still produces an inside-zone run, which is a normal play, instead of a collision at the mesh.
12.4 The Defense Answers: Swap, Sit, Squeeze-and-Scrape, and the Mesh Charge
Every option has a weakness, and it's the same weakness every time: the read defender is only one of the defense's eleven. The offense left one man unblocked and gave him two jobs. The defense can quietly assign one of those jobs to someone else. Once it does, the read is still correct, but the picture behind the read is wrong.
🛡️ The defense's view: Russ Kimbrough told me in the spring, at a breakfast where neither of us touched our eggs, that his staff's whole zone-read plan fits on an index card: "Somebody has the quarterback. Every snap. By name." The offense has three options at most: the dive, the quarterback, and the perimeter. The defense has eleven people. If the defense names a player for each option before the snap, then the conflict defender isn't in conflict anymore. He has one job, and someone else has the other. Russ's two looks were "Swap" and "Sit." He mixed them by series so Darius could never trust what the end was showing him. "The two have to look identical for the first half second," he said. "After that I don't care what he sees. He's already decided."
The scrape exchange ("Swap")
The scrape exchange, which some staffs call a gap exchange or squeeze and scrape, is the oldest answer to the read. The end and the linebacker behind him trade jobs:
- The end crashes hard and flat down the line and takes the dive.
- The linebacker, instead of filling inside, scrapes outside behind the crashing end and takes the quarterback.
The quarterback sees the end crash. That's a keep read, and it's correct. He pulls the ball and runs straight into a linebacker who arrived where the end used to be. The read was right. The picture was wrong.
The Sentinels called Swap in Game 2 at Sacramento, Week 15. First quarter, second-and-4 at the Sacramento 38, from the same Inside Read look we'd scored with in Game 1:
POST-SNAP — Game 2, Q1, 2nd-and-4 at SAC 38: Inside Read vs. "Swap"
(left half of the field and the box)
F M fits play-side
\
* W <----- Ames scrapes outside v
| \ (he owns the QB)
v v
H X <-- Vance keeps into Ames: +1
^
| (E)===> Rollins crashes: takes the dive
| O O O O O Y
\_______ Q
R ===> zone right
📊 Diagram (described): The left half of the field. At the snap Austin zones right and leaves Rollins unblocked. Rollins crashes flat down the line at Ruffin. Vance correctly reads the crash and pulls the ball, but Ames, the Will linebacker, hasn't filled inside. He has looped outside behind Rollins, into the space Vance is running toward. Vance runs into Ames for one yard. The nickel stays outside on the slot, and the Mike fits on the play side as normal.
Vance kept for one yard. Nobody made a mistake on our side. Vance read it right, and the line blocked it right. The Sentinels had a man assigned to the keep, and the man was there.
The slow-play ("Sit")
The scrape exchange has a weakness of its own, and the defense knows it: once the quarterback figures out that a crashing end means a scraping linebacker, he starts pulling the ball and looking for the scraper instead of the end. So the defense needs a second picture that starts the same way and ends differently. That's the slow-play, which the Sentinels call "Sit." Some staffs call it a "shuffle" or a "feather":
- The end sits: he shuffles down the line, stays square, stays wide, and takes the quarterback. He doesn't crash, so the quarterback reads "give."
- The linebacker behind him fills inside and takes the dive.
Two series after the Swap, the Sentinels showed us Sit, on first-and-ten:
POST-SNAP — Game 2, Q1, two series later: Inside Read vs. "Sit"
F M
\
* W Ames fills inside: owns the dive
| \
v \
(H) (E) v
| X<=== Ruffin +2 into Ames
Rollins sits: |
square, wide, | O O O O O Y
owns the QB v Q --> give
R ===> zone right
📊 Diagram (described): Same formation and the same unblocked end. This time Rollins shuffles inside but stays square and wide with his eyes on Vance, so Vance correctly reads "give" and hands off. Ames, instead of scraping, fills inside on the back's track and meets Ruffin after two yards. If Vance had kept, Rollins was waiting for him.
Ruffin gained two. Same play, two different calls, two short gains. Vance kept the zone read one more time that night, for four, and that was our whole Inside Read game in Week 15: two keeps for five yards and a handful of gives that did about what plain inside zone would have done.
🧩 Productive struggle: Before you read on, put yourself on the headset in Week 15. You've seen Swap once (Vance kept into the scraper for 1) and Sit once (Ruffin ran into the same linebacker for 2). The Sentinels are mixing them by series. You want to keep the zone read in the game because it makes Rollins stop rushing upfield on early downs. What do you change? Write down at least two answers, and for each one, name which of the Sentinels' two calls it beats and which it doesn't. Then read 12.5.
The other answers
Swap and Sit are two of the four or five answers you'll see. Here's the full list, from the offense's side:
| Defensive answer | What the read end does | Who has the QB | What the QB sees | Offense's counter |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scrape exchange / Swap / squeeze and scrape | Crashes the dive | The linebacker behind him, scraping outside | "Keep," then a linebacker in his face | Arc a blocker to the scraper; read the scraper; bubble/pitch to stress the next man |
| Slow-play / Sit / shuffle | Sits square and wide | The end | "Give," then the back meets the linebacker | Bash (the back goes outside); a better give read; Arc has nobody to block, so don't call it here |
| Mesh charge | Attacks the mesh point flat and fast | The end, trying to hit both; the alley player cleans up | A collision at the mesh | Pull and bounce around his back; slice or kick him with an H-back; quicker decision |
| QB player (alley safety or nickel) | Plays the back | A safety or nickel rotated down | "Keep," then a safety in the alley | Bubble/RPO throws behind the rotated player (Chapter 13); play-action |
| Spill and box | Squeezes, forces the QB to bounce wide | The force player (corner or safety) | Room outside, then a free hitter on the edge | Arc to the force; pitch phase (speed option) |
| Plus-one the box | Any | An eighth box defender | A crowded box everywhere | Throw. The plus-one came from the coverage. |
The mesh charge deserves a word because it's the most violent answer. The end doesn't crash down the line or sit. He attacks the mesh point itself, flat and fast, trying to arrive while the ball is still being shared. He's trying to hit both players, force a fumble, and at the least make the quarterback decide early and badly. The answer is speed and ball security. If the end arrives at the mesh before the front hip, he's committed to the inside, and the keep goes around his back. Vance's rule is "two hands at the charge": both hands on the ball as he pulls, because a charging end swings an arm at it. The longer answer is to stop leaving him unblocked: slice him with an H-back or fullback coming across the formation to kick him out, and read the next defender instead.
🎬 Film room: To tell Swap from Sit on film, freeze the frame at the mesh, about half a second after the snap, and look at the linebacker behind the read end, not the end. On Swap his first two steps are lateral, outside, and his shoulders stay square to the sideline. On Sit his first step is downhill and inside, toward the back's track. The end is built to look the same on both for the first half second. The linebacker can't hide what he's doing, because he has too far to go. Teo charts this column weekly on every opponent that's faced a zone read in its last four games. Before Week 15 his page said: "Since Week 6: exchange on 5 of 9, end on the QB on 4 of 9, alternated by series, never twice in a row." That's how we knew Russ was mixing, and it's also why we couldn't just guess.
🔄 Check your understanding: On a zone read, the end crashes and the quarterback keeps, and the Will linebacker tackles him for a yard. Was the read wrong? What was the defense's call, and who had what?
Answer
The read was right. A crashing end means keep. The defense was in a scrape exchange (the Sentinels' "Swap"): the end had the dive, and the Will scraped outside to take the quarterback. The fix isn't a different read. It's a different play: block the scraper (arc), read the scraper instead of the end, or attach a third option that punishes whoever helps on the quarterback.
12.5 Counters: Arc, Bash, Slice, and the Third Option
The option game is a conversation. The offense makes a defender choose. The defense assigns a second man so the choice doesn't matter. The offense then has to do something about the second man. There are four common counters, and each one beats a specific defensive answer.
Arc: block the scraper
The answer to the scrape exchange is to send a blocker at the scraper. In "Arc," a tight end or wing on the read side releases outside the read end (around him, without touching him) and climbs to the first linebacker or force player who shows outside. The end is still read. If he crashes, the quarterback keeps, and the linebacker who was supposed to scrape to the quarterback has a 255-pound tight end coming at him.
For Arc we need Harlan on the read side, so the zone has to go away from him. Our call grammar handles that with a direction word. "Eleven, Gun Wing Left, Inside Read Right, Arc" puts Harlan in a wing a yard off Achterberg's left hip, runs the zone right (away from him), reads the left end, and tells Harlan to arc. (Our default: Inside Read runs to the formation's strength. A direction word that points away from the tight end overrides it, and then Arc is legal.)
We ran it in Week 10 at Portland, five weeks before Russ showed us Swap. Leon Marchetti's Pioneers play the most disciplined Tampa 2 in the league (that's the Cover 2 where the Mike runs to the deep middle), and they scrape-exchanged every zone read we'd shown on film. On our first possession, from the regular Doubles look on first-and-ten at our own 38, their left end, Dion Fairley (#91), crashed, their Will, Nate Odegaard (#55), scraped, and Vance kept into Odegaard for 2. It was textbook, and it was the information I wanted. Four snaps later, still in the first quarter, still 0–0, first-and-ten at the Portland 45:
PRE-SNAP — Week 10 at Portland, Q1, 0-0, 1st-and-10 at POR 45
"Eleven, Gun Wing Left, Inside Read Right, Arc" vs. Tampa 2
F $
C * W M C
(E) T N E
X Y O O O O O H Z
R Q
(E) = Fairley #91, read Y = Harlan, wing off LT's hip
W = Odegaard #55 (the scraper on Swap-type calls)
📊 Diagram (described): Austin aligns with Harlan in a wing just outside and behind the left tackle, Sutton split wide left, and Powers and Gaines to the right. Ruffin is beside Vance on the left. Portland shows two deep safeties, a four-man front with the left end, Fairley, outside the left tackle, and two linebackers, with Odegaard at Will on the left side. Fairley is circled as the read.
POST-SNAP — Fairley crashes, Odegaard scrapes, Harlan arcs to him
F takes a late angle
\
\ ^ Vance keeps: +15
\ |
C v | W Odegaard scrapes outside...
] Y-----|->] ...into Harlan's arc block
X (E)|==> Fairley crashes the dive
\| O O O O O
Q zone right ---> ---> --->
:
R ==> fake, inside-zone track
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the line zones right. Harlan releases outside Fairley without touching him and runs up to where the scraping linebacker will be. Fairley crashes on Ruffin, so Vance pulls the ball. Odegaard scrapes outside to take Vance, which is his job in the exchange, and meets Harlan's block instead. Vance runs through the space between Harlan's block and the line, and the free safety arrives late from deep. Vance gains 15.
Vance kept for 15 to the Portland 30. The drive finished in the end zone four plays later, and we led 7–0. Odegaard did his job. Fairley did his job. The play beat the call, not the players, because Arc put a body on the man the call depended on.
So why didn't I just call Arc in Week 15 after the Swap? I wanted to. It was on the call sheet. Here's what stopped me, in the order I thought it on the sideline:
🎙️ On the headset: We've seen Swap once. Teo's page says they alternate by series and never show the same answer twice in a row. If they show Sit next and I've called Arc, Harlan runs around an end who's sitting on Darius and goes looking for a linebacker who isn't scraping. That linebacker is inside, filling on Jalen. Arc against Sit is a tight end blocking air and a zone run with one fewer blocker on the front side. I can't call Arc until I believe Swap is coming, and Russ built his whole plan so I'd never believe it.
Two series later they showed Sit. I had called the plain Inside Read, and Ruffin got two. If I'd called Arc, he'd probably have gotten less. The lesson isn't that Arc is bad. It's that a counter only beats the answer it was built for, and a defense that mixes its answers by series is betting you can't tell which one is coming. Russ won that bet in Week 15. In the spring, over the second-morning breakfast, he slid his zone-read cutup across the table and said, "You had Arc. I saw it at Portland. That's why you got Sit." That's the conversation, and it goes both ways.
Bash: send the back away
If the defense's answer is Sit (the end takes the quarterback and the linebacker takes the dive), the counter is to move the dive somewhere the linebacker can't get to it. "Bash" (from "back away"; the name varies by staff) flips the jobs: the back runs outside, on a sweep or outside-zone path away from the line's zone, and the quarterback runs the inside zone himself. Our call for it is "Inside Read Bash."
POST-SNAP — "Inside Read Bash" vs. an end who sits (slow-plays)
W fills inside for the "dive"...
\
<======= R ...but the back went OUTSIDE: give = sweep wide
^
| (E) sits on the QB
| | O O O O O Y
| v Q ---> keeps on the zone track inside
| :
R (starts offset right, aims for the left edge)
📊 Diagram (described): The back starts beside the quarterback on the right and, at the snap, runs toward the left sideline instead of into the line. The line still zones right. The read end on the left sits square to take the quarterback. If the end stays inside, the quarterback hands the ball to the back going wide, outside the end. If the end widens with the back, the quarterback keeps it himself on the inside-zone track. The linebacker who filled inside for the "dive" finds the quarterback there, but only if he guessed right, because the back is now the outside threat.
The geometry is simple. Sit asks the end to take the quarterback from outside and the linebacker to take the back from inside. Bash puts the back outside and the quarterback inside, so the two defenders are now on the wrong sides of their jobs. Bash is a great second-half call for a team that has seen Sit twice. It's a bad call against Swap, because a crashing end runs straight into a quarterback's inside path.
🩺 Player safety: Bash makes your quarterback the inside runner, which is the most expensive carry in the option game. He's running into linebackers and safeties, not out toward the sideline. We carry Bash for one or two calls a game at most, and never in a game where Vance has already taken two big hits. See 12.9.
Slice and kick: stop reading the end
Sometimes the right answer is to quit reading the end altogether. A slice block brings an H-back or fullback (for us, Sione Fale in Twenty-one personnel, or Harlan from a wing on the other side) across the formation at the snap to kick out the end. Now the quarterback reads the next defender: the linebacker who was supposed to scrape, or the alley safety. This is the zone-read version of a lesson Chapter 11 taught with gap schemes: whoever the defense makes its key, you can block him and read the man behind him.
The third option: make the next defender choose
The last counter is the one we scored with in Game 1. Attach a third option, a bubble screen, a pitch, or a quick throw, to the player who's supposed to help on the quarterback. On a scrape exchange the Will takes the quarterback, so the help on the perimeter has to be the nickel. Give the nickel a bubble to cover, and either the bubble is open or the quarterback has nobody but the Will between him and the end zone. That's why many coaches call Inside Read Bubble a triple option: three ball carriers, two defenders read, one snap.
The ineligible-downfield rule matters here. A bubble thrown behind the line of scrimmage doesn't cross the line, so the rules about linemen downfield don't apply to it. A throw that crosses the line does. That's the difference between a bubble tag and the RPOs in the next chapter, where the throw goes past the line and the linemen's run blocking has to stop at the legal depth (NFL, one yard; college and high school have allowed more, so check your code).
And here's the step that takes you to Chapter 13. Instead of reading the end for the run and the nickel for the bubble, read a linebacker for the run and the pass. Our opening drive in Game 1 began with that play. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant": inside zone right, Powers on a slant from the left slot, Vance reading Jordan Ames. On the first snap Ames triggered on the run and Powers caught the slant behind him for 17. On the next snap, same call, Ames sat, and Ruffin ran into the space he'd left for 7. That's a run-pass option, where the pass is the option. It has its own chapter, and its own rules, because once the ball goes over the line everything about the linemen changes. For now, see it as the same arithmetic: one defender, two jobs, read him.
| Counter | Beats | Loses to | Our call |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arc (Y/wing blocks the scraper) | Swap / scrape exchange; spill to the force | Sit (Y blocks air) | "Inside Read Right, Arc" from Wing Left |
| Bash (back outside, QB inside) | Sit / slow-play; a linebacker who fills fast | Swap (crashing end meets the QB) | "Inside Read Bash" |
| Slice / kick (block the end, read the next man) | Mesh charge; a dominant read end | A disciplined second-level read defender | "Inside Read Slice" (Twenty-one) |
| Bubble / pitch (third option) | Any answer that uses the nickel or safety to help on the QB | A defense that plays the perimeter with a corner and still has a QB player | "Inside Read Bubble" |
| RPO (read a linebacker, pass as option) | Linebackers who fit fast; plus-one boxes | Patient linebackers with good eyes; the ineligible-downfield rule if the line blocks too far | Chapter 13 |
📋 Try it: Make the call. Suppose it's Week 15 at Sacramento, early in the second quarter, first-and-ten at your own 27, tied. You've called Inside Read twice: Swap (keep, +1), then Sit (give, +2), on alternate series. Teo's page says the Sentinels never show the same answer on back-to-back series. This is the first snap of a new series. Your options: (a) plain Inside Read, (b) Inside Read Right, Arc from Wing Left, (c) Inside Read Bash, (d) Inside Read Bubble, (e) leave the zone read alone and run Inside Slant. Make the call and defend it in three sentences. The reasoning is what gets graded.
Worked answer
There's no single right answer, but there are better and worse bets. Teo's page says the next look should be Swap (they alternated Swap → Sit). If you trust it, (b) Arc is the purest counter: Harlan arcs to the scraping Ames, and Vance keeps behind him. The risk is that Russ breaks his own pattern, because he knows you can read it, and gives you Sit, and Arc against Sit blocks air. (d) Inside Read Bubble is the hedge. Against Swap, the bubble occupies Vo so a busted exchange is a big gain, and against Sit it's still a reasonable give with the bubble as a release valve. (c) Bash is the right counter for Sit, but against Swap a crashing Rollins meets Vance on the inside path. That's the worst result available, and it costs you a hit on your quarterback. (e) tells Russ you gave up on the read, which is information too. A strong answer picks (b) or (d), says which defensive call it's betting on, and says what you'll call next if the bet loses. (What we actually did that week: we didn't get another clean chance at it. The game moved to the quick game, and Inside Read went back in the drawer until the spring.)
🔄 Check your understanding: Match each counter to the defensive answer it beats: Arc, Bash, Slice. Answers: mesh charge, Sit, Swap.
Answer
Arc beats Swap (it blocks the scraping linebacker who's assigned to the quarterback). Bash beats Sit (the back goes outside the end who's sitting on the quarterback, and the quarterback runs inside the linebacker who's filling for the dive). Slice beats the mesh charge (it kicks the charging end out and moves the read to the next defender).
12.6 Speed Option and the Pitch Phase
The zone read reads one defender at the mesh. The speed option has no mesh. The quarterback takes the snap and runs straight at the edge, with the back running alongside him a few yards outside and behind, and he reads the pitch key: the first defender outside the last blocker, usually the end or an outside linebacker. If the pitch key takes the quarterback, he pitches the ball to the back. If the pitch key widens to take the back, the quarterback turns up inside him.
Speed option is the cleanest picture of the pitch phase, the outside half of every triple option. It's older than the zone read and simpler to block. It's also more dangerous for the quarterback, because the read happens at the point of contact, not half a second earlier at the mesh.
PRE-SNAP — "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Speed Right" vs. Cover 1 man
$ (rolled down to the alley)
F (deep middle)
C * W M S C
E T N (E)
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
(E) = pitch key: first defender outside the last blocker
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right and the back beside the quarterback on the right side. The defense shows one deep safety, a strong safety rolled down outside, a linebacker over the tight end, and a defensive end on the right side, circled as the pitch key. Everyone else is matched man-to-man on a receiver.
POST-SNAP — QB attacks the pitch key; back holds the relationship
$ <-- Y arcs to the alley player
]
Y
\ (E) widens with the back? -> QB turns up
O O O O O \ inside him
reach --> --> --> --> \
Q -------->--> attack his INSIDE shoulder
R ------>------> 4-5 yds outside, 1 deep
......> pitch if (E) takes the QB
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the whole line steps right and reaches. Harlan releases outside and arcs up to the rolled-down safety. Vance runs flat toward the edge, attacking the inside shoulder of the unblocked end. Ruffin runs parallel, about four or five yards outside and a yard deeper, in pitch relationship. If the end comes up to take Vance, Vance pitches to Ruffin outside him. If the end widens to take Ruffin, Vance turns up inside him.
The rules of the pitch phase:
| Pitch key does | Quarterback | Back |
|---|---|---|
| Attacks the quarterback | Pitch. Before he's hit if possible. | Catch it in stride, outside the key |
| Widens or sinks to the back ("plays the pitch") | Keep. Turn up inside him. | Stay in relationship; you're the threat that froze him |
| Feathers (stays between, backpedaling) | Attack his inside shoulder until he commits, then pitch or keep | Hold the relationship; don't drift upfield |
| Nobody shows outside the last blocker | Keep and get vertical | Become a blocker or stay as the outlet |
The pitch relationship is the back's job: a fixed distance outside and slightly behind the quarterback that he keeps no matter how fast the quarterback runs. If he's too close, the key can play both of them. If he's too far, the pitch has to travel, and long pitches get intercepted or fumbled. Four to five yards outside and a yard deep is a common teaching. More important than the number is that it never changes, so the quarterback can pitch without looking.
"Make him tackle you" or "pitch it early"?
There are two schools of quarterback technique in the pitch phase, and the choice is about your quarterback's body.
The classic option school says attack the key's inside shoulder and make him tackle you. Pitch only when he commits, ideally as he's hitting you. That maximizes the read. The key has no time to recover to the back. But the quarterback takes a hit on every pitch.
The other school says pitch early. If the key shows quarterback at all, pitch before contact. You'll give up some yardage on reads that weren't fully clear, but the quarterback stays upright.
At the mid-major college program where I was offensive coordinator, we ran speed option to the field side out of the gun every week. My second season there, our quarterback, a junior who'd played safety in high school and ran like one, took a late hit pitching against a team that taught its ends to "tackle the quarterback, every option, every time." That's a legal and common defensive coaching point: if you're the pitch key, hit the quarterback whether he pitches or not. He missed two games. We changed our coaching that week to "pitch it on the first sign," and we gave up maybe half a yard a carry and got our quarterback back for November. That trade is the option game in miniature: the read is worth something, and so is the reader.
In Austin, speed option lives in exactly one place: our Green panel, the red-zone and two-point panel, as a call against goal-line man coverage. When a defense plays Cover 0 (no deep safety) at the 2-yard line, every defender is turned to a receiver, and the quarterback and pitch back are two ball carriers nobody has been assigned to. We've called it a handful of times in four seasons. I'm not going to ask Darius Vance to take the pitch key's hit twenty times a year. He's worth more than that, and Chapter 31 explains the math.
📋 Try it: Whose fault? Practice, Thursday of Week 12. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Speed Right" against the scout defense's Cover 1. The scout end widens hard at the snap to take the pitch. Vance turns up inside him for 6. The next rep, same look, the end widens again, but this time Vance pitches, Ruffin catches it two yards behind where he should be, and the scout corner, who had released from his man when the X blocked down, tackles him for a 3-yard loss. Three players touched this play: Vance, Ruffin, and Sutton (the X). Whose fault, which rule, and what's the fix?
Worked answer
Primary: Vance. The rule is "key widens or plays the pitch → keep." The end widened. Vance pitched anyway, probably because he had pre-decided after the previous rep. Secondary: Ruffin. He drifted deep, out of the four-to-five-yards-outside, one-deep relationship. A pitch that has to travel backward gives the defense time. Not Sutton. Against Cover 1 the X's job on speed option is to run off his corner. If the corner released to the run, Sutton's route has stopped being a decoy and become an open receiver, which is information for the next call (a speed-option fake with an X go), not a mistake. The fix: Rome's pitch-key drill with the key's action randomized every rep, so Vance can't anticipate. Lonnie Briggs puts a cone at the relationship spot for the back's first ten reps.
🏫 Any level: In high school and college, the option is a much bigger part of the game than it is in the NFL, and the field is part of the reason. NFL hash marks sit 70 feet 9 inches from each sideline, close to the middle. College hashes are 60 feet from the sideline, and high school (NFHS) hashes are 53 feet 4 inches from it. From a high-school hash, the wide side of the field has nearly 40 yards of grass. A speed option run to the field from the hash in high school is a different play from the same call in the NFL. The pitch key has much more space to cover, and the force player is much farther from help. The other differences favor the option too. Quarterbacks are often the best athletes on the team, defenses get less practice time to prepare for it, and a scout team can't imitate it well. The cost is the same as in the NFL: the quarterback takes hits. If your high-school quarterback is also your best defender, your option menu is a decision about two positions.
🔄 Check your understanding: What's the difference between the zone read's read and the speed option's read, in where and when the quarterback makes the decision?
Answer
The zone read decides at the mesh, in the backfield, about half a second after the snap, by reading the backside end while the ball is in the back's stomach. The speed option decides on the edge, on the run, at the point of contact, by reading the pitch key as the quarterback attacks him. The zone read keeps the decision away from contact. The speed option's read is sharper because it's later, but it puts the quarterback in the collision.
12.7 Power Read (Inverted Veer): Trade Who Goes Where
The zone read reads the backside end and sends the back inside. Power read, also called the inverted veer or "dash read" in some systems, reads the play-side end and reverses the jobs: the back runs outside on a sweep path, and the quarterback runs inside behind a pulling guard. It's gap blocking (Chapter 11), not zone, and it turns a quarterback with some size into a power runner.
Our version is "Power Read Left": Pete Lorusso, our right guard and our power puller, pulls left and leads up inside for Vance. The play-side tackle and guard block down. The play-side end is left alone and read. Ruffin starts on Vance's right and runs a flat sweep path to the left.
PRE-SNAP — "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Power Read Left"
Week 12 vs. St. Louis, Q4, one-score game, 3rd-and-2 at STL 12
$ (walked down) F
C S M W C
(E) T N E
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
(E) = the play-side end, read Lorusso (RG) will pull left
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right; Ruffin is beside Vance on the right. St. Louis shows a single-high safety, a strong safety walked down on the left, and a loaded box with three linebackers. The left defensive end, outside the left tackle, is circled as the read. The right guard will pull to the left.
POST-SNAP — End widens with the sweep; Vance keeps behind Lorusso
M <---] Lorusso leads on the Mike
$ ^
(E) widens to chase | Vance keeps: +7 to the 5
\ the sweep |
v |
<==== R sweep LT->] LG->] C->] RG RT Y
^ | hinge hinge
Q <------'
Lorusso pulls left, turns up
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the left tackle, left guard, and center block down to their right, and Lorusso pulls from right guard toward the left. Ruffin runs flat toward the left sideline on a sweep path. The unblocked left end sees the sweep and widens to chase it. Vance reads him widening and keeps the ball, running up inside behind Lorusso, who leads through the hole and blocks the Mike linebacker. Vance gains seven to the 5.
Vance kept for 7, first down at the St. Louis 5. Frank Ostrowski's Stallions build their defense around eight-man boxes and ends who play the edge hard. That makes them a good power-read team to play against. An end taught to set a hard edge against the sweep will widen with Ruffin every time, and that leaves a quarterback-sized hole behind a pulling guard.
The read rules flip from the zone read:
| Play-side end (read) | Power read decision |
|---|---|
| Widens with the sweep, or upfield | Keep inside behind the puller |
| Squeezes inside, chasing the puller or the quarterback | Give the sweep outside him |
| Sits square (slow-play) | Give by default, and tell the booth: the next call is a play-action off this look |
Why reverse the jobs? Because it hits a defense in a different place. Zone-read answers like Swap assume the back is inside and the quarterback is outside. Power read puts the quarterback inside with a lead blocker, so a scraping linebacker scrapes to the wrong place, and the end's natural edge-setting instinct becomes the keep read. It's also a better play for a quarterback built like a fullback than for one built like a sprinter.
⚠️ Common mistake: power read with a small quarterback. Power read's keep is a downhill run between the tackles into linebackers. That's the most physically expensive carry in the option game. Teams sometimes put it in because it looked unstoppable for someone else's 245-pound quarterback, then watch their 200-pound quarterback take three linebacker hits in a half. The fix: match the option to the quarterback's body. Zone read and speed option let a lighter quarterback keep the ball outside, where he can slide or step out of bounds. Power read and Bash ask him to run inside. Vance is about 220 pounds and runs well, so power read lives on our third-and-short and red-zone menu, and Bash is a once-a-game call.
🔄 Check your understanding: In power read, which end is read, who runs outside, and who runs inside? How does that change the meaning of a widening end?
Answer
Power read reads the play-side end. The back runs outside on the sweep, and the quarterback runs inside behind a pulling guard. On a zone read, an end who widens or stays home is a give read, because he isn't taking the back inside. On power read, an end who widens with the sweep is a keep read, because he's taken the back, so the quarterback goes inside him.
12.8 Where It Came From: Veer, Wishbone, Flexbone, and the Spread
Every option in this chapter descends from a small number of ideas that college coaches developed in the 1960s and 1970s and passed down from there. This book's history chapter (Chapter 2) covers the lineage. Here is the part that matters for option rules.
The veer. Bill Yeoman's Houston teams of the 1960s are widely credited with the split-back veer, the first widely copied triple option. The quarterback reads the first defensive lineman outside the B gap (the dive key) for a handoff to the dive back, then reads the next man outside (the pitch key) for a keep or a pitch to the other back. Two defenders left unblocked, three ball carriers, and nobody on the line has to block either of the two best players on that side. (My own Ohio high-school team ran a version of it one fall, for reasons that had everything to do with a 165-pound quarterback. That story is the second case study for this chapter.)
POST-SNAP — Split-back inside veer (the triple option, in brief)
M $ <-- alley/QB help
]
Y arcs to the alley player
T N T (E)<-- 1st read: DIVE key (outside B gap)
\
(S)<-- 2nd read: PITCH key
O O O O O zone/veer blocks inside
Q ===> ride the dive back, then attack
: \ the pitch key
B : R ==> dive, B gap
\.......................> pitch back, relationship
📊 Diagram (described): A historical sketch. Two backs line up behind the quarterback. At the snap the quarterback rides the dive back into the B gap while reading the first defensive lineman outside that gap. If that lineman takes the dive, the quarterback pulls the ball and attacks the next defender outside, the pitch key, with the second back running in pitch relationship. The tight end releases outside to block the alley player. Two defenders are read, not blocked.
The wishbone. Emory Bellard, as an assistant at Texas, is widely credited with the wishbone in the late 1960s: a fullback directly behind the quarterback and two halfbacks behind him, built to run the triple option in both directions. Oklahoma and Alabama were among the programs that made it famous through the 1970s. Nebraska under Tom Osborne ran an I-formation option attack for decades.
The flexbone. The flexbone moves the wishbone's halfbacks up to wing alignments, where they can motion, block the alley, or become the pitch back, and spreads two receivers wide. It's associated with Paul Johnson (Georgia Southern, Navy, Georgia Tech) and is still common at the service academies. If you want to see the pitch phase coached at its purest, watch Navy, Army, or Air Force.
The spread option. In the 1990s and 2000s, college coaches moved the option into the shotgun. Rich Rodriguez is widely credited with developing the shotgun zone read, Urban Meyer built a spread-option attack that won national titles at Florida, and Chris Ault's Pistol at Nevada put the back directly behind the quarterback so the zone read could go either way without a tell. Power read, the inverted veer, became widely associated with Auburn's 2010 national-title offense.
The NFL. The NFL kept the option at arm's length for decades, mostly because of the quarterback-hit problem. The 2012 season changed that for a while, when Colin Kaepernick, Robert Griffin III, and Russell Wilson ran the read option with real success. Defenses adjusted, the hit counts piled up, and usage fell back. Then it came back in a new form: the 2019 Ravens, with Lamar Jackson and Greg Roman's run game, set the NFL single-season team rushing record. Most NFL offenses today, ours included, run the option the way that history suggests: as a threat called a few times a game, with a quarterback who can make the read and a coordinator who budgets the hits.
| Era / system | Read key(s) | Who's the "+1" | What modern offenses kept |
|---|---|---|---|
| Split-back veer | Dive key, pitch key | QB reads two defenders | The idea of reading, not blocking, the best defenders |
| Wishbone / I-option | Dive key, pitch key | QB + pitch back | Pitch relationship; arc blocks to the alley |
| Flexbone | Dive key, pitch key; motion | Wings as pitch/arc blockers | Motion to create the pitch phase |
| Spread / zone read | Backside end | QB (keep) | The zone read; bubble as the third option |
| Inverted veer / power read | Play-side end | QB (inside, behind a puller) | Gap-scheme options |
| RPO era | A linebacker or nickel | QB's arm | The pass as the option (Chapter 13) |
🔄 Check your understanding: The split-back veer reads two defenders. Name them, and say which modern play kept the second read (the pitch phase) and which kept the first (a handoff read at the mesh).
Answer
The dive key (the first defensive lineman outside the B gap) and the pitch key (the next man outside). The speed option is the pitch phase on its own: no dive, straight to the pitch key. The zone read is a descendant of the dive-key read: a handoff decision at the mesh based on one defender, now the backside end instead of a play-side lineman. Inside Read Bubble puts a version of both back together, with the bubble standing in for the pitch.
📋 Try it: Find the conflict. The Birmingham Forge (fictional) play Cover 1 and Cover 0 on most early downs, with a nickel aligned inside Powers in the left slot, a Will linebacker at five yards over Achterberg, and a free safety at 14 yards. Their defensive end on the left aligns very wide (what many defenses call a "wide 9") and rushes upfield on every snap. Austin is in "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right." Name the conflict defender for Inside Read Bubble, and say which option he's most likely to leave open.
Worked answer
In man coverage, the nickel is matched on Powers. If Powers runs the bubble, the nickel goes with him, so he can't help on the quarterback. The Will is the only box defender left on that side. The wide-9 end who rushes upfield is a give read every time, because he isn't taking the back, so the first decision probably sends the ball to Ruffin. The conflict defender is the Will: he's the only player who can take either the dive or a keep. If he fills inside on the dive, a keep (when the end does close) has nobody but the free safety at 14 yards. Since the end will rarely give you a keep read, the sharper call against the Forge is to read the Will himself: check to Inside Slant and let Vance read him for the handoff or the throw (Chapter 13). Man defenses turn their backs on the quarterback, which is why options work so well against them, as long as someone is reading the one defender who isn't turned around.
12.9 The Cost: How Much Can Your Quarterback Run?
Here is the bill. Every option play in this chapter gets its numbers by making the quarterback a potential ball carrier, and every ball carrier gets hit. When Vance keeps, he takes hits from linebackers and safeties. Sometimes he takes one when he doesn't keep, because the read end is allowed to play him as a runner while the fake is still live.
📈 By the numbers: Marisol Vega's season chart (fictional) on our Inside Read family, all versions: called 88 times. Vance kept 27 times (about 31%), the other 61 went to the back. On the keeps, success rate (by the usual definition: 40% of the yards to go on first down, 60% on second, all of it on third and fourth) was about 52%. On the gives it was about 46%, close to our plain inside zone. The difference is small, and with 27 keeps the sample is too small to call it real. Marisol says so in a footnote on every slide. The more useful number is the one in the four-game sample that Sacramento charted on us before Week 6: 12 designed quarterback runs in 4 games (7 zone-read keeps, 3 draws, 2 quarterback powers), or about three per game. League-wide, public charting over recent seasons has tended to show designed quarterback runs producing better efficiency than running-back carries, with a caveat that applies to every number in this book: offenses choose when to call them, so the comparison flatters the quarterback runs.
Three a game was not an accident. Before the season, Wade Harmon, Rome Pettaway, and I sat down with Marisol's numbers and agreed on what we call the budget: about three designed quarterback carries a game in the regular season, counting keeps, draws, and quarterback powers, and as many as five in a playoff game, with Wade's sign-off. Scrambles don't count against it, because Vance's scrambles are his own decisions on pass plays (Rome's four scramble rules govern those). The budget isn't about any single carry. It's about the season-long count of hits our quarterback can take and still be our quarterback in January.
Here's what the budget does to the option game. If Vance can only keep three times a game, the zone read has to make its money mostly on the give. Its real job is to freeze the backside end so plain inside zone works better, and the keep is the punishment for an end who ignores him. That's why we charted a different number than yards per keep: Rollins's first step on first and second down after the zone read showed up. In Game 1, after the opening-drive touchdown, Teo charted that first step on the early downs that followed, and on most of them it was a shuffle and a look at Vance, not a rush. He was honoring a keep we weren't going to call again for a while. Rollins finished that game with two pressures on thirty-one rushes. Not all of that was the zone read, but some of it was. That hesitation is the yardage the keep earns when it isn't called.
| Quarterback profile | Options that fit | Options to avoid or limit |
|---|---|---|
| Fast, light, durable passer | Zone read (keeps outside), speed option (pitch early), bubble tags | Power read, Bash (inside carries) |
| Big, strong, average speed | Power read, QB power, zone read | Speed option (the pitch-phase hit at full speed) |
| Elite passer, limited runner | Zone read as a give-first threat, bubble/RPO tags | Anything that needs him to keep more than once or twice |
| Your best player on both sides (high school) | Pick one option and run it well | A full menu: he's also your safety |
🪞 Learning check-in: Stop and check yourself against the threshold concept before you go on. Can you explain to a skeptical left tackle, in two sentences, why leaving the end unblocked isn't a blown assignment? When you watch a zone read on film, do you look at the end, or at the linebacker behind him? You should be looking at both, and the linebacker tells you the call. Could you sort the six counters in 12.5 by the defensive answer each one beats, without looking? If any of those feels shaky, it's usually the defensive answers. Reread 12.4 with a pencil and draw Swap and Sit yourself from memory. Most coaches learn the option from the offense's side and never learn the defense's side, and the defense's side is the half that tells you what to call next.
🏫 Any level: In high school, the budget question is sharper. Your quarterback may play defense, return punts, and be the only player on the roster who can throw a spiral. Two keeps a game might be the right number for him even if he's the fastest player on the field. In college you have scholarship depth, but a spread-option team's backup quarterback usually can't run the same offense, so an injured starter means changing the whole menu. Whatever your level, write the budget down before the season, decide who's allowed to break it (head coach? coordinator?), and track it on the call sheet, because nobody counts carries in the fourth quarter of a close game.
🔄 Check your understanding: If Vance only keeps the ball about three times a game, how does the zone read still help the offense on the other plays?
Answer
It changes what the backside end can do. As long as the zone read is on film and the keep is a real threat, the end can't crash freely on every inside run or rush upfield recklessly on every pass. He has to honor the quarterback. That hesitation helps plain inside zone (less backside pursuit) and play-action (an end who freezes on the fake). The keep is the punishment. The threat is the value.
Spaced Review
Before you look at the answers, try these from memory.
1. From Chapter 9 (Inside Zone): On plain inside zone, what does the back read, and how is the backside of the line blocked? What single change turns inside zone into the zone read?
Answer
On inside zone, the back aims at the play-side guard's outside leg and reads the first down lineman play-side of the center: bang (hit it front-side), bounce (if it spills), or bend (cut back). The backside is cut off. The backside tackle and end are blocked so they can't chase the cutback. The zone read changes one thing: the backside tackle steps inside and leaves the backside end unblocked, and the quarterback reads that end. The back's track and read stay the same. Only the end's blocker changes, from a lineman to a decision. See Chapter 9.
2. From Chapter 7 (Defensive Structure): What box count would you call "light" against 11 personnel, and why does a light box against a two-high shell make the zone read less necessary?
Answer
Six or fewer is light against 11 personnel. If the defense gives you six in the box and you have six blockers (five linemen plus an attached tight end), you can block them all, and the run doesn't need a read to have a hat for every hat. The option matters most when the box is neutral or loaded, when the defense has its plus-one in the box and you need the quarterback to cancel it. (The defense still has its alley safety against a light box, which is why the option stays useful there too.) See Chapter 7.
3. From Chapter 5 (The Offensive Line): How many gaps do five linemen and one attached tight end create? What does a running quarterback add?
Answer
Five linemen make six gaps (A, B, and C on each side). An attached tight end adds a D gap on his side, for seven. A running quarterback adds one more, the option's plus-one, so the defense needs an extra defender (or an extra assignment) just to account for him. That's the gap-language version of 12.1.
Project Checkpoint: Option Package
Last chapter you built your Gap Scheme Sheet: power and counter, who pulls, who kicks, who wraps, plus one trap. Now you'll make one of your runs, or both families, into an option.
This chapter's deliverable: the Option Package. It's a two- to three-page document containing:
- Your zone read (or your base read option if you aren't a zone team). For it, write: - the call name and the formations you'll run it from (at least two); - the read key and why you chose him (backside end? play-side end? a linebacker?); - an assignment table by position, like the one in 12.2; - the quarterback's read rule in one sentence, plus your mesh rules; - the keep path rules, and your slide/sideline rule.
- One more option (speed option, power read, Bash, Arc, a bubble triple, or a veer read), with the same five pieces.
- The defense's answers. For each play, list the two defensive answers you expect (Swap, Sit, mesh charge, a QB player) and the counter you have on your card for each.
- The budget. How many designed quarterback carries per game, who can break it, and how you'll track it.
A worked piece, from the Outlaws' card:
| Item | Inside Read (Outlaws) |
|---|---|
| Formations | Gun Doubles Right/Left; Gun Trips; Pistol Ace (for the cutback-friendly version) |
| Read key | Backside end. He's usually their best rusher, and reading him takes him out of the run and slows his rush on the next play |
| QB rule | "If he can tackle Jalen, he can't tackle you." Decide by the front hip, otherwise give |
| Expected answers | Swap (end crashes, Will scrapes to QB); Sit (end on QB, Will on the dive) |
| Counters on the card | Arc (vs. Swap), Bash (vs. Sit), Bubble (vs. either, when the nickel is the help) |
| Budget | About 3 designed QB carries a game, 5 in the playoffs with Wade's OK; Rome tracks on the sideline |
Four levels: - High school: One option, maybe two. Many great high school offenses run only the zone read and one counter. Pick your read key for clarity, not cleverness. Write your quarterback's slide rule and practice it every Thursday. - College: A zone read, a pitch-phase option (speed or a bubble triple), and power read if your quarterback is built for it. Plan for your backup quarterback: which of these can he run? - Pro: Option as a threat. Two or three calls a game, each paired with a counter, with the budget agreed on with your head coach before the season. - Film-room: Chart a team's zone reads for one game. For every snap, record the read end's action, the quarterback's decision, the linebacker's first step (scrape or fill), and the result. At the end, say whether the defense had a "Swap" and a "Sit," and whether it mixed them by series.
Next chapter: the third option becomes a throw. In Chapter 13 you'll build your RPO Menu: three run-pass options, each with a named conflict defender and the quarterback's rule for reading him. Your Option Package is the foundation. Every RPO is an option whose read key is a linebacker or a nickel instead of an end.
Chapter Summary
The core idea: the option gets the offense a numbers advantage by leaving one defender unblocked on purpose and reading him. A read defender is "blocked" by a decision: whatever he chooses, the ball goes to the other place. The defense's only real answer is to assign a second defender to the option the first one leaves open, and the offense's answer to that is to block, read, or stress the second defender.
| Play | Read key | Ball carriers | Read rule | Defense's best answer | Offense's counter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zone read ("Inside Read") | Backside end | Back inside, QB outside | End can tackle the back → keep; can't → give | Swap (scrape exchange), Sit (slow-play) | Arc (vs. Swap), Bash (vs. Sit), bubble |
| Triple ("Inside Read Bubble") | Backside end, then nickel | Back, QB, bubble | As above; nickel takes QB → throw bubble | A QB player who isn't the nickel | RPO (Ch 13); play-action |
| Speed option | Pitch key (first man outside the last blocker) | QB, pitch back | Key takes QB → pitch; key widens → keep | "Tackle the QB every time"; alley safety | Arc to the alley; pitch early |
| Power read (inverted veer) | Play-side end | Back outside (sweep), QB inside behind puller | End widens → keep; squeezes → give | Squeeze-and-scrape; a LB over the top | Play-action off the look; zone read the other way |
| Bash | Backside end | Back outside, QB inside on zone | End sits on QB → give wide; widens → keep | Swap (crash into the QB's path) | Go back to the plain zone read |
| Veer (heritage) | Dive key, pitch key | Dive back, QB, pitch back | Two reads in sequence | Assign dive, QB, pitch by name | Arc, load, motion |
The decision framework for an option call: 1. Count. What's the box? Who's the defense's extra man? If you can block everyone, you may not need the read. 2. Pick the key. Read the defender who's hardest to block, or whose hesitation helps your next play. 3. Ask who has the quarterback. Film tells you the defense's answers. Which one did they use last series? 4. Call the counter to the answer you believe, or the hedge (a third option) if you can't tell. 5. Check the budget. Is this carry worth a hit on your quarterback right now?
What's Next
Read Jordan Ames instead of DeShawn Rollins, and make the option a throw instead of a keep, and you have the play that opened our first game against Sacramento: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant." Chapter 13 tells that story snap by snap, explains why the ineligible-downfield rule shapes everything about it, and shows how Russ Kimbrough taught his Will linebacker to stop losing it.