Chapter 23 — Discussion Guide

Opening question

"A report on your desk says, 'They blitz 80 percent of the time on third-and-short.' Before you change a single call, what's the first question you ask?"

Collect answers. Most rooms produce "Who's blitzing?" and "From where?" Both are good, and neither is first. Wait for someone to ask "Out of how many?" If nobody does, ask it yourself and let the silence sit.

Why it works: it puts the chapter's core habit, Marisol's "write '9 of 14,' never '64 percent,'" into the students' mouths before you teach it. It also sets up the second-best question, "Against whom?", which is the lesson of §23.4's context split. Come back to it after question 4.


Discussion questions

Level 1 — Recall

1. What's the difference between a scouting report and a game plan? Which one says "Inside Slant on the first snap"? Listen for: the report describes; the game plan decides. The report says Ames came downhill 14 of 18; the plan says Inside Slant. Probe: "Why keep them separate? What goes wrong when the person who tags the film also decides the call?"

2. Why does Teo tag three passes per game, and why does each use a different camera angle? Listen for: situation (broadcast is fine), coverage (sideline, to see both safeties after the snap), front and fits (end zone, for first steps and eyes). That's 5–7 hours per opponent game. Probe: "What do you do when the angle you need doesn't exist?" (Write "?" and count it. Unknowns are data.)

Level 2 — Analysis

3. Teo found Ames downhill 14 of 18. Lyle said, "Show me the four." Why the four? Listen for: three exceptions came on the snap after a completion behind him, which became "Burned → sits." That's what told Vance which half of Inside Slant to expect on snap 2. Probe: "Name a tendency in your own life, or your team's, where the exceptions would tell you more than the rule."

4. The raw number said 15 of 26 third-and-long pressures. Why did Austin expect much less? Listen for: 8 of 9 came against one rookie-quarterback opponent, 7 of 17 against veterans. Vance is a veteran. Probe: "If you'd only had the 15 of 26, what would you have put on the call sheet, and what would it have cost?"

5. Look at §23.9's two-column table. Rows 1, 3, and 4 held. Row 2 changed. Rows 6, 7, and 8 changed. Why the difference? Listen for: foundations (what the defense is) hold in-season. Row 2 changed because Austin's own 42-of-49 Twelve tendency told Russ which group to build. Rows 6–8 changed because Russ was scouting his own defense. Probe: "Which of your own tendencies wrote the other team's Row 2 for them?"

Level 3 — Judgment and ethics

6. Twenty-nine of twenty-nine. Is a perfect streak the strongest evidence a report can have? Listen for: the chapter's answer is no, or at least not by itself. A streak with no exceptions has nothing to study, and against a coordinator who knows he's charted it may be "an investment." The 🛡️ callout: you only need to fool an offense on the snap it can't afford to lose. Probe: "Then how do you use a streak at all?" (A "since" date, a question mark, and a post-snap answer on the call.)

7. Your quarterback loves numbers and asks for the full third-down table. Your quarterbacks coach says, "Show him clips, not percentages" (Exercise D4). Who's right? Listen for: both, in order. "Earn the tell with the count, teach it with the clip, lock it in with a rep." Rome's line from the Thursday QB room: "Don't tell him the number again. Show him the clip again." Probe: "What happens to a player who's carrying forty items into the game?"

8. A young analyst hands you a page with bare percentages and no question marks. It looks more confident than Teo's. What do you tell him, and what do you tell the head coach who liked it better? Listen for: honesty about uncertainty is a professional obligation, not a style. A confident wrong page gets players hurt and coaches fired; a hedged right page gets checked. Probe: "Is it ever right to hide a small sample to win an argument in the staff room?"


Role-play: the Monday page

Roles: Teo (presents a new tell), Marisol (owns the honesty rules), Lyle (decides whether it goes on the page), and Wade Harmon (asks "How would I defend that?").

The material: Exercise D1. Teo has a tell at 11 of 14, but every clip comes from the opponent's first two games, and the last two games show nothing either way.

Rules: Teo must present the count with its denominator and the exceptions. Marisol may challenge any number but must propose wording, not just objections. Wade must say what the defense would do if it knew about the tell. Lyle must end with an exact row, written on the board in "by situation" format with a "since" column, or a written reason it stays off the page.

What to bring out: the split between "it's true" and "it's still true." A good outcome is something like "11 of 14, first two games only; nothing since," a question mark instead of bold, and a decision column that keeps the call but adds an answer if the tell is gone. Then ask the room what Russ would have done with the same row on his side of the field.


Connecting to the case studies

Case Study 1, "Three Rows, One Afternoon." The Week 6 page on the field: Row 8's Ames tell on the first two snaps (+17, then +7 when he sat); Row 8's creeping nickel on 3rd-and-6 in the third quarter (Powers slant at about 1.1 seconds, +16); and the rare call, Cover 0 at 1 of 26 on third-and-long, which still stayed on the band and decided the game on the 52-yard deep over. Ask: "Which of the three rows would you have been most tempted to cut, and why would that have been the worst cut?"

Case Study 2, "The Report That Expired." Lyle at 26, his second high-school season, Nick Dombrowski and Tony Sabatino, and a new defensive play-caller, Gary Hlavaty. Lyle wrote "garbage? opponent can't throw" next to the only game the new play-caller had called, ignored a Thursday phone call, trailed 10–0, and lost 17–13. Ray Kessler's question is the case: "What did their last game look like? … Then why are you surprised?" Put it next to the divisional page. One coach threw out the newest film; the other trusted the oldest streak. Ask which mistake is more common at the students' level, and why.


Closing synthesis prompt

"Lyle's whiteboard says, in red, 'Never let a tendency outlive its evidence.' Write the row from your own scouting that's most likely to outlive its evidence, and the one change that would protect you."

Have students read their rows aloud. You want "since" dates, question marks, and post-snap answers. Push anyone whose answer is "watch more film"; the chapter's point is that more film of the same streak doesn't help. Close with Lyle's spring line to Russ, "I can't trust my own notes anymore," and the chapter's reframe of it: that sentence isn't defeat. It's the start of a better report.