Chapter 38 Exercises — The Complete Offense
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall · ⭐⭐ application · ⭐⭐⭐ analysis and judgment · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension and independent film study
All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, Forge, and Sidewinders people, games, and numbers are fictional composites. Scenarios marked hypothetical are not part of the season this book follows. Selected answers are in Appendix J.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Define base play, defensive answer, and constraint play in one sentence each. Then give one Outlaws example of all three that belong together.
A2. State the threshold concept of this chapter in your own words. Then describe one habit of a coach who hasn't crossed it yet and one habit of a coach who has.
A3. The chapter says constraint plays "don't punish defenders for mistakes. They punish defenders for being right one snap too long." Explain what that means using Tre Holloway on the Anchor D drive.
A4. Why is tempo described as a multiplier rather than a play? What does it multiply, and what can it multiply that you don't want multiplied?
A5. Name the four beats of the middle-read tag, in order, and say what each one replaces.
A6. What is the design rule "one drop, two answers," and why does a concept without it fail the tag even if both of its throws are good?
A7. Explain the difference between cutting a play from the call sheet and cutting it from the playbook. When does each happen in the Outlaws' year?
A8. List the five big defensive answers from the chapter's defensive-answer table (load the box, and so on) and, for each, say in a few words what it gives up.
A9. Why is "disguise, then rotate after the snap" the hardest defensive answer to price? What is the only kind of play that can punish it?
A10. Marisol Vega's "kill the zeros" rule is described as system maintenance. Explain why a self-scout rule belongs in a chapter about how plays connect.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. You're watching an offense in 11 personnel, 2x2, with the tight end attached right and the back offset left. On three straight first downs it runs inside zone right. On the first two, the field-side safety triggers downhill at the handoff; on the third, the offense fakes the same run and the flanker runs a post behind him for a big gain. Name (a) the base play, (b) the defensive answer, (c) the constraint, and (d) what you would expect the offense to call next if its coordinator thinks the way this chapter does.
B2. Describe what you'd look for on the end-zone camera to tell whether a play-action pass was earned (a constraint cashing a real defensive answer) or hoped for (a play called without one). Name at least three things you'd check.
B3. Study this post-snap picture.
F $ (steps down)
W M
C * C
E N T E
X H O-->O-->O-->O-->O--> Y Z
| \ R ==Q (mesh)
v \ slant (ball out)
📊 Diagram (described): An offense in two-by-two runs inside zone to the right with the back and quarterback meeting at the mesh. On the left, the slot runs a slant and the ball is thrown to him; the outside receiver runs a go. The defense has a Will linebacker on the left side who has moved toward the line, and the strong safety on the right has stepped down.
Which defender was the read key, what did he do, and why did the ball go to the slant? What would the quarterback have done if that defender had stayed in place?
B4. On film, a backside end chases an outside-zone run flat down the line on four straight snaps. On the fifth, the offense runs a boot to the same side the end left. The quarterback is sacked by that end. Using Teo's "chases twice" rule and Marisol's boot table from the chapter, explain one way this could happen even though the end had chased four times.
B5. You see a Cover 2 cornerback sink under a corner route, and the quarterback throws the hitch in front of him for eight yards. A commentator says, "Great coverage, he took away the corner." Write a two-sentence response that a coordinator would give.
B6. Describe the difference you would see on film between a defense that is answering an offense's base play and a defense that is simply beating it with better players. Give one clue for each.
B8. On the broadcast you notice that an offense has run the same play-action pass three times in a game from three different formations, each time after a run from a different formation. The gains were 4 yards, an incompletion, and a sack. What does the System Map say is missing, and how would you check it on the All-22?
B7. Draw (or describe) the pre-snap and post-snap pictures of a play that uses the middle-read tag against a defense that stays two-high. What does the quarterback see on step three, and which throw does he make?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Make the call (hypothetical). Next season, at Sacramento. Q2, Outlaws lead 7–3. 2nd-and-4 at the Sacramento 41. You've run Inside from Eleven, Gun Doubles Right twice on this drive: +6 and +5. Teo's successor in the booth says: "Two high. Six. Holloway at nine and creeping." On the first of those two runs, Ames sat; on the second, he filled. What do you call, and why? Name the defender you're attacking and what happens if he does the other thing.
Answer
A strong answer: "Inside PA, Z Post" (or Inside Glance if you prefer the RPO version). Holloway at nine and creeping is the field safety starting his alley fill earlier; you have two same-look runs as receipts; 2nd-and-4 makes an incompletion cheap (third-and-4 is a medium down you like). The conflict defender is Holloway. If he stays deep instead of filling, the post is covered, and Vance's progression comes down to Powers sitting at 6 for a likely conversion, and you've also learned that the plain Inside has a lighter box the next time. Ames's mixed behavior is a reason not to call Inside Slant: he's not giving you a reliable answer.
C2. Draw it up. Draw the Outlaws' "one picture" (Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Harlan attached right, Ruffin offset left) against a single-high, eight-man box: the strong safety walked down to seven yards outside the tight end. Label the conflict defender, then draw the play that punishes him if he fills and the play that punishes him if he doesn't.
Answer
The conflict defender is the walked-down strong safety, the eighth man, outside Harlan. His run job is to fill the cutback or alley from outside in; his pass job in single-high is the curl/flat or the seam area on his side. If he fills, the punishment is Inside Glance: the line blocks inside zone, Vance reads him at the mesh, and Powers's skinny post goes into the space he left, underneath the middle-of-the-field safety. (Inside PA, Z Post is the shot version, but against single-high the post runs toward the deep safety, so the Glance's shorter window is usually the better first price.) If he stays home, the box is effectively seven, so the punishment is the handoff: "seven or fewer, run it." A complete drawing shows the same first second for both plays: line stepping right, Ruffin to the mesh, Harlan blocking the end man.
C3. Make the call (hypothetical). You're a high school coordinator. Your offense is Power from a two-tight-end wing set, a play-action pass to the tight end off it, and a bubble. Your opponent's strong safety has filled on Power from eight yards on every snap of the first half. It's the third quarter, 1st-and-10 at your own 45, tied 14–14. What do you call on this snap and the next two, and what will you watch for after each?
Answer
A strong sequence: Power first, to confirm the safety is still filling the same way after halftime (the defense may have changed at the break). If he fills, play-action off Power to the tight end behind him on the next early down. If he hesitates after the play-action, back to Power, because a hesitating safety is late to the hole. Watch his first step on each snap. If he stops filling entirely after halftime, your box count improved, so stay on Power and save the play-action. The reasoning matters more than the order: every call should either confirm the answer or cash it.
C4. Make the call. The Outlaws trail 20–17 at 2:41 of the fourth quarter with one timeout, 3rd-and-9 at their own 38. Two-high on third-and-long has held 29 straight times since the opponent's bye. Using this chapter's tools, write the call you'd want next season in that spot, with both throws on the band, and explain why it would still be the right call if the defense stayed two-high.
Answer
"Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, 60 Right, Mills" from the Blue panel, with the middle-read tag printed on it (the band reads OPEN = post, then the safety over #2 | CLOSED = dig, then flat or back). If the defense stays two-high, the tag changes nothing: Vance sees "open" on step three, and Mills is Mills, with the safety over #2 forced to choose between the dig and the post. If the defense rotates, Vance sees "closed" on step three and the dig under the middle safety comes out on the same rhythm; on the divisional-round snap that throw would have converted. The call keeps its upside against the likely look and removes its worst outcome against the unlikely one. A complete answer also notes the clock: with one timeout at 2:41, an incompletion or a short gain to the flat is survivable; an interception isn't.
C5. Draw it up. Draw "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, 60 Right, Mills, Eyes" against a defense that shows two-high and stays two-high. Show the quarterback's eyes on step one and step three, then the read of the safety over #2 and where the ball goes if he jumps the dig.
Answer
Pre-snap: Harlan attached left with Sutton wide left; Powers in the right slot, Gaines wide right; Ruffin on Vance's left, staying in. Two safeties at about thirteen yards. Post-snap: on step one, Vance's eyes go to the grass between the safeties' pre-snap spots; on step three, both safeties are still deep and nobody has arrived in the middle, so it's "open." Now Mills's own read is live: the safety over #2 (on the right, over Powers) has the dig and the post. If he jumps the dig, the post behind him to Gaines is the throw, into the open middle. If he sits on the post, the dig to Powers. Sutton's go and Harlan's flat hold the left side. The ball comes out on the same rhythm either way.
C6. Make the call (hypothetical). A division opponent has started rushing four with its edge rushers flying upfield on every 3rd-and-8 or longer, with both safeties deep. Your quarterback has been sacked twice in two weeks on those downs. Choose a two-call plan for third-and-long against this team and explain which defensive answer each call punishes.
Answer
One good plan: a Slip or Middle screen and a Draw, each built for an upfield four-man rush with two deep safeties. The screen invites the rushers past the launch point and throws behind them; the draw uses the same rush angle against a light box. Neither has to convert every time; their job is to make the edges hesitate on the next third-and-long, which helps the dropback concepts. Pair them with the rule from Chapter 26: on long-long, keep the ball and improve the next decision (field goal range, a manageable fourth down).
C7. Draw it up. Draw a minimum viable offense map for a college team whose engine is outside zone. Show at least five defensive answers and the play that punishes each, and mark which side of a college field (field or boundary) each play is best run to.
Answer
One good map: engine outside zone (toward the field when the back needs room to bounce, toward the boundary when the defense sets its strength to the field). Prices: backside end chases → boot toward the field, where the quarterback has grass to run and throw; force player flattens and fast-flows → cutback/Slice, often best into the boundary where the flow comes from; linebackers flow hard → play-action dig or crosser behind them; eighth man down → bubble or now screen to the field, where the wide college hash leaves room; corner squats on the quick game → hitch-and-go to the boundary, where the throw is shortest. A complete answer explains each side choice with the college hash: the boundary is short and fast to throw to, the field is wide and good for space plays.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Marisol's early-season ledger had plain Inside from Gun Doubles at about zero expected points per play over 58 calls while the play-action and RPOs from the same picture were well positive. A new head coach wants to cut the plain runs by half. Write the argument you'd make to him in three sentences, and say what evidence would change your mind.
D2. The chapter claims a constraint system "doesn't need the defense to make mistakes. It needs the defense to make choices." Describe a defense that would be hardest for such a system to beat, and say what the offense should do against it.
D3. Fast tempo after a 15-yard gain is one of the Outlaws' triggers; "no Fast with a fourth-quarter lead" is one of its vetoes. Write a situation in which the trigger and the veto are both live, decide, and justify the decision in terms of what tempo multiplies.
D4. The middle-read tag adds a read for the quarterback on the most pressured down of the game. What is the risk to execution of adding it, and what in the tag's design and practice rules is meant to control that risk? Is it enough?
D5. Curtis Bale's year-two offense had more than forty pass concepts in a game plan by midseason. Argue the strongest case for that volume, then explain why this chapter rejects it.
D6. A head coach asks you for "the one play we can always call when we need a first down." Using this chapter's threshold concept, explain why you can't give him one, and give him the answer you can: a short description of the two or three calls you'd choose between and what you'd watch to choose.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 38 + Chapter 13, RPOs + Chapter 9, Inside Zone.) The Outlaws' rule since Week 2 is "seven or fewer, run it; eight, take the throw." Show how that rule is a row of the System Map. Then explain what happens to the map if a defense learns to play eight in the box only after the snap (a safety who triggers from depth).
M2. (Ch 38 + Chapter 22, Pass Protection.) "Every protection has an answer for one more rusher than it blocks" is an Outlaws non-negotiable. Explain how the Game 2 sack showed a hole in the map even though that rule was being followed on paper, and how the Game 3 rule filled it.
M3. (Ch 38 + Chapter 19, Play-Action + Chapter 29, The Shanahan System.) Chapter 29 says "the run's value includes the value it lends," and Chapter 19 says you don't call play-action, you cash it. Use the System Map's dead-parent test to explain what happens to an offense that keeps calling its boot after it stops calling outside zone.
M4. (Ch 38 + Chapter 25, Play Calling.) Chapter 25 says a call is a bet on a distribution. How does the middle-read tag change the distribution of outcomes for Mills on third-and-long? Describe the tail it shrinks and the cost, if any, to the middle of the distribution.
M5. (Ch 38 + Chapter 23, The Scouting Report + Chapter 28, Analytics.) Teo's rule after the divisional loss is that perfect streaks get a question mark, not a bold. Connect that rule to the System Map: which arrow does a perfect streak tempt you to leave empty, and why?
M6. (Ch 38 + Chapter 33, Trick Plays.) The Week 13 reverse against Albuquerque was called once. Using the constraint loop, explain why its most valuable result was the Q3 jet sweep for eleven, not the 31-yard reverse.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Build a real team's map. Choose an NFL offense you can watch in full (All-22 if you have it, the broadcast if not). Over two games, chart every first- and second-down snap from its single most common formation: personnel, the play family, and what the most-stressed defender did. Build its System Map from the outside. Mark every arrow you can see with a snap and every arrow you suspect but can't prove with a "?". Then predict one call it will make in its next game when a specific defensive answer appears, and check.
E2. Find a family. Using a public play-by-play source (such as the nflverse community's data), group one team's plays by formation and personnel where the data allow, and compare the plain runs from one look to the play-action passes from the same look. Then write a paragraph, in Marisol's voice, on what your table can and cannot prove about whether the runs made the passes better.
E3. Watch for the empty arrow. Watch a full game and find the snap where one offense was beaten by a defensive answer it had no price for. Describe the answer, the snap, and the play you would have needed on the call sheet. Then watch that offense's next game and see whether the arrow got filled.