The placemat is framed now. It hangs on the wall of my office in Austin, between a game ball and a photo
In This Chapter
- The Hook: The Placemat and the Flag
- 3.1 What a Formation Is, and What It Isn't
- 3.2 The Rules of the Line: Legality, Numbering, Gaps, and Techniques
- 3.3 Backfield Sets: Where the Quarterback and the Backs Stand
- 3.4 Strength: Who Decides Which Side Is "Right"?
- 3.5 The Families: 2x2, 3x1, Trey, and Nub
- 3.6 Compressed Sets: Bunch, Stack, and Nasty Splits
- 3.7 Changing the Count: Unbalanced Lines, Wings, and Empty
- 3.8 The Five Things a Formation Does to a Defense
- 3.9 Formationing: Many Looks, Few Plays, and the Self-Scout
- Spaced Review
- Project Checkpoint: Formation Family
- Chapter Summary
- What's Next
Chapter 3 — Formations: How 11 Players Can Line Up in 500 Ways — and Why Each Alignment Creates Different Advantages
The Hook: The Placemat and the Flag
The placemat is framed now. It hangs on the wall of my office in Austin, between a game ball and a photo of my father behind the grill. It's the paper kind, with the diner's name across the top and a cartoon gyro in the corner, and on the back, in blue ballpoint, there's a formation I drew on a Thursday night in late October, about twenty years ago, when I was the offensive coordinator at a high school in northeast Ohio and we had a second-round playoff game the next night.
The formation was an unbalanced line. I took our left tackle, a 270-pound senior who could move a car, and lined him up on the right side, outside our right tackle. Now there were four linemen to the right of the center and one to the left. The tight end went to the right side too, outside both tackles. On paper it looked like a wall leaning to one side.
The defense we were playing set its front by counting from the center: so many linemen to this side, so many to that side. I had watched four games of their film, and they never moved their front for anything. If I gave them a line that was heavier on one side, they'd line up against where the center was, not where the beef was. They'd be a gap short on the right, and nobody would notice until we were five yards downfield.
Friday night, first snap of the second half, down 14–10, I called it. Three runs to the heavy side: 9 yards, 7 yards, 12 yards. Their coordinator was screaming on the sideline. Their linebackers were pointing at each other. We were at their 18, and I had the play I'd been saving. Same formation, fake the same run, and the tight end slips out the back side of the play into the flat where nobody lives, because everybody is running at the overload.
It worked exactly like the placemat. The tight end caught it at the 10 with nobody within eight yards of him and walked into the end zone. Our sideline went over the bench. I hugged a man I'd never met.
Then I saw the flag.
Our flanker, a sophomore named Danny Kostas who had been on the varsity for three weeks, had lined up on the line of scrimmage instead of a yard off it. He was standing outside the tight end. And when a receiver stands on the line outside the tight end, the tight end is no longer on the end of the line. He's covered up. He's an interior lineman, as far as the rulebook is concerned. He can block, but he cannot legally catch a forward pass. The touchdown came off the board, the penalty pushed us back, and four plays later we kicked a field goal that hit the upright. We lost 14–10.
I didn't sleep that night. I sat in the diner after close with my father, and he asked me what happened, and I tried to explain it, and he listened, and then he said the only thing I remember: "So the drawing was right and the boy was in the wrong place."
That's this chapter. A formation is the first thing the offense says to the defense on every snap, and it says a lot. Where you put eleven people can steal a gap from the defense before anyone moves. It can pull a linebacker out of the box. It can leave one cornerback on an island with nobody behind him. It can force a defensive coordinator to declare what he thinks your strength is, and if he guesses wrong, the play is half won before the snap. But a formation is also a contract with the rulebook, a habit the defense can study, and a set of alignments eleven people have to get right in seven seconds.
Danny Kostas is a dentist in Akron now. He sends me a Christmas card every year. The first one said, "Sorry about the flag, Coach." I wrote back that it was my fault. It was. I had drawn the formation and never taught the alignment rule that made it legal. The drawing was right. I hadn't put the boy in the right place.
🏃 Fast Track: If you already know the names (2x2, 3x1, trey, bunch, empty, unbalanced) and the legality rules, skim 3.1–3.3 and slow down at 3.4 (how strength forces the defense to declare), 3.8 (the five things a formation does to a defense), and 3.9 (formationing and the self-scout). Do the Project Checkpoint.
🔬 Deep Dive: Appendix A collects every alignment term, receiver number, gap letter, and technique number in one place: Appendix A. How formations interact with personnel continues in Chapter 4, and how the defense reads your formation from its side is in Chapter 7. Motion, the formation that changes while you watch, is Chapter 27.
📺 Film Watcher: This Sunday, before each snap, say out loud how many receivers are on each side and where the tight end is. Then watch the safeties. Within a quarter you'll start to see the defense answer the formation before the ball moves.
3.1 What a Formation Is, and What It Isn't
A formation is where the eleven offensive players stand when the ball is snapped. That's all it is. It is not the play, and it is not the personnel.
Those three things get mixed up constantly, even by people who coach, so let's pull them apart. Our fictional Austin Outlaws run a call like "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant." Every word in that call does a different job:
| Piece of the call | Example | What it tells the players |
|---|---|---|
| Personnel | "Eleven" | Who is on the field: one running back, one tight end, three wide receivers |
| Formation | "Gun Doubles Right" | Where they stand: QB in the shotgun with a back beside him; two receivers on each side; the tight end on the right |
| Play | "Inside Slant" | What they do after the snap: inside zone run, with a slant attached for the QB to read |
The same personnel can line up in a dozen formations. The same formation can run a hundred plays. The same play can be run from a dozen formations. That separation is the whole point. If formation and play were welded together, the defense would know the play the moment you broke the huddle.
Why the offense gets to go first
Here is the structural fact that makes formations matter. The offense lines up first, and the defense has to answer. The defense can disguise, shift, and rotate after it sees you, but it cannot line up until it knows where you are. Every defensive call sheet in the league is organized, in part, by formation: "versus 2x2, we play this; versus 3x1, we check to that; versus empty, we're in this."
So the formation is a question the offense asks. Where will you put your safeties against two receivers on each side? Who covers the third receiver when I put three to one side? How many men will you leave in the box when I spread you out? Which way will you set your front when my tight end is on one side and my receivers are on the other?
Every answer the defense gives tells you something. And because the defense must answer on every single snap, you get to ask a question on every single snap. That's what I mean when I tell Teo that formations are free information. You don't have to run a play to learn something. You just have to line up.
The "500 ways" problem
Coaches love to say eleven players can line up in "five hundred ways." Treat that as a magnitude, not a count. Let's do the arithmetic honestly with only the choices our offense actually coaches. We have roughly seven backfield sets (under center, I, offset I, shotgun, pistol, split backs, no back at all). We have roughly ten receiver distributions (2x2, 3x1, trey, nub, bunch, stack, quads, empty, wing, an unbalanced line). Every one can go right or left. Every receiver can take a normal split or a reduced one, and sometimes a wide one, so call that three split options.
Seven times ten is seventy. Times two directions is 140. Times three split choices is 420. And we haven't added motion, shifts, or personnel. Add a dozen motions and a handful of personnel groupings and the number of distinct pictures runs into the thousands.
Nobody uses all of those, and nobody should. The question isn't "how many formations can we make?" It's "how many can eleven people line up in correctly, at game speed, on a 40-second play clock, after a 9-yard run, in a road stadium?" Playbooks vary widely across the league. Many NFL offenses carry somewhere between a couple dozen and several dozen base formation families and then multiply them with tags and motions. We carry twelve formation words, six backfield words, and two directions. On a typical Sunday we show somewhere between 25 and 35 distinct formations. That's plenty, if each one is asking a question we want answered.
💡 Coach's point: A formation earns its spot in the playbook by forcing the defense to do something. If it doesn't change what they do, it's a costume, and costumes cost practice time.
🔄 Check your understanding: In "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant," which word would change if the Outlaws kept the same players and the same play but put three receivers on one side?
Answer
Only the formation word. "Doubles" (two receivers on each side) would become "Trips" (three receivers to one side) or "Trey" (three to one side with the attached tight end as the third). The personnel ("Eleven") and the play ("Inside Slant") stay the same. Whether the slant still makes sense from the new alignment is a separate question, and it's the kind of question this chapter teaches you to ask.
3.2 The Rules of the Line: Legality, Numbering, Gaps, and Techniques
Before a formation can be clever, it has to be legal. My placemat taught me that the expensive way. The rules below are the NFL's in broad strokes. College and high school codes differ in details, and the details change, so check your current rulebook before you install anything that lives near the edge.
Seven on the line, and only the ends are eligible
At the snap, the offense must have at least seven players on the line of scrimmage. The other four (or fewer) are backs, at least a yard behind the line or, for the quarterback, directly under center.
Of the players on the line, only the two on the ends are eligible receivers. Everyone between them is an interior lineman and may not catch a forward pass. The backs are all eligible. (The quarterback's own eligibility depends on where he lines up and which code you play under. Keep it simple and check the rule.)
That's why the X receiver and the Z receiver are different positions even though both are wide receivers. The X (split end) is on the line. He is the end on his side. The Z (flanker) is off the line, a yard back. He's technically a back. On the side where the tight end is attached, the tight end is the end of the line, so the Z must line up off the line or he'll cover the tight end up. That is Danny Kostas's lesson, and it's the most common formation penalty in football at every level.
LEGAL: Gun Doubles Right (7 on the line; X and Y are the ends)
ON LINE: X O O O O O Y
OFF LINE: H Z
Q R
COVERED UP: Z steps onto the line outside Y
ON LINE: X O O O O O Y Z
OFF LINE: H
Q R
(Y is now an interior lineman: ineligible to catch a pass)
📊 Diagram (described): In the top picture, seven players stand on the line: the split end X on the far left, five offensive linemen with the center in the middle, and the tight end Y attached on the right. The slot H, the flanker Z, the quarterback, and the running back are all off the line, so X and Y are the two eligible ends. In the bottom picture, the flanker Z has stepped up onto the line outside the tight end. Now Z is the end on that side, and the tight end is covered up: legally he is an interior lineman and cannot catch a forward pass.
Notice the bottom picture has eight players on the line, which is legal. The formation itself isn't illegal. The penalty only comes if the covered player catches a pass or goes downfield illegally on a pass. That's what makes it a trap: nobody throws a flag until the worst moment.
Ineligible numbers and reporting
In the NFL, players wearing numbers 50 through 79 are ineligible by number. If one of them is going to line up as an eligible receiver, he must report to the referee first, and the referee announces it to the defense. That's how our sixth lineman, Rodney Kalu (#70), becomes a goal-line tight end in our "Jumbo" package. The codes also require a minimum number of ineligible-numbered players on the line in a normal scrimmage formation. The exact requirements and exceptions differ by level and have been adjusted over the years, so check the rule you play under.
Shifts and motion, briefly
Two more rules shape formations, and Chapter 27 covers both in depth. In the NFL, only one player may be in motion at the snap, and he may not be moving toward the line of scrimmage. And after a shift (two or more players changing position), everyone must be set for one full second before the snap. The motion man must be a back. A player on the line can't go in motion without first resetting off the line. That's another reason teams like having the Z off the line: he's the receiver who can go in motion without any extra steps. College and high school codes differ in details. Check yours.
Receiver numbering: count from the outside in
On each side of the ball, number the eligible receivers from the outside in: the widest is #1, the next is #2, the next is #3. A tight end attached to the line counts in that sequence. In Gun Doubles Right with Harlan attached, Gaines (Z) is #1 to the right and Harlan (Y) is #2. On the left, Sutton (X) is #1 and Powers (H) is #2. If we move Powers to the right, he becomes #2 and Harlan becomes #3.
Defenses number the same way, and it matters. A Quarters safety might be told "read #2." A Cover 3 outside linebacker might be told "carry #2 vertical." The moment you change who #2 is, you change who that defender is reading. Much of the formation game is just reassigning numbers.
Gaps and technique numbers
Gaps are the spaces between blockers. The A gap is between the center and a guard. The B gap is between a guard and a tackle. The C gap is between the tackle and the tight end (or outside the tackle if there's no tight end). The D gap is outside the tight end. Five linemen create six gaps (an A, B, and C on each side). Each attached tight end or wing adds another. That's the arithmetic behind half of this chapter: adding a blocker to the surface adds a gap the defense must fill.
Defensive linemen are described by technique numbers, which say where they line up on the offensive line. A 0-technique is head-up on the center; a 1 is shaded on the center; a 2i is on the inside shade of the guard; a 2 is head-up on the guard; a 3 is on the guard's outside shade; a 4i is on the tackle's inside shade; a 4 is head-up on the tackle; a 5 is on the tackle's outside shade; a 7 is on the inside shade of the tight end; a 6 is head-up on the tight end; a 9 is on the tight end's outside shade. Some systems swap 6 and 7. Know which one your staff uses.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Doubles Right, 11 personnel, vs. Nickel two-high
$ F
C * W M C
E T N E
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
gaps: D C B A A B C D
numbers: #1 #2 #2 #1
📊 Diagram (described): The Outlaws' base look. On the left, the split end X is the #1 receiver and the slot H is #2. On the right, the flanker Z is #1 and the tight end Y, attached to the right tackle, is #2. The quarterback is in the shotgun with the running back beside him. Under the line are the gaps: A next to the center, B between guard and tackle, C outside the tackle (or between the tackle and tight end), and D outside the tight end. Against it, the Sacramento nickel shows four down linemen, two linebackers, a nickel defender over the slot, two corners, and two deep safeties.
Count the defenders in the box (inside the tight end and the tackle, within about five yards of the line): four linemen and two linebackers make six. Count our blockers: five linemen and Harlan make six. Six on six, with two safeties deep. Hold that number. It will matter in 3.5.
⚠️ Common mistake: drawing formations nobody coached. A staff draws a clever formation on Tuesday, installs the play on Wednesday, and never drills the alignment. On Sunday the Z covers the Y, or the slot lines up on the line and leaves only six on it. Fix: every new formation gets an alignment rep in the walk-through before it gets a play rep. Our rule: "If it's new this week, the first rep is just lining up, and the referee is Teo with a whistle."
🔄 Check your understanding: In Gun Doubles Right, the Outlaws motion Powers (H) from the left slot to the right side, just outside Harlan, and he sets. Who are #1, #2, and #3 to the right now, and who is #1 to the left?
Answer
To the right, counting outside in: Gaines (Z) is #1, Powers (H) is #2, and Harlan (Y), the attached tight end, is #3. To the left, Sutton (X) is now alone as #1. The formation has become a 3x1 with the tight end as #3, which the Outlaws call "Trey." Any defender keyed on "#2 to the right" is now reading Powers instead of Harlan.
3.3 Backfield Sets: Where the Quarterback and the Backs Stand
Before you distribute receivers, you decide where the quarterback and the running backs stand. This choice shapes the run game, the play-action game, the protection, and what the quarterback can see.
Our backfield words are Under (quarterback under center), Gun (shotgun, about five yards deep, back beside him), Pistol (shotgun at about four yards, back directly behind him), I (two backs stacked behind an under-center QB), Offset (two backs with the fullback shaded to one side; the classic offset I), and Split (two backs side by side, one on each side of the quarterback). And when there's no back at all, the formation word is Empty.
BACKFIELD SETS (offense only, line = O O O O O)
UNDER (one back) I OFFSET (offset I)
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
Q Q Q
B B
R R R
GUN (back beside) PISTOL SPLIT (gun)
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
Q R Q R Q B
R
EMPTY (no back)
O O O O O
Q (all five eligibles spread out wide)
📊 Diagram (described): Seven backfield sets, each drawn under a five-man line. Under center has the quarterback's hands at the center with a single back about seven yards deep. The I puts a fullback and then the tailback in a straight line behind the quarterback. The offset I moves the fullback a step to one side. The shotgun puts the quarterback about five yards deep with the back beside him. The pistol puts the quarterback about four yards deep with the back directly behind him. Split backs puts one back on each side of a shotgun quarterback. Empty has no back at all: the quarterback stands alone in the shotgun and all five eligible receivers are spread out.
Each set buys something and costs something. The table is how we teach it.
| Set | What it gives you | What it costs you | Outlaws use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under | Downhill run game; true play-action with the QB's back to the defense; hard-to-read run direction | QB loses sight of the defense on the drop; slower to get the ball out | Short yardage, four-minute, some 12-personnel boot |
| I / Offset | A lead blocker; runs to either side; the fullback can insert, kick out, or leak | Defense knows a second blocker is coming; fewer receivers to spread | 21/22 personnel with Sione Fale (#44); goal line |
| Gun | QB sees everything; quick game is quicker; mesh for RPOs and zone read | The back's alignment can tip run direction; weaker true play-action | Our base: most of our snaps |
| Pistol | Gun vision plus a downhill back who can go either way; hides run direction | Back is deep, so some protections take longer to fit | A change-up on early downs |
| Split | Two backs for protection or option; run either way with a lead | Fewer receivers; defense keeps more men in the box | Two-minute protection, some option |
| Empty | Five receivers stretch the coverage; the QB sees coverage clearly | Five blockers only; the QB is the "sixth blocker" with the hot throw | Third-and-medium, two-minute |
The back's alignment talks
Here is the first self-scout lesson of the chapter, and it's about one man. In the shotgun, the back stands beside the quarterback, left or right. Many shotgun run plays are cleaner if the back starts on the side opposite the run (so the mesh happens moving toward the hole), and many protections put the back on a particular side. So the back's alignment can tell the defense the run direction or the protection before the snap.
That's why the pistol exists, at least in part. Chris Ault built his pistol offense at Nevada in the mid-2000s around a back directly behind a short-shotgun quarterback. With the back behind the QB, the defense can't read the run direction from where he stands, and the back can still run downhill. We borrow it as a change-up. If Marisol's self-scout says Ruffin's alignment is predicting run direction on more than about two-thirds of our gun runs, we either flip some of them or move to Pistol for a week.
🧩 Productive struggle: Before you read on, try this. You're the defense. The Outlaws line up in Gun with Ruffin on the quarterback's left. You know that Austin's inside zone usually starts with the back opposite the run, and that their base protection puts the back on the "man" side of the slide. What two things might you guess about the play before the snap, and what could Austin do to make both guesses wrong?
One way to think about it
A defense with that self-scout would lean toward "if it's inside zone, it's going right" (back left, run right) and "if it's a dropback, the line is sliding right and the back is checking the left side." Austin can break both with the same alignment: run inside zone to the back's side some of the time (a "same-side" mesh), and put the back on the slide side in a different protection. Or move to Pistol so the back gives nothing away. The broader principle: any alignment that predicts the play is a tell, and a tell is only useful to the defense until you break it on purpose.🏫 Any level: In high school, under-center and two-back sets survive longer than in the NFL for a good reason: they're simpler to protect and easier to block for a line that practices two hours a day, not six. If your quarterback can't read a defense from the shotgun yet, under center with a clean play-action game is not old-fashioned. It's honest. And the shotgun snap is a skill: if your center can't deliver it at chest height every time, the formation is costing you more than it's buying you.
3.4 Strength: Who Decides Which Side Is "Right"?
Every formation has a strength, a side the formation leans toward. The offense names a direction for its own communication. The defense declares a strength for its own alignment. These are two different decisions made by two different staffs, and they don't have to agree. When they don't, somebody is in the wrong place.
The offense's strength rule
Our rule is short, because it has to survive a rookie in a road stadium. The direction word in the formation call names the side of the attached tight end. "Gun Doubles Right" means Harlan is attached on the right. With two tight ends, the direction follows the Y, Brooks Harlan; Cody Brandt (the U) goes where the formation word puts him. If no tight end is attached, the direction names the side with the most receivers, the passing strength. If the formation is balanced and nobody is attached, it names the Y's side wherever he stands; in Ten personnel, with no tight end on the field, it names the Z's side.
Why bother? Because the rest of the call depends on it. Our linemen's run rules start with "play side" and "back side." Our routes are drawn to the call side and mirrored to the other. When Vance says "Doubles Right," eleven people know where to stand and which side every rule refers to. That's all strength means to the offense. It's a reference point.
The defense's strength rules
The defense needs a reference point too, because its front, its linebackers, and its coverage all set off strength. But the defense picks its strength by its own rule, and different defenses use different rules. Here are the common ones:
| Defensive strength rule | "Strength" is set to… | What it's good at | How the offense attacks it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Field | The wide side of the field | Simple; matches where most space is | Put the tight end (your run strength) into the boundary |
| Tight end | The attached tight end | Matches the run strength | Detach the tight end, flip him, or put him alone opposite the receivers |
| Passing strength | The side with the most receivers | Matches the pass threat | Put your extra receivers away from your tight end (nub) |
| Back | The running back's side, or the side of the fullback offset | Matches the run read | Move the back late; use pistol |
| Call/check | Whatever the linebacker calls after seeing the formation | Flexible | Shift or motion after his call so his call is stale |
No rule is wrong. Each one leaves something. A field-strength defense is never caught with its front pointed at the short side. It is caught when the run strength is in the boundary. A tight-end-strength defense always has its front set to the run. It's vulnerable when the tight end isn't where the passes are going.
The duo into the boundary
Here's the clearest example I have. In Game 1 against our fictional division rival, the Sacramento Sentinels (Week 6 at our place, a game we won 34–27), their defense set its front strength to the field. Every snap. We'd seen it on tape and we built a plan around it: if their front goes to the wide side no matter what, put our tight end and our run strength into the short side.
Late in the first quarter, up 10–7, we had 1st-and-10 at the Austin 34 with the ball on the left hash. We called "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Duo." Harlan attached on the left, into the boundary. Their front set to the field, away from him. Duo is a downhill run with two double-team blocks at the point of attack and the back reading a linebacker. It wants the defensive tackles spread out and a bubble, an open space with no defensive lineman in it, near the double teams.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Doubles Left vs. Nickel Over set to the FIELD
(ball on the LEFT hash: boundary = left, field = right)
BOUNDARY FIELD
F $
C W M * C
E N T E
Z Y O O O O O H X
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): The ball is on the left hash, so the short side (the boundary) is on the left and the wide side (the field) is on the right. Austin has Harlan, the tight end, attached on the left with Gaines as the flanker outside him; Powers and Sutton are spread to the right. The Sentinels have set their front to the field: the 3-technique tackle is on the right guard's outside shade and the field end is outside the right tackle. To the left, toward Harlan, there's only the nose tackle shaded on the center and the boundary end outside the left tackle. The Will linebacker stands over the left side; the Mike is to the right.
POST-SNAP: Duo toward Harlan: two double teams into the boundary
(W)<- back reads him M
^ ^
| one climbs off \ one climbs
E] | each double N] T] E]
/ \ | / \ | |
Y LT LG C \ RG RT
Q ...> R
\__ aim: LG-LT (B gap)
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap, the tight end and left tackle double-team the boundary end, and the left guard and center double-team the nose. One man from each double team climbs to a linebacker when the defensive lineman is controlled. The right guard and right tackle block the 3-technique and the field end on their side. Ruffin takes the handoff aiming at the B gap between the left guard and left tackle and reads the Will linebacker: if the Will fills inside, he bounces outside; if the Will widens, he goes inside.
Ruffin went for 13. Not because the play was clever. Because the defense's strength rule put two of its four linemen on the side the ball wasn't going.
🛡️ The defense's view: Wade Harmon, our head coach, spent fifteen years as a defensive coordinator, and he's the one who explains this to the young guys. "A field-strength rule is a good rule. It's simple, it's fast, and it keeps your best rusher on the wide side where he has room. But it has a price, and the price is the boundary run with a tight end. If I'm the DC and I see two of those in a quarter, I've got two choices: change my rule, or check my front to the tight end when he's into the boundary. Either one costs me something somewhere else." The Sentinels did change. From Game 2 on, they set their front strength to the attached tight end. The conversation moved. It always does.
💡 Coach's point: You don't beat a strength rule by being clever once. You beat it by finding the side of the field its rule leaves light, and making the defense pay often enough that it has to change the rule. Then you attack the new rule.
🔄 Check your understanding: A defense sets its strength to the passing strength (the side with the most receivers). Austin lines up with three receivers to the left and Harlan attached alone on the right. Where will this defense set its front, and which run does that invite?
Answer
A passing-strength defense sets to the three-receiver side, the left. That leaves the right side, where Harlan is attached, as the defense's "weak" side, with fewer defenders. A run to Harlan's side (inside zone or duo to the right) attacks the side the defense just declared light. The Outlaws call this alignment "Nub Right," and 3.5 draws it.
3.5 The Families: 2x2, 3x1, Trey, and Nub
Most snaps in the NFL come from a small number of formation families. In the four games before our first meeting with Sacramento, the Sentinels' staff charted 247 of our snaps. Russ Kimbrough, their defensive coordinator, showed me their formation breakdown at the league meetings the following spring, and it matched Marisol's self-scout within a couple of snaps:
| Formation family | Snaps | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 2x2 (Doubles and its variants) | 104 | 42% |
| 3x1 (Trips, Trey, Nub) | 89 | 36% |
| Tight / condensed (Nasty, Bunch, Stack) | 22 | 9% |
| Empty | 21 | 9% |
| Two-back | 6 | 2% |
| Unbalanced (Load) | 5 | 2% |
Almost four snaps in five come from two families. That's normal for a modern offense, and it's not a weakness, as long as each family asks the defense a different question.
Doubles (2x2): balance as a question
Doubles puts two receivers on each side. With Harlan attached, it's our base: the look from Anchor A ("Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant"), from the four-play sequence in Game 1, and from most of our first downs.
Doubles is balanced, and balance is its question. The defense can't over-rotate to one side without leaving the other side's two receivers in a two-on-two. So it tends to play a balanced coverage, two-high or a disciplined single-high. And the moment the defense commits two defenders to each side outside the box (a corner and either a safety or a nickel), you can count the box.
Let's count the most famous run of our season. Game 1, second quarter, 2nd-and-6 at the Sacramento 45, Austin up 10–7. Gun Doubles Right, Harlan attached right, Ruffin offset to the left, inside zone to the right. The Sentinels were in their nickel with two safeties deep.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Doubles Right vs. Nickel two-high (box count 6 v 6)
F $
C * W M C
E T T E
X H O O O O O Y Z
R Q
|<--------------- THE BOX: 6 defenders ------->|
|<--------- 6 blockers: 5 OL + Y ------------->|
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right, Ruffin beside Vance on the left. Sacramento's nickel has four down linemen, two linebackers in the box, the nickel defender over the left slot, corners on both outside receivers, and two safeties deep. Counting everyone inside the formation near the line, the defense has six in the box. Austin has six blockers: five linemen and the tight end. Six against six, and the quarterback is not blocking anyone.
Six blockers on six defenders means every defender has a body assigned to him. The run doesn't need a great play; it needs one defender to miss his fit. On this snap, three did. Their play-side end squeezed hard inside, their Will, Jordan Ames (#45), filled a gap that was already filled, and the strong safety, Tre Holloway (#31), came down on a flat angle.
POST-SNAP: Inside zone right; the end squeezes, Ruffin bounces
W (fills a gap $ (flat angle)
already filled) M \
\
E T T E <-squeezes \
\ v
O O O O O Y-->]
R ..Q ______
\____________________/ \
bounce outside \
the tight end v 45, TD
📊 Diagram (described): The line steps right on inside zone. Sacramento's right-side end crashes down inside, and the tight end rides him further inside. The Will linebacker fills a gap a teammate already has. Ruffin, aiming inside, sees the end gone and the edge empty, bounces the run outside the tight end, and the strong safety, coming down at a flat angle, runs past him. Ruffin goes 45 yards for the touchdown.
Forty-five yards, touchdown, 17–7. The formation didn't make that run. Execution and three defensive mistakes made it. But the formation set the arithmetic: six on six, with the extra defenders spread out where Doubles put them. When the arithmetic is even, one mistake is a big play. That's the run game's deal with Doubles, and it's why 2x2 is our home.
🔍 Why this works: A 2x2 with an attached tight end forces the defense to put at least four defenders outside the box (two to cover each side's pair of receivers) or to leave somebody in man coverage with no help. Either the box is six (and you have six blockers), or the box is seven and a receiver is single-covered with no safety help (and you throw). The defense can't have seven in the box and two safeties deep and everyone outside covered. The formation forces it to choose which of those three it gives up. Chapter 7 teaches you to see which one it chose before the snap.
Trips (3x1): overload one side, isolate the other
Trips puts three receivers to one side and one to the other. In our 11 personnel, Trips Right is Gaines (#1), Powers (#2), and Harlan (#3) detached from the line on the right, with Sutton alone on the left.
Trips asks the defense a harder question than Doubles: who covers the third receiver? Two-high defenses have a dozen answers, and they all take a body from somewhere. Most rotate a safety or a linebacker toward the trips side. Some lock the backside corner on the single receiver and send the backside safety to help with #3. Some stay balanced and accept a three-on-two-and-a-half on the trips side.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Trips Right vs. Nickel two-high (Quarters)
F $
C W M * C
E T N E
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
#1 (alone) #3 #2 #1
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in Trips Right: Harlan detached as #3, Powers as #2, and Gaines wide as #1, all on the right. Sutton is alone on the left as the single receiver. The Sentinels show two high safeties, a nickel defender over Powers, two linebackers, and corners over both outside receivers. Before the snap, the defense must decide who will cover Harlan, the third receiver, and where that defender comes from.
Here's the post-snap picture against the most common two-high answer: the backside safety rotates toward the trips side to help with #3, and the backside corner is left alone on the single receiver.
POST-SNAP: The trips check rotates the backside safety; X is alone
F ----------------------------> (rotates toward #3)
^ $
| fade or W M * C
| back-shoulder
C (alone: no safety help)
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
(trips side: 3 receivers
vs. 3-4 defenders)
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap, the left-side safety rotates across toward the trips side to help cover the third receiver. That leaves Sutton, the lone receiver on the left, one-on-one with the boundary corner and no safety anywhere near. The trips side is crowded, but the backside is an island. Austin's answer is a fade or back-shoulder throw to Sutton.
That's the backside isolation, and it's why Devonte Sutton (#18, 6-foot-3) is the guy we put alone. In Game 1 he was targeted eight times, and on six of them Sacramento's second-year boundary corner, Cole Brennan (#29), was alone on him. Sutton caught five of those six for 86 yards. Trips didn't win those throws. Sutton did. But Trips is what got him alone.
Against a single-high defense, Trips asks a different question. Our Week 2 and Week 12 opponent, the fictional St. Louis Stallions, live in Cover 3 and Cover 1 with a safety down in the box. Against Cover 3, three deep defenders cover thirds of the field and four defenders cover underneath. Trips puts three receivers against the two underneath defenders on that side (typically a curl/flat player and a hook player) plus the deep-third corner.
POST-SNAP: Trips Right vs. Cover 3: three receivers stress two
underneath defenders on the trips side
[DEEP 1/3] [DEEP 1/3] [DEEP 1/3]
C F C
^
[HOOK] [HOOK] [CURL/FLAT]
W M ^ $ ^
| / \ |
X O O O O O Y H Z--'
(seam)(out) (go)
(one receiver alone vs. the corner's deep third)
📊 Diagram (described): Against Cover 3, the Stallions have three deep defenders splitting the field into thirds and four underneath. On the trips side, Harlan runs up the seam, Powers runs to the flat, and Gaines runs vertically to push the corner deep. The curl/flat defender, the strong safety rolled down, can't take both Harlan's seam and Powers's out; the hook defender is too far inside to help on the flat. One of the three trips receivers is open by numbers. Sutton, alone on the left, is matched by the corner's deep-third responsibility.
Same formation, two different defenses, two different weak spots. Against two-high, Trips usually wins on the backside. Against single-high, it usually wins on the trips side by numbers. The formation asked; the defense answered; the answer told us where to throw. That's Chapter 7's threshold idea arriving early: the defense tells you where to go.
Trey: the tight end as #3
Trey is 3x1 with the attached tight end as the third receiver. Trey Right: Harlan attached to the right tackle, Powers (#2) in the slot outside him, Gaines (#1) wide, and Sutton alone on the left.
Trey's power is that the run strength and the pass strength are the same side. A tight-end-strength defense and a passing-strength defense agree on Trey, which sounds like good news for the defense, until you realize what it means: the defense loads one side, and the backside is thin by design. And because Harlan is attached, the trips side has an extra gap the defense must fill in the run game and three receivers it must cover in the pass game.
At halftime of Game 2 in Sacramento, down 13–10, my sheet had three changes on it, and the first was a formation: Trips with Sutton alone into the boundary and the tight end as #3 on a drag. In our words, Trey to the field. The Sentinels had been squeezing our quick game from 2x2. Trey moved the problem: three receivers to the wide side with Harlan's drag coming underneath from the inside, and Sutton alone into the short side, where a second-year corner had to defend him with less help.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Trey Right (Harlan attached as #3), ball on LEFT hash
BOUNDARY FIELD
F $
C W M * C
E T N E
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
#1 (alone) #3 #2 #1
📊 Diagram (described): The ball is on the left hash. Sutton is alone on the left, into the boundary. To the right, into the wide field, Harlan is attached to the right tackle as #3, Powers is in the slot as #2, and Gaines is wide as #1. The defense has its nickel over Powers, two linebackers, two safeties, and corners over Sutton and Gaines. Both the run strength (the tight end) and the pass strength (three receivers) point to the field.
POST-SNAP: Trey Right: Y drag underneath, X backside isolation
C (alone) F $ C
^ W M * ^ ^
| ^ / |
| hitch or <-------------. | / (clear) | (go)
| back-shoulder Y drag | | / |
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap, Gaines runs vertically and Powers clears to take the nickel and the safety deeper, opening space underneath. Harlan releases from the line and drags across the formation underneath the linebackers. On the backside, Sutton has the boundary corner alone and runs a hitch or a back-shoulder route depending on the corner's leverage. The quarterback has a drag in front of him and an isolation behind him.
A formation change was the first thing I reached for at halftime because it's the cheapest adjustment there is. You don't need a new play. You need the old play to show up from a picture that makes the defense defend it differently.
Nub: the tight end alone, the receivers away
Nub is the reverse of Trey. The tight end is attached on one side with no receiver outside him, and all three wide receivers go to the other side. We call it "Gun Nub Right": Harlan attached on the right, alone; Sutton, Powers, and Gaines to the left.
Nub is the strength-rule breaker. A tight-end defense sets its front to Harlan, leaving three receivers against a coverage that hasn't rotated. A passing-strength defense sets its front and coverage to the three receivers, leaving Harlan's side light in the run game. A field-strength defense is wrong on one side or the other depending on the hash.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Nub Right vs. a defense that sets to the RECEIVERS
$ F
C * M W
E T N E
Z H X O O O O O Y (nobody outside Y,
Q R so no corner here)
#1 #2 #3 nub
📊 Diagram (described): Austin has all three receivers on the left: Gaines wide, Powers inside him, and Sutton on the line tight to the formation. Harlan is attached alone on the right, with no receiver outside him. This defense sets to the passing strength: its 3-technique tackle, its nickel, its strong safety, and both linebackers shade toward the three receivers on the left. To the right, past Harlan, there is no corner because there is no receiver to cover, and only one end on the edge.
POST-SNAP: Inside zone right, to the nub (Harlan) side
M W
^ ^
\ / (one climbs off the
E T N E center-guard combo)
^ ^ ^ \ ^
O O O O O Y-->]E
Q ..> R
\__ aim: RG outside leg
📊 Diagram (described): On inside zone to the right, toward Harlan, every lineman steps right. The center and right guard combine on the nose, and one of them climbs to the nearest linebacker, who had shaded toward the three receivers and is now a step late. Harlan seals the end. Ruffin takes the handoff aiming at the right guard's outside leg. Because the defense set its front toward the receivers, there are fewer defenders on this side than Austin has blockers.
📋 Try it: Find the conflict. Suppose a defense sets its front strength to the attached tight end (as the Sentinels did from Game 2 on) and its coverage strength to the passing strength. Austin lines up in Gun Nub Right: Harlan attached alone on the right, three receivers on the left. Which defender is in conflict, and what two plays would you pair to stress him?
Worked answer
The front goes right (toward Harlan); the coverage rotates left (toward the three receivers). Someone has to connect the two halves of that defense, and in a nickel structure that's usually a linebacker, often the Will, whose run fit is toward the tight end's side and whose pass job is the hook or the3 receiver toward the trips. He can't be in both places. Pair inside zone right (he must fit the
run toward Harlan) with a quick throw to #3 on the left, such as Sutton on a short in-breaking route into the space the linebacker vacates. If he fits the run, the throw is open. If he widens to
3, the box loses a defender and the run is six on five. The formation created the conflict; the
pairing exploits it. Chapter 13 builds that pairing into a single play with a read.
🔄 Check your understanding: Trey and Nub are both 3x1 formations with an attached tight end. What's the one alignment difference, and why does it change how a tight-end-strength defense lines up against them?
Answer
In Trey, the tight end is on the same side as the two other receivers (he's #3 of three). In Nub, he's on the opposite side, alone. A tight-end-strength defense sets its front to the tight end in both cases. Against Trey, that also points its front toward the three receivers, so run and pass strength agree and the backside is thin. Against Nub, it points the front away from the three receivers, so the coverage must handle three receivers with a front that's looking the other way.
Quads: four to one side
Quads is 3x1 taken one step further: four receivers to one side, with the back or a tight end providing the fifth eligible on the other. It's rare, and that's the point. Most defenses have a trips check; fewer have a clean quads check that they rep every week. Quads forces the defense to move a second safety or a linebacker all the way across the formation, and the backside is either a single receiver against a corner with no help or a tight end against a linebacker. We carry it as a two-minute and red-zone surprise, never as a staple.
3.6 Compressed Sets: Bunch, Stack, and Nasty Splits
Spreading the field is half of formation football. The other half is squeezing it. When receivers line up close together or close to the formation, three things happen. Man coverage gets harder, because defenders can't run through each other. Zone coverage gets harder to communicate, because two receivers who start in the same spot can end in different zones. And the receivers suddenly have room to break outside, toward the sideline, where the defense usually has the sideline as an extra defender.
Bunch: three receivers in a triangle
Bunch puts three receivers in a tight triangle, usually a yard or two apart. One receiver is on the line at the front of the triangle, the point, and the other two are off the line, one inside and one outside.
Against man coverage, the bunch makes defenders choose. If the three defenders each take a man and chase him through traffic, somebody will run into somebody. Our rule is that we teach this as route spacing, not blocking: receivers run their own routes at their own depths, and they never initiate contact with a defender. In the NFL, blocking downfield by an eligible receiver before the pass is offensive pass interference, and officiating emphasis on these plays shifts from year to year. Teach the spacing, and let the traffic happen.
Smart defenses don't chase through the traffic. They banjo or play in-out: the outside defender takes the first receiver who breaks outside, the inside defender takes the first receiver who breaks inside, and the deep defender takes the one who goes vertical. No chasing, no traffic, no rub.
We learned that late in our second series in Game 1, three snaps after Gaines's 41-yard post. 3rd-and-goal at the Sacramento 4, first quarter, Austin up 7–0. We came out in Bunch Right with Harlan on the point, Powers inside, Gaines outside. The design was simple: Harlan to the corner, Gaines under him toward the middle, and Powers escaping to the flat behind the traffic, where the man defender chasing him should have gotten caught in the wash.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Bunch Right, 3rd-and-goal at the SAC 4 (man look)
================== GOAL LINE ====================================
$ M F
C W * C
E T N E
X O O O O O Y
Q R H Z
(point Y; H inside, Z outside)
📊 Diagram (described): Four yards from the goal line, Austin has a bunch on the right: Harlan on the line at the point of the triangle, Powers a step behind and inside him, Gaines a step behind and outside him. Sutton is alone on the left. The Sentinels have three defenders across from the bunch: the nickel inside, the field corner outside, and a safety stacked deeper. The defense looks like man coverage.
POST-SNAP: Bunch vs. an "in-out" switch; nobody gets picked
========================== GOAL LINE ==========================
F (takes the vertical) ^
/
/ Y corner
* (takes first IN) <-------------. /
Z under \ /
\ /
\/ C (takes
/\ first OUT)
/ \ |
O O O O O Y--' '--Z v
Q R H -----------> flat:
tackled at the 3
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap Harlan runs to the corner, Gaines cuts under him toward the middle, and Powers escapes to the flat. But the Sentinels don't chase. The safety takes the vertical route, the nickel takes the first receiver to break inside, and the field corner, Malik Simmons, takes the first receiver to break outside, which is Powers. Nobody runs through traffic. Powers catches it in the flat and Simmons tackles him at the 3, a yard short.
Simmons made the tackle at the 3. We kicked a field goal on fourth down. 10–0. The bunch didn't fail; it got answered. A bunch beats defenders who chase. It doesn't beat defenders who switch. When we see in-out technique on film, our bunch calls change: we run two receivers to the same side of the switch so the in-out rule has to pick one (one goes out at three yards and one goes out at six), and we save our bunch-flat for teams that chase.
⚠️ Common mistake: calling "rub" when the defense is switching. A coordinator sees a man look pre-snap and calls a bunch rub. The defense was in man, but it was banjo man, and the rub has nothing to rub. Fix: before you call a bunch play against a man look, check two weeks of film: does this defense chase through traffic or switch at the snap? Put the answer on your call sheet next to the bunch calls.
Stack: one receiver directly behind another
A stack lines up one receiver directly behind another, a yard or two apart. It's a bunch with two people. Its job is release: against press coverage, the front receiver takes the press defender's attention, and the back receiver gets a free release in either direction. And against zone, the stack hides which receiver is going where until the routes split.
When the Sentinels showed man coverage before the snap on third down in the four games before Week 6, we went to a stack, a bunch, or mesh on 11 of 17 snaps. That's a good tendency to have. It's also a tendency, and 3.9 is about what the defense does with those.
Nasty: reduced splits and room to break outside
A split is how far a receiver lines up from the ball or from the nearest lineman. A normal split for our outside receivers is around the top of the numbers on the wide side and a few yards inside the numbers on the short side; we adjust by hash. A reduced split, our word is Nasty, pulls a receiver in close to the formation, often eight to ten yards from the tackle instead of fifteen-plus.
A reduced split does three things. It gives the receiver room to break outside, toward the sideline, so a corner route or an out has grass to land in. It lets him crack inside on a run play, blocking a linebacker or safety from outside in. And it changes how the defender across from him lines up: a corner who normally plays outside leverage has to choose between widening (giving up the inside) or staying inside (giving up the out).
🩺 Player safety: A crack block from a reduced split is legal only when it meets your code's rules for blocks from outside in: in the NFL, crack-back blocks below the waist are illegal, and the contact must be to the front of the defender, not his back or his knees. Rules on blocks near the line and outside the tackle box differ by level and have been tightened over the years. Teach the crack high, hands inside, eyes on the target's numbers, and check your current code.
Here's our best play from a reduced split, and its biggest risk. Game 1, third quarter, a one-score game, 2nd-and-9 at the Austin 38. Ball on the left hash. "Eleven, Gun Doubles Left, Z Nasty, Scissors." Harlan attached left with Sutton outside him. On the right, into the field, Powers in the slot and Gaines in a reduced split. Scissors (our name; many systems call it a post-corner combination) crosses #1 and #2: Gaines (#1) runs a post, Powers (#2) runs a corner. The Sentinels were in a two-high Quarters look, in which each safety reads the #2 receiver on his side.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Doubles Left, Z Nasty, vs. two-high Quarters
(ball on the LEFT hash: field = right)
F $ (reads #2)
C W M * C
E T N E
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q R
#2 #1 (reduced)
📊 Diagram (described): Austin has Harlan attached on the left with Sutton outside him. On the right, the wide side, Powers is in the slot and Gaines is in a reduced split, much closer to Powers and to the line than a normal flanker. The Sentinels show two safeties deep. The safety on the right, Holloway, is responsible for reading Powers, the #2 receiver. The corner across from Gaines is playing tighter than usual because of the reduced split.
POST-SNAP: Scissors: #2's corner pulls the safety; #1's post
breaks inside, behind him
Z post (+31) H corner
^ ^
[vacated \ /
deep middle] \ / $ widens
\ / with H
\ /
\ /
\ /
\ / C: expected inside
\ / help from $;
\/ none came
/\
/ \
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap Powers stems vertically and breaks toward the sideline on a corner route. Holloway, reading Powers as #2 going vertical, widens and chases him toward the corner. Gaines, starting from his reduced split, runs a post and breaks inside, into the deep middle that Holloway has just left. The corner across from Gaines expected inside help from the safety; it isn't there. Vance throws the post. Gaines gains 31 yards before Holloway recovers and pushes him out of bounds.
That's the reward. Here's the risk, which I didn't see until Marisol showed me during our bye: in the four games before Week 6, Gaines took 23 snaps from a reduced split, and all nine of our scissors calls came from one. The split was the scissors' signature. Russ told me in the spring that his staff had it on their sheet before Game 1. The play still worked that day, because knowing a play is coming isn't the same as stopping it. But a tell like that is a loaded gun the defense gets to fire whenever it chooses. Section 3.9 is about unloading it.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why does a reduced split help a corner route or an out, but tend to hurt a fade?
Answer
A reduced split moves the receiver closer to the formation, which gives him more grass between him and the sideline to break into: corners and outs need that room. A fade needs the opposite: it wants the receiver near the sideline so the throw can go outside and away from any inside help, with the sideline compressing the corner. From a reduced split, a fade has to travel across more of the field, giving the safety time to come over. So reduced splits pair with outside-breaking routes and crack blocks; wide splits pair with fades and isolation.
3.7 Changing the Count: Unbalanced Lines, Wings, and Empty
Some formations don't just move receivers. They change the arithmetic of the line itself, either by adding a gap the defense has to fill or by taking blockers away and making the quarterback part of the protection.
Load: the unbalanced line
An unbalanced line puts more linemen on one side of the center than the other. Our word is Load. In "Load Right," Ben Achterberg (#78), our left tackle, lines up on the right side outside Darnell Fitch (#72). Harlan attaches outside Achterberg. On the left, Cody Brandt (#84), our second tight end, is the end of the line, which keeps him eligible. Both wide receivers line up off the line as flankers. Count it: Brandt, Moss, Szabo, Lorusso, Fitch, Achterberg, Harlan. Seven on the line, Brandt and Harlan the two eligible ends, Achterberg covered up and ineligible, exactly as his number says he is. No one has to report. That's my placemat formation, done legally.
The point is the gap count. To the right of the center there are now three linemen and a tight end, which makes five gaps: A, B, C, D, and one more outside Harlan. To the left there are only three. A defense that sets its front by counting from the center, or by habit, lines up a gap short on the heavy side.
Week 12, at home against the St. Louis Stallions, the single-high, eight-in-the-box defense run by Frank Ostrowski, we had 1st-and-10 at our own 38 in the second quarter, tied 7–7. "Twelve, Under Load Right, Wide." Outside zone to the overload.
PRE-SNAP: Under Load Right (unbalanced) vs. single-high, 8 in box
F
C $ W M S C
E T T E
Z U O O O O (LT) Y X
(LG) (C) (RG) (RT)
Q
R
|<- 3 gaps ->|<-------- 5 gaps -------->|
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is under center in an unbalanced line. Brandt, the second tight end, is the end of the line on the left, next to the left guard. To the right of the center are the right guard, the right tackle, then Achterberg, the left tackle, now playing outside the right tackle, and Harlan attached outside him. Both wide receivers are off the line as flankers. Ruffin is deep behind the quarterback. The Stallions show one deep safety and eight defenders near the line, with their front set as if the line were balanced: two linemen to each side of the center. The right side now has more gaps than the defense has players aligned to fill them.
POST-SNAP: Wide (outside zone) to the overload
W M S
\ \ \ (late: one gap short)
E T T E v
^ ^ ^ ^
U O O O O (LT)-->] Y-->]
Q ....> R ---------------.
\ aim: Y's
v outside leg
(+9)
📊 Diagram (described): Every Austin lineman steps right and reaches the defender to his outside. With an extra blocker on the right, the line can reach the end and the tackle and still have Achterberg and Harlan to deal with the outside linebacker and the strong-side edge. The defense's linebackers flow right, but they started a gap short. Ruffin, running outside zone with an aiming point at Harlan's outside leg, cuts up through the crease for 9 yards.
Ruffin went for 9. In the third quarter, up 13–10 with 1st-and-10 at the Austin 44, we showed Load Right again. This time Ostrowski's front bumped a full gap toward the overload and his strong safety rolled down to that side. They'd fixed the count. So we ran "Load Right, Wide PA Boot": the same outside zone action, Vance faking to Ruffin and booting back to the left, the side the defense had just emptied, with Brandt slipping off the line into the left flat after a one-count block. Brandt caught it for 14.
🛡️ The defense's view: Ostrowski's adjustment is the correct one, and every good defensive coordinator teaches some version of it: count the line, not the center. Set the front to the side with more blockers, and slide the linebackers and a safety with it. The price is the side you slid away from. An unbalanced line is a question with two parts: "Can you count?" and then "What did you leave when you did?" The boot is the second question.
🏫 Any level: Unbalanced lines are more common, and often more devastating, in high school and small college, where defenses have less time to install adjustments and where a defense that misaligns once tends to misalign again. They are also where the legality traps live. Know your code's numbering requirements for the line, and drill the ends' alignment until it's boring. A covered-up tight end is not a formation; it's a penalty waiting for the worst possible moment. I know.
Wing and Ace: the extra gap you can move
A wing is a tight end or H-back lined up a yard off the line just outside the end man, usually the attached tight end. Ace is our word for a one-back set with two tight ends, or a tight end and a wing. A wing adds a gap on the edge like an attached tight end does, but because he's off the line he's a back. He can go in motion. He can block across the formation (a wham block on an interior lineman, or an arc block on the edge). He can release into a route without needing a clean release off the line. He adds a gap the defense must fill and moves it after the defense has filled it.
Joe Gibbs's Washington teams of the 1980s and early 1990s built much of their run game around one-back sets with a moving H-back, and the counter trey was the signature play of that tradition. Our Ace-and-wing family borrows from it directly: Brandt as the wing, Harlan attached, Ruffin alone in the backfield, and a run game where the extra gap shows up wherever we need it.
Empty: five out, five in, and the quarterback as a blocker
Empty removes the back from the backfield and spreads all five eligible receivers. Our empty formations are 3x2 or 4x1. Empty does one thing better than any formation in football: it makes the defense declare its coverage. With five receivers spread across the field, the defense can't disguise much. Five receivers need five defenders. Count the rest: whoever is left is either rushing, spying, or deep.
It also creates a hard protection fact. Five linemen block five rushers. If the defense brings six, somebody is unblocked, and the only answer is the ball: a hot throw, out before the free rusher arrives. In empty, the quarterback is part of the protection.
PRE-SNAP: Gun Empty (3x2) vs. nickel, mug look (2 LBs in A gaps)
$ F
C * M W C
E T N E
X H O O O O O Y R Z
Q
(2 receivers left) (3 receivers right)
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in empty: Sutton and Powers on the left, and Harlan, Ruffin (split out from the backfield), and Gaines on the right, with the quarterback alone in the shotgun and only five linemen to block. The defense shows four down linemen, both linebackers walked up into the A gaps next to the center, a nickel over Powers, two corners, and two safeties. That's six potential rushers against five blockers. If all six come, the two safeties have to come down and cover Harlan and Ruffin, and nobody is left deep.
POST-SNAP: Six rush, five block: the hot throw beats the free man
^ H: quick slant into the window the Mike left
/
/ ^
H --' \ ball out in about 1.0-1.3 sec
\
\ M (unblocked) ==> toward the QB
\ E T N E
\ X X X X (four linemen and the
\ O O O O O Will are blocked)
'.......Q
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap six defenders rush and the five linemen block the four linemen and one linebacker. The Mike linebacker comes through the A gap unblocked. Vance doesn't wait for him: he throws immediately to Powers on a quick slant into the space the Mike just vacated by blitzing. The throw is out in roughly a second, before the free rusher arrives.
Empty has a tell problem, too. In the four games before Week 6, 19 of our 21 empty snaps came from Peel motion: Ruffin starting in the backfield and motioning out. The Sentinels knew that when Ruffin moved out, they were about to see empty. We gave them the formation and a two-second warning.
🔄 Check your understanding: In empty, the defense shows six potential rushers and Austin has five blockers. Name two things the offense can do before the snap, and one thing it must do after the snap if all six come.
Answer
Before the snap: (1) check out of empty into a formation with a back in protection (bring Ruffin back or motion a tight end in), making it six blockers on six; or (2) keep empty and set the protection so the five linemen take the five most dangerous rushers, identifying who the free man will be. After the snap, if all six come: throw hot, immediately, to the receiver in the window the free rusher came from. Protection is arithmetic, and in empty the quarterback's quick throw is the sixth blocker. Chapter 22 builds the full rule set.
3.8 The Five Things a Formation Does to a Defense
Step back from the individual formations. Every one we've drawn does one or more of five things to the defense before the ball is snapped. When you design or choose a formation, name which of the five you're after. If you can't name one, see the Coach's point in 3.1.
| Effect | What it means | Formations that do it best | What the defense gives up when it answers |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Forces a strength call | The defense must decide which side is "strong," and its front, linebackers, and coverage all key off that decision | Nub, Trey, Doubles with the TE into the boundary, Load | The side it didn't pick |
| 2. Removes a defender from the box | Spreading receivers pulls defenders outside, lowering the box count | Doubles, Trips, Empty, 10 personnel spreads | Run fits (if it takes them out) or coverage (if it leaves them in) |
| 3. Creates a leverage advantage | Receivers start where the defender can't take away both directions | Nasty splits, bunch, stack, slot alignments | Either the inside or the outside break |
| 4. Isolates a receiver | One receiver ends up with one defender and no help | Trips, Trey, Nub (the backside X), wide splits | Help to the trips side, or the backside |
| 5. Creates an extra run gap | An added blocker on the surface adds a gap the defense must fill | Load, Wing, Ace, 12/13 personnel attached | A defender from coverage, or a fit in the run |
Here's what to notice. Every effect has a "what the defense gives up" column, because every answer costs the defense something. That's the offense's structural advantage stated in formation terms. You know where the ball is going. The defense has to answer the formation without knowing, and every answer leaves somewhere it can't be. Chapter 7 teaches you to read the answer; Part II and Part III teach you which play to run into it.
Box count: the arithmetic in plain English
The fastest way to see effects 2 and 5 at work is to count the box. Here's the routine our quarterbacks and our booth use.
- Count your blockers. Five linemen, plus every tight end or wing attached to the surface, plus a fullback if you have one. (The running back carrying the ball doesn't count.)
- Count their box. Every defender inside the outermost blocker and within about five to seven yards of the line. A safety walked down to eight yards over the tight end counts; a safety at twelve doesn't.
- Compare. Blockers equal to box defenders: the run is "even," and it needs execution. Blockers fewer than box defenders: somebody's unblocked, and you'd better be reading him (Chapter 12) or throwing. Blockers more than box defenders: run it.
On the 45-yard run, our count was six blockers against six in the box: even. Against the Stallions' Load snap, we had seven blockers on the line against their eight: one short on paper, but the defense's alignment was a gap short on the heavy side, which is why the count by side mattered more than the total. Count both: the total, and the side you're running to.
🔄 Check your understanding: Austin lines up in Gun Doubles Right (5 linemen plus Harlan attached). The defense has four down linemen, two linebackers at five yards, and the strong safety walked down to seven yards outside Harlan. What's the box count, and what does it say about the call?
Answer
Blockers: six (five linemen plus Harlan). Box: seven (four linemen, two linebackers, and the strong safety at seven yards outside the tight end). The defense has one more defender than Austin has blockers, so a straight run leaves a man unblocked. The call should either read that extra defender (a zone read or an RPO that throws behind him) or throw, because a seven-man box with an attached tight end and two receivers on each side usually means one-high or a receiver without help.
3.9 Formationing: Many Looks, Few Plays, and the Self-Scout
There are two ways to build an offense's formations, and they pull in opposite directions.
The first is more plays. Each formation has its own plays, designed to exploit what that formation does. Lots of ideas, lots of installation, lots of things for eleven people to remember.
The second is formationing: run few plays from many formations. The linemen's rules don't change, the back's read doesn't change, the quarterback's read barely changes. Only the receivers' alignments change, and with them the defense's picture. Coaches call this "dressing the play up." The Erhardt-Perkins tradition, built around naming concepts so they could be run from any formation, and the Shanahan tradition, built around making everything look the same, both lean hard on this idea in different ways.
Here's our inside zone, the same play for the linemen, six different questions for the defense:
| Formation | What the defense must answer | What inside zone gets |
|---|---|---|
| Gun Doubles Right | Balanced: two-high or rotated? Six or seven in the box? | An even count, or a read on the extra man |
| Gun Trey Right | Strength agrees; who fits the backside? | A cutback lane against a defense loaded to the TE side |
| Gun Nub Right | Front to the TE or to the receivers? | The light side, whichever they choose |
| Pistol Ace | Which way is the run going? (No backfield tell) | A back who can hit either side |
| Under Load Right | Can they count the overload? | An extra gap on the heavy side, or the boot if they slide |
| Gun Doubles Left, Z Nasty | Does the corner widen or stay in? | A crack-block perimeter with the run's same rules inside |
The linemen block inside zone exactly the same way in all six. The back reads the same defender. That's six formations for the price of one run-blocking install. That's formationing.
The danger: your formation is a tell
Now the cost. The defense watches your formations the way you watch its safeties. Every formation that predicts a play is information you're giving away, and good defenses count it. Here's what the Sentinels' staff charted on us in the four games before our first meeting, as Russ showed me at the league meetings:
| What they saw | What it predicted | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Gaines in a reduced split | Scissors | 9 scissors, all 9 from a reduced split (23 reduced-split snaps) |
| Ruffin motioning out of the backfield | Empty | 19 of 21 empty snaps |
| 3rd-and-4–6 | A 3x1 formation | 22 of 26 |
| 3rd-and-4–6 from 3x1 | Dig or flood | 14 of 22 |
| First snap of a drive from 2x2 | Inside zone with the slant RPO | 7 of 11 |
| Man coverage shown before the snap on 3rd down | Stack, bunch, or mesh | 11 of 17 |
Read that table as a defensive coordinator. On third-and-medium, he knows our formation family before we line up, and once we line up he can guess the concept better than six times in ten. When Gaines takes a reduced split, he knows the scissors is on the menu. When Ruffin moves, he knows empty is coming and has two seconds to check into his empty coverage.
None of that means those plays stopped working. The scissors went for 31 in Game 1 even though they had it on their sheet. But a tell is a loaded weapon the defense gets to fire when the moment matters most.
During our bye, Marisol put a version of this table on the screen in the staff room.
Marisol: This is our reduced-split chart. In the first four games alone, twenty-three snaps with Gaines in a reduced split, nine of them scissors. And every scissors we've run all year has come from a reduced split.
Teo: So if I'm them, a reduced split means "watch the post."
Marisol: If you're them, a reduced split means the scissors is possible on roughly two snaps in five, and on the other three it's something you've already seen. That's a lean, not a lock. My working line is that when one look predicts one play more than about 70 percent of the time on ten-plus snaps, we've got a tell. This one's not there yet. But the reverse is a hundred percent: every scissors is a reduced split.
Lyle: Which is the one that matters. They don't need to know what a reduced split means. They need to know that the scissors can't come from anything else. So when he's in a normal split, they can play the post-corner with no fear at all.
Gus: If you're about to tell me we're running the ball out of that split, I need to know who the receiver is cracking, because my tackle's rule changes when somebody's coming down on his man.
Lyle: We're about to tell you exactly that. Crack toss, from the same split, starting next week.
That's the fix, and it has three parts. First, break the tell on purpose: put the dig, the crack toss, and the quick game into Gaines's reduced split so the split stops meaning one thing. Second, spread the signature: run the scissors from a normal split some of the time, even if it's a little worse, so the post-corner can come from anywhere. Third, use what they know: if they jump the scissors when Gaines is reduced, the play that looks like the scissors and isn't is now worth more than the scissors. That's sequencing, and Chapter 19 owns it.
🎬 Film room: To self-scout your formations, sort a month of your own snaps by formation family and split, then sort again by the play that followed. Look for the one-to-one columns: a split that only carries one concept, a motion that only ever ends in one formation, a backfield alignment that predicts run direction. Then watch the defense's first reaction on those snaps on the end-zone angle. If its linebackers are moving before the ball, they know.
My recurring mistake as a play caller is trusting the defense's tendency longer than the defense lets it stay true. The mirror-image mistake is trusting your own formation longer than the defense lets it stay secret. Russ's staff had the reduced-split column on their sheet before Game 1. I found it after our bye. That gap, five games of a tell I didn't know I had, is why our self-scout now runs every Monday, not every bye week.
⚠️ Common mistake: the formation of the week. A coordinator who wants to look multiple adds four new formations every week, each with one or two plays. By midseason the playbook has forty formations and the players are lining up wrong on 5 percent of snaps, which is three or four plays a game. Meanwhile, each formation-with-one-play is a perfect tell. Fix: new formations must carry at least two existing plays, one run and one pass, before they carry anything new. If the players can't line up in it on a 40-second clock without looking at the sideline, it's not ready.
📋 Try it: Make the call. You're Austin. Game 1, ball on the left hash, 2nd-and-4 at the Sacramento 47, first quarter. The Sentinels set their front strength to the field every snap so far. You want to run duo. You have 11 personnel on the field. Choose a formation, say where Harlan lines up and why, and name the risk.
Worked answer
With the ball on the left hash, the field is to the right. A field-strength defense will set its 3-technique and its strong-side structure to the right regardless of where Harlan is. So put Harlan into the boundary: Gun Doubles Left (Harlan attached left). Duo toward Harlan now attacks the side where the defense has its nose and one end, with your two double teams. The risk: the defense has seen you do it (Ruffin went 13 on the same idea earlier in the quarter), and a good staff will check its front to the tight end when he's into the boundary. If you see the 3-technique walk over to Harlan's side before the snap, you need a check: either duo the other way, or a play that punishes them for moving (the quick game to the field, where the front just left). What Austin actually did on this down was even sneakier: 12 personnel, with Harlan detached in the slot so the defense matched with nickel, then Harlan motioning back to attach. The defense was in a light box against two tight ends. Ruffin gained 6 and a first down. (Chapter 4 explains why that works.)📋 Try it: Whose fault? A practice rep, Thursday, team period. The call is "Eleven, Gun Trey Right, Y Seam." Harlan is attached as #3 and the seam is his. Jaylen Cross (#15), a backup receiver in for Gaines, lines up on the line of scrimmage as #1 instead of off it. Vance throws the seam, Harlan catches it for 25, and the officials working practice throw a flag. Who's at fault, what's the rule, and what's the fix?
Worked answer
The rule: only the two players on the ends of the line are eligible. With Cross on the line outside Powers and Harlan, Harlan is no longer the end; he's covered, an interior lineman, and ineligible to catch a forward pass. (Powers, off the line, is still eligible as a back.) Whose fault: Cross made the alignment error, but the coaching fault is ours. A backup who plays the Z position in Trey needs the alignment rule ("Z is off the ball when the Y is to your side") drilled in walk-through, not assumed. The fix: (1) an alignment rep for every backup at every formation they could play, in the Friday walk-through; (2) Vance checks the end man before every snap on Harlan's side, and a single word ("Off!") moves the receiver back; (3) the formation card on the wristband shows on/off the line for every position. This is the Danny Kostas rule, and it's never retired.
Spaced Review
Answer each before you open it.
From Chapter 1: Where does a formation live in the hierarchy of philosophy → system → playbook → game plan → call sheet → call? Is "we use few formations, run from many alignments" a philosophy decision or a game-plan decision?
Answer
Formation families live in the system and the playbook: they're the structure your offense is built on. Which formations you use against a particular opponent is a game-plan decision, and which one you call on 2nd-and-4 is the call. "Few plays from many formations" is a philosophy-level choice (Chapter 1's non-negotiables) because it shapes everything below it: what you install, how you practice, and how your self-scout reads your tendencies.
From Chapter 2: Clark Shaughnessy's T formation with man-in-motion helped the 1940 Bears beat Washington 73–0 in the championship game. In this chapter's language, what was the man-in-motion doing to the defense before the snap?
Answer
It was changing the formation after the defense had aligned to it, forcing defenders to adjust or be outflanked, and it revealed coverage: if a defender went with the motion man, it was man coverage; if not, the defense had to rebalance its zones. In this chapter's terms, it forced a strength call late and could create a leverage advantage or isolate a receiver. Motion is just a formation that changes while the defense watches, which is why Chapter 27 builds directly on this one.
🪞 Learning check-in: Close the book and draw Gun Doubles Right, Gun Trey Right, and Gun Nub Right from memory, with the receivers numbered. Then ask yourself three questions. Where did you hesitate? (Most readers hesitate on which receivers are on the line.) Could you explain to a friend why Nub forces a strength decision that Trey doesn't? And when you watched the last game you saw, did you notice formations at all, or did your eye go straight to the ball? If it went to the ball, that's normal. The fix is a habit, not a talent: for one quarter this weekend, say the formation out loud before every snap. Notice how much faster it gets by the end of the quarter. That speed is the difference between knowing the names and seeing the game.
Project Checkpoint: Formation Family
Where you are. In Chapter 1 you wrote your Offensive Philosophy Statement. In Chapter 2 you built your Lineage Map: which historical offenses your system borrows from. Now you decide where your players will stand.
The deliverable. A Formation Family: six to eight named formations that will carry your offense. For each one, write a formation card with:
- Name and call words in your own grammar (e.g., "Gun Trey Right").
- Alignment rules for every position: backfield set and depth, each receiver's position on or off the line, and his split (normal, reduced, wide) with a landmark (top of the numbers, two yards outside the tight end, and so on). Adjust for the hash.
- Strength rule: how the direction word is set.
- Legality check: who the two ends are; any player who must be off the line; any reporting requirement.
- The defensive problem it creates: which of the five effects in 3.8 it's after.
- The tell to watch: what this formation might predict, and one play you'll run from it to keep it honest.
A worked example (pro level):
GUN TREY RIGHT. Backfield: QB at 5 yards, RB beside him, either side (vary it). On the line: X (left end), five OL, Y attached to the RT (right end). Off the line: H in the slot 4–5 yards outside Y; Z at the top of the numbers to the field or 3 yards inside the numbers to the boundary. Strength: right = the Y's side. Legality: ends are X and Y; H and Z must be off the ball. Problem it creates: run strength and pass strength agree, so the defense loads one side and the backside X is isolated (effects 1 and 4). Tell to watch: if Trey only ever runs to the TE side, the defense squeezes it; carry one weak-side run (inside zone away) and one backside throw (X back-shoulder).
Choose your level.
- High school: Six formations is plenty. At least one should be two-back or under center. Make every card fit on an index card a sophomore can read. Add a line on your code's numbering rules.
- College: Seven or eight formations. Note how each changes with the wider college hash: the field side is much wider and the boundary much shorter than in the NFL.
- Pro: Eight formations, plus a one-line "dress-up" list for each: two splits or tags that change the picture without changing the play.
- Film-room: Chart two quarters of one NFL team. Tag every snap with its formation family (2x2, 3x1, empty, condensed, unbalanced, two-back). Build a table like the one in 3.5 and write one sentence on what that team's formations tell a defense.
Next. In Chapter 4 you'll decide who plays in these formations: your Personnel Packages and Role Cards. You'll find out that the same formation with different people in it asks a completely different question.
Chapter Summary
A formation is the offense's first sentence on every snap. It forces the defense to answer before the ball moves, and every answer leaves something open.
| Formation (Outlaws word) | Alignment | The question it asks | Usually beats | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Doubles (2x2) | Two receivers each side | Two-high or rotated? Six or seven in the box? | Even-count runs; quick game both sides | Becoming the only first-down look |
| Trips (3x1) | Three receivers detached to one side | Who covers #3? | Backside isolation vs. two-high; numbers vs. Cover 3 | The defense locking the backside and banjoing trips |
| Trey (3x1, TE as #3) | Attached TE plus two receivers outside him | Run and pass strength agree: how do you load? | Backside X; the TE drag under a loaded side | Only running to the TE side |
| Nub | TE alone on one side, three receivers opposite | Front to the TE or to the receivers? | Whichever side the defense leaves light | The defense splitting the difference with a good linebacker |
| Bunch / Stack | Receivers clustered | Chase through traffic or switch? | Man coverage that chases; press | In-out and banjo switching |
| Nasty (reduced split) | A receiver tight to the formation | Inside or outside leverage? | Outside-breaking routes; crack blocks | One play per split (the scissors tell) |
| Load (unbalanced) | More linemen on one side | Can you count the overload? | Runs to the heavy side; boot away if they slide | Legality: covered ends, numbering rules |
| Ace / Wing | Two TEs or TE plus wing | Where's the extra gap going to be? | Edge runs, wham, play-action | Defenses that answer with big nickel |
| Empty | No back; five receivers out | Show me your coverage, and count your rushers | Coverage recognition; quick game | Six rushers vs. five blockers; Peel motion as a tell |
The decision rules to keep:
- Every formation must cause at least one of the five effects (strength call, box removal, leverage, isolation, extra gap). If it causes none, cut it.
- The offense's strength word and the defense's strength call are separate decisions. Attack the side the defense's rule leaves light.
- Count the box in total and by side. Even counts need execution; short counts need a read or a throw.
- Few plays, many formations. Every new formation carries existing plays first.
- Self-scout your formations as hard as you scout the opponent's coverages. Anything that predicts one play too often is a tell; break it on purpose.
- Legality is the first rep. Seven on the line, ends eligible, nobody covered by accident.
What's Next
You now know where eleven people can stand. Chapter 4 asks who those eleven people are. The same Gun Doubles Right means one thing with three wide receivers on the field and something entirely different with Brooks Harlan and Cody Brandt both in it, and the defensive coordinator across the field has to decide, in about fifteen seconds, which players to send in to match. That's the personnel game, and it's where formations start to multiply.