Instructor Companion
Teaching NFL Offensive Coordination: The Art and Science of Moving the Football
This companion accompanies a forty-chapter book that is free, openly licensed (CC-BY-SA-4.0), and built to be adapted. It was written for several very different rooms at once: a university coaching-methods course, a high school offensive staff working through the offseason, a clinic presenter with ninety minutes and a whiteboard, and a sports-analytics or media program that wants students to stop saying "great call" or "terrible call" and start saying which defender the call put in conflict and what the caller knew when he made it. Take what fits your room. Change the sequence if your calendar demands it. Everything here is a starting point.
What is in the instructor companion
| Item | Files | What it gives you |
|---|---|---|
| Syllabi | 4 | A 15-week university course covering all forty chapters; a 12-session high school staff-development series; an analyst and film-study course; and a self-paced independent study with checkpoints |
| Chapter notes | 40 | For each chapter: what it is for, measurable objectives, timing for a 75-minute session and a 150-minute block, where students get stuck, a whiteboard or film-room activity, assessment notes, any-level adaptation, and connections. Index: chapter-notes/index.md |
| Discussion guides | 40 | For each chapter: an opening question, discussion questions in three levels with "listen for" notes, a structured debate or role-play, case-study connections, and a closing synthesis prompt. Index: discussion-guides/index.md |
| Common struggles | 1 | common-struggles.md — the fourteen misconceptions learners bring to offensive football, each with a diagnostic and a fix |
| Film-lab guide | 1 | film-lab-guide.md — running broadcast and All-22 labs, the Chapter 40 checklist, a simplified version of Teo's tagging sheet, and eight lab sessions |
| Chalk-talk and simulation guide | 1 | chalk-talk-and-simulation-guide.md — chalk talks, a mock game-plan meeting, a 40-second play-calling simulation, a halftime-adjustment simulation, and the eleven-man say-back |
| Rules and player-safety teaching guide | 1 | rules-and-player-safety-teaching-guide.md — rules that differ by level (ineligible downfield, motion, pick plays, cut and chop blocks, quarterback protection), the contact ladder, quarterback hits and the carry budget, and heat |
| Additional assessments | 4 | Midterm exam (Chapters 1–20), final exam (comprehensive), rubrics, and an assessment bank of multiple-choice and short-answer items tagged by chapter |
The four syllabi are syllabus-15-week-university.md, syllabus-high-school-staff-development.md, syllabus-analyst-and-film-study.md, and syllabus-self-paced.md.
Who this companion is for
The university instructor teaching coaching methods, sport management, or kinesiology. You need a semester with assessments that measure more than recall, and you probably have a mixed room: former players, students who have never put on pads, analytics majors, and a couple of future graduate assistants. The 15-week syllabus is built for you.
The high school head coach or coordinator running offseason staff development. You need sessions that end with something your staff can install in August, built for the players in your building, under your state association's rules. The staff-development series is built for you.
The analytics, media, or film-study instructor. Your students will never call a play, but they will spend careers explaining them. They need to see the conflict defender on a broadcast copy, chart a game honestly, and grade a call without "resulting." The analyst syllabus is built for you.
The clinic presenter and the independent learner. For one-day clinics, see "Choosing your course shape" below. For the reader working alone or a supervising instructor overseeing an independent study, see the self-paced syllabus.
Course design philosophy
Three commitments shape everything in this companion. They come straight from the book, and if you hold onto them the rest of the course mostly organizes itself.
1. The defense tells you where to go
The book's thesis is that the offense has exactly one structural advantage: it knows where the ball is going and the defense doesn't. A great offense multiplies that advantage three ways: conflict (make one defender responsible for two things), sequence (every play makes another play better), and illusion (plays that look alike until it's too late). Plus the thing no scheme replaces: eleven people executing on the same count.
Every one of those is a seeing skill before it is a calling skill. A student who has memorized smash but cannot find the cornerback it puts in conflict, on a live snap, has learned a drawing, not an offense. So the course is built around film and the board. Every week of the university syllabus has a film lab, every high school session ends with your own cutup, and the analyst course is a film course with honest numbers attached. The book supports this directly: Chapter 40 gives a fixed seven-item pre-snap checklist (situation, personnel, formation and strength, shell, box, leverage, motion and reaction), four things to see in the first two seconds after the snap (the line's first step, the read defender, the decision, the block or route that decided it), the "why this call, now?" questions, and a process-versus-result grade. Teach the Chapter 40 checklist early, not late. It is the last chapter in the book, but its method is the one students should practice from Week 2. The film-lab guide shows how.
2. Draw it, say it, say it back
Lyle Petrakis, the book's narrator, has a rule he calls the July-rookie test: "If the rookie can't say it back to me in July, it's not a word in our offense." His mentor Walt Dupree's version is shorter: "Every play is a question. Know what you're asking." Every concept in the book is drawn in one notation (Appendix A and the front matter's "Reading the Diagrams"), offense at the bottom moving up the page, with a pre-snap and a post-snap picture and a plain-language description.
That gives you the course's core assessment act: the student at the whiteboard. Not a multiple-choice question about what Inside Slant is, but "Here is nickel with two high safeties against Eleven, Gun Doubles Right. Draw Inside Slant. Who is the read key, what are his two jobs, and what does Vance do if he sits?" A student who can draw the answer and say the rule in one sentence has it. A student who cannot has the illusion of it. The book's own oral exam, the eleven-man say-back from Chapter 8 (Teo reads a call; the rookie says all eleven assignments, not just his own), is the best single check of whether the language has turned into understanding. The chalk-talk and simulation guide shows how to run it.
3. The Playbook Project is the spine
Every chapter ends with a Project Checkpoint that adds one deliverable to The Playbook Project: Build Your Offense: an Offensive Philosophy Statement in Chapter 1, a Formation Family in Chapter 3, an Offensive Line Rules Sheet in Chapter 5, a Defensive Recognition Card in Chapter 7, a Nomenclature System and Wristband in Chapter 8, install sheets for each run family in Part II, an RPO Menu in Chapter 13, a Core Coverage-Beater Set in Chapter 16, a Protection Plan in Chapter 22, a Scouting Template and Sentinels Tendency Report in Chapter 23, a Game Plan and 15-Play Opening Script in Chapter 24, a Call Sheet in Chapter 25, and so on through the Chapter 39 capstone, which assembles a 60–70 play core offense and a complete game plan against the Sacramento Sentinels' defense from the scouting packet in Appendix G. Chapter 40 closes with a Film Grading Rubric and a ten-snap self-test.
Learners choose a level at the start: high school, college, pro, or "film-room" for analysts and fans. The deliverables scale accordingly; a high school coordinator's RPO Menu is built under a different ineligible-downfield rule from a pro coordinator's, and a film-room learner's Protection Plan is written as a viewing guide rather than an install sheet. This is the spine of any course built on this book. It produces a real artifact a graduate assistant can bring to an interview (Chapter 37's Coordinator Interview Binder is literally that) and a high school coordinator can install in August. It also solves the assessment problem: you are not grading whether students read; you are grading whether they can build an offense and defend it in a staff meeting.
Decide before the term begins whether you are running the project. It does not work as a late addition, because each deliverable depends on the ones before it. A student without a Nomenclature System cannot write a wristband, a student without an Inside Zone Install Sheet cannot marry play-action to it in Chapter 19, and a student without a Scouting Template has nothing to build a game plan from in Chapter 24.
The book's structure, and what it asks of you
Four anchor scenarios carry the whole book
The fictional Austin Outlaws play the Sacramento Sentinels three times in the book's season: a 34–27 win in Week 6 at Austin, a 20–23 loss in Week 15 at Sacramento, and a 17–20 divisional-playoff loss at Sacramento. Four snaps are told in full in their home chapters and then revisited from other angles:
| Anchor | The snap | Home | Revisited |
|---|---|---|---|
| A — The RPO the linebacker can't win | Game 1, the first two snaps: "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Inside Slant." Vance reads the Will, Jordan Ames. Ames triggers: Powers slant +17. Ames sits: Ruffin +7 | Ch 13 | Ch 1, 7, 12, 38, 40 |
| B — Smash vs. Cover 2 | Week 10 at Portland, 2nd-and-6 at the Portland 31, tied 7–7. Corner Josh Kiel squats on Sutton's hitch; Powers's corner route over him for a 31-yard TD | Ch 16 | Ch 7, 15, 38 |
| C — The third-and-seven decision | Game 3, 3rd-and-7 at the Austin 41, down 10–7. A six-man protection built for the double-A mug (center on Bell, back on Ames, right tackle widening to the corner) and Gaines's sight-adjust hitch: zero free rushers, +10 | Ch 25 | Ch 22, 26, 28, 39, 40 |
| D — The four-play sequence | Game 1, fourth quarter, down 27–20, same look every snap: inside zone +5, inside zone +7, "Inside PA, Gaines Post" for 35, inside zone 4-yard TD | Ch 19 | Ch 1, 9, 24, 25, 38, 40 |
And one more: Lyle's mistake. Game 3, 3rd-and-9 at the Austin 38, 2:41 left, down 20–17. "Mills" was written in the third-and-long box with no branch, against a two-high streak that had held 29 straight times. At the snap the strong safety rotated down and Ike Royce spun to the middle; Vance threw the post into him. Rome Pettaway had asked in writing for a post-snap check on Tuesday. The book returns to that snap more than any other: the whiteboard in Chapter 24, the sideline and the office in Chapter 35, the middle-read tag in Chapter 38 §38.8, and the honest grade in Chapter 40 §40.7.
Lean into the repetition. Anchor D is a sequencing story in Chapter 19, a "two receipts" rule in Chapter 24, a "call as investment" story in Chapter 25, a constraint-theory story in Chapter 38, and a "why this call, now?" exercise in Chapter 40. When an anchor reappears, ask the room where they saw it last and what it meant there. Students who can answer have integrated the material. Students who cannot have been reading chapters as isolated units.
Eight threshold concepts are your assessment targets
| Ch | Threshold concept |
|---|---|
| 7 | The defense tells you where to go |
| 9 | You block an area, not a man, and the back reads the blocks |
| 12 | You can "block" a defender with a decision |
| 15 | The quarterback reads a defender, not a receiver |
| 19 | The run game is the first half of every play-action pass |
| 22 | Protection is arithmetic, and the quarterback is part of the protection |
| 25 | A play call is a bet on a distribution, not a promise of an outcome |
| 38 | An offense is a system of constraints |
Each is marked 🚪 Threshold concept in its chapter with an explicit before-and-after contrast. These
make the best exam questions and discussion openers, and they are the best diagnostics for the "I read
it and it seemed obvious" failure. A student who can explain, with a drawn example, why the Game 2 sack
happened with six blockers against five rushers has understood Chapter 22. A student who can define
"slide protection" has not.
The learning-science features look like padding. They are the parts that work.
Every chapter contains retrieval prompts (🔄 Check your understanding) roughly every 1,500 words; a
## Spaced Review (after Chapter 2) that revisits earlier ideas; at least one 🧩 Productive struggle
that poses a problem before teaching the answer; a 🔍 Why this works that explains the mechanism;
📋 Try it drills in four signature types (Draw it up, Make the call, Find the conflict, Whose
fault?); and an interleaved Part M in every exercise set that mixes the chapter with named earlier
ones. Metacognitive 🪞 Learning check-in prompts appear every third chapter (3, 6, 9 … 39).
Learners will want to skip all of it. Tell them early that the smooth feeling of reading forward is the feeling of learning nothing. Practically: assign the spaced reviews, grade Part M, and use the productive-struggle problems as opening activities rather than reading.
How to use the chapter notes and discussion guides
Chapter notes (index) are for your preparation. Read the note before you read the chapter's case studies, so you know which section carries the weight and what to cut when you fall behind. The timing section cites real section numbers. The "Where students get stuck" section names three to five chapter-specific misconceptions, each with a diagnostic you can run in the first ten minutes and an intervention. The whiteboard or film-room activity is written so you can put it on the board cold: the drawing, the question, and what a strong answer sounds like. Use it as the center of your session, not a closer.
Discussion guides (index) are for the room. They run from recall to analysis to judgment, and the judgment level is where offensive football gets interesting: Was the Mills call wrong, or unlucky, or both? Is Curtis Bale, the brilliant designer who called "the cool play" and was fired a season later, a cautionary tale or just an unlucky one? When should Wade Harmon overrule Marisol Vega's fourth-down chart, and when should Lyle stop arguing for the reset run? Each guide includes a structured debate or role-play (OC vs. DC, coordinator vs. analyst, Lyle vs. Curtis Bale) with roles and rules. These work best with eight to twenty people. With a larger lecture, run them in groups and take one report from each.
A practical 75-minute rhythm: ten minutes of retrieval (a cold board drawing or a whose-fault clip), thirty-five on the whiteboard or film activity, twenty of discussion, and ten on the Project Checkpoint.
How to use the anchors and the Playbook Project together
The anchors are not just stories. They are the worked examples your students' deliverables should imitate, and they map onto the project like this:
| Project Checkpoint | The anchor it should be checked against |
|---|---|
| Ch 7 Defensive Recognition Card | Anchor A's pre-snap picture: two high, a six-man box, the nickel outside, one of their six with two jobs. Can the student's card produce that read? |
| Ch 13 RPO Menu | Anchor A itself: the conflict defender named by position, his run job and his pass job, and the throw window he owns. If the student's RPO can't be described in that sentence, it isn't an RPO yet |
| Ch 16 Core Coverage-Beater Set | Anchor B: which defender is in the hi-lo, what he does against Cover 3 instead, and what the quarterback throws then (the Week 12 hitch +7) |
| Ch 19 Play-Action Package | Anchor D: each play-action pass married to a run from the identical look, with the "two receipts" rule written into the call sheet |
| Ch 22 Protection Plan | The Game 2 sack and Anchor C together: "one more rusher than it blocks," and a hot that can't be dropped into |
| Ch 24 Game Plan v1 | Lyle's mistake: every box carries a branch. A blank contingency row is an automatic revision |
| Ch 25 Call Sheet | Anchor C: at least three defensible calls for one situation, with the reasoning written before the result |
| Ch 39 Capstone | All four anchors plus the Mills snap, against the Sentinels packet in Appendix G |
A useful habit: at every milestone, ask each student to point to the anchor their deliverable resembles most and explain how theirs differs. The ones who can do it understand the deliverable. The ones who can't usually copied a template.
Level choice changes the deliverable, not the standard. A high school student's personnel cards assume the roster they have and a wristband rather than a radio; a college student's RPOs may use a deeper ineligible-downfield allowance (under their code; check it); a pro student builds under the NFL's one-yard rule and the 15-second radio cutoff; a film-room student writes each deliverable as a viewing and charting guide (what to look for, what it would prove) rather than an install. The rubrics apply to all four.
Assessment and grading philosophy
The assessment model mirrors what coordinators are actually evaluated on: can you draw it, can you see it, can you build it, can you call it under a clock, and can you defend it in a staff meeting?
| Mode | What it measures | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Board work | Can draw any run, pass concept, protection, or RPO pre- and post-snap in the book's notation, against a named defense, and state the rule in one sentence | Chapter-note whiteboard activities; chalk-talk guide |
| Film practicals | Can run the seven-item checklist, find the read or conflict defender, and grade process and result separately on unseen snaps | Film-lab guide; Chapter 40's ten-snap self-test |
| The Playbook Project | Can build a coherent, installable offense and a game plan against a real tendency report | Project Checkpoints; Rubrics 1 and 2 in rubrics |
| Simulations | Can make and defend calls inside the 40 seconds; can triage at halftime; can say back all eleven jobs | Chalk-talk guide; Rubric 5 |
| Exams | Can apply the threshold concepts and the box, protection, and option arithmetic to new situations | Midterm, final, assessment bank |
Four grading principles matter more than the weights.
Grade the reasoning, not the call. The book never claims one concept or one system is universally correct. Chapter 25 lays out at least three defensible calls for Anchor C. A student who calls smash where you would have called levels, and defends it with the shell, the leverage, the down, and the opponent's tendency, has done the job.
Grade process and result separately, always. This is the threshold concept of Chapter 25 turned into a grading rule. Marisol Vega grades every one of Lyle's calls twice, and the Chapter 40 process/result grid (earned, unlucky, lucky, deserved) belongs on every film assignment. A student who says "the interception proves Mills was a bad call" has made the most common error in football commentary. A student who says "Mills was a defensible call from a box with no branch, and the missing branch was knowable on Tuesday" has done the work.
Grade whose-fault answers by first cause, using the book's C / R / X marks. On Lyle's sheet a failed snap is the Call, a Rule, or a player's eXecution. The most common film error is blaming the player nearest the ball: the quarterback for the sack, the receiver for the interception. The Game 2 sack was a rule problem (the protection's answer to a dropping lineman), not Lorusso's ("I blocked air, Coach") and not Vance's ("I did it right, Coach"). Make proximity grading cost points.
Grade honesty with numbers. The book's analytics are hedged on purpose: counts before percentages, sample sizes stated, "since" dates on every tendency. Marisol's rule of thumb for calling something a tell is roughly 70 percent on ten or more snaps, and a small sample is a lean, not a fact. A student whose scouting report says "Kimbrough blitzes 58% on third-and-long" without the denominator should lose more points than a student whose number is wrong but correctly qualified.
The player-safety stance
The book takes a clear position, and this companion asks you to hold it in every room. The quarterback is the most protected person in the building: Austin's quarterbacks wear red no-contact jerseys every day, and in a blitz-pickup rep the scout rusher runs past and the coach calls it a sack. Contact is rationed using the ladder in Chapter 34 (walk, on air, thud, control, live), and most reps live at the low end; "thud means thud." Designed quarterback runs have a budget (about three a game for Vance, up to five in the playoffs with Wade's sign-off), and the slide is taught as a technique with reps. The book does not teach backside cut blocks, treats chop blocks as restricted at every level, and teaches crack and perimeter blocks in front of the defender, above the waist, head out of it. Rubs are route spacing, never blocks. Rules differ by level and change, so the book gives the principles and says "check your current code" rather than inventing numbers it can't stand behind, and so should you. A coach never decides a player is fine after a possible head injury; the medical staff does.
Required 🩺 Player safety callouts appear wherever cut, chop, or crack blocks, quarterback runs, or
contact drills are taught. The rules and player-safety teaching guide
covers how to teach this material responsibly and what to do if you run any on-field component.
Other things to say early
The numbers are fictional and honest about it. Every Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, Forge, and Ospreys person, game, call name, and statistic is a fictional composite. They are internally consistent so the arithmetic teaches something real (the four-game sample Russ's staff charted on Austin, 247 snaps, adds up every way you slice it) but they are not facts about any NFL team. Real history (the single wing, Shaughnessy's T, Paul Brown, Lombardi's sweep, Gillman and Coryell, Walsh's West Coast offense, Erhardt-Perkins, the run-and-shoot, Shanahan and Alex Gibbs, the Air Raid, the spread-option era, the 2017 Eagles' RPOs) appears only where it is well documented, and league-wide magnitudes are always hedged. Teach students to hedge the same way.
Defensive coaches are the smartest opponents in the book. Russ Kimbrough, the Sentinels' coordinator, is the best coach Lyle faces, and he wins two of three. Wade Harmon, Austin's head coach, is a former defensive coordinator who asks "how would I defend that?" in every meeting. The book's companion, NFL Defensive Coordination, tells the same season from Russ's sideline; you can name it to students who want the other half of the conversation. Model the respect. A room that sneers at defenses learns less offense.
No prior coaching is assumed. The prerequisite is basic football knowledge. Every term is defined on first use in each chapter, Appendix A covers the notation, and Appendix I is a full glossary. Mixed cohorts (former players, analytics students, fans, defensive coaches) are an asset. Structure discussion so the former quarterback and the student who has never played both have something to teach.
Choosing your course shape
| If you have… | Use | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| A 15-week semester, coaching-methods or sport-science program | syllabus-15-week-university.md | All forty chapters, core and reference sections marked each week; midterm after Chapter 20 |
| A high school offensive staff, spring through the season | syllabus-high-school-staff-development.md | Twelve sessions; the staff builds its own playbook against its own opponents |
| An analytics, media, fantasy, or betting program | syllabus-analyst-and-film-study.md | Film recognition and honest numbers; the Playbook Project at film-room level |
| Individual learners with no cohort | syllabus-self-paced.md | Stage-based, with self-tests at each checkpoint |
| A one-day clinic | Chapters 7, 13, and 19, plus the Chapter 40 checklist | Where to go, the conflict defender, and sequencing: three hours, three threshold ideas, one film method |
| A half-day for experienced coaches | Chapters 22 and 25 | Protection arithmetic and the bet-on-a-distribution idea, built around Anchor C and the Mills snap |
Adapting the book
The license lets you edit, reorder, translate, and redistribute, as long as you attribute it and share your version under the same license. Common adaptations:
- Substituting your own opponent for the Sentinels. Entirely reasonable for a high school staff. The Project Checkpoints describe the deliverable, not the opponent, so they transfer. Appendix G is the only file you must replace; give your staff a tendency sheet of their own opponent built on the Chapter 23 template.
- Re-leveling the field geometry. NFL hash marks sit near the middle of the field; college hashes
are wider apart; high school hashes divide the field into rough thirds. Field and boundary mean far
more below the NFL (a field-side quick out from the far hash is the longest throw in the menu), and
every chapter's
🏫 Any levelcallouts say how. - Re-ordering Parts II and III. Some programs teach the passing game first. The book is written run first because the run is "the first half of every play-action pass," but Chapters 15–18 and 21 stand on their own after Chapter 8 if your students arrive from a spread background.
- Teaching it alongside the defensive companion. Pair chapters by anchor: the same Game 3 interception is a disguise story on one side and a missing-branch story on the other. Students who read both learn that every snap is two plans meeting.
Where to start
- Read the front matter: the preface, "How to Use This Book," "Reading the Diagrams," and "Learning Paths."
- Read Chapter 7 and Chapter 13. They carry the first threshold concept and the book's signature idea (the conflict defender), and they set the voice, the notation, and Anchor A.
- Read Chapter 40 next, out of order. Its checklist is the film method you will use all term.
- Pick a syllabus.
- Read common-struggles.md before your first session, and the rules and player-safety teaching guide before you teach Part II.
- Decide whether you are running the Playbook Project, at which levels, and build the milestone dates into your calendar from day one.