Part V — Modern Innovations

Chapters 29–33


The year Curtis Bale got his first coordinator job, his offense was the one everybody in the league talked about. I watched every snap of it I could get my hands on, usually late at night with two coffees, and I wasn't watching to find holes. I was watching because it was beautiful.

Curtis and I had worked together on Walt Dupree's staff for two seasons. He was the best pure designer I've ever shared a room with. He could draw a play on a whiteboard that made every coach in the room go quiet, and then draw three more before anyone had finished writing the first one down. His first year calling plays, his offense led his conference in explosive plays. There were gadgets every week, shots off every look, formations nobody had a name for yet. Sixty-one formations, as it turned out, and thirty-eight of them carried exactly one play.

Nobody counted that in the first year. Defenses were too busy trying to line up.

By the second year they'd counted. They played deep, kept everything in front, and dared him to be patient. He wasn't. He stopped running the ball because the run wasn't where the highlights were, and once the run was gone, nobody in the box had a reason to stay honest. His quarterback was a pocket passer, and the pocket got smaller every week. In seventy long-yardage downs that season he didn't call a single screen. Then, down thirteen, on third-and-6 near midfield, his quarterback threw a choice route into a robber who'd been sitting in that exact spot on nine of the opponent's last thirteen third downs. He was fired before the next season.

I like Curtis. He isn't a villain in this book, and he isn't a fool. He's the most talented example I know of a mistake every one of us is tempted to make. He summed it up for me once, better than I could:

"I had the Air Raid's plays. I didn't have its patience."

That's the warning label for this part of the book. Every system in these five chapters changed football, and every one of them is easy to copy badly. You can copy the plays in a week. The reasons behind them are what's hard to copy, and the reasons are the part that works.


What this part teaches

Part V is five chapters on the ideas that reshaped offensive football in the last generation. Each one is taught the same way. What defensive problem did it answer? What makes it work? How did defenses answer it back? And what should you borrow, adapt, or leave alone?

Chapter 29 is the Shanahan system: wide zone, boot action, condensed formations, and one rule that holds the whole thing together. Everything starts as the same run for as long as possible. It's the purest form of illusion in football, and its coaching tree has spread across the league. Chapter 30 is the Air Raid, a solution to a talent problem that became a system. Its real inventions weren't the concepts. They were the exchange rate of fewer plays for more reps, and a practice method most teams never copied.

Chapter 31 is the quarterback revolution. When the quarterback is a runner, or just has to be accounted for as one, the defense loses its free tackler. The chapter teaches that arithmetic, the three taxes a running quarterback charges a defense, the scramble as a play you build for but never call, and the budget that keeps your quarterback upright. Chapter 32 is pace: no-huddle, tempo, and the clock. Pace is a play call too, and it has costs. The chapter covers the four-minute offense, kneel math, and two-minute clock budgeting. Chapter 33 is the gadget, the trick play done properly. A gadget punishes a habit, not a defense, and it needs a parent play, film evidence, and a trigger that shows up in the game itself.

What we took, and what we left

The Outlaws borrow from every one of these systems, and we reject parts of every one. Here's the short version. Each chapter gives you the long one.

Ch System The problem it answered What Austin adopted What Austin left or changed
29 Shanahan tree Big fronts and play-action nobody believed The identical first second; the boot as an evidence call Backside cut blocks; running into eight as an identity; under center adapted to Vance
30 Air Raid A line that couldn't win up front Mesh, Y Cross, Stick; the 12-minute "Air" period Five-man protection as a base; wide splits; tempo as an identity
31 The running QB The defense's free tackler on every handoff The plus-one on Inside Read; Rome's scramble rules A run-first quarterback identity; about three designed carries a game
32 Tempo Substitution and disguise Fast mode as a change-up after a big play; a four-minute plan Tempo as who we are; we're a motion team
33 Gadgets Defenders with habits A gadget card with a trigger; twelve clean reps first Novelty for its own sake; five gadgets all regular season

None of those verdicts is the right answer for you. They're right for Darius Vance, Gus Ferrante's line, and a staff that believes motion for information, the run for credibility, the pass for the kill. A high school with a 165-pound option quarterback should fill in that table very differently. That's the point of the deliverables in this part.

Why it sits here

Part V could have opened the book. Instead it comes after you've built a complete offense and learned how a week works, because you can't judge a system until you know what it would cost you to install. Every system in this part makes a trade. The Air Raid trades menu for reps. Tempo trades thinking time for the defense's legs. A running quarterback trades hits for arithmetic. A gadget trades a practice period for one snap. You can't price those trades until you've spent a Tuesday building a game plan and a Thursday deciding which periods to cut.

It also sets up Part VI. The next chapter after this part is about installation, which has one hard rule: if you can't rep it, you cut it. Part V is where you decide what's worth repping.

The chapters

  1. Chapter 29 — The Shanahan System: Wide Zone, Boot Action, Condensed Formations. Why the first second has to match exactly, why the boot is a withdrawal against runs you've already made, and how defenses answered with two high safeties and then heavier fronts.
  2. Chapter 30 — The Air Raid and Its NFL Children. The rep economy, the concepts and their conversion rules, pat-and-go and routes on air, and what the NFL kept and rebuilt.
  3. Chapter 31 — The Quarterback Revolution: Dual-Threat, Designed Runs, and Offensive Math. The plus-one, the box, rush, and spy taxes, the scramble rules, and designing for the quarterback you actually have.
  4. Chapter 32 — No-Huddle, Tempo, and Controlling the Clock. The gears of pace, the four taxes tempo charges, its costs to you, the four-minute offense, and two-minute budgeting.
  5. Chapter 33 — Trick Plays, Gadgets, and Calculated Deception. The parent play, the three conditions, the passing rules you have to know cold, and why most gadgets on a good staff are carried rather than called.

The four anchors in Part V

None of the four anchors lives in this part, but two of them have parents here.

Anchor D's four plays — run, run, play-action, run, all from one look — are the Shanahan tree's central rule applied to inside zone. Chapter 29 shows where that rule came from and why it works best when the defense has been paid twice. Anchor A's drive ended with Vance keeping the ball on a zone read for a 4-yard touchdown, the plus-one arithmetic Chapter 31 explains. The RPO that started the drive is a college idea, and Chapter 30 follows its trip to the NFL.

Anchors B and C are Part III and Part IV stories. You won't need them here.

Your Playbook Project in Part V

Part V's deliverables are mostly decisions, and most of them are about what you won't do. Every one of them should be written in three columns, adopt, adapt, and reject, with a reason in each row.

Ch Deliverable
29 Wide Zone & Boot Family (or "Shanahan Borrow List"): what you adopt, adapt, or reject
30 Spread Quick-Game & Tempo Borrow List: the Air Raid concepts and practice methods you'll use
31 QB-Run Package: designed QB runs scaled to your quarterback's ability and durability
32 Tempo Package: a no-huddle call system, signals, and a four-minute plan
33 Gadget Package: 2–3 trick plays, each with a trigger condition and a practice plan

Before you write any of them, apply our install rule: nothing new goes in unless something comes out. Every borrowed idea costs practice reps that something else in your offense is already using.

Before you start

  1. Name one play in your offense that looks exactly like another play for its first second. If you can't, what does the defense learn from your first step?
  2. Your quarterback runs a 4.9 forty. Should your offense have a zone read in it? What would its job be?
  3. You hit a 25-yard pass. What do you gain by snapping the next play fast, and what do you give up?
  4. A defensive end has chased your jet sweep on 19 of 23 snaps on film. What has to happen in this game before you call the reverse?
  5. You've just watched a championship offense you love. Which of its plays will you copy, and what problem in your league does each one solve?

If you only read one chapter in this part

Read Chapter 29. "Everything looks the same" is the idea that turns a pile of plays into an offense, and it's the reason Anchor D worked.

Chapters in This Part