Chapter 24 — Instructor Notes
What this chapter is for
Chapter 23 produced a report. Chapter 24 turns it into a plan: the middle rung of the ladder from Chapter 1 (philosophy → system → playbook → game plan → call sheet → call). The worked example is the divisional-round plan against Sacramento: 112 calls, of which Austin used 61 snaps. The chapter builds it piece by piece: the three questions (§24.3), take away / attack / avoid (§24.4), the run/pass mix (§24.5), the 15-play script (§24.6), series cards (§24.7), situation boxes (§24.8), and contingencies (§24.9).
The hook is the chapter's argument in one image. It's 12:40 a.m. on the Tuesday of divisional week. Teo walks in with the updated page: "Twenty-nine for twenty-nine." Lyle writes "Mills" in the box marked "3rd LONG vs. 2x2" and caps the marker without writing a branch. The rest of the chapter is a well-built plan, and you should let students admire it, because it was good. Then §24.9 shows the contingency table with its last row blank. Every tendency box needs a branch, and the branch needs reps. The deepest sentence in the chapter is "a rule that fires on doubt can't protect you from confidence."
Teach this chapter as both a craft lesson and a cautionary tale. A plan can be excellent in eleven places and still lose in the twelfth.
Teaching objectives
By the end of the session a student should be able to:
- Write the three plan questions for an opponent (What will they leave, and is my guy better than theirs there? What must we take away? What do they do when we do X?), each with a concrete example.
- Build a TAKE AWAY / ATTACK / AVOID table where take-aways are rules and attacks carry conditions (Sutton vs. Brennan only without a safety over the top).
- Set early-down mix targets from the opponent and explain why a six-man box at the snap against Quarters became an eight-man fit at the mesh.
- Write a script slot with a call, a question, "if A →," and "if B →," including at least one call that breaks the offense's own tendency.
- Build a series card from one look, with a written trigger for each step.
- Write contingency rows with no blank lines, each with a rep plan.
- Run the four-step disagreement process (tape test → one-sentence test → rep test → coordinator decides and writes the dissent in the margin).
Timing
In a 75-minute session: 10 minutes on the hook and §24.1's architecture (the boxes). 15 minutes on §24.3–§24.4, using the 🧩 Productive struggle (three take-away lines, using Vance's 28-of-36 against five-plus and 31-of-52 with three interceptions against four with rotation) before showing the answer. 15 minutes on §24.6: Walt's "Script the first fifteen to learn, not to win," then script slot #1, the jet sweep at the Austin 29, and what "rolled" told the staff. 15 minutes on §24.7's bender branch (board drawing below). 20 minutes on §24.9: the contingency table, the Mills pair, and "Why rule 1 and rule 4 didn't save it."
In a 150-minute block: add §24.2's Tuesday 7 a.m. meeting as a role-play (Gus vs. Marisol on Twelve: 3 of 8 successful against big nickel; resolved by turning Twelve into a boot package). Add §24.5's mix table (plan targets 32/18/20/23/7 against the sample's 37/20/21/17/5), the 📋 Make the call on which script question to drop, and the 📋 Whose fault? on the Mills interception. Close with Case Study 2.
What to cut when you're behind: §24.8's red-zone and clock boxes go to reading, because Chapter 26 owns situations; keep only the mug box and the "behind by three, about four minutes" box's first line (range line about the Sacramento 35). Reduce §24.2's weekly calendar to the disagreement rule. Don't cut §24.9. Without it the chapter teaches a beautiful plan and hides how it lost.
Where students get stuck
The plan is a list of our best plays. Diagnostic: ask students to write a ten-call plan for any opponent before reading. Most will list favorites. Intervention: the three questions come before any play. Case Study 2 dramatizes it: Curtis Bale's "Score in 15" script and Walt's "Which one of these is asking them anything?"
A script is a list of questions, and that's enough. Students who learn the first lesson overcorrect. Diagnostic: have them write five script slots; most will have no answer columns. Intervention: Walt's second line to Lyle in Case Study 2: "Good questions. What are you going to do when they answer?" Every slot needs "if A →" and "if B →," and a slot whose answer wouldn't change a later call gets deleted.
Run/pass mix is a philosophy. "We're a 50/50 team." Diagnostic: Exercise B1. Two safeties at eleven yards, both coming downhill at the mesh. Ask for the box count. Intervention: six at the snap, eight fitters at the mesh. Against Quarters, Marisol's six-man-box runs looked like the seven-man number. The mix is an output of the opponent; what stays fixed is that every kept run is paired with play-action and RPOs that punish the fitting safety.
A sequence can be called whenever you like. Diagnostic: ask when they'd call "Inside PA, Gaines Post." Many will say "first down, early." Intervention: Case Study 1's Holloway card (15 of 21 fills). Two runs first, from the identical look, with "no motion, no personnel change, no new formation while the card is live" and "the card waits."
A 29-for-29 tendency doesn't need a contingency. This is the chapter's main trap. Diagnostic: quiz item 14. Intervention: the blank last row, Thursday's scout team showing two-high on every Mills rep, and Rome's margin dissent ("Post vs. two-high is pre-snap. Want a post-snap check?") answered with "Rule four covers." Rule four is a doubt rule, and the plan had removed the doubt.
Whiteboard / film-room activity
One route, two answers. Draw the bender branch from §24.7 and run it as a read, not a play.
BENDER vs. Home -- "Eleven, Gun Trey Right, 60 Left, Bender"
(field to the right; read = Simmons's eyes)
$ Holloway carries the stem
12 yds +-----------------> A: bender
| (eyes jump)
9 |
| C Simmons
6 | Z< B: hitch
| | (eyes stay)
Y H Z
Q pump at the hitch, read Simmons
📊 Diagram (described): Three receivers are to the right. Harlan is attached, Powers is in the slot, and Gaines is wide. Gaines runs a six-yard hitch. Powers stems straight upfield past nine yards so Holloway stays deep with him, then breaks out at twelve. Vance pumps at the hitch and reads Simmons. If the corner's eyes jump to the hitch and he drives forward, the ball goes to Powers on the out behind him. If his eyes stay on Powers, the ball goes to Gaines at six.
What to ask: "Who is the conflict defender? What is he torn between? In the second quarter at 2nd-and-7 from our 36, his eyes jumped, and we gained 14. Russ's staff saw it at halftime. On 3rd-and-6 at their 44 his eyes stayed home. What should the ball have done, and what part of the plan was responsible for that snap?"
What a strong answer sounds like: "Simmons is torn between the hitch underneath and Powers's out behind him; Holloway is held by the vertical stem. In the third quarter the card said hitch. The plan did its job, because it had both answers and Thursday repped both versions of Simmons in equal numbers. The miss was the read." Then contrast it with Mills: the bender box had two answers and reps for both; the third-long box had one answer and reps for one. Same staff, same week.
Assessment notes
Assign: A2, A5, A7, and A10 for recall; B1 (box count at the snap vs. the mesh), B3 (the bender picture), and B5 (Mills against rotation; name the missing line); C1 (script slot #1 with the RPO moved to #2), C2 (build a series card and draw step 3), and C7 (four contingency rows, each with a rep plan; the answer key gives half credit to rows without reps). D2 (how many of ten Thursday reps go to the branch?) and D5 (add an unrepped second answer or leave the box alone?) are the best judgment items. M5, with Chapter 1, asks at which rung the interception's deepest cause lived.
Quiz: items 4, 5, 14, and 19 are the core. Items 20 and 21 are paired applied scenarios: one plan that handled a defensive change, one that didn't. Teach them side by side.
The Project Checkpoint is Game Plan v1 + a 15-Play Opening Script vs. the Sentinels, five pages: (1) the three questions, (2) the menu of boxes from openers through backed up, each call with a sponsor and a one-sentence reason, (3) two or three series cards with triggers, (4) at least five contingency rows, including one for a tendency that has held on every charted snap, with no blank rows, and (5) the script with columns for #, call, question, if A →, if B →, at least one conditional slot, and at least one tendency-breaker.
A strong one traces every script call back to a row on the student's Chapter 23 page, and its contingency for the perfect tendency has both a call and a rep count (the chapter's model row gives four branch reps on Thursday). The most common failure is a script with no answer columns; the second is a contingency page whose hardest row says only "adjust." Grade both hard. For pro-level submissions, require the dissent in the margin.
Any-level adaptation
High school staff: the checkpoint's track is an 8–10 call script, a 30–40 call menu, boxes split by hash, and one contingency per third-down box. The disagreement rule matters even more on a three-coach staff, and writing a dissent in the margin is a good habit for a young assistant.
College class: a 12–15 call script and a 60–80 call menu. Have students note which calls depend on their code's ineligible-downfield rule, since RPO and play-action boxes change by level. Check the current code.
Analyst course: the film-room track and Exercise E1 reverse-engineer a real team's opening possessions and guess the question behind each call. Exercise E3 compares two coordinators' first fifteen. Insist on the chapter's honesty line: you never see the call sheet.
Connections
Backward: Chapter 23 supplies every input; Chapter 19's four-play sequence is the Holloway card; Chapter 13 explains why Inside Slant moved from slot #1 to #2; Chapter 22 built the mug box's protection; Chapter 7's "the shell is not the coverage" is the warning the third-long box ignored.
Forward: Chapter 25 turns the plan into a call sheet and owns the Game 3 third-and-7 and Mills decisions; Chapter 26 develops the situation boxes; Chapter 36 shows what Russ did between the two bender snaps. Appendix F has the script and plan templates; Appendix G is the opponent.