Chapter 5 Exercises — The Offensive Line
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and explanation · ⭐⭐ recognition and application · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment, trade-offs, and design · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension: research and film study beyond the chapter
The Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Forge, Ospreys, and Pioneers are the book's fictional teams. Selected answers are in Appendix J; short answers to Part C items appear below each problem.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Name the five offensive line positions from left to right, and give one job that belongs to each position more than to any other.
A2. Define covered and uncovered as this chapter uses the terms for zone blocking. Why does the definition use the lineman's play-side gap and not only the man directly in front of him?
A3. In your own words, explain why a combination block waits for the linebacker to commit before one blocker climbs. What happens to the play if the climber leaves early? If he leaves late?
A4. Zone blocking and gap blocking differ in who decides the hole. Explain the difference, and name one kind of defense each family is designed to punish.
A5. On Power, the center blocks away from the play. Explain why, using the word "puller."
A6. Describe the three pass sets a tackle uses (vertical, angle, quick). For each, name the rusher alignment it fits best and the price the tackle pays for using it.
A7. What is an overset? Why is the inside rush that follows it more dangerous than a rusher who beats the tackle around the corner?
A8. Explain the difference between passing off a twist and manning it. Which blocker usually causes the sack on a T-E twist, and why?
A9. What is a Mike ID, and why can an offense legitimately point at a defender who isn't the defense's actual middle linebacker?
A10. Define an air block. In the Game 2 sack, how many air blocks were there, who made them, and what did they do to the protection arithmetic?
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. End-zone view. At the snap, all five linemen take a short lateral step to their right. The center and right guard both put a hand on the 3-technique; the left guard and left tackle both put a hand on the nose. The tight end on the right releases outside without blocking the end. What is the run-blocking family, which direction is the play, and which defender is being left alone on purpose?
B2. End-zone view. At the snap, the right tackle and right guard block down to their left, the center blocks to his right, the left guard opens his hips and runs flat behind the center toward the right, and the left tackle steps inside and sets up like a pass protector. A fullback runs at the end man on the line of scrimmage on the right. Name the play and the direction. What is the left tackle doing, and what is the term for it?
B3. Same picture as B2, except both the left guard and the left tackle pull to the right, the guard kicking out the end man on the line and the tackle turning up through the hole. The back took a jab step to the left before taking the handoff. Name the play.
B4. Third down, a four-man rush. The defensive tackle over the right guard drives hard outside into the right tackle; a beat later, the right defensive end comes inside behind him. The right guard follows the tackle outside, and the end runs untouched into the A-gap. What was the defensive game, what was the blocking error, and what's the one-word call that should have been made?
B5. Read this pre-snap picture and name what it suggests:
W M
E N T E
LT LG C RG RT
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Two linebackers stand right at the line, one in each A-gap on either side of the center. The nose tackle has moved from the center to head-up on the left guard; a 3-technique is on the right guard's outside shoulder; the ends are outside both tackles. The quarterback is in the shotgun with the back on his right.
What is this look called in this chapter, what alignment detail is a tell, and what protection question does it force before the snap?
B6. On a third-and-8 dropback against a four-man rush, the end-zone film shows the right guard set, punch, and then stand with his hands open, looking around, as the 3-technique in front of him backpedals into the short zone under the slot. A linebacker runs free through the A-gap. What happened, and what does it tell you about how the defense scouted your protection?
B7. Watch the left tackle on three consecutive pass plays in one series: on the first two he kicks straight back, deep and wide, and the end runs a speed rush around him. On the third, he kicks even deeper and wider, and the end plants and spins back inside. Name the tackle's error and the rusher's counter. What does Teo's charting say about this tendency for Ben Achterberg?
B8. Broadcast view, second-and-6. The quarterback is under center. Before the snap, every lineman is in a three-point stance except the left tackle, who is in a two-point stance — on this snap only. Earlier in the game, the left tackle was in a two-point stance on the three obvious passing downs and in a three-point stance on every early down. What is the left tackle's stance telling the defense, and what would you tell your line coach on Monday?
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. Draw it up. Draw inside zone to the right from Gun Doubles Right (11 personnel, Harlan attached right) against a Nickel Under front: weak-side end in a 5-technique outside the left tackle; a 3-technique on the left guard's outside shoulder; a nose shaded on the center's right shoulder; a strong-side end in a 5-technique outside the right tackle; Will and Mike off the ball. Label each blocker covered or uncovered and give his assignment.
Short answer
Play-side is right; check each blocker's own spot and his play-side gap.
| Blocker | Check | Covered? | Assignment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Y | D-gap empty | Uncovered | Arc to the alley player (strong safety) |
| RT | 5-technique on his outside shoulder | Covered | Block the end |
| RG | Nobody on him; play-side B-gap empty | Uncovered | Combo the end with the RT, eyes on the Mike; climb |
| C | Nose shaded on his right (play-side) shoulder | Covered | Block the nose |
| LG | 3-technique on his backside shoulder; play-side A-gap empty | Uncovered | Combo the nose with the C, eyes on the Will; climb |
| LT | 3-technique in his play-side B-gap | Covered | Scoop/cut off the 3-technique |
| Backside end | — | — | Left alone; held by the fake |
The hardest block is the left tackle's scoop on a 3-technique who starts a step closer to the ball than he does — which is why Under fronts are built to make backside zone blocking difficult.
C2. Draw it up. Draw Power Right from Twenty-one personnel, Offset I Right, Harlan attached right, against a 4-3 Under: strong-side end in a 9-technique outside Harlan, nose in a 1-technique shaded on the center's right, 3-technique on the left guard, weak end in a 5. Sam, Mike, Will off the ball. Who pulls, who kicks, and who back-blocks?
Short answer
Power Right: Y down to the backer (Sam) or double with the RT if the 9 slants; RT and RG double-team the nose (shaded into the RG's inside gap) and one climbs to the Mike; C back-blocks to the left, toward the 3-technique, to fill the space the puller leaves; LG (Kendrick Moss, going this way) pulls and wraps inside the kick-out to the first linebacker; LT hinges on the backside end; fullback (Fale) kicks out the 9-technique; R follows the puller. Notice the weak point: the center's back block on a 3-technique who is outside the left guard is a long reach. Against this front many staffs change the backside rule (for example, the backside tackle blocks down on the 3-technique and the center takes the backside A-gap) or simply run the play the other way.
C3. Make the call. A hypothetical against the Birmingham Forge, whose DC Dwight Seldon blitzes everything from Cover 1 and Cover 0: 3rd-and-6 at the Forge 38 in a one-score game. The Forge show six on the line — four linemen and both linebackers walked into the A-gaps — with a single safety at 14 yards. You have "60 Left," "70," and "80 Max" available, and a quick-game call (slants to Powers and Gaines) on the wristband. Pick a protection-and-play pairing, name the hot, and say what you give up.
Short answer
A defensible answer: "60 Left" with the quick game. Six blockers on six visible threats; if a seventh comes (a corner or the safety), the slant to the side of the extra rusher is the hot, and the ball is out at about 1.0–1.3 seconds — before the extra man arrives. You give up the deep shot, but against Cover 0 you want the ball out fast. An equally defensible answer is "80 Max" with a two-man route (the "zero bin" logic: protect everything and throw over the top), which beats Cover 0 if it holds for about three seconds — you give up the checkdown. "70" in between is the weakest: seven blockers still might not cover seven rushers, and you've lost a receiver. The reasoning is graded: count rushers, count blockers, name the hot.
C4. Make the call. A hypothetical from the wild-card game at Oklahoma City. Terrence Vail's Ospreys love simulated pressures: they show five or six rushers and bring four, dropping a lineman. You've been beaten twice by a dropping 3-technique in the field slot window. It's 2nd-and-9 at your own 33, first quarter, 0–0. What change do you make in your protection rule or your route to make the dropping lineman pay?
Short answer
Two good options. (1) Change the hot's location, not the protection: put the hot throw on the boundary side or on a route that breaks away from where the dropper goes (a quick out outside him, or a seam behind him). (2) Treat the dropper as a blocker you get back: if your guard's man drops, the guard's rule becomes "help inside, then look for the A-gap runner" — exactly what we did in the divisional playoff when the right guard's man dropped. Either way, stop throwing into the spot the dropper is designed to occupy.
C5. Draw it up. Draw a T-E twist on the right side of the line (the 3-technique on the right guard crashes outside; the right end loops inside), and show how the right guard and right tackle pass it off. Then draw what happens if the right tackle sets three yards deeper than the guard.
Short answer
Passed off on the same level: the RT takes the crashing tackle as he comes outside; the RG feels his man leave, stays home, and takes the end looping inside; one of them calls "Switch!" With the RT three yards deeper, the looper runs between their two levels: the guard can't reach him because he's already past the guard's shoulder, and the tackle is behind the play. Uneven depth kills the exchange.
C6. Make the call. Game 3 rewind. You're in the coaches' booth with Teo before the Q3 opening drive at Sacramento, trailing 10–7. Your scouting says: on third-and-7-plus against two-by-two, the Sentinels have stayed two-high every snap since their bye, except that the double-A mug with the corner blitz beat you in Game 2. Write the two-sentence protection rule you'd give Vance and Szabo for a third-and-7 where the mug shows, and the one-sentence instruction you'd give Gaines.
Short answer
Protection: "Against the mug, the center takes the Mike, the back takes the other A-gap linebacker, and the right tackle widens to the corner if the field corner is within seven yards; if the 3-technique drops, the guard helps inside." Gaines: "If your corner blitzes, sight-adjust to a six-yard hitch and get your eyes around immediately." That's what we used — and it produced zero free rushers and a 10-yard first down.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Your left tackle has given up four pressures to the opponent's best rusher by halftime. You can (a) chip with the back on every dropback, (b) keep the tight end in to help, (c) slide the protection toward him on long downs, or (d) call more quick game and screens to his side. Rank the four by what each costs your offense, and explain what the defense learns from each. (Hint: reread the Game 2 sack before you rank (c).)
D2. You're playing on the road in a loud stadium. Your starting right guard is out, and your backup has eight snaps of NFL experience. Gus wants to cut the line's call list in half for this game. What do you lose by simplifying, what do you gain, and how would you decide?
D3. Your tackles use a two-point stance on third-and-long and a three-point stance on early downs. Marisol shows you that a division opponent's ends are starting their rush a beat earlier on two-point snaps. Do you change the stance rule? Lay out the trade-off, and propose a way to "break" the tell without making your left tackle slower on third-and-long.
D4. You coach high school. A colleague recommends backside cut blocks on your outside zone, because "that's how the Broncos did it." Write a short answer that addresses legality (by code, without quoting a specific rule number), player safety, and whether your scheme needs it.
D5. Our base protection rule against an overload was "slide to the most bodies, set the back to the same side, make the leftover your hot." The Game 2 sack showed that a defense that knows the rule can manufacture a crowd (by walking an end out late) to move the back away from a rusher. Propose one change to the rule that keeps its strengths but removes that weakness. What new weakness does your change create? (There is always one.)
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 3 + Ch 5) In the Game 2 sack, Harlan was flexed four yards off the left tackle rather than attached. Using Chapter 3's strength rules and this chapter's covered/uncovered logic, explain how flexing the tight end changed the Sentinels' front and therefore what the line had to count. Would the same pressure have looked the same against Harlan attached?
M2. (Ch 4 + Ch 5) In Game 1, our 12-personnel snaps saw nickel on 9 and base on 5. After that game the Sentinels played big nickel against 12 every time. Explain how each of those defensive personnel answers changes the line's arithmetic on outside zone (blockers vs. box defenders), and which you'd rather run against.
M3. (Ch 2 + Ch 5) Chapter 2 traced Vince Lombardi's Packers power sweep, Joe Gibbs's counter trey, and the Shanahan–Alex Gibbs outside zone. For each, name the line technique this chapter introduced that the play depends on most (pull, kick-out, wrap, reach, scoop, cutoff), and explain why that technique, not the ball carrier, is the play's heart.
M4. (Ch 1 + Ch 5) Lyle's thesis is "Motion for information, the run for credibility, the pass for the kill." Rewrite that thesis as three sentences about what the offensive line must provide for each clause to be true.
M5. (Ch 3 + Ch 5) Rodney Kalu reports as eligible in our Jumbo package. Using Chapter 3's formation legality rules, explain what Kalu must do before the snap, where he must line up to be an eligible receiver, and what common formation error would make an eligible tight end ineligible in the same package.
M6. (Ch 1 + Ch 4 + Ch 5) On the second snap of our opening drive in Game 1, Vance handed off on inside zone into a box the Will linebacker had just left, and Ruffin gained 7 with "five blockers on five." Using this chapter's covered/uncovered rules, explain what "five on five" means for the line — which defenders were left for the combos to climb to, and why a read play that removes one linebacker from the box makes every zone rule easier. Then connect it to the thesis "every play is the reason the next one works": what did the first snap of the drive do for the line on the second?
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. The air-block count. Choose one NFL team and watch every third-and-6-or-longer dropback from one game on end-zone film (All-22 or a coaches' cut). For each snap, record: number of rushers, number of blockers, number of air blocks (a blocker who set and had no rusher), whether there was a free rusher, and the result. Then answer: were the free rushers caused by more rushers than blockers or by blockers on droppers? What does the defense seem to know about this team's protection?
E2. Pressure vs. sacks. Using a public source that reports pressures and sacks by team (for example Pro Football Focus, Next Gen Stats–based metrics, or play-by-play data from the nflverse community), compare five teams' pressure rates with their sack rates. Which teams turn pressure into sacks least often? Watch two of their quarterbacks under pressure and describe what they do (climb, throw away, escape). Write a paragraph on how much of a team's sack rate you'd assign to its line, hedging honestly.
E3. The continuity study. Pick a team that had multiple offensive-line injuries in one season. Using public game logs, note how many different starting five-man combinations it used and chart its rushing success (or yards per carry, if success rate isn't available to you) by combination. Then watch two games with a backup in the lineup and look specifically for communication failures — two blockers on one defender, or a stunt not passed off. Do you see evidence for the "five who can hear each other" idea? State the limits of your sample.