Case Study 1 — Sixty-Eight From One-Ninety: Building the First Austin Core

A professional-level case about assembly and cutting, told by Lyle Petrakis about his first spring as the Outlaws' offensive coordinator, four seasons before the season this book follows. The Outlaws and everyone in this case are fictional; the counts are illustrative.


Setup

When I got to Austin, the offense I inherited lived in four three-ring binders on a shelf in the coordinator's office. The coordinator before me was a good coach from a different tree, and his offense had real ideas in it: a deep dropback game, a big set of route combinations, a lot of formations. By my count on the first night, the binders held a little over 190 plays.

I had about four months before the first rookie walked into the building in July and about five months before the first preseason game. Here's what I had to work with:

Input What it was
The binders 190-odd plays, sorted by formation, not by family
Last season's film Every offensive snap, plus the opponents' film on us
A head coach Wade Harmon, a former defensive coordinator, who'd hired me to build a motion, run-and-play-action offense
A quality control coach The one we had then, who would leave for a college job a couple of years later
My own history A college RPO world, a West Coast mentor (Walt Dupree), and one season on a wide-zone staff
One rule from Walt "Every play is a question. Know what you're asking."

What I didn't have was a philosophy written down. I had one in my head. That turned out to be the problem with the first week.


What Happens

Week one: reading the binders

I spent the first week reading every page. That was a mistake, though a common one. By Friday I had opinions about 190 plays and no way to decide among them, because I hadn't written the thing every decision had to answer to. Every play looked good on its own page. Most plays do.

Week two: the napkin

In my second week, Wade called me into his office, slid a napkin across the desk, and asked, "What do you believe? One napkin." I wrote four lines:

Motion for information. The run for credibility. The pass for the kill. Every play is the reason the next one works.

Wade read it, folded it once, and put it in his desk drawer. (It's on his desk now.) "Good," he said. "Now cut the binders until every page agrees with that."

That sentence gave me a test I could apply 190 times.

Weeks three and four: the film test

The quality control coach and I charted every offensive snap from the previous season: play, formation, personnel, result. Then we sorted the binders by how often each play had actually been called.

How often a play was called last season Plays
Never 71
Once or twice 48
Three to nine times 39
Ten or more 33

More than half the binder had been called twice or less. A play called twice in a season isn't really in your offense; it's a guest. Some of those guests were excellent, but every one of them had cost practice time in the week it was installed and teaching time every camp after that.

Weeks five and six: the entrance exam

This is where the six questions I still use were written, on a legal pad, in roughly the order I asked them:

  1. Picture. Does it share a formation, personnel group, and backfield with at least one other play?
  2. Defender. Which defender does it stress, by role?
  3. Partner. What does it set up, or what sets it up?
  4. Words. Can it be called in ten words or fewer?
  5. Reps. Will it get two full-speed reps in a week it's on the plan?
  6. One sentence. Can the quarterback explain it in one sentence?

The napkin decided which families we were building around: inside zone and duo from Eleven, outside zone from Twelve, play-action and boot off both, a quick game, and dropback concepts read by defenders. So the exam started there. Every inside-zone-family play that passed went in. Every play that failed question 1 or question 3 went to a new page at the back: the parking lot.

The hardest cut was a beautiful double-move shot from a formation the old offense used for almost nothing else. It had been called three times the season before and gained big yardage once. It failed the picture test and the partner test. I hated cutting it. I parked it, and it stayed parked, because it never found a picture of its own.

Week seven: the pictures

Once the plays were sorted by family, we sorted them again by picture. The old binders had more than thirty formations that carried at least one play. The new core had eleven pictures, and the most-used one was already the one this book's opening anchors came from: Eleven, two-by-two, the tight end attached, the back offset. From it, the first core carried Inside, Inside Read, Inside PA, Counter, and a slant RPO.

CUTTING THE INHERITED BOOK (first spring in Austin)

  190+ plays in 4 binders, sorted by formation
        |
        |  film test: 71 never called last season;
        |  60 parked, 11 argued back in by a coach
        v
  ~130 plays still under review
        |
        |  napkin test: does it serve "run for credibility,
        |  pass for the kill, motion for information"?
        v
  ~95 plays
        |
        |  entrance exam: picture, defender, partner,
        |  words, reps, one sentence
        v
  68 plays from 11 pictures  ------>  PARKING LOT
  (the first Austin core)             (kept, not called)

📊 Diagram (described): A funnel from top to bottom. It starts with a little over 190 plays in four binders sorted by formation. The film test found 71 plays that were never called the season before; 60 of them were parked and 11 were argued back in by a coach, leaving about 130 plays under review. The napkin test, asking whether each play serves the philosophy's lines about the run, the pass, and motion, leaves about 95. The six-question entrance exam leaves 68 plays from eleven pictures, the first Austin core, with an arrow to the side showing the rest going to a parking lot where they're kept but not called.

Camp: the say-back

The test of the core came the night before the first preseason game, in the eleven-man say-back that's now our rookie final exam: one call, eleven players, each one saying his job out loud. If a rookie couldn't say it back, the word or the play came out. Two words came out that summer. No plays did, because the plays had already been cut to what the room could learn.

What the core got wrong

The core was right about plays and wrong about one rule. In that first season we ran every motion on one clock, and the timing busts piled up until we gave each motion word its own clock (early or late) with an owner. That rule became part of our language page, and it's why the capstone puts the language page in front of the play list: the list of plays was fine; the rules around it were thin.


Analysis

Why the cut worked: the mechanism. The film test removed plays the old offense didn't really use. The napkin test removed plays that didn't serve the new offense's beliefs. The entrance exam removed plays that couldn't live in a system: no shared picture, no partner, too many words, not enough reps. Each test cut a different kind of play, which is why all three were needed.

Test What it caught What it would have missed alone
Film test Guests: plays called twice or less A good, often-called play that fights the new philosophy
Napkin test Plays that serve a different belief A play that fits the belief but has no shared picture
Entrance exam Orphans, long calls, unrepped plays A play that's systemic but serves the old philosophy

Why the order mattered. I started with the play pages and got nowhere for a week. The napkin went first after that, and every later decision was easier, because each cut answered to a written sentence instead of to my taste. That's the capstone's order: philosophy, language, picture, then plays.

The honest limit. A smaller core is not automatically a better one. Sixty-eight plays from eleven pictures was right for a team with our quarterback's skills and our line's practice time, and wrong for nobody in particular. The previous offense wasn't foolish; it was built for a different philosophy, and its size was a cost that philosophy chose to pay. The cut made our offense coherent, and coherence is what the defense can't solve by studying one play.

What the parking lot is for. Parked plays are not deleted. Several came back over four seasons when a new picture gave them a home, and that's exactly the condition the exam sets.


Discussion Questions

  1. Lyle spent his first week reading every play and got nowhere. Why does a philosophy have to come before the play-by-play review, not after it?
  2. The film test found 71 plays never called the previous season. Should a never-called play always be cut? Describe a play that might deserve to stay even with zero calls, and the condition it must meet.
  3. The double-move shot gained big yardage once in three calls. Why wasn't that enough to keep it? What would have had to change for it to pass the exam?
  4. The first core's biggest flaw was a motion rule, not a play. What does that tell you about where to look first when your capstone fails in camp?
  5. Lyle says the previous offense "wasn't foolish." Why is that judgment important for a coordinator who inherits a playbook, and for the players who learned it?

Your Turn

Take the playbook you have now, whether it's your own, your team's, or a real NFL team's inferred from film. In one sitting:

  1. Write your napkin, four lines or fewer.
  2. Count how often each play was called in your last season (or the last four games you can chart).
  3. Run every play through the six questions and sort it into core or parking lot.
  4. Group the core by picture and count the pictures.

Report three numbers (plays in, plays in the core, pictures) and the hardest cut you made, with the question it failed.