Chapter 37 Exercises — The Coaching Career
Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and understanding · ⭐⭐ application to a described situation · ⭐⭐⭐ judgment under trade-offs · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension, research, and film study
These exercises treat a coaching career the way the rest of this book treats a defense. There are inputs, a structure, a decision, and a reason. Where a question asks for a decision, the reasoning is graded, not the answer. Selected answers are in Appendix J.
All Austin Outlaws people and events are fictional. Real coaches and real league policies appear only where they're widely documented, and policy details should always be checked against the current version.
Part A — Conceptual ⭐
A1. Name the six main rungs of the offensive coaching ladder from the bottom to the top (any level). For each, write the skill it teaches in five words or fewer.
A2. What is a graduate assistant (GA), and why does the NFL have no direct equivalent? What does the GA get paid in, besides money?
A3. Lyle says a move across ladders is "almost always a trade of title for learning, or learning for title." Classify each of these moves: (a) Lyle, college OC → NFL QC; (b) Teo, NFL QC → FCS passing-game coordinator; (c) an NFL quarterbacks coach → college offensive coordinator; (d) a high-school head coach → college GA.
A4. Give two reasons, from Section 37.4, that coordinator hires tend to travel through coaching trees. Then name the cost of that habit in one sentence.
A5. Explain why "who you know" is better understood as "who has seen your work." Use Lyle's Christmas cards to Walt Dupree as the example.
A6. Why are coaching staffs usually fired as units? What does that mean for an assistant who had an excellent season?
A7. Describe the Rooney Rule in three sentences: when it was adopted, who it's named for, and what it originally required. Then name one way it has been expanded since, and say why you should check the current version.
A8. What is the "pipeline argument" about diversity in coaching, and why does it point at GA, QC, and quarterbacks-room hires rather than head-coaching interviews?
A9. Lyle says his 140-page binder was "sampled, not read." What design rule follows from that?
A10. State Lyle's four job questions and the rule that sits on top of them.
Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐
B1. A head coach draws this on the whiteboard in your interview: single-high safety, four down linemen, Mike and Sam linebackers, strong safety walked down over the tight end, and the Will in an apex between the left tackle and the slot. He says, "Eight in the box." (a) Count the box the way Lyle did. (b) Name the defender with two jobs. (c) Name the two jobs.
B2. Same whiteboard. The head coach erases the Will and walks the nickel over your slot with inside leverage. Does Inside Slant still have a conflict defender? What does the inside-leverage nickel give up, and what would you do with it?
B3. Here is a career timeline. Identify the one move that traded learning for title, the one that traded title for learning, and the one that was a lateral title for a new skill.
SEASONS ROLE WHERE
1 - 4 High-school WR coach, then OC Small-town HS
5 - 6 Graduate assistant Big-conference program
7 - 9 Quality control, then asst. OL NFL team No. 1
10 Run-game coordinator NFL team No. 2
11 - 12 Run-game coordinator NFL team No. 3 (gap
scheme -> wide zone)
📊 Diagram (described): A career timeline. Seasons 1 to 4 are as a high-school receivers coach and then offensive coordinator. Seasons 5 and 6 are as a graduate assistant at a big-conference program. Seasons 7 to 9 are as an NFL quality control coach and then assistant offensive line coach. Season 10 is as run-game coordinator at a second NFL team. Seasons 11 and 12 are as run-game coordinator at a third NFL team that switched from a gap scheme to wide zone.
B4. Look at the Outlaws staff chart in Section 37.8. For each of these situations, name the staff member whose "voice" is supposed to catch the problem: (a) the game plan has three new RPOs and no new run-blocking rules; (b) a tendency on Teo's page rests on six snaps; (c) a third-and-long call has no post-snap check for the quarterback; (d) a receiver's dig is breaking at 9 yards instead of 12.
B5. A head coach's hiring history over five seasons: offensive coordinator hired from his former staff; quarterbacks coach hired from his former staff; two QCs, both sons of coaches he played with; one assistant OL coach from an open posting. Using Section 37.4 and 37.7, describe the pattern and its likely effect on his staff in ten years.
B6. Read the calendar diagram in Section 37.5. A college offensive coordinator gets a call from an NFL team on January 20. Name two things happening at his own program that week that make the decision harder.
B7. A coordinator candidate's binder has these tab titles: "Highlights," "Our Best Plays," "Records Broken," "Testimonials," "Philosophy." Using the binder rule, say what's wrong and rename three tabs so they'd survive being sampled.
B8. A head coach shows you two cut-ups sent in by GA applicants and asks which one you'd interview. Cut-up 1: four minutes of touchdowns from a 12–0 season, set to music. Cut-up 2: ten minutes, fourteen clips. Each clip opens with a card ("3rd-and-6, they spin the safety on the near hash; we called a sight-adjust hitch; rule: the hitch belongs to whoever the safety leaves"), and two clips show calls that failed with the fix the next week. Which applicant do you call, what can you learn from cut-up 2 that you can't from cut-up 1, and what is cut-up 1 good for?
Answer
Call applicant 2. Cut-up 2 shows how the coach sees a defense, decides, and corrects, which are the three things a GA does every day. Cut-up 1 shows that a team was talented. It's good evidence that the program can win, not that this coach thinks clearly. If applicant 1 is promising for other reasons, ask him to send a teaching cut-up before you decide. (Compare Case Study 2, attempts 1 and 2.)
Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
C1. (Draw it up) Interview whiteboard: Cover 2 (two deep halves, rolled-up corners), 11 personnel, 2x2, 2nd-and-6 at the opponent's 31. Draw a concept that puts the Cover 2 cornerback in conflict. Label #1 and #2, give depths, and write the quarterback's read in one sentence. Then write one sentence on why it's weaker against Cover 3.
Answer
Smash: #1 runs a hitch at 6 yards, and #2 runs a corner route that stems to about 12 and breaks toward the pylon at about 18. The read: if the corner squats on the hitch, throw the corner over him; if he sinks under the corner, throw the hitch. Against Cover 3, the corner bails to a deep third and is already on top of the corner route, so the conflict disappears.
C2. (Make the call) You're a high-school OC, 27, in your third season. A college GA spot opens in March at a program four hours away. Your spouse has just started a new job she loves, and you have no children. You've learned a lot this season, and next season you'll have your best quarterback ever. Run the four questions and decide: apply now, or wait a year?
Answer
A defensible call is wait a year, and tell the college staff you want to be considered next spring. Q1: you're still learning where you are (your best quarterback ever is a new problem to solve). Q3: your spouse pays a big cost right now. Q4: the door doesn't close in a year at 27, though GA doors do narrow with age. Use the year to make your work visible: send the college staff your cut-ups and philosophy page now, so next spring you're someone they've already seen. The opposite call can be defended if the GA spot comes with an unusual mentor or the program rarely opens spots, but you'd have to say so.
C3. (Make the call) You're an NFL QC in your third season. Your coordinator is about to be named a head coach elsewhere and wants you to come as his quarterbacks coach. Your current head coach offers to promote you to assistant receivers coach if you stay. Use the four questions. What one fact would you most want before deciding?
Answer
The most important fact is how secure the new job is (Q2): a first-time head coach's staff is fired as a unit if he fails, while your current staff's security depends on your current head coach's record. The new job teaches a room (quarterbacks), which is a bigger learning step than assistant receivers coach, so Q1 favors leaving. Q3 depends on your family. Q4 is usually fine, because quarterbacks coaches are hireable. A strong answer asks the new head coach about his contract length and the owner's expectations before saying yes.
C4. (Draw it up — staff) You've just been hired as a coordinator and may hire three people: a QC, a running-backs coach, and an analytics assistant. Write the one "voice" (the question that person is supposed to ask you) you want each hire to bring, and one interview task for each that tests for it.
Answer
QC: "How many snaps is that?" Task: tag thirty snaps and find two tells with sample sizes (Teo's test). RB coach: "What does the back see?" Task: draw your inside-zone read against two fronts and teach it back to you as if you were a rookie. Analytics assistant: "How sure are we, and compared to what?" Task: take one of your third-down tendencies and say whether it's a tell or noise, with a recommendation a coach could act on.
C5. (Make the call) Your head coach has just been fired on the Monday after the season. You're the passing-game coordinator. List, in order, the first four things you do in the first seven days, and one thing you don't do. Justify the order.
Answer
(1) Don't say anything in public you'll want back; thank the players and staff. (2) Cut your work while it's fresh: twenty clips with a one-line rule each. (3) Call people who've seen your work and ask for information ("Who's hiring a passing-game coach?"). (4) Tell your family the realistic timeline (the NFL hires in about two weeks) and decide together what moves you'd accept. Don't wait to see if the new head coach keeps you before doing any of this; by the time you know, the hiring window is half over. The order puts reputation first, because it's the one thing you can lose in a day.
C6. (Make the call — Teo) Using only the facts given in Section 37.9, write Teo's answer to the FCS head coach as three sentences: yes or no, why, and the one question he needs answered before he signs.
Answer
A strong version: "I want the job. I need to coach a room and build half a game plan, and I can't learn that as a QC. Before I sign, I'd like to know how long your contract runs and what the administration expects in the next two seasons." The question is Q2, the security of the boss, because staffs are fired as units.
C7. (Make the call — hiring) You're hiring a QC. Candidate A is a former player at your head coach's college, warmly recommended by your head coach's oldest friend. His work sample is clean, with no errors, but it finds no tendencies you didn't already know. Candidate B came through an open posting. His sample finds one real tell and one false one, which he flagged himself as "small sample — check." He has no references anyone on your staff recognizes. Which candidate gets the second interview, and how do you explain the decision to your head coach?
Answer
Give Candidate B the second interview, and probably give one to A as well if there's room. B's sample shows the two things a QC is for: finding something new, and knowing how much to trust it. The flagged false tell is a point for him, not against him. That's how Teo got hired. Explain it to the head coach on the merits of the work, not as a criticism of the reference: "A's sample tells us he's careful. B's tells us he can find what we don't know and won't oversell it. I'd like to see both of them at the whiteboard." That keeps the relationship intact and the process honest, which Section 37.7 argues is how a coordinator widens the pool.
Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐
D1. Lyle took a step down in title (college OC → NFL QC) and a big pay cut (high-school OC → GA). Is "take the step down" good general advice? Describe one coach for whom it would be the wrong move, and say why.
D2. Curtis Bale's first season as a coordinator produced the league's most-talked-about offense, and he was fired after his second. Using this chapter and Chapter 1, argue whether his firing was mostly a scheme failure or a career failure (not learning from feedback). What would you have told him after year one?
D3. A head coach says, "I hire from my tree because I don't have time to be wrong in January." Write a response that respects his constraint and still widens his pool. Give two concrete practices he could adopt during the season, when he does have time.
D4. Lyle printed his family's ledger with his wife's permission. Is the "family cost" a legitimate part of a professional decision, or something a coach should keep separate from his career? Defend a position, and say how it changes for a coach with no partner or children.
D5. The Rooney Rule governs interviews, not hires. Some critics say that makes it toothless, while supporters say interviews themselves are a career asset. Lay out the strongest version of each argument, then say what evidence would change your mind. Avoid claiming specific statistics you can't verify. Describe the kind of data you'd want instead.
D6. Lyle's four questions treat a career as a sequence of learning steps. Some coaches deliberately stay on one rung for decades: a career high-school coordinator, a twenty-year NFL offensive line coach. Is that a failure of ambition or a different definition of success? Use Lyle's line that "plenty of the best coaches I know chose a rung and stayed there on purpose," and describe what Q1 ("What will I learn?") looks like for a coach who never intends to move.
Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐
M1. (Ch 37 + Chapter 23) Teo's QC hiring test asks the candidate to "find two tells, each with a sample size and a 'since' date." Using what Chapter 23 says about the Sentinels' tells that vanished by Week 10, explain why the "since" date is part of the test, and what a candidate who leaves it off is telling you about how he thinks.
M2. (Ch 37 + Chapter 36) Chapter 36 limits a halftime fix to two or three adjustments. Apply the same triage to a career decision. You've been offered a job, and your list of pros and cons has eleven items. Reduce it to the three that should decide, using the four questions, and explain why the others are "adjustments the line can't execute."
M3. (Ch 37 + Chapter 13) Walt Dupree's 40-clip test showed that only 11 of Lyle's 40 college RPOs would survive the NFL's one-yard ineligible-downfield rule. Explain what this says about crossing from the college ladder to the NFL ladder. Name one more thing a college coordinator must unlearn, using the hash widths from this chapter.
M4. (Ch 37 + Chapter 1 + Chapter 34) Build the first page of Tab 4 (Install) of your binder so that it's visibly generated by Tab 1 (your philosophy). Write one rule from your philosophy and show two install-calendar decisions that follow from it.
M5. (Ch 37 + Chapter 24) Walt's Tuesday ritual had his two youngest assistants each hand in a one-page script. Lyle's had fifteen questions and Bale's was titled "Score in 15." Explain how that ritual worked as career development as well as game planning, and design a version you'd run with your own young assistants.
M6. (Ch 37 + Chapter 35) In a coordinator interview, the head coach asks, "Your quarterback just threw a pick to lose a playoff game. What do you say to him on Monday?" Answer using Chapter 35, and then explain what the head coach is really testing about you with that question.
Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐
E1. Trace a hire. Pick an offensive coordinator hired by an NFL team this past January. Using only public information, note (a) the coaches he worked under, (b) his previous offense's early-down run/pass split and play-action use, as reported by public charting services such as nflverse-based sites, Next Gen Stats, or PFF, and (c) his new team's numbers in its first four games. Write one page on what traveled with him and what changed. Be careful with any number you can't source. Give ranges where needed.
E2. Build a tree carefully. Choose one widely discussed coaching tree. Using reputable public sources, such as team media guides, the Pro Football Hall of Fame, and major news organizations, draw it with only the links you can confirm. Next to each link, write what you think traveled, such as a scheme, a practice method, or a way of running a building, and mark which claims are documented and which are your inference.
E3. Read the policy, not the summary. Find the NFL's current published description of the Rooney Rule and its related programs, such as the coaching fellowship and the compensatory-pick resolution. Compare it with the summary in Section 37.7, list every detail that has changed or that the chapter told you to check, and write a paragraph on which change you think matters most for the offensive coaching pipeline, and why.