Case Study 1: St. Louis, Twice — The Boot You Haven't Paid For
Austin Outlaws vs. the St. Louis Stallions, Week 2 and Week 12. Every team, player, and number in this case study is fictional.
Setup
The St. Louis Stallions are in our division, and they're the defense that makes play-action and the boot look easy on a whiteboard. Frank Ostrowski, their defensive coordinator, builds his defense to stop the run with numbers: one deep safety, eight men near the line, a strong safety who walks down late and fills like a linebacker on the tight end's first step. On paper, that's exactly the defense the bootleg was invented to beat. The walked-down safety bites, the linebackers flow, and the crosser runs into the grass behind them.
There's one more fact about the Stallions that matters for this case, and it isn't on their defensive film. Their offense, with Tyler Haugen at quarterback, runs outside zone and the boot about as purely as anyone in our division. That means Ostrowski's defense practices against wide zone and bootlegs every day in training camp and most days in season. His defensive ends have seen more boots by the end of August than we'll throw all year.
We played them twice. The same call, against the same defender, produced opposite results. This case is about why.
Week 2, at St. Louis. We lost 17–20. Our inside zone into their eight-man boxes had been miserable in the first half (6 yards on 5 carries), though we scored our only first-half touchdown on a 3-yard play-action pass to Brooks Harlan. We'd run outside zone exactly once all day, a first-down Wide on which our center left a combo too early, for minus 2. The Stallions led 10–7 at halftime.
Week 12, at home. We won 23–16. You've read the Week 12 boot in Chapter 10's hook. Here we put the two snaps side by side.
What happens
Week 2, third quarter: the boot with no deposits
About 9:00 left in the third quarter, Stallions 10–7. Our drive started at our own 17 after a punt. I wanted a chunk play to flip the field, and I had a bootleg on the call sheet that had been one of the best plays in our install all summer.
1st-and-10 at the AUS 17. "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left."
The Stallions were in their usual early-down picture: 4-3 Over, the strong safety walked down outside Harlan, the free safety, Wes Carrow (#28), in the middle at about 14 yards. Their backside end on our left was Tobias Grange (#93), a long, patient veteran.
POST-SNAP (Week 2, Q3: Wide PA Boot Left -- Grange stays home)
W (holds: no Wide to flow from)
^ X clear | M--> $-->
| <--------------+--------------------- Y cross (W sits
| v in the lane)
| <---U flat W
E Grange: squeezes, looks inside, sees the guard
| ^
v |
]<====LG (pulls into a waiting end)
Q <== rolls left: Grange in his face at 1.6 s
R ==> (fake right)
📊 Diagram (described): The line steps right and Vance fakes Wide Right to Ruffin. The Mike and the walked-down strong safety step toward the fake, but the Will on the left side holds instead of flowing and settles into the crossing lane. Grange, the left end, squeezes down the line with his eyes inside, sees Moss pulling toward him, and turns up the field toward Vance. Moss gets only a piece of him. Vance rolls left and has Grange in his face about 1.6 seconds after the snap. Brandt's flat route is underneath the Will, Harlan's crosser is running into the Will, and Sutton's clear is a deep throw on the run with a rusher on him.
Vance did what our boot rule says: "throw the flat now, or throw it away; never take the sack on a boot." He threw it at Brandt's feet. Incomplete.
2nd-and-10 at the AUS 17. "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Inside Right." Eight in the box again. Ruffin found 4 yards on a cutback before Hollis Mabry (#55), their Mike, got him. +4.
3rd-and-6 at the AUS 21. "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Stick." Harlan's stick route at six yards, against a Mike who sat on it. Vance threw it on time; Mabry tackled Harlan short of the sticks. +3. Punt from our 24.
Three plays, seven yards, and the field-flipping play I'd wanted had done the opposite.
The Monday meeting
The next morning, Marisol Vega, our analytics director, put the boot on the screen with the sound off. Teo Arriaga, our quality control coach, was in the room, along with Gus Ferrante and Rome Pettaway.
Marisol: Before you tell me what went wrong, how many outside-zone runs had we shown them before this?
Lyle: One. For minus two. In the first quarter.
Gus: So Grange had seen one Wide all day, and it was a bad one.
Rome: And he's seen ten thousand boots in practice. He's not chasing anything he hasn't been shown.
Teo: In El Paso we counted chases. On every zone run, somebody in the press box made a tally mark for whether the backside end chased. We didn't boot until he'd chased twice.
Lyle: High school?
Teo: High-school ends chase everything. That's why the rule worked there. I'm saying the rule's the same; the number's different.
That's where our "chases twice" rule came from: an index card Teo had carried out of a high-school press box. Teo started counting chases from our booth that week. By the playoffs, the rule was printed on the call sheet next to the boot.
Week 12, second quarter: the boot that was paid for
Ten weeks later, at home, tied 7–7 in the second quarter. We'd run three Twelve-personnel outside-zone runs against the same eight-man box: 3, 2, and 4 yards. Teo read me the gains from the booth: "Three, two, four." I'd watched the backside end, Grange again, chase Ruffin from behind on all three.
2nd-and-6 at the Stallions' 38. "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left."
The same call. The same formation. The same backside end. This time Grange chased the fake, because three times in a row the fake had been the ball. The linebackers flowed right, the strong safety came down, and Harlan crossed behind all of it. Vance threw it on the run. Harlan, 18 yards, to the Stallions' 20.
Later, in the third quarter, with us up 13–10, the Stallions bumped their front a gap against our Load Right unbalanced look and rolled the strong safety down. We called the boot off that look, and Brandt caught it in the left flat for 14.
Analysis
Same call, same defender, opposite outcome: the difference was evidence. In Week 2, Grange had no reason to chase. He'd seen one Wide all day, and his defense practices against the boot daily, so his default was to squeeze, look inside, and wait for a guard. The Will on his side was playing the same logic. In Week 12, three runs in a row had told both of them the ball was going right, and when the boot came they were already gone.
The Stallions are a "rule-fit" defense, but the boot's defender isn't. In Chapter 19, I called the Stallions' strong safety rule-fit: he comes down on the tight end's first step every time, by design, so play-action works against him whether or not your run is working. That's true, and it's why our Week 2 first-half play-action touchdown worked even though our runs didn't. But the boot doesn't lie to the strong safety. It lies to the backside end, and the backside end's choice to chase is evidence-fit: he chases when the run has proven he must. You can't borrow the strong safety's reliability for the end's decision. Ostrowski's answer to the boot, as I wrote in Chapter 10, was to keep the backside end home; he accepts a bigger cutback lane in exchange. In Week 2 we never made him pay for that.
Deposits and withdrawals. Marisol's season table split our boots by what the backside end had done earlier on the drive: 13 calls after two or more chases averaged about 10 yards; 5 calls after no chases averaged under 2. The Week 2 boot is one of those five. The table is a small sample, and she'd tell you so, but the mechanism behind it is not mysterious. A boot spends the credibility the run has built.
My mistake was a classic one. I treated the boot as a good play rather than a good answer. It had been one of the best plays in our summer install, against a scout team whose ends were told to chase. I called it because I liked it and because I wanted a chunk of yards, not because Grange had shown me anything. That's the same error as my wide-zone-staff Trips boot in the chapter's hook, in a more polished form: the picture was right this time, but the history behind the picture was missing.
What the Load Right boot adds. The third-quarter boot to Brandt worked for a slightly different reason. The unbalanced look changed the Stallions' front, and their adjustment (bumping a gap and rolling the safety down) committed defenders to a run they'd already been shown that day. The deposit didn't have to be the same play. It had to be the same story.
Discussion questions
- Grange is the same player in both snaps. List everything that was different about his situation in Week 12, and rank which difference mattered most.
- In Week 2, if you were determined to throw on that first down, what call would have attacked the Stallions' rule-fit defender (the strong safety) instead of their evidence-fit one (the backside end)?
- Rome's line was "He's not chasing anything he hasn't been shown." Does that mean you should never call a boot on the first snap of a drive? Under what circumstances could a first-snap boot be justified?
- Teo's rule was "chases twice." Should the number be different against the Stallions than against a defense whose offense never runs wide zone? Why?
- The third-quarter boot to Brandt came off a different formation (Load Right). Explain how a deposit made with one formation can pay off a boot from another, and when it can't.
Your turn
You're Teo in the booth for a game against a defense like the Stallions'. Design the chase card you would keep on the desk: the columns you'd mark for every zone run (backside end's name, chased or squeezed, looked for the guard or not, the Will's flow), the one sentence you'd say on the headset when the boot is "ripe," and the one sentence you'd say when it isn't. Then write the threshold you'd use for Boot versus Naked, and defend the numbers in two sentences.