Chapter 11 Exercises — Gap Schemes: Power, Counter, Trap

Difficulty legend: ⭐ basic recall and understanding · ⭐⭐ apply the idea to a new picture · ⭐⭐⭐ analyze, decide, and defend a choice · ⭐⭐⭐⭐ extension work (film study and original research).

All Outlaws, Sentinels, Stallions, Pioneers, Forge, and Ospreys people and games are fictional. Selected answers are in Appendix J. Short answers to Part C appear below each item. Items marked (hypothetical) are teaching scenarios, not snaps from our season.


Part A — Conceptual ⭐

A1. In one sentence each, define a zone scheme and a gap scheme by answering the same question: who decides where the hole is, and when?

A2. Name the five parts every gap play is built from (11.1). For Power Left in the hook, name the Outlaws player who did each part.

A3. What is the end man on the line of scrimmage, and why does a kick-out block always target him rather than a specific position?

A4. Explain the difference between a kick-out and a log block. Who decides which one happens, and how does the back know?

A5. On Power, why does the center block back, away from the play? What happens to the play if he doesn't?

A6. Define the GT counter. Which two Outlaws linemen pull on Counter Right, which one kicks, which one wraps, and why does each man's build suit his job?

A7. State the Outlaws' rule "we flip the formation, not the linemen." What is one advantage of the rule and one tell it creates?

A8. What is an influence release on trap? Give two ways a play-side guard can influence the defender he's leaving alone.

A9. Why do coaches disagree about whether duo is a gap scheme? State the Outlaws' resolution in one sentence.

A10. What is the plus-one on QB Power, and what does it cost?


Part B — Film & Diagram Recognition ⭐⭐

B1. Pre-snap: Eleven personnel, two-by-two, tight end attached left, back offset left (toward the tight end). Post-snap: the left guard and left tackle both leave their spots and run flat to the right behind the line; the back takes one step left, then cuts right. Name the play, the two jobs of the two pullers, and the block the center must make.

B2. You're watching end-zone film. At the snap the right guard steps inside, never touching the 3-technique in front of him, and runs to the Mike linebacker. The 3-technique charges two yards into the backfield, and the left guard hits him from the inside. The back is through the hole before the safeties move. Name the play and the technique the right guard used.

B3. POST-SNAP (what you see on film)

                 W                M
              E      N       T        E
              x      x       x        x
            Y==LT    LG==C   RG       RT
                       ^
                       R  (reads the Mike, cuts away from him)

📊 Diagram (described): The tight end and left tackle double-team the end outside the left tackle; the left guard and center double-team the nose. The right guard and right tackle each block a man by themselves. Nobody pulls. The back aims between the two double teams and is watching the Mike linebacker.

B3 question: Name the play. Which defender would you expect the play-side tackle to come off the double team to block? Which defensive alignment would make you prefer to run this play the other way?

B4. Pre-snap: I formation, tight end attached left, fullback and tailback stacked behind the quarterback. Post-snap: the fullback runs to the left and blocks the outside linebacker on the line; the right guard pulls left and turns up through the hole; the tailback follows. Name the play and identify the one defender in an eight-man box who is most likely to be unblocked.

B5. Same pre-snap as B4. Post-snap: the fullback runs to the left exactly as in B4, the tailback steps left, then the left guard and left tackle pull to the right. Name the play. What linebacker key is this play built to fool, and why?

B6. Pre-snap: shotgun, two-by-two, tight end attached right, back offset right. Post-snap: the back crosses in front of the quarterback to the left and kicks out the end; the right guard pulls left and wraps; the quarterback keeps the ball and follows the guard. Name the play and the extra blocker it creates.

B7. On a play-action pass, the right guard pulls left exactly as on Power — and then stops at the line of scrimmage and blocks an edge rusher. Both linebackers fill hard to the left. A receiver from the right side catches a dig behind them. Name the concept, and explain the rule that forced the guard to stop at the line.

B8. A defensive end, seeing the tackle in front of him block down, squeezes flat down the line and attacks the pulling guard's inside half with his inside shoulder, collapsing the kick-out into the hole. Name the technique and describe where the back has to go now.

B9. You're charting a defense. On five straight gap runs from your opponent's film, the Will linebacker's first step goes with the pulling guard every time, even when the back's first step goes the other way. On two zone runs, his first step goes toward the guard in front of him when that guard fires out at a double team. What is the Will's key? Which play in this chapter is he most vulnerable to, and which is he least vulnerable to?


Part C — Make the Call / Draw It Up ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

C1. Draw it up. ⭐⭐ Draw Power Right from "Twenty-one, I Right" (Harlan attached right) against a 4-3 Over set to the tight end: Sam on Harlan's outside shoulder, 5-technique end on the right tackle, a 3-technique on the right guard, nose shaded toward the left guard, weak end outside the left tackle, Mike and Will stacked, strong safety walked down outside the Sam. Give a pre-snap and post-snap diagram and a rules table. Remember the Outlaws' puller rule.

Short answer

Power Right pulls the left guard — Kendrick Moss — because the backside guard always pulls on Power; the Outlaws' "Lorusso pulls on Power" rule refers to Power Left. (In our playbook we'd usually flip the formation to Harlan-left and call Power Left so Lorusso pulls; drawing Power Right is good practice for reading the rules.) Harlan down on the 5-technique; RT and RG double the 3-technique, RG climbs to the Mike; center back on the nose; LG pulls and wraps to the first backer (usually the Will scraping); LT hinges on the weak end; Fale kicks the Sam; the back aims at the double and cuts inside the kick. The walked-down strong safety is the free man.

C2. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical) Week 10 at Portland, second quarter, 1st-and-10 at the Austin 40, tied 7–7. Portland is in nickel Over with two deep safeties, six in the box. Film tendency: their Mike, Owen Talbert, steps with the back's first step on 9 of 11 early-down runs in their last two games. Their 3-technique, Dion Pratt, is a one-gap penetrator. You have Eleven personnel. Choose one gap run and justify it; name the conflict defender and the partner play you'd call if your first call works.

Short answer

Counter Right from Gun Doubles Left is the cleanest answer to a back-reader: the jab step takes Talbert the wrong way, and six in the box against six blockers plus two pullers favors you. Trap is a fine alternative aimed at Pratt. Partner: once Talbert stops stepping with the jab and starts reading the guards, go to counter play-action from the same look (or Counter Y / Dart to show him a different guard picture). Conflict defender: Talbert — run fit versus his Tampa 2 deep-middle drop.

C3. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical variation on the hook) Week 12 vs. St. Louis, fourth quarter, Outlaws lead 23–16, 2nd-and-8 at the Austin 41, 3:40 left, Stallions out of timeouts. Ostrowski has eight in the box and one deep safety. You have run Power Left five times this drive; the Stallions' Mike has started shooting the gap where Lorusso turns up, arriving before him. Fale has been kicking out cleanly. What do you call, and why?

Short answer

The linebacker has switched from reading Fale to jumping Lorusso's pull. The key-breaker for a guard jumper is a play where the guard's pull means something else. Strong answers: Dart (Lorusso stays home and back-blocks; the tackle wraps — the Mike's key says "zone"), or Power with the fullback leading through the hole instead of kicking (so the man who meets the shooting linebacker is Fale, not Lorusso). Play-action is tempting but risky in four-minute: an incompletion stops the clock. A run that gets four yards and keeps the clock moving is the goal.

C4. Draw it up. ⭐⭐ Draw Trap Left (Lorusso traps) against a nickel Under front with the 3-technique on the left guard. Identify which play-side lineman makes the influence release and who blocks back for the trapper.

Short answer

The trap man is the 3-technique on the left guard. Moss (LG) releases inside to the play-side backer (influence) without touching him; Achterberg (LT) releases inside to the backside backer or blocks the end, depending on your rule; the center blocks back on the nose (the gap Lorusso leaves); Lorusso (RG) pulls short behind the center and traps the 3-technique; Fitch (RT) hinges on the backside end; the back aims at the 3-technique's original spot.

C5. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ Game 2 at Sacramento, third quarter, 2nd-and-5 at the Sacramento 42. You expect nickel Over with two high. Your self-scout shows that when Ruffin aligns toward Harlan, you have run counter or counter play-action on 14 of 19 snaps. You want a run. What do you call — and from which backfield alignment?

Short answer

Don't call counter from the alignment that tells. Better: inside zone from the same alignment (Ruffin toward Harlan) to punish a Will who's now reading guards and running with the pullers; or counter from the other offset, so the tell no longer predicts the play; or Counter Y, which shows a guard-reader only one guard pulling. What we actually ran was counter from the telling alignment, and it was spilled for one yard (Case Study 1).

C6. Draw it up. ⭐⭐⭐ Draw QB Power Left from "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right" against a bear front (0-nose, 3-techniques on both guards, 5-technique on the left tackle, Sam on the line outside Harlan). Show who is unblocked and explain whether you'd keep the call or check out.

Short answer

Against bear, every interior lineman is covered, so there's no natural double team; the backside 3-technique can follow Lorusso's pull because the center can't reach him. Most staffs check out (trap or a perimeter play) or accept that the backside end is unblocked and run QB Power only if the quarterback's fake holds him. A reasonable answer: check to Trap, or to a quick throw outside if the box is eight.

C7. Make the call. ⭐⭐⭐ (hypothetical) Week 8 vs. Birmingham. The Forge show a bear front on first down — 0-nose, 3-techniques on both guards, a 5-technique, a Sam on the line, and a safety walked down to eight in the box — and they slant the whole front on about half of first downs. You have Eleven personnel on the field and Twelve available. Your call sheet's first-down gap runs are Power, Counter, and Trap. Pick one (or none), and say what you'd add to it.

Short answer

Power and counter both depend on a double team and a center's back block, and bear takes both away: every interior lineman is covered, and the backside 3-technique can follow your pullers. Trap is the best of the three against a slanting, penetrating bear — the 3-technique who slants upfield is the man you trap — but you must accept that the walked-down safety is unblocked. A strong answer adds Twelve personnel with a Wham-style block (the extra tight end trapping a 3-technique) so both guards can climb, or skips the gap runs entirely for a quick throw outside the eight-man box.


Part D — Judgment & Trade-offs ⭐⭐⭐

D1. Your offensive line coach wants to flip the linemen (the same two players always pull on counter, regardless of direction). Your quarterbacks coach says it will create a substitution and communication problem on the next snap. Write the case for each, then decide for a pro team and for a high school team, and explain why the answers might differ.

D2. A defensive coordinator tells you, "I don't care what you call. My ends wrong-arm everything and my linebackers run over the top." Name two plays from this chapter that become better against that rule and one that becomes worse. Explain the mechanism for each.

D3. Your quarterback is your best runner and your only quarterback with NFL starts. QB Power gains an average of four yards a carry in your goal-line package. Your head coach asks how many times per game you'll call it. Answer with a number, a set of situations, and the safety rule you'll live by.

D4. Four-minute offense, up seven, 4:30 left. One assistant wants to keep calling Power Left until the defense stops it. Another wants a counter now, "before they figure it out." Using the hook, argue for the sequencing you'd use and when you'd break it.

D5. Your self-scout shows a 74 percent tell (counter when the back aligns toward the tight end). You can fix it three ways: run more inside zone from that alignment, run counter from both offsets, or change the puller (Counter Y). Rank the fixes by cost (practice time, risk) and by how long each one will keep a smart defensive staff guessing.

D6. Marisol's chart says gap runs were a little under a quarter of our designed runs, and that the share nearly doubled in the fourth quarter with a lead. A columnist writes that "the Outlaws become predictable late in games." Is he right? Write a three-paragraph answer: what the defense gains from knowing a gap run is likely, what it still can't stop, and what we'd have to see on film before we changed anything.


Part M — Mixed / Interleaved ⭐⭐–⭐⭐⭐

M1. (Chapter 5 + Chapter 11) ⭐⭐ Chapter 5 says the center's back block "is what lets the guard next to him pull at all." In Counter Right against nickel Over, the center has to block back on a 3-technique two gaps away. Use the line vocabulary from Chapter 5 to explain why this is harder than the back block in Power Left, and name two ways the 3-technique's own coaching can help the center.

M2. (Chapter 7 + Chapter 11) ⭐⭐ Using Teo's box words from Chapter 7 (light, neutral, loaded; an apex nickel counts as half), classify the box in the hook and in the Portland trap. For each, say how the gap scheme changed the count after the snap.

M3. (Chapter 9 + Chapter 11) ⭐⭐⭐ Inside zone with a "show" double team and counter are the first two plays of the three-play test. Describe what a guard-reading linebacker sees on each, using Chapter 9's covered/uncovered language, and explain why the 45-yard run in Game 1 was the first play of the test whether or not we planned it that way.

M4. (Chapter 4 + Chapter 11) ⭐⭐ Why does Twenty-one personnel suit a four-minute Power drive better than Eleven personnel? Give one personnel reason and one defensive-substitution reason from Chapter 4.

M5. (Chapter 8 + Chapter 11) ⭐⭐⭐ Write the full Outlaws call (Chapter 8 call grammar) for: (a) Power Left from Twenty-one in the I with Harlan attached left; (b) Counter Right from Eleven in the gun with Harlan attached left; (c) the play-action off (a). Then explain which word in each call a defensive signal-stealer would find most useful, and why it doesn't matter as much as the backfield alignment.

M6. (Chapter 10 + Chapter 11) ⭐⭐⭐ Outside zone and pin-and-pull both try to get to the edge. Compare how each one handles a defensive end aligned in a 5-technique on the play side, and say which one you'd call against a defense whose ends are coached to squeeze hard on every down block.


Part E — Research & Film Study ⭐⭐⭐⭐

E1. The puller census. Watch one NFL team's first-half runs on All-22 or end-zone film. For every run, chart: zone or gap; who pulled (guard, tackle, tight end, none); who kicked out; and what the play-side linebacker did with his first step (with the back, with the guard, or held). Find the linebacker's key from his first steps and report one play in the opponent's film that would have made it lie.

E2. The counter step test. Find six counter runs from any level. For each, measure (by counting frames, or by eye) whether the back's counter step took the play-side linebacker the wrong way. Compare the gains on runs where the linebacker stepped with the back against runs where he didn't. Write a paragraph on what your small sample suggests — and why six runs can't prove it.

E3. Gap schemes in history. Using the Pro Football Hall of Fame's public materials and the books in this chapter's Further Reading, write a one-page history of either the Packers power sweep or the Washington counter trey: the problem it solved, how it was blocked, and how defenses answered it. Use only facts you can verify; where sources describe something loosely, say so.

E4. Build a key-breaker cut-up. Choose one college or NFL team that runs a lot of Power or counter. Find every gap run in one game and, for each, write down the play-side linebacker's first step. Then search the same game for a play-action pass or a different run from the same formation and backfield alignment. Did the offense ever make the linebacker's key lie? If yes, what did that snap gain compared with the gap runs around it? If no, write the play you would have called and the down and distance where you would have called it.