Chapter 23 Key Takeaways — The Scouting Report
Key Takeaways
- A scouting report turns film into decisions. It answers three questions: What do they do? What can't they do? What do they do when we do X? Then Lyle's fourth line: What will they leave, and is my guy better than theirs there? A report describes; the game plan decides.
- Choose the film deliberately. The last four games (newest weighted most), games against offenses like yours, same-coordinator history, and situational cut-ups for rare situations. The coordinator matters more than the uniform: when the play caller changes, the sample starts over.
- Use the right angle for each job. Sideline (All-22) for coverage; end zone for fronts, fits, first steps, and eyes; broadcast copy only for the situation.
- Tag every snap the same way, in three passes: situation, coverage, front. Keep two shell columns, before and after the snap. When you don't know, write "?" and count the question marks.
- Every count carries its denominator. Write "9 of 14," never "64 percent." Small samples lie confidently: 9 of 14 happens by luck about one time in five. The 70-percent-on-ten-snaps threshold is a floor, not proof.
- Context is part of the count. Split by opponent before you trust a number. The Sentinels' third-and-long pressure was 15 of 26 overall but 7 of 17 against veteran quarterbacks.
- The exceptions are the report. Ames came downhill 14 of 18; the four exceptions revealed burned → sits, which decided the second snap of Game 1.
- One page wins games. The "by situation" page: one row per key situation, a count, and the decision it points to.
- Build the plan on the tendencies; build the bin on the exceptions. Cover 0 on third-and-long was 1 of 26 in Week 6, and it decided the game.
- Self-scout in both directions. Ask "What does this look predict?" and "Where does this play come from?" Break the tendencies that tell the defense how to beat the play; keep the ones that don't; list the tells you accept.
- Coaches get the binder; players get three things. Earn the tell with the count, teach it with the clip, lock it in with a rep.
- Every report expires, and the other coordinator chooses when. Foundations hold; personnel answers, pressure packages, and tells change. Never let a tendency outlive its evidence.
Action Items (this week)
- Build a tagging sheet with at least 14 fields, including shell before and after, box count, and an "eyes / first step" column.
- Tag one full game of an opponent (or an NFL defense) in three passes. Count your question marks.
- Write five "by situation" rows with counts, denominators, and a decision column.
- For your best tendency, watch every exception and write one sentence about what they share.
- Run a four-game self-scout on your own offense. Mark five tendencies keep, break, or accept.
- Cut the report to three things per position room and attach a clip to each.
Common Mistakes (and the fix)
| Mistake | What it costs | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Tagging the pre-snap shell as the coverage | A report that says "two-high" when the defense rotated | Two shell columns; coverage tagged from the sideline after the snap |
| Percentages without denominators | Confident calls built on 4 or 5 snaps | Write counts: "4 of 5," then decide how much to trust it |
| Ignoring who the opponent played | Overestimating pressure, coverage, or run fits built against weak opponents | Split every key count by opponent |
| Explaining away the newest film | Game-planning a defense that no longer exists | Weight the newest game most; restart the sample when the play caller changes |
| Self-scouting in one direction | Missing reverse tells like "every scissors from a reduced split" | Sort by look and by play |
| The forty-item player handout | The one tell that mattered gets lost | Three things per room, each with a clip |
| Bolding a perfect streak | The defense springs the disguise on the snap that matters | Give every row a "since" date; question-mark streaks with no exceptions; every long-yardage call needs a post-snap answer |
Decision Framework: From Film to the Page
| Step | Question to ask | Done when |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Film | Is the play caller on this film the one we'll face? | Sample starts at the current play caller |
| 2. Tag | Did every snap get every field, with "?" where unsure? | Question marks under about one in ten per column |
| 3. Count | Does every number show its denominator? | No bare percentages on the page |
| 4. Test | Does it clear 70% on 10+? Who were the opponents? What do the exceptions share? | Every tell has a count, a context note, and an exception note |
| 5. Decide | What call or rule does this row point to? | Every row has a decision column |
| 6. Mirror | What does the opponent's report on us say? | Five tendencies marked keep, break, or accept |
| 7. Present | What three things does each room need to see? | Clips cut, walkthrough reps scheduled |
| 8. Expire | Since when has this been true, and who could end it? | Every row has a "since" date |