Chapter 24 Key Takeaways — Building the Game Plan

Key Takeaways

  1. The game plan is the middle rung of the ladder: philosophy → system → playbook → game plan → call sheet → call. It chooses part of what you own for one opponent and can't fix a hole in the system in one week.
  2. Answer three questions before choosing plays: What will they leave — and is my guy better than theirs there? What must we take away from them? What do they do when we do X?
  3. "Take away" is mostly rules, not plays. A defense's best weapons (a disguise, a premier rusher, an unpredictable pressure) are answered with protection rules, read rules, and throws built into the call.
  4. Matchup hunting comes with conditions. Sutton vs. Brennan was a good matchup only without a safety over the top — which made it a third-down rule and a low-red throw.
  5. Run/pass mix is an output of the opponent. Against Quarters, a six-man box at the snap becomes an eight-man fit at the mesh; pair every kept run with play-action and RPOs that punish the fitting safety.
  6. The script asks questions. "Script the first fifteen to learn, not to win." Every slot gets a question and an "if A / if B" column, and at least one call should break your own tendency.
  7. Series cards put sequence on the plan. A conditional chain from one look, with triggers, that waits until the defense has been taught to believe the setup (the Week 6 Holloway card).
  8. Every likely look gets two answers. Third-and-short in Game 3: the slant was sacked; the zoom-motion quick out converted.
  9. Every tendency box needs a branch, and the branch needs reps. Twenty-nine for twenty-nine is evidence, not a promise.
  10. A rule that fires on doubt can't protect you from confidence. Build the check into the call.

Action Items (this week)

  • Write the three questions for your next opponent on one page before you open your playbook.
  • Run your own self-scout: find your first-play-of-drive tendency and your "zeros" (a personnel group that never runs a whole play family).
  • Add an "if A / if B" column to your opening script. Delete any slot whose answer wouldn't change a later call.
  • Build one series card with a single look and written triggers.
  • Find the box on your plan built on your opponent's strongest tendency, and write its branch line. Give the branch at least a few practice reps.
  • At your next staff meeting, write every losing argument in the margin next to the call it objected to.

Common Mistakes (and the fix)

Mistake What it looks like Fix
The best-plays plan Twenty favorites, no reference to this defense Build from what the defense leaves and what it does best
Scripting to win Fifteen shots and gadgets; nothing learned by the second quarter Every slot asks a question with an answer column
Questions without answers A script of curiosities nobody acts on "If A → / If B →" for every slot
Spending a sequence early The play-action payoff called before the defender has learned to bite Put it on a series card with triggers
The plan built by one voice Staff nods at a finished plan Proposal sheets first; the four-step disagreement process; dissent in the margin
The tendency with no branch "They always do X → call Y," nothing else Add "if not X →" and give it practice reps
The fixed mix "We're a 50/50 team" every week Set targets from the opponent; keep runs that make play-action work
Planning against last game only Copying the plan that won last time Ask what the opponent will change — Wade's "how would I defend that?"

Decision Framework: Building the Plan

Step Ask Write down
1 What do they do, and what do we look like? Opponent page + self-scout (with sample sizes)
2 What's their best weapon? 2–3 TAKE AWAY lines, each with how
3 Where's my guy better than theirs? ATTACK / AVOID table with conditions
4 What does this defense make efficient? Early-down targets by play type (targets, not quotas)
5 What answers each situation? Boxes from openers to backed-up, two answers per likely look
6 Which calls set up which? 2–3 series cards with triggers
7 What if they don't do it? Contingency rows — no blank rows
8 What do we need to learn first? 15-slot script: call, question, if A, if B
9 Who disagrees? Tape → one sentence → reps → decide; dissent in the margin