It was 6:40 on a Monday morning, the year before I came to Austin. I was the passing-game coordinator
In This Chapter
- The Hook: "Which One Is the Pass?"
- 29.1 An Illusion Machine
- 29.2 Where It Comes From: Denver, Gibbs, and a Tree Everyone Draws Differently
- 29.3 The Engine: Wide Zone Is the Base, Not a Play
- 29.4 Boot and Naked: The Backside Pays the Bill
- 29.5 Yankee and the Crossers: Passes That Start as Runs
- 29.6 Condensed Formations: Tight Splits, Crack Angles, and the Two-Way Go
- 29.7 Motion, the Fullback, and Players You Can't Read
- 29.8 Under Center and Yards After the Catch
- 29.9 How Defenses Adapted, and How the System Answered
- 29.10 What Austin Adopts, Adapts, and Rejects
- 29.11 The System at Every Level
- Spaced Review
- Project Checkpoint: Wide Zone & Boot Family (the "Shanahan Borrow List")
- Chapter Summary
- What's Next
Chapter 29 — The Shanahan System: Wide Zone, Boot Action, Condensed Formations, and the Offense That Defined a Decade
The Hook: "Which One Is the Pass?"
"Freeze it there."
It was 6:40 on a Monday morning, the year before I came to Austin. I was the passing-game coordinator on a wide-zone staff (a fictional team, like every team in this book that isn't named from history), and the line coach had the clicker. He was the quiet man I've mentioned before, the one who'd been coaching outside zone since before most of his players were born. He'd asked the video staff to build him a split screen: three clips side by side, all from our two-tight-end set under center, all frozen at the same instant, eight-tenths of a second after the snap.
"Which one is the pass?" he asked me.
I looked for a long time. In all three frames, all five linemen had taken the same short lateral step to the right. In all three, the right tight end's helmet was working outside the defensive end. In all three, the quarterback had his back to the defense and the ball was at the running back's belly. In all three, the back was on the same track, aiming at the tight end's outside leg, and both wide receivers were coming off the ball in their stalk-block stances.
I picked the middle one.
"That's the run," he said. "Left is the play-action dig. Right is the boot." He didn't smile. He just clicked to the fourth clip.
The fourth clip was mine. On Sunday, third quarter, down 13–10, second-and-7 at our own 41, we'd run a bootleg I had built into the game plan. It came from a shotgun trips formation, and my sales pitch in the Wednesday meeting had been simple: "They've never seen us boot from Trips." Our coordinator liked it and called it.
The line coach froze my clip at three-tenths of a second. You didn't need eight-tenths. Our linemen were already kick-stepping back into pass sets. The back's "fake" was a lateral jog toward a mesh that didn't look like any handoff we'd ever made from that formation. And the backside defensive end, the man the whole play depended on, hadn't moved an inch toward the run. He had his eyes on our quarterback, and when our guard pulled toward him, he simply waited. Our quarterback turned around into him. Sack, minus 11. We punted.
"They'd never seen us boot from Trips," the line coach said, "because we'd never run the ball from Trips. There was nothing to fake." He set the clicker down. "You built a play. We build pictures."
He had told me on my first day, "If the boot looks different for one step, it's a different play." He had made me take the reach step in sneakers in the team parking lot. I'd nodded at all of it. I hadn't understood that it wasn't a coaching point. It was the entire offense.
That's what this chapter is about. The offense most people call the Shanahan system is not a list of plays. It's a rule for building them: everything starts as the same run, for as long as possible. Outside zone is the engine; the boot, the play-action crossers, the condensed formations, the motion, and the fullback are all ways of making the defense's first second wrong. It ran through one of the most successful coaching trees of the last thirty years, and it shaped my brain more than any single season I've coached.
I'm not a pure version of it. Austin's offense runs on the shotgun, the RPO, and a quarterback who punishes the blitz, and some of this system doesn't fit Darius Vance. So the chapter ends with the list every coordinator should make about every famous offense: what I took, what I changed, and what I left on the table.
🏃 Fast Track: If you already coach outside zone and the boot, skim §29.1 for the "first second" rule and go to §29.6 (condensed formations), §29.9 (how defenses adapted), §29.10 (the borrow list), and the Project Checkpoint.
🔬 Deep Dive: The blocking rules live in Chapter 10 and Appendix B; the play-action protections and Yankee live in Chapter 19; every concept's routes and reads are in Appendix C.
📺 Film Watcher: On Sunday, pick one team that runs outside zone from under center. Pause the broadcast on any snap at the moment the quarterback turns his back. Guess run, play-action, or boot. Then let it play. Keep score. If you're right more than about half the time, that offense isn't doing its job.
29.1 An Illusion Machine
Start with the defense, because that's where this system starts.
Every defender has a key: the thing he looks at in the first second to decide what the play is. A linebacker keys the backfield and the guards. A safety who fits the run keys the tight end. A backside defensive end keys the ball and the back. Keys exist because nobody can watch everything, and a defender who waits to be sure is a defender who arrives late. You learned in Chapter 7 that the defense tells you where to go. This system goes a step further. It asks: what if every one of those keys said "run" on every snap, for the first second, whether or not it was a run?
That's the design rule. The Shanahan system is an offense in which the base run, outside zone, is copied exactly by its play-action passes, its bootlegs, and its tags, so that the defenders' keys can't separate them until it's too late. In this book's language, it's the purest expression of the third multiplier, illusion: plays that look alike until it's too late.
Three things make an illusion work, and you'll see all three in every section of this chapter.
- The run is real. If outside zone doesn't gain yards, nobody keys it, and nothing built on it fools anyone. (My Trips boot had no run behind it.)
- The first second matches. Same personnel, same formation, same first step for every lineman, same track for the back, same turn for the quarterback, same start for the receivers.
- The split comes late, and it comes where the keys took the defenders. The pass goes behind the linebackers who stepped up, outside the end who chased, and into the grass the safety left.
Who is being lied to
| Defender | His key | What he sees for the first second | If he trusts it | The play that punishes him |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Play-side linebackers (Mike, Will) | Backfield flow and the guards' first step | Linemen stepping laterally, back on a wide track | He flows hard to the play side to beat the reach | Wide PA dig or crosser behind him; bend cutback |
| Alley/force safety | The tight end's first step | Tight end reaching the end: "run" | He fills downhill into the alley | Yankee, Wide PA shot, crack-go |
| Backside end | The ball and the back | Handoff going away from him | He chases flat down the line | Boot and Naked |
| Backside linebacker | Flow, then cutback | Everything going away from him | He runs over the top | The crosser that comes back his way |
| Middle-of-the-field safety | The quarterback and the run fit | Run action; strong safety coming down | He creeps toward the line or the strength | The post or the deep over over his head |
Read the right-hand column again. Every play in the system is the answer to a defender doing his job correctly against the run. That's what makes it so hard to coach against: the defender who gets beaten usually did exactly what his coach told him to.
The first second, drawn
Here is the picture. It's our two-tight-end set against a 4-3 Over front with one deep safety and a strong safety walked down: the kind of run-stopping defense this system was built to beat.
PRE-SNAP (Twelve, Under Ace Right vs. 4-3 Over, Cover 3 Sky)
install view: one picture, three plays
F
C C
$
W M
E N T E S
X U LT LG C RG RT Y Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Austin has two tight ends attached, Brandt (U) on the left and Harlan (Y) on the right, with Sutton (X) on the line wide left and Gaines (Z) off the line wide right. Vance is under center and Ruffin is about seven yards deep behind him. The defense shows one deep safety, two corners, a strong safety walked down to about eight yards outside Harlan, a Sam linebacker on Harlan's outside shoulder, four down linemen, and two inside linebackers: eight defenders near the line.
POST-SNAP at 0.8 seconds -- identical on Wide Right, Wide PA, and
Wide PA Boot Left (what each key sees)
F (sees run action; holds the middle)
$ keys Y: reach = run,
W--> M--> v so he fills the alley
E--> N--> T E S
(chases)
U LT LG C RG RT Y-->
-> -> -> -> -> -> (every blocker: reach step)
Q ...> R==> (QB's back to the defense;
ball at the back's belly)
📊 Diagram (described): Eight-tenths of a second after the snap, every Austin blocker has taken the same short reach step to the right, and Harlan is working his helmet outside the end. Vance has turned his back to the defense and the ball is at Ruffin's belly as Ruffin runs his outside-zone track to the right. The defense reacts to its keys: the Will and Mike flow right, the walked-down strong safety reads Harlan's reach step and starts down into the alley, the backside end on the left chases the handoff, and the deep safety sees run action and holds the middle. Nothing in the picture tells any of them whether the play is the run, the play-action pass, or the bootleg to the left.
Everything that happens after that frame is a different play. On Wide Right, Ruffin presses Harlan's outside leg and cuts once. On Wide PA, the backside linemen turn back to protect, Ruffin carries out his fake and blocks the edge, and Harlan releases into a dig behind the linebackers who just flowed past him. On Wide PA Boot Left, Vance keeps the ball and rolls away from all of it, and the left guard pulls to block the end if the end didn't chase. Same frame. Three different plays.
What has to match
| Player | On Wide | On Wide PA | On Wide PA Boot | When it may differ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Linemen | Reach step, then block the rule | Same reach step; play side blocks like the run, backside turns back | Same reach step; the boot-side guard pulls flat | After the first step, and only at the line ("high hat") |
| Tight end (Y) | Reach the end or Sam | Same reach step, then release | Same reach step, then cross | After his second step |
| Quarterback | Open, hand off, carry out | Open, fake, set up at ~7 yards | Open, fake, keep it, roll away | After the fake: about one second |
| Back | Track to the landmark, one cut | Same track, then block the edge | Same track, carry out the fake hard | Never visibly: he sells it all the way |
| Receivers | Stalk block or crack | Start like the stalk, then release | Start like the stalk, then clear or cross | After three steps |
The last column is the coaching. If any player differs before his cell says he may, the defender keyed on him gets the answer early. My Trips boot broke four rows at once.
🔄 Check your understanding: In the post-snap frame above, which defender decides whether Wide PA Boot Left needs the pulling guard, and what is he keying?
Answer
The backside defensive end on the left. He keys the ball and the back. If he chases the handoff flat down the line, he's out of the play and the quarterback gets outside him; Naked (no puller) would have worked. If he stays home, he's the threat, and the left guard's pull is what blocks him. His first-second behavior is the evidence for which version to call.
29.2 Where It Comes From: Denver, Gibbs, and a Tree Everyone Draws Differently
The offense is most closely associated with Mike Shanahan and his offensive line coach Alex Gibbs in Denver. Their Broncos won Super Bowls after the 1997 and 1998 seasons with an outside-zone running game and a play-action and bootleg passing game built to look exactly like it. Gibbs is widely credited as one of the great teachers of zone blocking, and the Denver run game became famous for producing big seasons from backs other teams had passed on. Terrell Davis, a sixth-round pick, became the face of it and is now in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
From there the system spread through what is usually called the Shanahan tree. Gary Kubiak coordinated Denver's offense and later ran his own version as a head coach. Kyle Shanahan, Mike's son, built his own offenses on the same foundation. Around 2017, when Kyle Shanahan took over in San Francisco and Sean McVay in Los Angeles, outside zone and under-center play-action came back into fashion across the league, and coaches such as Matt LaFleur are widely grouped with that tree.
I'm going to stop there on purpose. You'll find coaching-tree charts all over the internet, and they disagree with each other, because "tree" is a loose word. Some branches are coaches who worked directly for a Shanahan; some are coaches who worked for those coaches; some are coaches who simply ran the same ideas. What they share is easier to see on film than on a chart: under-center play-action, outside zone as the base run, boots and keepers off it, motion at or before the snap, and everything built to look the same as long as possible.
What each era is commonly said to have added
This table is how most film analysts describe the system's evolution. Treat it as a broad sketch, not a history exam: every one of these features existed somewhere before, and every team mixed them differently.
| Era | Features widely associated with it | What it was answering |
|---|---|---|
| Denver, late 1990s | Outside zone with one-cut backs; backside cut blocks (since restricted, see the safety note below); boot and naked off the zone; under-center play-action | Eight-man fronts that stopped power football; linebackers who keyed the backfield |
| The tree through the 2000s and early 2010s | The same core carried to new teams; play-action crossers and deep overs; fullbacks and versatile tight ends | Defenses that had now seen the boot for a decade |
| The late-2010s revival | Heavy pre-snap and at-the-snap motion; condensed formations from 11 personnel; under-center play-action in a league that had moved to the shotgun; catch-and-run crossers | Single-high defenses with safeties in the box; a league that had stopped practicing against under-center football |
That last row matters for a reason that isn't schematic. By the mid-2010s, most offenses lived in the shotgun, and defenses built their practice weeks around shotgun runs and spread passes. An offense that went back under center and ran outside zone with boots was showing defenders a picture they practiced against less often. Part of the revival's success, as many coaches have pointed out, was simply scarcity: the old picture had become new again.
🩺 Player safety: The classic Denver outside zone was famous, and controversial, for backside cut blocks: linemen going low at a pursuing defender's legs. Rules on blocks below the waist have tightened repeatedly at every level since then. Chop blocks (one blocker high and another low on the same defender) are illegal everywhere. The NFL, NCAA, and high-school codes each restrict where, when, by whom, and from which direction a low block may happen, and the details change often. Check your current rulebook every season. Austin's backside linemen block high; Gus Ferrante's line is "Cut him off with your feet, not your shoulder pads at his knees."
Why it has lasted
🔍 Why this works: Most offensive systems are answers to a particular defense, and they fade when that defense changes. This one has survived for about three decades because it's built on something defenses can't stop doing: keying. Every defense, in every era, has to teach its players to react to the first second, because a defense that waits to be sure loses to the run. As long as defenders key, an offense that controls what the keys show will get them wrong some of the time. The particulars changed (fronts, coverages, low-block rules), but the target never did. That's also why the system's best counters aren't new coverages. They're discipline rules for specific defenders, like the backside end who "squeezes and looks for the guard," which you'll meet in §29.4.
🔄 Check your understanding: Name three features that film analysts commonly use to identify an offense as part of the Shanahan tree, and say which one of them is the foundation the others depend on.
Answer
Any three of: outside zone as the base run, under-center play-action, boots and keepers off the zone action, heavy motion, condensed formations, catch-and-run crossers. The foundation is outside zone: the boots, the play-action, and most of the motion and formation choices exist to copy it or protect it. Without a real outside-zone run, the rest is a set of rollouts and fakes with nothing to fake.
29.3 The Engine: Wide Zone Is the Base, Not a Play
Chapter 10 taught outside zone as a run: the reach step, the overtake, the back's bang, bend, and bounce. In this system it's also something larger. It's the picture that every other play borrows. On our sideline the run is called "Wide," and before you read further, answer this from memory.
🔄 Check your understanding: On Wide Right, what is the back's landmark in Austin's teaching, what are his three answers, and which one is supposed to be the least common?
Answer
His landmark is the outside leg of the play-side tight end (or the tackle when no tight end is attached). His three answers are bounce (outside the edge when it's reached and soft), bang (up inside the blocker who is running his man wide), and bend (back across the center when the front and linebackers overflow). The bounce is listed first because the track threatens it first, but it should happen least; Marisol Vega's season chart had 72 of Ruffin's 96 Wide carries going inside the tight end.
Why does the whole system hang on this one run? Three reasons, and each of them is about the other plays.
First, outside zone moves everyone sideways. A defense facing inside zone can play its gaps by stepping forward. A defense facing outside zone has to run laterally just to stay in its gaps. A defender running sideways is a defender whose eyes are on the ball and whose momentum is going the wrong way when the ball turns out to be somewhere else. That lateral flow is the raw material for every boot and every crosser.
Second, its first step is the most copyable step in football. Every lineman takes the same short lateral step on every Wide play, regardless of who is in front of him. That single step can be repeated exactly on play-action and on the boot, because the play-action protection and the boot pull both start from it. A gap scheme can't do this as cleanly: a pulling guard is a loud key, and if he pulls on the run he has to pull on the fake.
Third, it's a run you can afford to call for four yards. Outside zone rarely gets stuffed for a big loss if it's blocked by the rules, and when it doesn't hit, it usually gains three or four. That means you can keep calling it while it does its real job: teaching the linebackers to flow, the safety to fill, and the backside end to chase.
🧩 Productive struggle: Before you read on, work this out. Your Wide from Twelve averages about 4 yards a carry against single-high, eight-man boxes. Your Wide PA Boot averages about 10 yards a call when the backside end has chased the run, and about 2 when he hasn't. A young coach on your staff says: "Our boot is two and a half times better than our run. Let's call the boot more and the run less." Write down, in two sentences, what's wrong with that argument. Then read on.
Here's what's wrong with it. The young coach is measuring each play as if it stood alone, and in this system no play stands alone. The run's value includes the value it lends to the boot. Every Wide that makes the backside end chase is a deposit; every boot spends it. Call the boot more and the run less, and you'll get more calls at 2 yards and fewer at 10, because the ends will stop chasing. In Chapter 10 I put it this way: a boot is a payment for runs you've already made. That's the first lesson of the whole system, and it's why a coordinator in this tradition will cheerfully call outside zone for three, two, and four.
The family on one page
Here's Austin's Wide family as it sits on our call sheet. Each play is the answer to one defender doing his job against Wide; the right-hand column is the evidence I want before I call it.
| Call | Lied-to defender | What he did on Wide | The evidence I want first |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wide | Nobody; it's the deposit | — | A box of seven or fewer, or a reason to make the defense flow |
| Wide PA, Y Dig | Mike and the alley safety | Stepped up hard to the reach | Two fast fills by the second level |
| Wide PA Boot / Naked | Backside end | Chased flat down the line | Two chases on the drive (Teo counts them from the booth) |
| Wide PA Max, Yankee | The single deep safety | Crept toward the strength or the run | A walked-down strong safety and a middle safety who leans |
| Toss Crack | The force safety | Fit outside-in, fast | A safety who is the force player and fills early |
| Jet / Fly (with Wide away) | Linebackers who sit | Waited for the run to declare | Linebackers who play patient against Wide |
That right-hand column is the difference between a system and a playbook. A playbook says "we have a boot." A system says "we call the boot when the backside end has chased twice." The first is a list of plays; the second is a list of reasons.
29.4 Boot and Naked: The Backside Pays the Bill
Chapter 10 drew the bootleg and Chapter 19 drew its protection, so I won't redraw them. Here I want to show you what the boot looks like as a system piece: what it does against the different coverages it will meet, and why a defensive coordinator who knows it's coming can still struggle to stop it.
A quick reminder of our words. Wide PA Boot Left means the fake goes right (Wide Right action) and the quarterback goes left; the word after "Boot" is always the quarterback's direction. On Boot, the boot-side guard pulls flat to block the first defender outside the tackle. On Naked, nobody pulls and nobody blocks that edge; the quarterback is betting the end chased. Many systems call the naked bootleg a keeper, because the quarterback can keep it and run. The routes form a three-level flood on the move: a flat route at 3–5 yards, a crosser at 10–12 coming from the other side of the formation, and a clear route deep to take the corner away. We never add "Flood" to a boot call; the flood is built in.
The boot against two high safeties
The bootleg grew up attacking single-high defenses, where a walked-down strong safety fills on the fake and the crosser runs into the space behind him. Two-high defenses like Russ Kimbrough's Sentinels are a harder problem. Here is Naked Right against a two-high Quarters look.
PRE-SNAP (Twelve, Under Ace Left vs. Nickel Over, two-high Quarters)
"Wide PA Naked Right" -- the same picture as Wide Left
F $
C C
*
M W
E T N E
Z Y LT LG C RG RT U X
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Austin's two-tight-end set is flipped: Harlan (Y) is attached on the left with Gaines (Z) off the line outside him, and Brandt (U) is attached on the right with Sutton (X) on the line wide right. Vance is under center with Ruffin behind him. The defense is in nickel with two deep safeties at about 11 yards, a four-man front, two linebackers, and the nickel at an apex position outside Brandt on the right.
POST-SNAP (Naked Right vs. Quarters: fake Wide Left, nobody blocks
the right edge; flat, crosser, clear)
F $ (reads U: U goes
<-C (Z post) out, so he caps X)
^ X clear
<-M <-W (flow with the fake) |
,---------------------------------> Y cross 10-12 |
/ (in front of $) |
/ <-E <-T <-N (E) chases the fake |
Z Y LT LG C RG RT U------> flat 3-5 * (widens) |
<- <- <- <- <- (line steps left) X
R <=fake== Q ========> rolls right, outside (E)
📊 Diagram (described): The whole line steps left with the Wide Left action, and Vance fakes the handoff to Ruffin going left. The linebackers and the backside end on the right flow left after the fake. Vance keeps the ball and rolls right, where nobody is blocking the edge. Brandt releases into the right flat at 3 to 5 yards, and the nickel widens to cover him. Harlan comes all the way across the formation from the left at 10 to 12 yards, underneath the right-side safety. That safety reads Brandt; when Brandt goes to the flat, he moves to cap Sutton's deep clearing route instead of driving on the crosser. Gaines runs a post on the backside.
Look at what the two-high shell does to the boot. The crosser doesn't run behind a safety who filled; it runs in front of a safety who stayed back. The deep clear is capped. So against Quarters the boot is not an explosive play. It's an efficient one: the flat and the crosser, thrown on time, for 6 to 12 yards, with a quarterback who has a run option if the nickel and the linebackers all drop. That's still worth calling, but it's a different promise.
The boot by coverage
| Coverage | Who has the flat | Who has the crosser | Who has the clear | What the boot usually gets |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cover 3, safety walked down | The walked-down safety or the curl-flat linebacker | Nobody, if the linebackers flowed | The corner (deep third) | The crosser behind the flow; explosive potential |
| Cover 1 (man) | The man on the flat receiver | The man on the crosser, chasing across the field | The corner on the clear | The crosser running away from his man; the QB's legs |
| Quarters (Cover 4) | The nickel or apex player | Underneath the boot-side safety | The boot-side safety caps it | Flat or crosser for 6–12; efficient, rarely explosive |
| Cover 2 | The corner (squats) | The hook defenders, if they recover | The half-field safety | Crosser in the hole; flat is the corner's |
💡 Coach's point: Against single-high, the boot is a shot. Against two-high, it's a first down. Call it for what the coverage will give you, and don't ask it for twenty yards against two safeties.
Our boots that mattered
These are snaps from our fictional season that you've seen in other chapters. Put them side by side and the pattern is clearer than any single one.
| Game | Situation | Call | Defense | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Week 10 at Portland | Q2, 1st-and-10 at our 42, tied 7–7 | Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left | Single-high Cover 3; the Will jumped Brandt's flat | Harlan +23 on the crosser, to the Portland 35 |
| Week 12 vs. St. Louis | Q2, 2nd-and-6 at the Stallions' 38, tied 7–7 | Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left (after Wide went 3, 2, and 4) | Eight-man box; the backside end chased | Harlan +18 to the St. Louis 20 |
| Week 12 vs. St. Louis | Q3, 1st-and-10 at our 44, up 13–10 | Load Right, Wide PA Boot (left) | Front bumped a gap; strong safety rolled down | Brandt +14 in the left flat |
| Divisional at Sacramento | Q4, 1st-and-goal at the Sentinels' 9, down 17–10 | Twelve, Under Ace Left, Wide PA Boot Right | Rollins chased on all five Wides of the drive | Harlan 9-yard TD, 17–17 |
Three of the four came against single-high defenses, and the fourth came on a short field where the crosser only had to get to the goal line. That's not a coincidence. We threw no boots against Sacramento in the two regular-season games, and Russ noticed.
The defense's answer: squeeze and look
🛡️ The defense's view: At the second-morning breakfast in the spring, Russ Kimbrough drew his plan against our Wide on a menu: "force, flatten, chase." A force player outside-in to take away the bounce, interior linemen sliding flat down the line to take away the bang, and Rollins chasing from the backside to take away the bend. Then he told me the rule that kept the chase from becoming a liability: his ends squeeze down the line and look for the guard. If a guard pulls away from the run, it's a boot, and the end stops chasing and turns to the quarterback. "You never booted us," he said, meaning the two regular-season games. A good defensive coordinator doesn't stop the boot with a coverage. He stops it with one disciplined player whose key changes from "the ball" to "the guard." That's exactly why Naked exists: it takes away the guard he's looking for. And it's why the boot is a sequence call. The touchdown in the divisional round came after Rollins had chased five straight times on the same drive, long enough that he'd stopped looking for a guard he hadn't seen.
This is the conversation between coordinators in miniature. The offense says, "Your end chases, so I boot." The defense says, "My end looks for the guard, so your boot is a rollout." The offense says, "Then I won't pull the guard," and calls Naked. The defense says, "Then my end stays home on every Wide," and the offense says, "Thank you; my cutback just got bigger." Every answer opens a door. The coordinator who wins is the one who knows which door is open today, and that's an evidence question, not a scheme question.
Marisol's boot table
After the season, Marisol Vega, our director of analytics, split every Boot and Naked we called by what the backside end had done on the zone runs earlier in the same drive. These are our fictional numbers, and they're a small sample, which she said three times while presenting them.
| Evidence before the call | Calls | Completions | Yards per call |
|---|---|---|---|
| End chased on two or more zone runs earlier on the drive | 13 | 10 | 10.2 |
| End chased once | 6 | 3 | 4.5 |
| End never chased, or no zone run yet on the drive | 5 | 2 | 1.8 |
"Twenty-four calls," she said. "I wouldn't bet the house on the middle row. But the top and bottom rows aren't close." The bottom row is where my worst boot of the season lives, and you'll find it in Case Study 1: Week 2 at St. Louis, a boot called before we'd shown them a reason to chase. The top row is the evidence behind the "chases twice" rule, which Teo brought into our booth the week after that game. By the playoffs it was printed on the call sheet next to the boot: when 94 chases twice and we're inside the 15.
⚠️ Common mistake: throwing the crosser late. On a boot, the crosser is open for a short window, after he clears the flowing linebackers and before the boot-side safety or corner can drive on him. A quarterback who looks at the flat, pumps, and then comes back to the crosser throws it into a defender who has had a full second to recover. The fix: Rome Pettaway teaches the boot read as "edge, then flat, then crosser, then clear — and the ball comes out by the time your back foot hits the numbers." If it isn't out by the numbers, it's the flat, a run, or out of bounds.
🩺 Player safety: The boot and especially Naked put the quarterback on the move with his body exposed, and on Naked the most dangerous rusher on the field may be unblocked by design. Teach the quarterback to throw it away, slide, or step out of bounds rather than absorb a hit while trying to extend the play. In practice, run boots against a scout end who is told to thud (wrap without taking the quarterback to the ground), and keep live contact on the quarterback off the schedule.
📋 Try it — Whose fault?: A Thursday practice rep, team period, scout defense playing St. Louis-style single-high with an eight-man box. The script calls "Twelve, Under Ace Left, Wide PA Naked Right" on the first snap of a drive. The scout end on the right, told to play the Stallions' rule ("stay home until the cutback hurts you"), doesn't chase. Vance carries out the fake, turns, and finds the end three yards in front of him. He tries to step up and around him, gets thudded by the end for what would have been a sack, and the ball comes out on the ground. Gus is yelling at Fitch, the right tackle, for not blocking the end. Vance is apologizing for the ball. Whose fault, what's the rule, and what's the fix?
Worked answer
Mostly mine, the play-caller's, and partly Vance's.
The call: Naked is only right when the backside end has proven he chases. On the first snap of a drive, against a defender whose rule is to stay home, there's no evidence at all. Naked against a stay-home end is a quarterback walking into an unblocked rusher. If I wanted the boot there at all, it had to be Boot (the right guard pulls to the edge), and really it should have been Wide, to make a deposit first.
Not Fitch's fault: on Naked, the right tackle's assignment is to "hinge," stepping and sealing inside. Nobody blocks the edge by design. If Fitch had left his man to block the end, he'd have broken the play's rules to cover for the call.
Vance's part: our boot rule is "throw the flat now, or throw it away; never take the sack on a boot." When he turned and saw the end, the flat (Brandt) was his answer or the sideline was. Trying to make the end miss with the ball in one hand is how a sack becomes a fumble.
The fix: in the script, the Naked goes on the card only behind two zone runs to the other side in the same period, and the scout end is told to chase unless he's seen two Nakeds in a row. In games, Teo's chase count decides between Boot and Naked, and Vance's rule gets repeated in the walkthrough.
29.5 Yankee and the Crossers: Passes That Start as Runs
If the boot is the system's most famous pass, the crossing route is its most important one. A crosser is any route that runs across the field, from one side of the formation to the other. In this offense the crossers come at every depth, and they all share one idea: the run action pulls the second level one way, and the crosser runs the other way, behind it.
Here is the whole family as Austin uses it. You've seen each of these drawn somewhere in the book; what matters here is that they're one family.
| Crosser | Depth | Off what action | Who runs it | Lied-to defender | Drawn in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Boot crosser | 10–12 | Wide PA Boot / Naked | Harlan (or the backside #2) | Linebackers who flowed with the fake | Chapter 10 |
| Wide PA, Y Dig | 12 | Wide PA (pocket) | Harlan, breaking behind the flow | Mike and the alley safety | Chapter 19 |
| Yankee deep over | 18–22 | Inside PA or Wide PA, Max protection | Gaines or Sutton | The single deep safety | Chapters 18 and 19 |
| Shallow | 5–6 | Dropback, often from condensed sets | Powers | The man defender chasing him | Chapter 17 |
Why does a system built on the run lean so hard on crossers? Three reasons.
The geometry matches the fake. Outside zone moves the linebackers laterally. A route that runs laterally in the opposite direction gets separation without needing a fast receiver or a great release: the defenders take themselves away from it. That's why Brooks Harlan, a 255-pound tight end, can run free on a boot. He isn't outrunning anyone. He's running away from people who are running the other way.
Crossers are hard to cover in man. A defender in man coverage on a crosser has to run across the whole formation, through traffic, chasing a receiver who's already moving. Against single-high man defenses, the crossers are the system's most reliable throws, which is why the deep over sits in our zero bin.
Crossers are caught on the move. A receiver catching a crosser is running full speed across the field, often into open grass on the far side, and that's where yards after the catch come from. You'll see in §29.8 why the system treats that as designed yardage rather than a bonus.
Yankee: the crosser as a shot
Yankee is the crosser family's shot play, and it's widely associated with the Shanahan tree: play action, max protection, a post from one side and a deep over from the other, landing at 18 to 22 yards. Chapter 18 drew our best one, and it's worth retelling here as a system play.
Week 10 at Portland, fourth quarter, about 5:50 left, Outlaws up 24–13. Second-and-2 at our 47. We'd been running from Twelve to drain the clock, and the Pioneers, down eleven, had gone to a single-high, eight-man box. The call was "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Inside PA, Yankee." Eight men protected. Sutton ran the post and the Pioneers' lone deep safety, Darnell Price, stayed on it. The linebackers bit on the fake. Gaines caught the over at the Portland 33, and Josh Kiel pushed him out at the 26. Plus 27.
Notice what made it a system play rather than a gamble. The down was cheap (second-and-2 meant an incompletion cost almost nothing). The defense was the one Yankee is built for (single-high, a safety committed to the run). And the picture was the one we'd been running from all quarter (Twelve, under center, a run fake toward Harlan). Take away any one of the three and it's a different decision.
The read is one man: the middle-of-the-field safety. If he stays on the post, the over is open behind the linebackers and in front of the corner. If he jumps the over, the post is behind him. The reason Yankee lives on our St. Louis and Portland call sheets and not on our Sacramento one is that a two-high shell has two players for two routes. Against Russ's Quarters, each deep route has a safety on it before the ball is snapped.
🎬 Film room: On any deep crosser off play-action, watch the second-level defenders' feet for the first second, not the ball. If the linebackers' first two steps go toward the fake, the crosser was open before the quarterback finished his turn. If they drop straight back, the fake failed and the crosser is a contested throw. Then watch the quarterback's feet: on a well-timed crosser, the ball comes out as his back foot hits, not after a hitch.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why is the boot crosser usually run by a tight end or a slot from the opposite side of the formation from the boot, instead of by a receiver already on the boot side?
Answer
Because the run fake goes toward the crosser's starting side and the crosser runs the other way. A receiver who starts on the fake side runs against the flow of the linebackers and safety, who are moving toward where he started, so he gets separation from defenders taking themselves away. A receiver who starts on the boot side runs with nobody fooled about him; the defenders on that side aren't flowing anywhere.
29.6 Condensed Formations: Tight Splits, Crack Angles, and the Two-Way Go
For most of football history, wide receivers lined up wide. The late-2010s version of this system made a habit of doing the opposite: lining receivers up condensed, a few yards outside the tight end or tackle, inside the numbers. Many coaches call these reduced splits or tight splits; our word is "Nasty." "Twelve, Under Ace Right Nasty" condenses the whole formation; "Z Nasty" reduces only the Z's split.
Why bring receivers in? Because a receiver close to the formation can do four things a wide receiver can't do as well.
| What a condensed split gives you | Why | What it costs |
|---|---|---|
| Crack angles | A receiver inside the force defender can block him from the outside in | Brings the corner closer to the run too |
| A two-way go vs. press | With 10+ yards of grass outside him, the corner can't use the sideline as help; the receiver can break in or out | Fewer pure "outside" fade throws |
| Room outside for boots and outs | The flat and the out-breaking routes have space to work | Compresses the field horizontally for the defense too |
| An alignment that doesn't tell | A receiver who can block or run looks the same either way | Requires receivers who'll actually block |
The last row is the system idea. A wide split usually means pass; a tight split, in many offenses, usually means run or a rub. If your tight splits carry runs and passes, the defense can't read your alignment. If they don't, you've built a tell.
How we learned that the hard way
We built one. In the four games before Week 6, Gaines took a reduced split on 23 snaps, and every scissors we ran (9 of them) came from a reduced split. The scissors is our post-and-corner concept, and in Game 1 it went for 31 yards: second-and-9 at our 38, Gaines's post from a reduced split. Marisol found the tell during our Week 9 bye. Russ told me in the spring that his staff had it before Game 1.
The fix was the system fix: make the condensed look carry the run. After the bye we put the dig, the crack toss, and quick game on Gaines's reduced split, ran some scissors from a normal split, and added Wide with a crack block from Nasty. In Week 15 at Sacramento, a condensed crack look for Gaines in the fourth quarter gained only two, and Russ had an answer for it waiting. That's fine. It doesn't have to gain much. It has to make the next reduced split mean nothing.
The crack, drawn
Here's Nasty against the defense it bothers most: single-high with a walked-down strong safety who is the force player.
PRE-SNAP (Twelve, Under Ace Right Nasty vs. Cover 3, $ walked down)
Nasty: both receivers about 4 yards outside the tight ends
F
C C
$
W M
E N T E S
X U LT LG C RG RT Y
Q Z
R
📊 Diagram (described): The same two-tight-end, under-center set as before, but both wide receivers have condensed: Sutton (X) is on the line about four yards outside Brandt, and Gaines (Z) is off the line about four yards outside Harlan. The corners have followed them inside, lined up at about seven or eight yards. The strong safety is walked down outside Harlan, the Sam is on Harlan, and one deep safety is in the middle.
POST-SNAP (Wide Right, Z Crack: Gaines cracks the force safety;
the corner must replace him from depth)
W] M] $]<--Z (crack: see
/ / ^ the numbers)
E] N] T] E] S] |
/ / / / / / / | C (replaces
U LT LG C RG RT Y | the force,
Q late)
'..>R----------------> bounce if C is late
📊 Diagram (described): The line blocks Wide Right exactly as it always does: reach, combo, climb. Gaines comes inside from his tight split and cracks the walked-down strong safety from the outside in, taking away the defender who would have filled the alley. That makes the corner the force player, and he has to come downhill from about eight yards outside. Ruffin presses Harlan's outside leg. If Harlan runs his man wide, Ruffin bangs inside; if the corner is late, the bounce is open outside.
Chapter 10's Toss Crack does the same thing with a pitch and a pulling tackle to replace the corner, and it went for 14 against St. Louis. The Wide version is simpler: no puller, the same first step as everything else, and the back reads the corner instead of having him blocked. Both rely on a defensive rule called crack-replace: when a receiver cracks the force player, the corner replaces him. That rule is sound. It's also a key, and every key can be lied to.
POST-SNAP (Wide PA Max, Z Crack Go: the crack is the fake; the
corner replaces the run, and Gaines runs past him)
F (holds on X's post)
^ Z go: ball
W-> M-> $-> | over the
| outside
E N T E S Z-----+ shoulder
U LT LG C RG RT Y (two crack steps,
Q ..fake..> R then up the field)
(sets at 7) C--> (comes down to
replace: beaten)
📊 Diagram (described): The same picture and the same first second as Wide Right, Z Crack, but it's play-action with eight protecting: both tight ends and Ruffin stay in after the fake. Gaines takes two hard steps inside as if to crack the strong safety, and the corner, playing crack-replace, comes downhill to take over the force. Gaines then turns up the field behind him. Sutton runs a post from the left to hold the deep safety in the middle. Vance sets at about seven yards and throws the go over Gaines's outside shoulder.
We call it "Z Crack Go." It's the condensed formation's version of the boot: the run asks the corner to do his job, and the pass punishes him for doing it. Like every play in this chapter, it's only as good as the cracks that came before it. A corner who hasn't seen Gaines crack doesn't replace, and the go becomes a contested fade against a corner sitting on it.
🩺 Player safety: Crack blocks are where some of the game's most dangerous hits used to happen, and every level now restricts blocks below the waist and blind-side blocks with forcible contact. Teach the crack with the head out of it, the hands inside the defender's frame, above the waist, and only on a defender who can see it coming. Cal Boateng's rule: "See the numbers or don't hit." If the safety turns his back, the receiver runs past him and blocks the next man. Check your current code every season.
The two-way go
The crack is the run-game reason to condense. The pass-game reason is the two-way go. Against a corner in press-man coverage, a wide receiver aligned near the sideline has one realistic way to win: inside, because the sideline is the corner's help on the outside. Move the receiver in to a condensed split and the corner has grass on both sides of him. Now the receiver can break in on a dig or a slant, or out on an out or a corner route, and the corner has to guess or play soft.
| Corner's leverage vs. a condensed Z | What the Z wins with | What the quarterback looks for |
|---|---|---|
| Inside (taking away the dig) | Out-breaking routes into the space outside him | Gaines's break and the corner's hip turn |
| Outside (respecting the out) | The dig, the slant, the crosser under him | The window behind the linebackers who flowed |
| Head-up press | Whichever way the corner commits; Cal teaches a "two-way stem" | The release: if the corner opens, throw the side he opened away from |
| Off, soft | The crack and the run, or a quick hitch | Take the free yards and keep the picture honest |
Condensed splits also create legal traffic for man-beaters: two receivers close together can run routes that cross, and the defenders chasing them have to work through each other. Teach that as route spacing, never as blocking. In the NFL, a receiver who blocks a defender more than a yard downfield before the pass is thrown commits offensive pass interference; contact that happens while both players run their paths is treated differently, and officiating emphasis changes year to year. Chapter 17 draws the legal line.
📋 Try it — Find the conflict: Austin is in "Twelve, Under Ace Right Nasty" against a single-high defense. Pre-snap, the strong safety is walked down to six yards outside Harlan, the corner on Gaines is at seven yards with outside leverage, and the deep safety is at 14 yards in the middle. On the drive's first two plays, Gaines cracked the strong safety on Wide Right (+6) and on Toss Right, Z Crack (+9). On both, the corner came downhill hard to replace the force. Name the conflict defender, his two jobs, and the play that makes him wrong.
Worked answer
The conflict defender is the corner on Gaines. His two jobs: on a run with a crack block, he's the force player who must replace the cracked safety and come downhill; on a pass, he has the deep outside third. He can't do both after he's committed to the first. Twice now he has replaced fast, which is correct against the run.
The play: "Twelve, Under Ace Right Nasty, Wide PA Max, Z Crack Go." Gaines shows the same two crack steps, the corner comes down to replace, and Gaines turns up the sideline behind him. Sutton's post holds the deep safety in the middle, and the max protection buys the time for a vertical throw.
Why now: the two cracks are the evidence. If the corner had stayed deep on the first two, the crack go would be a contested throw; you'd keep running the crack and take the yards. The call is earned by what the corner did, not by what the play could do.
29.7 Motion, the Fullback, and Players You Can't Read
The system adds two more tools to the illusion: motion, which makes the defense move before the snap, and versatile personnel, which keeps the defense from knowing what the people on the field are for.
Motion: making the defense run before the snap
Austin used pre-snap motion on about 55 percent of our snaps last season (our fictional charting), which is a lot. Chapter 27 is the full motion chapter. In this system, motion does four jobs, and you've seen each of them in our games.
| Motion job | What it does to the defense | Example from our season |
|---|---|---|
| Run sideways early | Linebackers and safeties shift with a jet man before the run starts | Jet fake with Wide away (drawn below) |
| Force a declaration | Who travels with the motion tells you man or zone | Game 1 opening drive: Vo traveled with Powers's motion, telling us man, and Powers ran the switch release for 12 |
| Create a new run threat | A jet sweep makes the defense honor the perimeter on the motion side | Divisional round, first quarter: Powers's jet sweep gained 1 against a defense that rolled a safety with it |
| Change the strength at the snap | The defense's front and rotation are set to a picture that's gone | A tight end zipping in to attach; an H back moving to the other side |
The jet sweep in the divisional round is a good example of the system's patience. It gained one yard, against a defense that rotated a safety down with the motion; Russ told me in the spring they called that adjustment their "roll" on jet. But a defense that rotates a safety toward every jet has told you where the safety won't be when the jet is a fake.
🏫 Rules note: In the NFL, only one player may be in motion at the snap, and he may not be moving toward the line of scrimmage. After a shift, every player must be set for one full second before the snap. A jet man moving parallel to the line at full speed at the snap is legal under those rules. College and high-school codes differ in their details; check your code.
PRE-SNAP (Eleven, Under Doubles Right, H Jet: Wide Left)
vs. Nickel Over, two-high; Powers starts in the left slot
F $
C C
*
W M
E T N E
X LT LG C RG RT Y Z
H ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~> (jet, timed to the snap)
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Austin is in 11 personnel with Vance under center and Ruffin deep behind him. Harlan (Y) is attached on the right with Gaines (Z) wide right; Sutton (X) is on the line wide left and Powers (H) starts in the left slot. Powers comes in full-speed jet motion toward the right, timed to arrive behind Vance at the snap. The defense is in nickel with two deep safeties, the nickel over Powers's original spot, a four-man front, and two linebackers.
POST-SNAP (H Jet fakes right; Wide Left goes where the rotation left)
F <-- spins toward the middle $ rotates down to the jet
v
* ----------------------> (runs with the jet: gone)
<--W] M--> (steps to the jet, then back)
<--E] <--T] <--N] E (backside: late)
X] LT LG C RG RT Y
<- <- <- <- <- <- (line steps left)
<----R Q ...> H (fake; keeps running)
aim: LT's outside leg
📊 Diagram (described): Vance fakes the jet sweep to Powers, who keeps running right. The nickel runs with Powers, the strong safety on the right rotates down toward the jet, and the Mike takes a step toward the jet before he finds the ball. Meanwhile the whole line steps left and blocks Wide Left: the left tackle reaches the end, the left guard and center handle the tackle and nose, and a climber gets to the Will. Ruffin takes the handoff going left, aiming at the left tackle's outside leg, toward the side the defense just thinned out. The free safety, who rotated toward the middle, is the last defender.
The jet doesn't have to be the play to change the play. When a defense rolls toward motion, the motion has moved a defender away from the run. When it doesn't roll, the jet sweep itself is open on the edge. That's a conflict built before the ball is snapped, and it's why so many offenses in this tree run some form of motion on most of their snaps.
Orbit is the jet's mirror. The H runs behind the quarterback instead of in front of him, which sells a sweep to the far side while the line and the back flow the other way. Then the boot comes back toward the orbit man, and he's already moving into the flat. In our book it's simply "H Orbit" with a boot called away from the run, and the flat belongs to Powers.
The fullback: the system's Swiss army knife
As much of the league moved away from the fullback in the 2000s and 2010s, teams in this tree were known for keeping one, and using him in more ways than the old lead blocker. Sione Fale is ours. In our Twenty-one package he can lead on Wide, insert on Inside (the "Twenty-one, Under I Right, Inside Insert" that Moose Odom carried for 6 at 8:20 of the fourth quarter against St. Louis in Week 12), wham an interior lineman, slice back to cut off the backside end, kick out on Power, and run routes. That last job is the one defenses forget.
PRE-SNAP (Twenty-one, Under I Right: Wide PA Boot Left, B Slice Flat)
vs. 4-3 Over, single-high, $ walked down
F
C C
$
W M
E N T E S
X LT LG C RG RT Y Z
Q
B
R
📊 Diagram (described): Austin has a fullback and a tailback in the I formation behind Vance, who is under center. Harlan (Y) is attached on the right, Sutton (X) is on the line wide left, and Gaines (Z) is off the line wide right. Fale (B) is the fullback, Ruffin the tailback. The defense is a 4-3 Over with a walked-down strong safety on Harlan's side and one deep safety.
POST-SNAP (fake Wide Right; Fale slices back and leaks to the flat;
Moss pulls to the edge; Vance boots left)
^ X clear Z post ^
| W--> M--> $--> /
| <------------------------------------------ Y cross 10-12
|
| <------------------B (one step right, slices back
| across, leaks to the flat 3-5)
E (chases -->)
LT LG C RG RT Y (line steps right)
]<=====LG (pulls flat to the edge)
Q <==== rolls left R ===> (fake; blocks right)
📊 Diagram (described): Everything starts as Wide Right: the line steps right, Vance fakes to Ruffin going right, and Fale takes one step right as if leading. Then Fale turns back across the formation behind the line, exactly the path of a slice block on the backside end, and keeps going into the left flat at three to five yards. The left guard pulls flat to block the first defender outside the left tackle, and Vance rolls left behind him. Harlan crosses from right to left at ten to twelve yards behind the linebackers and strong safety, who flowed right. Sutton clears the left corner deep, and Gaines runs a post on the backside.
Look at what the fullback's path does to the backside end. A fullback crossing toward him looks like the slice block from Chapter 10, which tells the end "run, and someone's coming to block me." If he squeezes to take on the slice, he isn't attacking the quarterback; if he chases, he's out of the play. Either way, Fale's route is the first read, and it's open early because defenders don't cover a blocker.
Players you can't read
| Player | What he can be on any snap | What it does to the defense |
|---|---|---|
| Brooks Harlan (Y) | In-line blocker, wing, flexed seam runner, boot crosser, arc blocker | The defense can't pick base or nickel by his presence alone |
| Sione Fale (B) | Lead, insert, wham, slice, kick-out, flat route | A two-back set that might be a pass |
| Mekhi Powers (H) and Jaylen Cross | Jet sweep, jet fake, orbit flat, slot routes | A receiver who might be the run |
| Jalen Ruffin (R) | One-cut Wide runner, edge protector on play-action, screen target | The back's track doesn't tell run or pass |
That table is a personnel argument, and Chapter 4 made it first: personnel is how you choose the defender. In this system it's also how you protect the illusion. If your 21-personnel snaps are always runs, the fullback is a tell. If your 11-personnel snaps never feature a jet man who gets the ball, the jet is a tell. In our own sample before Week 6, 21 personnel was only 8 of 247 snaps, which is part of why Fale is a package player for us and not a base one.
🔄 Check your understanding: A defense rotates a safety down toward every jet motion. Name two plays that take advantage of that rotation, and say which defender each one makes wrong.
Answer
Wide away from the jet (the jet fake, drawn above): the rotating safety and the nickel who traveled with the jet are now on the wrong side of the run. A boot back toward the side the safety left, or a play-action post behind the rotation: the safety who rotated down can't also be deep on that side. (A jet sweep itself attacks a defense that doesn't rotate.)
29.8 Under Center and Yards After the Catch
Under center in a shotgun league
By the 2010s, the shotgun was football's default. Offenses in this tree kept far more of their snaps under center than most of the league did, and around 2017 that under-center play-action game spread widely again. Public charting in those years generally showed the tree's teams using play-action and under-center alignments more than the league norm; read that as a broad pattern, not a precise ranking.
Why under center? Three reasons, and each comes with a cost.
| What under center gives you | Why it matters here | What it costs |
|---|---|---|
| The quarterback's back hides the ball | The play-action and boot fakes are invisible for a beat | He loses sight of the defense during the fake |
| The boot starts naturally | The quarterback is already turning; rolling out is one motion | He needs time to get to depth on dropbacks |
| Outside zone's mesh is cleaner | The back can take a deeper, wider track | Fewer RPO options; the quarterback's read is harder from under center |
Chapter 19 gave you the rule that settles it: the best play-action fake is the one that copies the run you actually run from that picture. That's why Austin is split. From Eleven, our runs are shotgun Inside and RPOs, so our Eleven play-action is shotgun Inside PA. From Twelve, our runs are under-center Wide and Duo, so our Twelve play-action, our boots, and Yankee are under center. A team that ran outside zone only from the gun would build its boots from the gun, and they'd be just as good, as long as the run was real.
YAC as a design goal
Yards after the catch (YAC) are the yards a receiver gains after he catches the ball. Many offenses treat them as a bonus that great receivers provide. This system treats them as something you design: throws to receivers already moving, across the field, into space the run action emptied, so the catch and the run are one motion.
The boot crosser, the flat on the boot, the dig behind the flow, the shallow from a condensed split, and the screens built off the same action all share that shape. The quarterback's job on them is less about fitting the ball into a tight window and more about putting it in front of a moving man on time. That's part of why this system has a reputation for making the quarterback's job easier, a reputation that's earned in the design and overstated when people forget that somebody still has to make the throw on the move.
📈 By the numbers: Public charting services have often listed Shanahan-tree offenses among the league's leaders in yards after the catch. That's usually credited to design, but read it carefully: teams with excellent run-after-catch players also design more catch-and-run throws, so the number mixes scheme and talent. Our own version, from Marisol (fictional): on our Wide PA and boot completions, a little over half the yards came after the catch; on our dropback completions, about a third. Her caveat: "The boots are thrown to people with nobody near them. That's not a skill difference. That's the point."
⚠️ Common mistake: the crosser thrown behind. A crosser caught on the back hip turns a 15-yard play into a 9-yard one, because the receiver has to stop, turn, and restart; thrown far enough behind, it's no play at all. In Week 10 at Portland, on our first drive of the third quarter, first-and-10 at their 27, Vance threw a boot crosser to where Harlan was instead of where he was going. Harlan reached back for it and it went off his hands, incomplete, and the drive ended in a field goal instead of a touchdown. The fix: Cal Boateng's rule for any moving target: "Lead him to grass, not to his number." In practice, the boot drill ends with the coach grading the catch point, not the completion.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why does Austin run play-action from the shotgun in Eleven and from under center in Twelve, instead of picking one?
Answer
Because a play-action fake must copy the run that personnel and formation actually run. Eleven's runs are shotgun inside zone and RPOs, so a shotgun fake is the exact copy; Twelve's runs are under-center outside zone and duo, so an under-center fake is the exact copy. Choosing one for both would turn half of the fakes into new pictures, and a new picture has no run history behind it.
29.9 How Defenses Adapted, and How the System Answered
No offense stays ahead for long, and this one has been studied harder than almost any. The broad shape of the defensive response, as most coaches describe it, came in two waves. I'll describe them in general terms, because every defense mixed them differently, and then show you what each looked like across the line from us.
Wave one: two high, light box, "take your four yards"
The revival of the late 2010s feasted on single-high defenses: a strong safety walked into the box, eight men near the line, and linebackers who flowed hard to stop the run. That's the defense the boot, Yankee, and the crack-go were built to punish. So many defenses did the obvious thing. They backed a safety out of the box, played two high, and accepted a lighter box against the run. The bargain was explicit: you can have four or five yards a carry, but the play-action shots and the boot crossers behind a walked-down safety are gone, because there is no walked-down safety.
That is Russ Kimbrough's whole defense, and it's why our Sacramento games looked nothing like our St. Louis games. Against the Sentinels, Wide gained its yards and the boots were efficient at best. "We'll take four a carry from you all day," Russ told me in the spring. He meant it.
How did the system answer? Mostly with patience, and with a few specific tools.
- Run it. Six blockers on six box defenders, with the safeties at 10 or 11 yards, is a good run look. A coordinator who gets bored with four-yard runs and starts throwing into two deep safeties is doing exactly what the defense wants.
- Pick the defender. Personnel and formation decide who the force player is. In our divisional week we ran Wide from Eleven, where Russ's nickel (Kenny Vo) set the edge, and saved Twelve, which brought Tre Holloway into the box, for the boot.
- Make the boot efficient, not explosive. Flat and crosser in front of the safeties; a quarterback run option on Naked.
- Use motion to pull a safety down. If the defense rotates to the jet, the jet has created a single-high look on the snap, and the old shots come back.
Wave two: heavy fronts behind two high safeties
The second wave was smarter. Defenses kept two high safeties but made the front heavier and harder to reach. The best-known version is often called a tite front (some call it mint): both defensive tackles aligned in the inside shoulders of the offensive tackles, and a nose tackle head-up on the center. I'll give technique numbers once here: 0 is head-up on the center; 1 is a shade of the center; 2i is the inside shade of a guard; 2 is head-up on the guard; 3 is the guard's outside shade; 4i is the inside shade of the tackle; 4 is head-up on the tackle; 5 is the tackle's outside shade; 7 is the inside shade of a tight end; 6 is head-up on the tight end; 9 is the tight end's outside shade. (Some systems swap 6 and 7; ours uses 7 for the inside shade.) A tite front is 4i–0–4i.
PRE-SNAP (Twelve, Under Ace Right vs. a tite front, two-high)
4i - 0 - 4i: both tackles inside the offensive tackles
F $
C C
W M
E T N T E
X U LT LG C RG RT Y Z
Q
R
📊 Diagram (described): Austin's two-tight-end, under-center set faces a two-high defense with two linebackers and five men on the line: a nose tackle head-up on the center, a defensive tackle on the inside shoulder of each offensive tackle (4i), and an end outside each tight end. The guards have nobody directly over them, and both safeties are deep.
POST-SNAP (Wide Right vs. tite: the 4i squeezes and the reach dies)
F $ (fills from 11)
W] M (scrapes over the top,
unblocked late)
E T] N] T E]
/ / \ /^\ |
U LT LG C RG RT Y
(C can't reach the 0 alone;
RG has to help, so no one climbs to M;
RT can't get outside the 4i)
Q '..>R---> bang lane squeezed shut
📊 Diagram (described): On Wide Right, the right tackle tries to reach the 4i, who is already inside him and squeezes down the line, so the tackle can't get his helmet outside. The nose is head-up on the center, so the center needs the right guard's help to move him, and that means nobody climbs cleanly to the Mike, who scrapes over the top. Harlan handles the end. Ruffin presses his landmark and finds the bang lane between the guard and tackle squeezed shut by the 4i, with the Mike arriving and the strong safety filling from depth.
That front attacks outside zone's arithmetic. Outside zone works by getting helmets outside defenders and creating combos that free a climber. A 4i is already inside the tackle and wants to squeeze; a 0 nose demands two blockers. The front doesn't need to beat any block. It just needs to make the reach impossible and the climb late. Add an edge player who squeezes and looks for the guard, and you've taken away the boot's free edge too.
The system's answers, as you'd expect, were mostly other runs and other angles rather than a better outside zone.
| Defensive adaptation | What it takes away | The system's answer | Austin's version |
|---|---|---|---|
| Two-high, light box | Play-action shots behind a walked-down safety | Run it; efficient boots; motion to pull a safety down | "Five is fine"; Wide from Eleven; Naked for the flat |
| Tite / mint front | The reach and the play-side combo | Duo and gap runs that hit the B gap the 4i vacates by squeezing; Toss | Our early-down Wide-to-Duo check; Counter away from Harlan |
| Ends who squeeze and look for the guard | The boot's free edge | Naked (no guard to see); boot only after chases | The chase count from the booth |
| Corners who replace fast on cracks | The crack toss's edge | Crack Go; quick game to the condensed receiver | "Z Crack Go" and the condensed dig |
| Rotation toward motion | The jet sweep | Wide or boot away from the rotation | Jet fake, Wide away |
| Spill everything to the sideline | The bang and bounce | Bend (the cutback) and the backside boot | Rollins chases; boot behind him |
Two things in that table deserve emphasis. First, the answers are mostly runs. When defenses took away outside zone's reach, the tree didn't throw more. It ran differently: duo, counter, toss, and gap schemes appeared more often in offenses that had once been nearly pure zone, as most film analysts describe it. Second, every answer is conditional. You don't install "the answer to tite." You install a check: when you see 4i–0–4i, this is what you run. That's the same logic as our early-down check from Wide to Duo against a bear front, which you met in Chapter 10.
🛡️ The defense's view: Wade Harmon, our head coach, was a defensive coordinator for a long time before he became a head coach, and when I showed him the tite clip in the staff room he laughed. "That's not a new front," he said. "That's an old front with two safeties behind it." His point was that the fronts weren't new; the combination was. A defense used to have to choose between a heavy front with one high safety (good against the run, vulnerable to the boot and the shot) and a light front with two high safeties (good against the shot, soft against the run). The modern answer was to try to have both, by asking five linemen to do what six or seven used to. "So find out which of the five is tired," Wade said. "And run at him in the fourth quarter."
📋 Try it — Make the call: Hypothetical: next season, a division opponent that has watched our film all spring. Second quarter, Outlaws lead 7–3. First-and-10 at our 34. You're in Twelve, under center. On the drive's first two plays, the defense has shown two high safeties at 12 yards and a tite front (4i–0–4i) with both ends squeezing; your Wide Right went for 1 and Wide Left for 2, with the Mike scraping over the top unblocked both times. Their backside end squeezed and looked inside on both, and never chased. Teo's booth note: "Both 4i's slanting inside at the snap." Choose your call and defend it in three sentences: what the front is giving you, which defender is the problem, and what your call does about him.
Worked answer
A strong answer: "Twelve, Under Ace Right, Duo" (or Counter, away from Harlan). The front is giving us double teams: a 4i who slants inside is a man our guard and tackle can double straight back, and a nose head-up on the center is a man the center and a guard can double, while the linebackers are left for the tight ends and the back's read. The problem defender is the Mike who has scraped free twice, because Wide's lateral combos never got anyone to him; duo's vertical doubles get a blocker to him from the inside out, and its downhill track takes away the scrape-over-the-top angle. We stop asking for a reach the front won't give.
Not the boot. The backside end has squeezed and looked inside twice; he hasn't chased once. By our chase count, the boot is a rollout into a waiting end. If you want a pass here, the honest one is a play-action off the duo look, not the boot.
Also defensible: Toss Crack, if the force player is a safety coming from 12 yards, because the toss gets outside the squeezing front before the safety arrives. Weaker: another Wide. Two snaps of evidence is enough to stop asking for the same reach.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why does a tite front hurt outside zone more than it hurts duo?
Answer
Outside zone needs lateral reach blocks and combos that free a climber. A 4i is already inside the tackle, so the tackle can't get outside him, and a 0 nose takes two blockers, so nobody climbs to the Mike. Duo is a vertical double-team run: it wants defenders in front of the guards and tackles to drive straight back and reads the linebackers. The tite front's alignment hands duo the doubles it wants.
29.10 What Austin Adopts, Adapts, and Rejects
The Tuesday before our Week 12 game against St. Louis, a little after midnight, Teo Arriaga asked me a question I'd been expecting since he joined the staff. Teo is our offensive quality control coach, 26 years old, and he sits in the coaches' booth on game days. He'd been watching the Stallions' defense all night, and for context he'd pulled up a few clips of their offense too. St. Louis's offense, with Tyler Haugen at quarterback, runs wide zone and the boot as purely as anyone in our division; our defense sees it twice a year.
Teo: Can I ask a dumb one?
Lyle: Those are my favorite kind.
Teo: You came from a wide-zone staff. Gus is a zone guy. Their offense is everything you talk about. Why aren't we them?
Gus: (not looking up from his cut-ups) Because we've got Darius.
Lyle: That's most of it. Think about what Darius does best. He punishes the blitz from the shotgun, he's a great RPO reader, he's a creative scrambler, and most of his scrambles go to his right. If I put him under center for two-thirds of our snaps and roll him out on half the passes, I'm using the most dangerous player in the building as a decoy.
Teo: But the boot works for us.
Lyle: The boot works because it's rare and it's earned. Marisol, how many boots did we have through ten games?
Marisol: About one a game. More against single-high teams. None against Sacramento.
Lyle: And that's right. The pure version would call it more. Our version calls it when the end has chased twice.
Wade: (from the doorway) And their defense practices against that boot every day in August. Their ends have seen more bootlegs than ours will throw all year. That's why the boot we called in Week 2, with no Wides in front of it, went nowhere. If you want one of those ends to chase on Sunday, you're going to have to pay for it first.
Teo: So what did you take?
Lyle: The idea. Everything we do from one picture has to start the same way. That's the part of that system that's true for every offense, including one built for Darius.
What that exchange reveals is the difference between borrowing a system and borrowing its reasons. Teo was asking why we didn't copy the purest version of an offense I admire. Gus answered with personnel, Wade with the defense's practice habits, and I answered with the principle. All three are the real answer. A system isn't good or bad in the abstract. It's good for a particular quarterback, against particular defenses, with a particular amount of practice time.
The borrow list
Here is Austin's list. It's the template for this chapter's Project Checkpoint.
| Idea from the system | Austin's verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Everything starts as the same run | Adopt | It's true for any offense; it's our "every featured run has a play-action from the same picture" non-negotiable |
| Outside zone as the base run | Adapt | Base in Twelve; a complement in Eleven; inside zone and duo carry our Eleven world |
| Under-center play-action and boots | Adapt | Under center from Twelve only; Eleven's play-action stays in the gun because its run does |
| Boot and Naked | Adopt, with a rule | Called on evidence: the chase count, two chases on the drive |
| Yankee and the deep crossers | Adopt for single-high weeks | A two-high defense has a safety for each deep route |
| Condensed formations | Adopt | But every condensed look must carry a run and a pass ("kill the zeros") |
| Motion on most snaps | Adapt | Motion has a job: information first, then eye candy; a motion that never tells us anything gets cut |
| The fullback as a weapon | Adapt | A package player for Twenty-one and short yardage, not a base player |
| Backside cut blocks | Reject | Rules have tightened at every level, and Gus teaches cutoff with the feet and hands |
| Running into eight-man boxes as an identity | Reject | Our rule since Week 2: "Seven or fewer, run it; eight, take the throw." We run Wide into eight only to buy the boot |
| The quarterback as a point guard on the move | Adapt | Vance gets the boot, but his best football is in the pocket and the gun; we keep Alert, Kill, and Check |
Notice what's on the reject side. Neither of those is a rejection of the system's ideas. They're rejections of specific practices that don't fit our rules or our evidence. That's the healthiest way to borrow: keep the reasons, adjust the tools.
💡 Coach's point: Before you copy an offense, finish this sentence for every piece of it: "They do this because ___." If you can't fill in the blank, you're copying a play. If you can, you're borrowing a reason, and reasons transfer to your players. Plays don't always.
🔄 Check your understanding: Austin "adopts" Yankee only for single-high weeks and "rejects" running into eight-man boxes as an identity. Why are those two decisions consistent with each other?
Answer
Both come from reading the defense's structure. Against an eight-man, single-high box, Austin doesn't want to grind runs into the extra defender; it wants to use that walked-down safety, and Yankee (and the boot) is exactly how you punish a safety committed to the run. Against two-high, there's no walked-down safety to punish, so Yankee loses its target and the run gets better. The run-versus-throw choice and the Yankee choice are the same decision seen from two sides.
29.11 The System at Every Level
🏫 Any level: This system was built in the NFL, and four things change it below that level.
The hashes. NFL hash marks sit 70 feet 9 inches from each sideline, close to the middle of the field. College hashes are 60 feet from each sideline, and high-school hashes are 53 feet 4 inches from each sideline under the national federation's rules. On a college or high-school hash, the boundary can be a fraction of the field's width. Outside zone into the boundary runs out of grass fast, and a boot into the boundary has almost no room for the flat. Most lower-level teams that run this system run Wide to the field (the wide side) and boot back toward the boundary only from the middle of the field, or use Naked into the boundary as a quick flat throw.
The quarterback. Under-center exchanges, the outside-zone mesh, the boot's footwork, and throwing on the move are all skills. Many high-school quarterbacks have spent their whole careers in the shotgun. You can run the whole family from the gun if your runs are gun runs; the picture is what matters, not the stance.
The rules. Low-block rules differ by code and change often, so teach backside cutoff with the feet and hands. On boots and play-action, the ineligible-downfield limit matters: the NFL allows an ineligible lineman no more than 1 yard beyond the line when a forward pass that crosses the line is thrown; NCAA rules have historically allowed up to 3 yards and the national high-school code 2 yards, and those numbers have been debated and changed. Check your current code.
The ends. This is the good news. Young defensive ends chase. A high-school backside end who has seen three outside-zone runs is very likely to chase the fourth, and the boot can be the best pass in a high-school playbook. The chase count is the easiest booth job in football; a student manager can do it. Case Study 2 follows a high-school staff that learned all four of these lessons in one season.
Spaced Review
Answer each before you open it.
🔄 Check your understanding (Chapter 12): The threshold concept of the option chapter was "you can block a defender with a decision." Where does that idea show up in this chapter's boot family?
Answer
Naked. On Naked, the backside end is left unblocked on purpose, and the quarterback "blocks" him with a decision: if the end chased the fake, the quarterback is outside him; if he stayed home, the quarterback throws the flat now or throws it away. The end is a read, not a blocking assignment, exactly like the read defender on zone read. The chase count is how you decide, before the snap, whether that read is likely to go your way.
🔄 Check your understanding (Chapter 7): Before the snap, the defense shows one deep safety in the middle and a strong safety walked down to eight yards. Is the middle of the field open or closed, and which two plays from this chapter is that structure built to lose to?
Answer
Closed (MOFC): one deep safety. That's the structure the boot and Yankee punish. The walked-down strong safety fills on the run fake, so the boot crosser and Yankee's deep over run into the space he left; Yankee's post and over then put the lone middle safety in conflict. (Remember the shell isn't the coverage: a two-high look can rotate to MOFC at the snap, which is why we confirm with what the safety does on the runs.)
🔄 Check your understanding (Chapter 1 and the motion chapter): One of Austin's five non-negotiables is about motion. What is it, and how does it change the way Austin borrows this system's heavy motion?
Answer
"Motion has a job." The system uses motion on most snaps, sometimes simply to make the defense move. Austin adopts the motion but requires each one to do something specific: diagnose man or zone (who travels), make the defense rotate so the run or boot goes away from the rotation, change the strength, or threaten the jet sweep. A motion that never tells us anything, or never makes a defender move, gets cut.
Project Checkpoint: Wide Zone & Boot Family (the "Shanahan Borrow List")
Last chapter you built your Offensive Metrics Dashboard and your Fourth-Down / Two-Point Decision Chart: the numbers you'll use to judge your plays and your decisions. Now use that discipline on a whole system. This chapter's deliverable is two pages.
Page 1: Your Wide Zone & Boot Family. Start from one run picture: your outside-zone run (or, if you don't run outside zone, your best run). List five to seven plays that start from exactly that picture. For each, fill in five columns:
- The call in your terminology.
- The lied-to defender (the man whose key the play exploits).
- What he must have done on the run to make the play right.
- The evidence rule (how many times, and who reports it).
- The coverage it's built for (single-high, two-high, man).
A filled-in row from Austin's page:
| Call | Lied-to defender | What he did on Wide | Evidence rule | Built for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Twelve, Under Ace Right, Wide PA Boot Left | Backside (left) end | Chased flat down the line | Two chases on the drive, counted by the booth | Single-high best; efficient vs. two-high |
Add one line under the table: your boot rule, in one sentence, for when you call Boot and when you call Naked.
Page 2: Your Shanahan Borrow List. Three columns: Adopt / Adapt / Reject. Put at least eight ideas from this chapter in the columns (outside zone as the base, under center, boots, Yankee, condensed splits, motion, the fullback, the move tight end, catch-and-run design, backside cut blocks). For each, write one sentence that begins "Because…" and names your quarterback, your line, your practice time, or your opponents' defenses.
At your level:
- High school: three plays from one picture is plenty (Wide, Boot, and one play-action pass). Write your hash rule (which way Wide goes from each hash) and assign the chase count to a specific person in the press box.
- College: five plays from the picture, including one condensed-formation version and one motion version. Note your code's ineligible-downfield limit and how it affects your boot crossers.
- Pro: the full seven, with a separate column for which of the season's opponents each play is built for, and a tite-front check (what you run when the front takes the reach away).
- Film-room: pick one NFL team that runs this system. Chart ten of its outside-zone-picture snaps and fill in the family table from what you see, including the lied-to defender for each.
Next chapter you'll make the same kind of list for a very different family tree: the Air Raid, its quick game, its practice methods, and its tempo. Your Spread Quick-Game & Tempo Borrow List will sit next to this one, and the two together are most of what modern offense borrowed from the last thirty years.
Chapter Summary
The system in one sentence: an offense in which the base run, outside zone, is copied exactly by its play-action passes, boots, and tags, so that every defender's key says "run" for the first second.
| Piece | What it does | The defender it lies to | When to call it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wide (outside zone) | Moves the whole defense sideways; makes the deposits | — | Seven or fewer in the box; or to buy the next call |
| Wide PA, Y Dig | Dig behind the flowing second level | Mike, alley safety | After the second level steps up twice |
| Boot / Naked | Three-level flood away from the run | Backside end | After two chases; Naked only when he's proven it |
| Yankee | Post and deep over, max protection | Single deep safety | Single-high, walked-down safety, a cheap down |
| Condensed (Nasty) + crack | Crack angles; two-way go; alignment that doesn't tell | Force safety, then the replacing corner | When the force player is a safety; Crack Go after the corner replaces |
| Jet / Orbit | Defense moves before the snap | Linebackers and the rotating safety | When the defense rotates to motion, go away from it |
| Fullback slice flat | A blocker who becomes the first read | Backside end and the flat defender | Twenty-one boots after slice blocks |
Decision framework (the call tree in prose): Count the box and read the shell. Single-high with a walked-down safety: run Wide to make the safety fill, then boot or Yankee behind him. Two-high and a light box: run Wide and be patient; boot for the flat and crosser, not the shot. A tite or bear front: stop asking for the reach and check to duo, counter, or toss. Before any boot: ask the booth for the chase count. Before any crack go: ask whether the corner has replaced. Before any motion: say what it's for.
Borrowing rule: keep the reasons, adjust the tools. Every piece of a famous system gets an Adopt, an Adapt, or a Reject, and a "because" that names your players.
What's Next
The Shanahan tree grew from the pro game outward. The next family grew the other way: from small college programs that couldn't recruit linemen, into the NFL by way of quarterbacks who had thrown thousands of quick passes before they were drafted. Chapter 30 takes apart the Air Raid, its quick game and practice methods, and shows how much of Austin's Eleven-personnel side came from it.