Every July, on the first night of training camp, I tape over the receivers.
In This Chapter
- The Hook: Painter's Tape
- 15.1 What a Route Concept Is
- 15.2 Horizontal Stretch: Not Enough Defenders Across the Field
- 15.3 Vertical Stretch: High and Low on One Man
- 15.4 The Triangle: Hi-Lo and Horizontal at the Same Time
- 15.5 Overload, Flood, Isolation, and Traffic
- 15.6 Reading a Defender: Progressions, Keys, and Where the Eyes Go
- 15.7 Timing: The Drop Matches the Break
- 15.8 Landmarks, Spacing, Names, and Families
- 15.9 When Concepts Fail: The Mistakes, and the Defense's Fix
- Spaced Review
- Project Checkpoint: Concept Framework
- Chapter Summary
- What's Next
Chapter 15 — Route Concepts: How Combinations of Routes Attack Coverage Structure
The Hook: Painter's Tape
Every July, on the first night of training camp, I tape over the receivers.
Not on the field. On the screen. The quarterback room in our building has a projector and a pull-down screen, and before the quarterbacks come in I freeze one clip, walk up to the screen with a roll of blue painter's tape, and put a strip over every eligible receiver on the offense. Five strips. The linemen stay visible, the quarterback stays visible, and all eleven defenders stay visible. Then I sit down next to the coffee and wait.
This past July the first man in was our undrafted rookie quarterback, Owen Strand, number 9, who had a big arm, a good college career, and the posture of a man who'd been told the NFL was going to be hard and had decided not to believe it. Teo Arriaga came in behind him with his laptop, because Teo was in his second season with us and had sat through this same drill the summer before. Rome Pettaway, our quarterbacks coach, stood in the back. Rome always stands for this one. He says he likes to watch faces.
"Third-and-five," I said. "Ball on the left hash, near midfield. Opponent tape — a Stallions game from last year, somebody else's offense. They're in Trips Right. Defense is in Cover 3. Tell me where the ball goes."
Owen leaned forward. "Where are the receivers?"
"Under the tape."
He laughed. Nobody else did. I clicked, and the clip played one second — snap, the quarterback's first two steps, the defenders moving — and froze.
"I can't see the routes, Coach."
"I didn't ask about the routes. I asked where the ball goes."
He tried. He guessed the outside, because the trips side had three strips of tape on it and "that's where they want to throw." He wasn't wrong that they wanted to throw there. He was wrong about everything after that.
Teo went next. A year ago he'd stared at that screen for a full minute and said, honestly, "I don't know." This year he pointed at the screen before I asked him. "The nickel ran to the flat. Whoever's inside of him is open." Then he hesitated. "But I don't know if somebody's inside of him."
"Fair," I said. "Darius?"
Darius Vance had come in late with a plate of food, which is a quarterback's privilege in July. He glanced at the frozen screen for maybe a second and a half. "Nickel widened. Mike carried the middle. There's a hole at six over the ball. If they're running stick, the stick's open."
Rome laughed in the back of the room. I peeled the tape off the third strip from the right, the innermost receiver in the trips. He was standing at six yards, turned around, facing the quarterback, in exactly the hole Darius had described. In the clip, the quarterback hit him for seven and a first down.
Owen stared at it. "So you knew where he'd be because you knew the play."
"No," Darius said, and he set down his plate. "I knew where he'd be open because I watched the guy who was supposed to cover him leave."
That's the chapter. It took me twenty years to say it as cleanly as he said it with his mouth full.
Three months later, in Week 6, against Sacramento, on a third-and-5 at the Sacramento 39 in the third quarter, Darius stood in the pocket with three receivers running a flood to one side. Before the snap the Sentinels showed us their two-high "Home" look. After the snap they checked to what Russ Kimbrough told me months later they call Lock, and their Mike linebacker, Marcus Bell, turned his shoulders to the middle of the field, toward the dig he was expecting. Darius never looked at Brooks Harlan, who was running to the flat. He looked at Bell. When Bell turned, the ball went to the flat, and Harlan caught it, cut back underneath the pursuit, and gained 11 to the Sacramento 28. If you had put tape over Harlan, Darius would have thrown it to the same spot.
🏃 Fast Track: If you already coach, skim 15.1–15.2 (definitions, horizontal stretch) and the landmark table in 15.8. Slow down in 15.4 (the triangle), 15.6 (reading a defender: pre-snap vs. post-snap, half-field vs. full-field), and 15.7 (timing) — those are where good concepts die in practice.
🔬 Deep Dive: Every concept in this chapter is catalogued, with its read against each coverage, in Appendix C. The coverages themselves — their rules, tells, and weak spots — live in Appendix E. The core three concepts get full treatment next chapter in Chapter 16.
📺 Film Watcher: On Sunday, pick one third down and watch the quarterback's helmet instead of the ball. Note which way it points in the first second. Then rewind and find the defender who was standing in that direction. Nine times out of ten, the throw went to wherever that defender didn't.
15.1 What a Route Concept Is
A route is one receiver's path: a stem, a break, a depth, a landmark. You learned the Outlaws' route tree in Chapter 6 — evens break in, odds break out; 0 is the 6-yard hitch, 2 is the slant, 4 is the curl, 6 is the dig at 12, 7 is the corner, 8 is the post, 9 is the go.
A route concept is two or more routes run together on purpose, so that the routes' combined spacing creates a problem for the coverage. That's the whole definition, and every word matters. "On purpose" means the routes aren't five unrelated decisions; they were chosen as a set. "Spacing" means the routes are placed in specific relationships to each other — one in front of another, one outside another, one under another. And "a problem for the coverage" means the concept is aimed at a rule the defense must follow.
Walt Dupree, my first NFL boss, used to say: "Every play is a question. Know what you're asking." A route concept is a question asked of one defender. "You're the flat defender. There's a man in front of you and a man behind you. Which one do you want?" The defender has to answer. He answers with his feet. And the quarterback reads the answer.
Why coverage can be attacked at all
A pass defense is a set of rules. In zone coverage, each defender is given an area — the deep third, the curl-to-flat, the hook — and rules for how to play the receivers who enter it. In man coverage, each defender is given a receiver and must go where he goes. Most modern coverages blend the two: they are zones that turn into man once routes declare themselves, which coaches call pattern-match or match coverage. Russ Kimbrough's Quarters is a match coverage; the safety's rule is written in terms of what our #2 receiver does.
Every rule has the same weakness. It tells the defender what to do before he knows what you're doing. The offense knows where the ball is going; the defense doesn't. That's the one structural advantage you get, and a route concept is how you cash it in the passing game.
There are only so many ways to make a rule fail:
| Principle | The defender's problem | Example concepts |
|---|---|---|
| Horizontal stretch | Two receivers on the same level, spaced wider than one defender can cover | Curl-flat, stick, spacing |
| Vertical stretch (hi-lo) | Two receivers in one defender's area, one in front of him and one behind | Smash on a Cover 2 corner, drive on a hook defender |
| Triangle | Three receivers: a hi-lo and a horizontal stretch on the same defender or pair | Snag |
| Overload | More receivers than defenders in an area | Trips concepts vs. a two-man side |
| Flood | Three receivers at three depths to one side | Flood, sail |
| Isolation | One receiver alone against one defender, with space | Backside fade, back-shoulder, the "breaker" |
| Rub / traffic | Crossing paths that make a man defender fight through bodies | Mesh, shallow, bunch releases |
The first five attack zones. The last two mostly attack man. Most good concepts carry both, which is how a single call survives a disguised coverage.
🚪 Threshold concept: The quarterback reads a defender, not a receiver. A concept stresses one defender; the throw goes wherever that defender isn't.
Before this clicks, the passing game looks like this: the quarterback drops back, looks for the receiver who is open, and throws it to him. Receivers "get open." A good quarterback has good "vision." When a throw is intercepted, he "didn't see the guy." The concept is a list of receivers in order of preference, and the quarterback checks them one at a time.
After it clicks, you see that a receiver is never open by himself. He is open because a defender made a choice. The concept was built so that one defender — the key defender, sometimes called the conflict defender — must choose between two routes, and so the quarterback's eyes go to that defender, not to the routes. He knows where the routes will be; he drilled them all week. What he doesn't know is which way the key will jump. So he watches the key, and throws opposite. When it works, the ball is out before the receiver looks open on television, because the quarterback saw the defender commit, not the receiver separate.
The difference is not cosmetic. A quarterback reading receivers is always late — he waits for separation, which happens after the defender commits. A quarterback reading the defender is early — he throws on the commitment itself. Early is completions. Late is sacks and interceptions.
This is why the painter's tape works. Owen couldn't do it because he thought the question was "where are my guys?" Darius could do it because the question was "where did their guy go?"
🔄 Check your understanding: In your own words, why is a quarterback who reads the key defender earlier than one who waits for a receiver to come open?
Answer
Separation is a result of the defender's decision. The defender commits first — he widens, sinks, squats, or turns — and only then does the receiver he left come open. A quarterback who watches the defender can throw at the moment of the commitment; one who watches the receiver must wait for the separation that follows. That gap is a fraction of a second, but against a pass rush and closing defenders it is the difference between a completion and a breakup or a sack.
The taped screen, drawn
Here is the frame from the July drill, in the notation this book uses. Offense at the bottom moving up,
defense at the top. I've drawn the taped receivers as [#] and left out the four defensive linemen, who
were rushing.
THE TAPED SCREEN (Trips Right vs. Cover 3, ~1 second after the snap)
F
^
C | C
^ ^
| |
$ W M *---->
^ ^ ^
[ ? ]
O O O O O
[#] Q R [#] [#] [#]
📊 Diagram (described): The offense has one taped receiver on the left and three taped receivers to the right in a trips formation, with the quarterback in the gun and the back beside him. The defense is playing Cover 3: both corners and the free safety are backpedaling into three deep zones. Underneath, the strong safety on the left, the Will, and the Mike are dropping straight back, and the nickel on the right is running hard toward the sideline. A question mark sits in the empty space at about six yards, just inside where the nickel started — the hole he left.
TAPE OFF (the same frame: Stick from Trips Right)
F
C Z C
^ ^ ^
| | |
$ W M *----> |
Y< H------> |
| | |
| | |
O O O O O | | |
X Q R Y H Z
:..............^ ball to Y at 6
📊 Diagram (described): With the tape removed, the three trips receivers are visible. The outside receiver, Z, runs a go straight up the field and takes the right corner deep. The middle receiver, H, runs to the flat, and the nickel widens with him. The inside receiver, Y, runs six yards up the field and turns around to face the quarterback — the stick route — in the space the nickel left, with the Mike too far inside to reach him. The ball goes to Y.
The receiver in the hole was a tight end. It could have been anybody. What made him open was the nickel.
15.2 Horizontal Stretch: Not Enough Defenders Across the Field
Start with arithmetic, because coverage can't escape it.
The field is 53⅓ yards wide. In a four-man rush with three deep defenders — Cover 3 — the defense has four underneath defenders to cover that entire width at the short and intermediate levels. Even if you give each one a perfect spot, that's more than 13 yards of field per man. A defender standing still can close maybe 3 or 4 yards in either direction in the time it takes a quick throw to arrive. Do the subtraction and you find seams between every pair of underneath defenders.
A horizontal stretch puts two receivers at roughly the same depth, spaced far enough apart that one underneath defender can't cover both. The defender must pick. If he takes the outside man, the inside man is open; if he takes the inside man, the outside man is open. The quarterback's job is to watch which one he picks.
The oldest and cleanest horizontal stretch in football is curl-flat: the #1 receiver runs a curl (the 4 in our tree — push to 12, settle back to 10 or 11 facing the quarterback), and the #2 receiver runs to the flat at 2 to 3 yards. Many systems trace their passing game back to this one pairing; the West Coast offense that Bill Walsh developed was built on short, timed horizontal stretches like it.
Week 2 at St. Louis. Our fictional Outlaws trailed the Stallions 7–0 early in the second quarter, 2nd-and-7 at our own 33. Frank Ostrowski's Stallions are a single-high team — Cover 3 and Cover 1 with a safety walked down into the box. We were in "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Curl-Flat," which by our default put the concept on the two-receiver side away from Harlan: Devonte Sutton (X) on the curl, Mekhi Powers (H) to the flat.
PRE-SNAP (Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, Curl-Flat left, vs. Cover 3)
F
C C
$
* W M
E T T E
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap the Outlaws have two receivers on each side: Sutton (X) and Powers (H) on the left, Harlan (Y) attached to the right tackle and Gaines (Z) wide right. The Stallions show one deep safety in the middle of the field, corners off, the strong safety walked down toward Harlan's side, a nickel over Powers, and two linebackers. One safety deep means the middle of the field is closed — a Cover 3 or Cover 1 family.
At the snap the left corner bailed to his deep third — that confirmed zone. That left two defenders who mattered on our left: the nickel, who in Cover 3 owns the curl-to-flat area, and the Will, who owns the hook. The nickel was our key. He had a man in his curl window and a man in his flat, and he could only play one of them.
POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3 (the nickel widens: throw the curl)
C [DEEP 1/3]
^
|
| X> curl: push to 12, settle at 10-11
| | W
| | ^ [HOOK]
| | <-----* nickel widens with the flat
| |
| <-|-------H flat at 2-3
| | |
X H O O O O O
Q ball: Q to X on the settle
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap the left corner backpedals into the deep outside third. Sutton pushes up the field to about twelve yards, then settles back to ten or eleven, facing the quarterback. Powers releases flat toward the sideline at two to three yards. The nickel, who had to choose between them, widens with Powers toward the flat. The Will drops straight back into the hook but stays inside. The window between the Will and the bailing corner is where Sutton sits, and that's where the ball goes.
The nickel widened. Darius threw the curl on the settle, Sutton caught it at the 42 and fell forward to the 44, +11, first down. The nickel did nothing wrong. His flat was threatened, and in Cover 3 the flat is his. He just couldn't be in two places, and Darius was watching to see which place he chose.
The same concept against Cover 2
Here's the part that separates a concept from a play. If you run curl-flat against a two-high Cover 2 — two deep safeties splitting the field in halves, five underneath — the key defender changes jerseys but not jobs. In Cover 2 the corner is the flat defender. He squats at 5 or 6 yards, reroutes the #1 receiver, and sits in the flat. The curl window is now between that squatting corner and the outside hook defender, with the half safety above both.
POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2 (the corner squats in the flat: curl in the hole)
F [DEEP 1/2] $
^ ^
| |
X> curl settles at 10-11 [HOLE]
| W
| ^ [HOOK]
|
C<-|---- corner sits in the flat at 5
|
<-------------H flat at 2-3
| |
X H O O O O O
Q read the corner; throw opposite
📊 Diagram (described): Against Cover 2, the left corner jams Sutton and then stays shallow, sliding toward the flat as Powers releases there. The left-half safety retreats into his deep half. The Will drops into the hook. Sutton's curl settles at ten to eleven yards in the hole between the squatting corner, the Will, and the safety above. The key defender is now the corner: if he squats, the curl is open; if he sinks under the curl, Powers is open in the flat.
Same routes, same footwork, same throw. Different man to watch. That's why Outlaws concepts are taught with the defender's role in the read — "the flat defender" — not a position. In Cover 3 that was a nickel; in Cover 2 it's a corner; in some fire zones it's a defensive end who dropped. The quarterback has to identify who holds the role before the snap and confirm it after.
💡 Coach's point: The read is written in roles, not positions. "Read the flat defender" survives a coverage change. "Read the nickel" doesn't.
Spacing rules
A horizontal stretch only works if the receivers are actually stretched. Our rule, and a common one at every level, is that receivers on the same level should be at least five yards apart, and ideally more. Closer than that and one defender can stand between them and play both, which is called splitting the difference — the defender sits in the middle and breaks on whichever ball is thrown.
⚠️ Common mistake: the curl that drifts. In a padded practice before Week 4, Sutton caught a curl that had drifted to eight yards outside the numbers while Powers's flat had flattened early, and the two ended up four yards apart. The scout-team nickel — doing exactly what we'd asked, playing Cover 3 rules — stood between them and broke on the ball. Interception, returned for six in a practice period that was supposed to be about timing. The fix wasn't a new play; it was a landmark. Sutton's curl now settles no wider than the top of the numbers, and Powers's flat aims at the bottom of the numbers with a depth of two to three, so the two can never collapse inside five yards of each other.
🔄 Check your understanding: Against Cover 3 you call curl-flat to the left. Who is your key defender, and what does each of his two choices tell you to do? Now suppose the defense rotates to Cover 2 at the snap. Who is the key now?
Answer
Against Cover 3 the key is the curl/flat defender on that side — often a nickel or a strong safety. If he widens with the flat route, throw the curl; if he sinks under the curl, throw the flat. Against Cover 2 the corner becomes the flat defender, so he is the key: if he squats in the flat, throw the curl (in the hole before the safety arrives); if he sinks under the curl, throw the flat. The routes don't change; the defender wearing the role does.
15.3 Vertical Stretch: High and Low on One Man
A vertical stretch, or hi-lo, puts two receivers in the same defender's area at two depths — one in front of him and one behind him. The defender's rule tells him to take something, and whatever he takes, the other route is open. If he comes up, the ball goes behind him. If he stays back, the ball goes in front.
You'll meet the most famous hi-lo in football properly in Chapter 16: smash against Cover 2. A quick preview, because it's the cleanest example there is. In Week 10 at Portland, tied 7–7 in the second quarter on 2nd-and-6 at the Portland 31, we called "Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Smash." Sutton ran a 6-yard hitch; Powers, inside him, ran a corner route to the pylon. The Pioneers' corner, Josh Kiel, number 23, had the flat in their Cover 2 — so the hitch was in front of him and the corner route was behind him. He squatted on the hitch, Darius threw the corner over him and under the half-field safety, Darnell Price, and Powers scored from 31 yards. The next time we called it, in the third quarter, Kiel sank under the corner route, and Sutton caught the hitch for 8. The corner must choose; both choices lose. I'll leave the rest — five formations' worth — to the next chapter.
Hi-lo isn't only for corners. You can hi-lo any underneath defender who has depth to protect. The inside version is aimed at a hook defender — a linebacker dropping into the middle — with one route underneath him (a drag or shallow at 2 to 3 yards) and one over him (a dig at 12). Many systems call this drive.
Week 10 at Portland again, third quarter, Outlaws ahead 17–10, 2nd-and-8 at the Portland 42. Leon Marchetti's Pioneers play Tampa 2: two deep safeties in halves, and the Mike, Owen Talbert (#52), runs from his linebacker spot to the deep middle at the snap, so the seam between the safeties is guarded. That leaves four defenders underneath. The man we wanted to stress was the Pioneers' Will linebacker, number 55, Nate Odegaard, who dropped to the weak hook on every pass we'd shown them.
PRE-SNAP (Eleven, Gun Doubles Right, 60 Left, Drive, vs. Tampa 2)
F (Price #30) $
C (Kiel #23) C
* W (55) M (52) S
E T T E
X H O O O O O Y Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap the Outlaws are in two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right. Portland shows two deep safeties — Price on the left, the other safety on the right — corners pressed up near the line, a nickel over Powers, the Will (Odegaard, 55) and the Mike (Talbert, 52) in the box, and a Sam on Harlan's side. Two high safeties mean the middle of the field is open before the snap.
Drive, as we run it from this look: Gaines (Z) runs the dig at 12 from the right, breaking left. Harlan (Y) releases into a drag at 2 to 3 yards under him, also breaking left. Powers runs a seam up the left hash to hold Talbert in the middle. Sutton runs a go to clear Kiel. Ruffin checks his protection and releases late.
POST-SNAP (the Will jumps the drag: throw the dig behind him)
F M $
^ ^ (runs the middle) ^
C | H | |
^ ^
| | Z <-------------------- Z dig at 12
| | ^ ball
X | : W
| : v
* | : Y <------------ Y drag at 2-3
O O : O O O
Q
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap both safeties retreat to their halves, and the Mike runs to the deep middle carrying Powers's seam. Sutton's go pushes the left corner deep. Gaines breaks in at twelve yards, running from right to left across the field. Harlan releases underneath at two to three yards on the same track. The Will, who had been dropping into the hook, sees Harlan crossing in front of him and comes downhill to take him. The space he vacated, at about twelve yards between the Mike and the left safety, is where Gaines arrives, and the ball goes there.
Odegaard came down on Harlan's drag. He'd been told all week, I'd guess, that our tight end catches the ball underneath and turns it up, and he had seen us do it twice in the first half. He was right about Harlan. That's what made him wrong about Gaines, who caught the dig behind him for 15 and a first down at the Portland 27. If Odegaard had sunk to the dig instead, Harlan would have caught the drag with nobody in front of him for the first eight yards — not a big play, but a completion on schedule.
🔍 Why this works: A hook defender's rule is to "wall" or "match" anything crossing his face and to protect a depth — in Tampa 2, typically eight to twelve yards. A drag under him and a dig over him present two crossers at once, one in front and one behind. His eyes are on the quarterback; he feels the crossers more than he sees them. Whatever he reacts to first, the other route is in the space he just left. The geometry, not the receivers' speed, does the work — which is why a hi-lo still works against a better athlete.
Hi-lo against man coverage
Against man coverage, a hi-lo isn't really a hi-lo — there's no defender sitting in an area to be stretched. Each receiver has a man on him. But the routes still do something useful: the crossing paths create traffic. A drag and a dig crossing the same zone of the field force two man defenders to work through each other. This is where a hi-lo concept starts to overlap with the man-beaters of Chapter 17. The legal rule is the one you must teach your receivers: the routes are spacing that defenders have to work around, never blocks. An eligible receiver who deliberately blocks a defender more than a yard beyond the line before the pass is thrown is committing offensive pass interference. Officiating emphasis on "rubs" varies year to year, so teach the route depth and the landmark, never "hit the guy."
🔄 Check your understanding: In a Tampa 2, why is the Will, rather than the Mike, the right key for a drive concept?
Answer
In Tampa 2 the Mike runs to the deep middle at the snap, so he isn't in the intermediate zone where the drag and dig cross. The Will is the defender who drops to the hook at eight to twelve yards, exactly between the drag (two to three) and the dig (twelve). He is the man who must choose. Find the defender who actually lives between your two depths — that's your key.
🧩 Productive struggle: Before you read on, try this. Against Cover 3 you have four underneath defenders and three deep. You get three receivers on one side of the field. You want a concept where at least one of the three is open whether the curl/flat defender widens, sinks, or sits — and, ideally, one that still has an answer if the coverage turns out to be Cover 2 instead. Where would you put the three routes? Sketch it. The next section gives the classic answer, but try it on a napkin first.
15.4 The Triangle: Hi-Lo and Horizontal at the Same Time
If you sketched three receivers on a napkin a minute ago, there's a good chance you drew a triangle: one route deep-outside, one shallow-outside, one shallow-inside. That's the classic answer, and coaches call it a triangle read or a triangle stretch. It combines a vertical stretch (one route over another) with a horizontal stretch (two routes side by side at the same level), so that the defenders near the triangle face two different problems at once.
The cleanest version in our book is Snag. From Gun Trey Right — three receivers to the right with the attached tight end as #3:
- #1 (Gaines, Z) — the snag route: release vertically, break inside at about 5 yards, and settle at 5 to 6 in the first open window, facing the quarterback.
- #2 (Powers, H) — the corner: stem to 12 and break to the pylon at about 18 (the 7 in our tree; the slot's corner stays at 12).
- #3 (Harlan, Y) — the flat: release and run to the flat at 2 to 3 yards, aiming at the bottom of the numbers.
- Backside (Sutton, X): a go, the isolation "breaker."
- Ruffin: protects in 60 Left on the man side (right) and checks out late.
Look at the shape. The corner route and the flat route are a hi-lo on whoever plays the outside. The snag and the flat are a horizontal stretch on whoever plays the curl-to-flat. One call puts both stresses on the field.
Week 12 at home against St. Louis, fourth quarter, a little under eight minutes left, Outlaws ahead 23–16, 3rd-and-5 at the Stallions' 45. I wanted the ball out quickly against a defense that loved Cover 3 and loved to rally to the flat.
PRE-SNAP (Eleven, Gun Trey Right, 60 Left, Snag, vs. Cover 3)
F
C C
$ *
W M
E T T E
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap the Outlaws have three receivers to the right — Harlan attached to the right tackle as #3, Powers in the slot as #2, Gaines wide as #1 — and Sutton alone on the left. Ruffin is in the gun beside Vance on the right. The Stallions show one deep safety in the middle, corners off, a nickel over Powers, the strong safety down near Harlan, and two linebackers to the left of the ball.
POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3 (corner bails, nickel widens: ball to the snag)
F H corner, to ~18
^ / C
/ ^ [DEEP 1/3]
H |
|
$ Z <----|------ Z snag, sits at 6
^ [HOOK] | |
| | * ----->
| | Y -------> flat
O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap the right corner bails into his deep third and takes Powers's corner route as it climbs toward the pylon. The nickel, who owns the curl-to-flat area, widens with Harlan's flat route. The strong safety drops into the hook to the inside. Gaines releases up the field and breaks inside at about five yards, settling at six in the window between the widening nickel and the hook defender. With the corner deep and the nickel outside, the snag is open, and the ball goes there.
The nickel widened, Darius hit Gaines at six, and Gaines turned upfield for 7 and a first down at the Stallions' 38. We didn't score on the drive. We didn't need to; the first down kept the clock moving for another two and a half minutes. The play was built for exactly what happened: against Cover 3 the corner route is never the throw — the corner bails and takes it away — so the corner route's real job is to clear him out and to keep the curl/flat defender from sinking. That leaves him one decision: snag or flat.
But the triangle's value is that it doesn't need to know it's Cover 3. Suppose the shell had been two high and the coverage had been Cover 2:
POST-SNAP vs. COVER 2 (corner squats in the flat: ball to the corner)
$ [DEEP 1/2]
^
H <- corner, ~16
/
H
|
M Z <---------|-- Z snag at 6
^ [HOOK] | |
| | C ------> (squats)
| | Y -------> flat
O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Against Cover 2 the right corner doesn't bail. He sits shallow and slides toward the flat as Harlan releases there. The right-half safety retreats toward his deep half, staying inside on the hash. Powers's corner route climbs toward the sideline between the squatting corner and the safety. The corner has a hi-lo — the flat in front of him, the corner route behind him — and by squatting he has chosen the flat, so the ball goes to Powers on the corner route.
The routes are the same. The key changed. Against Cover 3 the corner removes himself from the read by bailing, so the key becomes the curl/flat defender. Against Cover 2 the corner is the flat defender, and he becomes the key for the hi-lo. That's why we teach Snag as a two-question read:
| Coverage (post-snap) | First key | If the key… | Throw | If the key… | Throw |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cover 2 (corner squats) | Corner | squats in the flat | Corner route | sinks under the corner route | Flat |
| Cover 3 (corner bails) | Curl/flat defender | widens with the flat | Snag | sits inside on the snag | Flat |
| Quarters (safety reads #2) | Apex/nickel | widens | Snag | sits | Flat (often the first-read throw — Quarters struggles to cover the flat quickly) |
| Cover 1 / man | Best matchup, picked pre-snap | — | Snag vs. outside leverage, flat for a TE vs. a linebacker, corner vs. a safety in trail | — | — |
That last row matters. Against man coverage there's no zone defender to read — every receiver has a man on him — so the triangle stops being a read and becomes a matchup choice made before the snap. Our rule, the one Rome teaches: "If it's man, pick a guy before the snap and win with him. If it's zone, pick a defender after the snap and throw away from him."
🔄 Check your understanding: Why is the corner route in Snag almost never the throw against Cover 3 — and why do you still run it?
Answer
In Cover 3 the corner's rule is to bail into the deep outside third, so he is sitting right on top of the corner route. You still run it because it does two jobs: it clears the corner out of the short area, and it threatens the outside so the curl/flat defender can't drift too deep. That reduces the read to one defender and two short throws. And if the coverage turns out to be Cover 2, the corner route becomes the best throw on the field.
📋 Try it — Find the conflict: The Ospreys line up against your Gun Trey Right with two safeties at twelve yards and corners at seven yards off. At the snap, the field safety sprints to the deep middle, the boundary safety drops straight back, the field corner bails, and the nickel over Powers runs straight back to about nine yards. You're running Snag. Name the coverage, the key defender, and the throw.
Answer
One safety rotating to the deep middle with the corner bailing is a rotation from a two-high shell to Cover 3 — the shell was not the coverage. The corner removes himself, so the key is the curl/flat defender, the nickel. He has run straight back (sinking toward the curl/corner area rather than widening), so he is neither on the snag's level nor in the flat. The flat to Harlan is the cleanest throw — the nickel can't come back down and out in time. If he had stopped at five and squatted inside, the flat would still be right; if he had widened, the snag. The two-high shell told you nothing about the throw; the nickel's feet told you everything.
🪞 Learning check-in: Stop and be honest with yourself for a minute. When you watched the last diagram, where did your eyes go first — to the receivers' arrows or to the defenders' arrows? Most people, even coaches, go to the receivers; that's where the ball ends up and that's what television trains us to watch. If you went to the receivers, try this: cover the bottom half of each diagram in this chapter with your hand and predict the throw from the defense alone. If you can do it for curl-flat and Snag but not yet for drive, that's normal — the hook defender's choice is subtler than a corner's. Note which concepts you can "read with tape on" and which you can't. That list is your study plan for the rest of Part III.
15.5 Overload, Flood, Isolation, and Traffic
The first three principles put one defender in conflict. The next four change the count, the depth, or the matchup.
Overload: more receivers than defenders
An overload puts more receivers into an area than the defense has defenders to cover it. It's arithmetic, not choice. Count the defenders who can reach the area in time, count your receivers in it, and if your number is bigger, somebody is uncovered before anybody makes a decision.
The classic place to find an overload is the outside third against Cover 3. In Cover 3 the defenders who can get to the outside third to one side are the corner (deep) and the curl/flat defender (short). That's two. If you send three receivers into that area at three different depths, the defense is a man short — and that's where the overload becomes a flood.
Flood: three levels
A flood puts three receivers into one side of the field at three depths: one deep (a go or a corner), one intermediate (an out or a sail at 12 to 18), and one short (a flat at 2 to 3). Our version, which Chapter 16 develops fully, is called Flood, and its intermediate route is our sail — a deep out breaking at about 15 to 18.
PRE-SNAP (Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Flood, vs. Cover 3)
F
C C
$ *
W M
E T T E
X O O O O O Y H Z
Q R
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap the Outlaws have three receivers to the right — Harlan detached just outside the right tackle as #3, Powers in the slot as #2, Gaines wide as #1 — and Sutton alone on the left. The defense shows one deep safety, corners off, a nickel over Powers, a strong safety down inside, and two linebackers. One high safety means Cover 3 or Cover 1.
POST-SNAP vs. COVER 3 (two defenders, three levels)
F Z go
^ ^ C
| ^ [DEEP 1/3]
H-----------> sail at 15-18
| |
$ | |
^ | *---> |
| Y-------> flat at 2-3
O O O O O Y | |
Q R H Z
📊 Diagram (described): After the snap Gaines runs a go and the right corner carries him deep into the outside third. Powers pushes up to fifteen and breaks out toward the sideline — the sail. Harlan runs to the flat. The nickel, the only other defender who can get to that side, has to choose between the sail above him and the flat in front of him. Two defenders, three receivers, three levels: if the nickel takes the flat, throw the sail; if he gains depth under the sail, throw the flat; if the corner sinks to the sail, the go is alone over the top.
Here is the read we teach, in roles:
| Defender's action | Throw |
|---|---|
| Corner carries the go deep, curl/flat defender widens to the flat | Sail (between them) |
| Corner carries the go, curl/flat defender gains depth under the sail | Flat |
| Corner jumps the sail early, no safety over the top | Go (only if the deep middle didn't rotate over — an "alert" throw) |
| Pressure from the flood side | Flat now — it's the hot |
In Game 1, in the third quarter, 2nd-and-7 at our 30, Darius used a hard count to get the Sentinels to show their hand and checked to a flood to the left. The Sentinels rotated from two high to single high at the snap — a coverage Russ later told me they call Spin 3 — and Tre Holloway, the rotating safety, flinched toward the flat. Harlan caught the sail behind him for 19. That's an overload working through a disguise: the shell said two-high, the rotation made it Cover 3, and a flood against Cover 3 still has three receivers against two defenders.
Isolation: one-on-one, with space
Isolation is the opposite of conflict. Instead of putting one defender between two receivers, you put one receiver against one defender with nobody else nearby — and you make sure there's nobody nearby by sending everyone else to the other side. Our isolation receiver is Devonte Sutton, our 6-foot-3 X, alone on the backside of a three-by-one formation, running a fade or a back-shoulder throw. We call him the breaker: the route that breaks the defense if it rolls coverage toward the trips.
Isolation lives on the pre-snap read. The quarterback asks one question: is there help over the top of the isolated receiver? If the backside safety is deep and outside, no. If he's in the middle of the field or cheating toward the trips, the backside is one-on-one. In Game 1, Sutton was targeted eight times; on the six when Cole Brennan had him alone, Sutton caught five for 86 yards. Over two seasons, Marisol's count had Sutton at 2 of 7 against Cover 2 or with a safety over the top. Same receiver, same routes. The difference was the defender who wasn't there.
Rub and traffic: the man-beaters
Against man coverage, there's no area to stretch; each defender is chasing a man. What beats man is separation through traffic — crossing routes, stacked releases, and bunch formations that make a defender work around his own teammates or around other receivers' paths. Mesh (two shallow crossers passing each other), the shallow cross, and bunch releases are the family. They get their own chapter, Chapter 17, so I'll only repeat the rule I gave you in 15.3: receivers run routes, never blocks. Teach the depth, the landmark, and the timing; let the defender run into the geometry.
🛡️ The defense's view: When I sat with Russ Kimbrough at the league meetings in the spring, he told me that his staff's working description of our passing game was that we put somebody in conflict on every snap. His answer, he said, was never to make the conflict defender smarter. It was to add a second man to the conflict or take the conflict defender out of it. A robber safety who drops down into the middle to sit on the dig adds a second man; now our hook defender doesn't have to choose, because somebody is already standing where his mistake would have been. A corner who bails instead of squatting takes himself out of the smash conflict. Russ's coverage menu — Quarters, Cover 6, the rotations — is, from his side of the ball, a set of ways to change which defender holds the conflict after the snap. "The coverage is a contract," I told him, "and I get to read the contract before I sign it." He laughed and said, "That's why we change it after you sign."
🔄 Check your understanding: Explain the difference between an overload and a conflict. Why does a flood beat Cover 3 even if every defender plays his rule perfectly?
Answer
A conflict puts one defender between two receivers so he must choose; an overload puts more receivers in an area than the defense has defenders. A flood against Cover 3 sends three receivers into the outside third, where only two defenders — the corner and the curl/flat defender — can reach. Even if both play their rules perfectly, three receivers at three depths can't all be covered by two men; one of them is open by arithmetic. The quarterback still reads the curl/flat defender to know which one.
15.6 Reading a Defender: Progressions, Keys, and Where the Eyes Go
There are two ways to teach a quarterback where to throw, and most offenses blend them.
A progression is an order of receivers: look at #1, then #2, then #3, then the checkdown. It's easy to teach and easy to grade ("he skipped his second read"). Its weakness is the one the painter's tape exposes: the quarterback is waiting for receivers to come open, and he has to move his eyes — and often his feet — from one receiver to the next.
A key read is an order of defenders: watch the flat defender; if he widens, throw the curl; if he sinks, throw the flat. The quarterback's eyes stay on one man, and the receivers come into his picture because they're running to spots he already knows. It's harder to teach — the quarterback must identify who holds the key role, and that changes with the coverage — but it's faster, and it's what this book's offense is built on. One of the Outlaws' five non-negotiables is literally "read defenders, not receivers."
In practice, our reads are a progression of keys: key 1 tells you whether the first throw is there; if it isn't, key 2 tells you the next one. The receivers are attached to the keys, not the other way around.
Teo pushed on this in October, after our first four games, and the conversation is worth repeating because you probably have the same question.
Teo: If Trey's our best receiver, why don't we just tell Darius to look at Trey first every time? Make him the first read and let the concept be the backup plan.
Lyle: Because the defense knows he's our best receiver too. Marisol, what's the number?
Marisol Vega: In our first four games, Gaines got 19 of our 41 third-down targets. Nobody else had more than seven. And every defense we play has that same tape.
Lyle: So if Gaines is always the first look, the defense doesn't have to read anything. They put a second man on him — a bracket, a robber — and they've covered our first read before the snap. Then Darius is late to everything else.
Rome Pettaway: And Darius stares at him. The safety reads Darius's eyes, and Darius's eyes are going to Trey. That's how you throw picks to a guy you should never throw picks to.
Teo: So the key read protects Trey.
Lyle: The key read uses Trey. If they bracket him, the key defender for the other side is now alone. If they don't, he's in a concept with everybody else and the read finds him when he's the right answer.
What that exchange shows is the systemic point: a progression built around one receiver gives the defense a one-step answer. A read built around defenders forces the defense to cover the concept, which takes more men. In Game 2 the Sentinels did exactly that to us on a third-and-9 at our 27: they bracketed Gaines with a corner under and a safety over, and Darius, reading the key on the other side, found Ruffin on the checkdown for 5. It wasn't enough for the first down. But it wasn't an interception into a bracket either.
Pre-snap and post-snap: two looks with one pair of eyes
Every read has two halves. The pre-snap read uses the picture the defense shows before the ball is snapped — the shell (one high safety or two, which you learned as MOFC and MOFO in Chapter 7), the corners' depth and leverage, the box count, any motion reaction — to decide which side to work and which defender is likely to hold the key role. The post-snap read confirms it, or changes it, in the first one or two steps of the drop. Rome's phrase for this is "two looks with one pair of eyes": the eyes go to the middle of the field on the first step, and by the third step the quarterback knows whether the picture held.
You know the cost of trusting only the first look. On the last real snap of our season, Game 3's 3rd-and-9 at our 38, the Sentinels showed two high at 13 yards, then rotated at the snap: the strong safety came down and Ike Royce spun to the middle. Darius threw the post into the pre-snap picture and Royce intercepted it. The concept wasn't the problem. The key — the deep middle — had changed jerseys after the snap, and the read hadn't been built to check it.
📈 By the numbers: Marisol's split of Darius's dropbacks from our first four games — the same four games Sacramento's staff charted on us before Week 6: when the defense rushed four and the shell held, he was 24 of 36 for 7.2 yards per attempt, 3 touchdowns, 1 interception. When it rushed four and rotated after the snap, he was 31 of 52 for 6.1 yards per attempt, 1 touchdown, 3 interceptions. Against five or more rushers: 28 of 36, 9.4, 4 touchdowns, 0 interceptions. Marisol's caveats, which she'd insist I print: these are small samples, a single bad game can swing them, and "rotation" was her charting call. What the split suggests is consistent with the film: Darius is deadly when the key defender's role is clear (blitz, held shell), and less sharp when the role moves after the snap. That's a reading problem, not an arm problem, and it's the reason my off-season project is a post-snap middle-read tag built into every third-and-long call.
Half-field and full-field reads
A half-field read decides before the snap which side of the field the quarterback will work, and reads only the keys on that side. A full-field read starts on one side and can travel across the field, key by key.
| Half-field read | Full-field read | |
|---|---|---|
| When the side is chosen | Before the snap (shell, leverage, motion, matchup) | After the snap, as keys declare |
| Time needed | Less — the ball can come out on rhythm at 1.1–2.6 s | More — often 2.6 s and up; protection must hold |
| QB demand | Lower; fewer defenders to identify | Higher; eyes and feet must reset across the field |
| Protection | Usually five or six blockers | Often six or seven; sometimes max |
| Typical concepts | Curl-flat, stick, snag, smash, flood, the "both" call | Mills, dagger, Y cross, drive with a backside dig |
| Weakness | A defense that rolls away from the chosen side after the snap | Sacks and late throws if the rush gets home |
Our signature half-field call is the "both" call — a concept with a zone-beater on one side and a man-beater on the other. Here's how I put it to Russ in the spring: "If nobody runs with the motion, I go to my 'both' call; if somebody runs, I go to my man-beater." Motion before the snap asks the defense a question. If a defender runs across the formation with the motion man, it's probably man coverage, and we can call a man-beater outright. If nobody runs, it's zone — or disguised man — and the "both" call lets the quarterback decide after the snap.
PRE-SNAP ("Both": Gun Doubles Right, Z Zip; zone side L, man side R)
F $
C C
* W M S
E T T E
X H O O O O O Y Z <~~~~ Z
Q R
[ZONE SIDE: curl-flat] [MAN SIDE: slant-flat]
📊 Diagram (described): Before the snap the Outlaws are in two-by-two with Harlan attached on the right. Gaines (Z) motions a few steps in toward the ball — the zip. On the left side, Sutton and Powers have curl-flat, the zone-beater. On the right side, Gaines and Harlan have slant-flat, the man-beater. The defense shows two high safeties, a nickel, two linebackers, and a Sam; the right corner does not follow Gaines's motion, so the quarterback suspects zone.
POST-SNAP (the corners turn and run: it's man, so the eyes go right)
F
^
C (turns, runs with X)
^ Z slant
| /
X / C (trails Z)
* (runs with H) $ / ^
< \ /
H Y---/--------------> flat
O O O O O Y Z
Q R eyes right: slant, then flat
📊 Diagram (described): At the snap both corners turn their backs and run with the outside receivers, and the nickel turns and chases Powers — man coverage disguised as zone. That kills the curl-flat side, because every receiver there has a man on him. The quarterback's eyes go to the right. Gaines slants inside with the right corner trailing him; Harlan releases to the flat underneath, crossing Gaines's path so the corner and the strong safety must work around each other. The slant is the first throw; the flat is the second.
📋 Try it — Make the call: Hypothetical, built from our Week 12 plan against St. Louis. Third quarter, 3rd-and-6 at the Stallions' 40, Outlaws ahead by three. Teo's page says the Stallions play Cover 3 on 70 percent of third-and-medium snaps and Cover 1 on the rest, and in Cover 3 their nickel "jumps anything in the flat." You have Eleven personnel on the field and every concept in this chapter available. Call a concept, name the key, and say what you'll do if it's Cover 1.
Answer
A strong answer: Snag from Gun Trey Right (or Stick from Trips). Against Cover 3 the corner bails, so the key is the curl/flat defender — the nickel — and the scouting says he jumps the flat. If he does, the snag at six is open in the window he left, which is enough for the first down if the receiver turns upfield. If he sits, Harlan is in the flat. For Cover 1, use the motion or the corners' alignment before the snap: if a man runs with a zip, it's man — pick the matchup (the snag route against outside leverage, or Harlan on a linebacker in the flat) or check to a man-beater with a "both" call. Weaker answers: smash (the corner route dies against Cover 3's bailing corner, and the hitch alone may not get six); four verticals (fine against Cover 3, but ambitious for six yards and slower to develop). What's graded is that you named a defender and a plan for both coverages.
FULL-FIELD READ (Mills, Game 3 look): post (1) -> dig (2) -> flat (3)
(1) Z post: read the deep
X go \ middle safety
^ \
| \
| \
| H <----------------------------+ \
| (2) dig at 12: read the hook | \
| and any robber | |
<---Y (3) flat | |
X Y O O O O O H Z
Q R (Ruffin stays in)
📊 Diagram (described): From the Game 3 formation — Harlan attached on the left, Sutton wide left, Powers in the right slot, Gaines wide right — Sutton runs a go, Gaines runs a post breaking toward the middle at twelve, Powers runs a dig at twelve breaking left across the field, and Harlan releases to the left flat. Ruffin stays in to protect. The quarterback reads three defenders in order: the deep-middle safety for the post, the hook defender (and any robber) for the dig, and finally the flat on the far side as the outlet. His eyes travel across the whole field.
The full-field read is how Mills is meant to work: the post is the first throw only if the deep middle is open after the snap. That "after" is the whole lesson of the interception, and it is the cross-link between this chapter and the protection math of Chapter 22: a full-field read needs time, and time costs blockers.
🔄 Check your understanding: Name one advantage and one weakness of a half-field read, and say what the "both" call does about the weakness.
Answer
Advantage: the quarterback decides the side before the snap and reads one or two defenders, so the ball comes out on rhythm and the protection doesn't have to hold long. Weakness: if the defense rotates away from the chosen side after the snap, or plays the opposite family of coverage, the chosen side may be dead. The "both" call puts a zone-beater on one side and a man-beater on the other, so the post-snap identification of zone or man tells the quarterback which half to work — it keeps the speed of a half-field read while hedging the coverage guess.
15.7 Timing: The Drop Matches the Break
A route concept is a set of routes and a clock. If the quarterback's drop finishes before the receivers reach their breaks, he has to wait, and waiting is when sacks happen. If the drop finishes after the breaks, the receivers are open and then covered again, and the ball arrives late into a closing window. The rule every system teaches in one form or another: the depth of the drop matches the depth of the route.
From under center, the traditional language is three-step, five-step, and seven-step drops. From the shotgun, where the quarterback already starts about five yards deep, coaches commonly treat a gun "one-step" or catch-and-throw as roughly the equivalent of a three-step from under center, and a gun three-step (with a hitch) as roughly a five-step. Systems vary; the principle doesn't.
TIMING: THE DROP MATCHES THE BREAK (shotgun; depths in yards)
depth receivers' breaks QB's drop and release
----- ------------------------------- ------------------------------
18 sail, corner finish 5-step + hitch: ~2.7-3.2 s
15 comeback stem, sail break
12 curl, out, dig, post, corner 3-step + hitch: ~2.3-2.7 s
10 the slot's curl, out, and dig
6 hitch, stick, snag catch-and-throw or 1-step:
5 quick out ~1.0-1.3 s
~3 slant (breaks on the 3rd step)
0 ===== line of scrimmage ====== QB starts ~5 deep in the gun
📊 Diagram (described): A ladder of depths from the line of scrimmage up to eighteen yards. Next to each depth are the routes that break there, and next to the routes is the matching quarterback drop and release time: the six-yard and shorter routes go with a catch-and-throw or one-step and a release around one second; the ten- and twelve-yard routes go with a three-step drop and a hitch and a release around two and a half seconds; the fifteen-to-eighteen-yard routes go with a five-step drop and a release around three seconds. The quarterback begins about five yards deep in the shotgun.
| Family | Drop (gun) | Route depths | Outlaws examples | Ball out (approx.) | Usual protection |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quick | Catch-and-throw / 1-step | 5–6 | Slants, Hitches, Stick, Snag, Speed Out | 1.0–1.3 s | 50 or 60 |
| Dropback, intermediate | 3-step + hitch | 10–12 | Curl-flat, Smash, Levels, Drive, Mills | 2.3–2.7 s | 60 |
| Dropback, deep | 5-step + hitch | 15–20 | Flood (sail), comebacks, All Go, deep over | 2.7–3.2 s | 60, 70, or 80 Max |
| Play-action | Run fake, then set | 12–25, behind the second level | Inside PA Gaines Post, PA dig, Wide PA Boot | ~2.8–3.3 s and up | The run's protection (Inside PA, Wide PA) |
| Screen | Retreat and lure | Behind the line | Slip, Bubble, Tunnel, Y Screen | varies | Linemen release on purpose |
The times come from our own charting, and they're targets, not laws. The ranges matter more than the decimals.
🔍 Why this works: A coverage is strongest when its defenders have had time to reach their landmarks and weakest while they're still getting there. A route that breaks at the moment the quarterback's back foot hits gets the ball into a window before the defender who owns it has finished arriving. A route that breaks after the quarterback is set gives the defender those extra beats to close. Matching drop to depth is how you throw into a coverage while it is still moving — which is also why the quarterback must read a defender: the defender's movement is the window.
Play-action deserves its own line, because the timing is different in kind. The fake costs the quarterback time — about as long as a handoff — and the protection has to hold longer behind it. What you buy is a second level that has stepped toward the line. The routes therefore aim behind the linebackers, where those defenders were standing before they took the fake. That's the entire subject of Chapter 19. A rule about linemen that matters for every play-action concept: on any forward pass that crosses the line of scrimmage, an NFL lineman may not be more than one yard downfield when the ball is thrown. College and high school codes have allowed more (historically about three yards in college and two in high school), and those numbers have changed over time, so check your current code. That rule limits how deep a play-action pass can look like a run.
⚠️ Common mistake: a twelve-yard route on a quick drop. In my second year as a coordinator, at the college program where I learned the spread, I put a curl at twelve into our quick-game menu because the corner was playing soft and "the curl was open on film." It was open on film because on film the quarterback had taken a five-step drop. On our quick-game drop he was set at about 1.2 seconds and the curl wasn't breaking until about 2.3. He held the ball, the edge rusher got home, and we fumbled at our own 30 in a game we lost by a field goal. The fix was a rule that's still on my wall: every route on the menu is listed with its drop. If the drop and the break don't match, it isn't on the menu.
15.8 Landmarks, Spacing, Names, and Families
Landmarks
Receivers don't run to "about twelve yards over there." They run to landmarks — places on the field the quarterback can see and the receiver can find at full speed. Depth landmarks are yards from the line of scrimmage. Width landmarks are painted on the field: the sideline, the numbers, the hash marks, and the middle of the field.
LANDMARKS, SIDELINE TO MIDDLE (NFL field, yards in from the sideline)
sideline fade lane numbers (varies) hash middle
| |---| |---------| | |
0 4 6 ~7 ~12 ~23.6 26.7
+--------+---+-------+---------+------------+------------+
never closer outs and curls seams run posts and
than 4 settle here near here digs cross
📊 Diagram (described): A strip of the field from the sideline to the middle, with distances in yards measured in from the sideline. The fade lane is between four and six yards from the sideline, and a go route never gets closer than four. The painted numbers sit roughly seven to twelve yards in, depending on the field; outs and curls settle around them. The NFL hash is about twenty-three and a half yards in, where seams run, and the middle of the field is about twenty-six and two-thirds yards in, where posts and digs cross.
The NFL hashes are 70 feet 9 inches from each sideline and 18 feet 6 inches apart, so the ball is never far from the middle. College hashes are 60 feet from each sideline and 40 feet apart; high school (NFHS) hashes are 53 feet 4 inches from each sideline. The painted numbers vary more by field than people think — pace off yours rather than trusting a chart. Our Outlaws landmarks, which come straight from the route tree in Chapter 6, are: the go route's fade lane 4 to 6 yards from the sideline, never closer than 4; the bottom of the numbers as the flat's aiming point; the top of the numbers as the outside limit for a curl; and the hash as the seam runner's lane.
Spacing
Spacing is the rule that makes the principles work. Ours:
- Five yards minimum between receivers on the same level, so one defender can't split the difference.
- Three depths, not two, when you want to beat a deep zone with an underneath defender — the flood's 2–3, 12–15, and deep.
- Hold the landmark against leverage. A curl that drifts to get open against man coverage has wrecked the zone spacing that made it a concept. If the coverage is zone, the receiver settles in the window and faces the quarterback; if it's man, he wins with the route's break, then works back toward the ball.
- Splits set spacing before the snap. A wide split gives the outside receiver room inside; a reduced or "Nasty" split gives him room outside — and tells the defense something, which is why Teo tracks Gaines's split as a tell on our own self-scout.
Names across systems
How a concept is named shapes how it's taught and how fast it can be called. Three traditions:
- Numbered route trees, associated with Don Coryell's Air Coryell offenses, give each receiver a number and assemble a play from the digits. Flexible; long to call; easy to build anything.
- Concept names, associated with the Erhardt-Perkins system and the New England offenses that later made it famous, give one word to a whole combination of routes. Fast to call; every player learns his job in every concept; the concept travels from formation to formation unchanged.
- Descriptive calls, common in West Coast-rooted systems, spell out formation, protection, and the routes of several receivers in a long call. Precise; heavy in the huddle.
The Outlaws use concept words in the huddle and numbers for teaching, tags, and signals, as Chapter 8 laid out. So "Smash" and "Digits Zero-Seven-Six" are almost the same play from Doubles Right: in Digits, the X runs a 0 (hitch), the H runs a 7 (corner), the Z runs a 6 (dig), and the Y and back run their default check routes; in Smash, the Y runs the backside seam by default. One word is faster. The digits are how we build something new on a Thursday without inventing a name.
Concept families
Every concept lives in a family, and the family tells the line, the back, and the quarterback what kind of play it is before anyone hears the concept word.
| Family | What it attacks | Protection and timing | Home chapter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quick game | Leverage and cushion; pressure | 5–6 man, ball out by ~1.3 s | Chapter 21 |
| Dropback | Zone structure (stretches, floods) and man matchups | 6–7 man, ~2.3–3.2 s | Chapters 16–18 |
| Play-action | Linebackers and safeties who trigger on the run | The run's protection, longer hold | Chapter 19 |
| Screen | Rush and pursuit — lets defenders through on purpose | Linemen release; ineligibles must respect the downfield rule on any pass past the line | Chapter 20 |
🏫 Any level: In high school the hashes sit about 17.8 yards from each sideline, so with the ball on a hash the wide side of the field is roughly twice the width of the short side. That changes concept design more than any other single fact. Flood and curl-flat belong to the wide side, where a horizontal stretch has room to stretch; quick isolation and hi-lo belong to the short side. Most high school staffs also have less meeting time and younger quarterbacks, so favor half-field reads with one key each, chosen before the snap by the shell, and a short menu — four to six concepts, repeated from many formations — instead of twenty concepts from one. At the college level, the hashes are 20 yards in; the same field/boundary logic applies, a little less sharply. And at every level, practice reps decide how many concepts you can afford: a concept you've repped against Cover 2, Cover 3, and man in team periods is worth three you've only walked through.
🔄 Check your understanding: Why does the Outlaws rule list every route with its drop, and why do width landmarks matter as much as depth?
Answer
A route only works if the ball can arrive as it breaks; listing the drop with the route prevents calling a twelve-yard break off a one-second drop (the quarterback waits and gets sacked) or a six-yard break off a long drop (the window closes). Width landmarks keep the stretches stretched: if two receivers drift within five yards of each other, one defender covers both; if a go route drifts inside the fade lane, the throw has no room. Depth tells the defender when to choose; width makes sure he has to.
15.9 When Concepts Fail: The Mistakes, and the Defense's Fix
Most failed concepts aren't bad concepts. They fail in one of a handful of ways, and every one has a fix.
| Failure | What it looks like on film | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Reading the receiver | QB stares at a route, waits for separation, throws late into the defender who chose it | Teach and grade the key, not the receiver; painter's-tape drills in the QB room |
| Wrong key after rotation | QB reads the pre-snap key; the role moved after the snap | Post-snap confirmation step: "two looks with one pair of eyes" |
| Spacing collapse | Two receivers within 3–4 yards; one defender covers both | Width landmarks; grade landmarks in individual and 7-on-7 periods |
| Timing mismatch | QB set and waiting, or receiver broke before QB was ready | Every route listed with its drop; timing period with QB and receivers only |
| The defense adds a man | Key defender plays it right and a robber or bracket sits in the window | Read the robber as a second key; attack him with a hi-lo of his own, or work away from him |
| Wrong concept for the coverage | Smash vs. Cover 3, curl-flat into a squatting Cover 2 corner with the hook defender walling | Pair concepts with coverages on the call sheet; carry a "both" call |
📋 Try it — Whose fault? Our second preseason game this past August, third quarter, 3rd-and-4 at our own 36. Owen Strand, our rookie, at quarterback. Call: "Eleven, Gun Trips Right, 60 Left, Stick" — Cody Brandt on the stick at six as #3, Jaylen Cross to the flat as #2, the Z on a go. The defense played Cover 3. At the snap the curl/flat defender, the nickel, didn't widen with the flat; he sat right on the stick. Owen threw the stick anyway, because Brandt "was open when I looked." The nickel undercut it. Interception at our 42. Whose fault — Brandt, Cross, Owen, or the call? What's the fix?
Answer
The quarterback, and the fix is the eyes. The call was sound against Cover 3: the nickel was the key, and he had two choices. He chose the stick. That made the flat the throw — Cross was alone in it. Brandt ran the route to the right depth and settled correctly; Cross was where he was supposed to be. Owen's eyes went to Brandt, not the nickel. "He was open when I looked" means he looked at Brandt before the nickel had made his choice, then threw on that stale picture. The fix: in the QB room, painter's tape over the receivers on stick clips until he can call the throw from the nickel alone; on the field, a stick-only period where Rome stands behind him and asks "who's the key?" at the snap. (It was preseason. He threw two more stick throws that night, both to the right man.)
⚠️ Common mistake: running your favorite concept into the coverage that kills it. Smash is a beautiful Cover 2 beater. Against Cover 3 the corner bails, the corner route is covered, and you're left with a hitch. Curtis Bale, my old colleague, built one of his third-down packages around two concepts he loved and ran them regardless of the shell — and his quarterback learned to throw the hitch, which isn't a third-and-6 route. The fix isn't to stop calling smash. It's to call it when the shell and the tendency say Cover 2, and to carry something like Snag that has a Cover 3 answer built in.
🛡️ The defense's view: From Russ's side of the ball, the cheapest way to beat a concept is not to cover its routes but to change who the key is. Rotate a safety down at the snap, and the curl/flat defender the quarterback was told to read may no longer be the man in the curl/flat. Play a robber, and the hook defender can jump the drag because somebody else is sitting on the dig. Russ's staff charted our concepts by which defender they stress, not by name — which is exactly how we chart theirs. Two staffs, each writing on a whiteboard the name of a defender on the other side.
Spaced Review
Try each before you open the answer.
1. From Chapter 13: In Anchor A, the "Inside Slant" RPO, who was the read defender, and what were his two jobs? How is that read the same as a curl-flat read?
Answer
The read was the Will linebacker, Jordan Ames (#45): his run job was the backside A/B gap, his pass job was the slant window. Vance read him at the mesh — he triggered on the first snap (slant to Powers, +17) and sat on the second (handoff, Ruffin +7). A curl-flat read works the same way: one defender with two jobs, the quarterback watching him and throwing opposite. An RPO is a route concept in which one of the "routes" is a handoff.
2. From Chapter 7: A defense shows two safeties at twelve yards. What does that tell you about the coverage, and what doesn't it tell you?
Answer
It tells you the middle of the field is open before the snap (MOFO) — the shell suggests Cover 2, Cover 4, or Cover 6. It doesn't tell you the coverage: a two-high shell can rotate to a one-high Cover 3 or Cover 1 at the snap. The shell is not the coverage, which is why every read in this chapter has a post-snap confirmation step.
3. From Chapter 6: Without looking, give the Outlaws route numbers and depths for the hitch, curl, dig, corner, and go. Which of them break in?
Answer
0 hitch at 6; 4 curl, pushed to 12 and settling at 10–11; 6 dig at 12; 7 corner, stemmed to 12 and breaking to the pylon at about 18; 9 go, in the fade lane 4–6 yards from the sideline. Evens break in, so the curl and the dig break in (the hitch, 0, stops and turns in). Odds break out, so the corner breaks out. The go doesn't break.
Project Checkpoint: Concept Framework
Last chapter you built your Short-Yardage & Goal-Line Package — four runs and two passes for the yards that have to be won. Now you start the passing game, and before you collect concepts you need a framework that tells you how every concept will be named, taught, and read. Without one, a playbook becomes a pile of drawings. With one, every new concept slots into a system your quarterback already knows how to read.
Format: two pages. Page 1 is the framework; page 2 is three filled-in concept cards.
Page 1 — the framework, five parts:
- Naming rule. Concept words, numbers, or both? Who decides a concept's name, and what makes a name legal (short, unique in sound, one meaning)?
- Families. List quick, dropback, play-action, and screen, with the drop and protection each family assumes by default.
- Read language. Commit to reading roles: "flat defender," "hook defender," "deep-middle defender." Write the post-snap confirmation step your quarterback must take.
- Spacing and landmark rules. Minimum separation; your field landmarks; how splits adjust.
- Install order. How a new concept is taught: walk-through → air (no defense) → against a scout look in 7-on-7 → team. Name the defense each concept must be repped against before it goes on the call sheet.
Page 2 — concept cards. Each card: name; family; formations it runs from; routes by position with tree numbers and depths; the key defender against Cover 2, Cover 3, Cover 4, and man; the read table; drop and ball-out target; protection; and the "nothing's there" rule.
Worked example (one card, abbreviated):
| Field | Curl-Flat |
|---|---|
| Family | Dropback, intermediate (3-step + hitch, ~2.3–2.6 s) |
| Formations | Doubles, Trips (to the two-man side), Trey backside |
| Routes | #1: 4 (curl, 12 → 10–11, no wider than top of numbers). #2: flat at 2–3, aim bottom of numbers. Backside: dig (6) and seam |
| Key vs. Cover 3 | Curl/flat defender: widens → curl; sinks → flat |
| Key vs. Cover 2 | Corner: squats → curl (before the safety arrives); sinks → flat |
| Key vs. Cover 4 | Apex/nickel: widens → curl; sits → flat (often open early) |
| vs. man | Not a read — check to the "both" call or the backside man-beater |
| Protection | 60, slide away from the concept |
| Nothing there | Rule four: the free square — throw the ball you know, or throw it away |
Your level:
- High school: eight concepts at most, all half-field, each with one key. Put the cards on a laminated sheet the quarterback keeps in his playbook.
- College: add field/boundary versions of each card and note which concepts you'll only call to the wide side.
- Pro: add the defense's most likely "cancel" for each concept (rotation, robber, bracket) and your answer to it.
- Film-room: chart twenty dropbacks from one team's game. For each: concept (your best name), the key defender, what he did, where the ball went. Count how often the ball went opposite the key.
Next: In Chapter 16 you'll use this framework to build your Core Coverage-Beater Set — smash, flood, and levels, each with its read against Cover 2, 3, and 4.
Chapter Summary
A route concept is a set of routes chosen together to break a coverage rule. The quarterback doesn't look for an open receiver; he watches the defender the concept stresses and throws where that defender isn't.
| Principle | What it does to the defense | Example | Best against | Weakest against |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Horizontal stretch | One underneath defender, two receivers on a level, 5+ yards apart | Curl-flat, stick | Cover 3, any spot-drop zone | Man; zones that expand late |
| Vertical stretch (hi-lo) | One defender, a route in front and a route behind | Smash (corner), drive (hook) | Cover 2 (smash); hook defenders in any zone | Cover 3 for smash; robbers for drive |
| Triangle | Hi-lo plus horizontal on adjacent defenders | Snag | Cover 2 and Cover 3 | Man (becomes a matchup choice) |
| Overload / flood | More receivers than defenders; three levels to a side | Flood, sail | Cover 3 | Coverages that roll to the flood side |
| Isolation | One receiver, one defender, no help | Backside fade, back-shoulder | Any coverage rolled away from the iso | Two-high with help over the top |
| Rub / traffic | Man defenders work through crossing paths | Mesh, shallow, bunch releases | Man | Zone that passes crossers off |
The read in five questions, every snap:
- Before the snap: One high or two? Who holds the key role on my concept's side?
- Motion or matchup: Did anybody run with the motion? If so, man — pick the matchup or the man-beater side.
- At the snap: Did the shell hold? If a safety rotated, who holds the key role now?
- The key: Which way did he commit? Throw opposite, on rhythm with the drop.
- Nothing there: Rule four — the free square. Throw the ball you know.
What's Next
You now know the principles; next you get the plays. Chapter 16 takes the three concepts that beat almost every coverage — smash, flood, and levels — and draws them from five formations, against Cover 2, 3, and 4, starting with the afternoon in Portland when Josh Kiel had to choose between Sutton and Powers and didn't get to be right.