Film-Lab Guide
Running broadcast and All-22 film labs
The film lab is where this course stops being a reading course. A learner who can recite the rules of Inside Slant but can't find the Will linebacker's first step on a live snap hasn't learned the RPO yet. This guide covers what film to use, how to set up the room, the method every lab uses (the Chapter 40 checklist), two charting sheets (a simplified version of Teo Arriaga's tagging fields and Lyle's twelve-field offensive chart), the whose-fault protocol, eight lab sessions, and how to use footage responsibly.
1. What film you need, and what each angle shows
| Angle | What it shows | What it hides | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Broadcast | The ball, the quarterback, the line at the snap; replays; the score bug with down, distance, and clock | Usually both safeties at the snap, often the corners and wide receivers | Situation, personnel, formation (in the pre-snap wide shot), the line's first step, the mesh, the result |
| All-22 (sideline, high and wide) | All twenty-two players from the snap to the whistle | Line-of-scrimmage detail; exact depths are hard to judge | Shells and rotation, coverage, route spacing, the read defender in the pass game, whose-fault |
| End zone | Line play, gaps, the back's track, the box count, linebacker depth and first steps | Safeties and wide receivers usually out of frame | Zone vs. gap blocking, combos and climbs, protection counts, the mesh read on option and RPOs |
Most pass-game questions need All-22. Most run and protection questions need the end zone. Most "why this call, now?" questions need nothing but the broadcast and a chart of the previous snaps. A good lab uses two angles on the same snap when it can: watch the end zone to find who was free in the protection, then the All-22 to see where the hot throw should have gone.
Teach the broadcast deliberately. Analysts and fans will spend their lives with the broadcast copy, and Chapter 40 §40.5 is honest about it: the safeties are often out of frame at the snap, so the shell column gets a "?" unless you saw it in the pre-snap wide shot, and the overhead or end-zone replay often shows what the shell turned into. A learner who writes "?" correctly is doing better work than one who guesses.
Sources. In recent seasons the NFL's subscription service has offered All-22 and end-zone film; check what is currently offered and on what terms. High school teams generally exchange game film through film-exchange platforms, and your own program's film is the best teaching material you will ever have. College programs share film under conference arrangements. Broadcast footage is everywhere.
2. Room setup
- One screen everyone can see, with the instructor on the clicker. Learners should not scrub film on their own laptops during the shared portion; the room watches the same frame at the same time.
- A whiteboard beside the screen. Every snap that goes wrong gets drawn in the book's notation, offense at the bottom moving up. A learner who identifies a concept on film should be able to turn around and draw it.
- Printed charting sheets (Section 4), one per learner per lab.
- A cutup, not a game. Pre-select eight to thirty snaps per lab, organized by the day's idea (twenty inside-zone snaps against different fronts; every third-and-medium from one game; every snap with motion). Whole games in order are for Lab 8 and the final practical.
- Painter's tape. Borrowed from the hook of Chapter 15: on a still frame, tape over every eligible receiver and ask where the ball should go. It is the fastest cure for reading receivers.
Timing for a 50-minute lab. Five minutes of review (one snap from last week, cold). Fifteen minutes of individual charting: each clip at full speed twice, then once slowed, no talking. Ten minutes of comparison in pairs. Twenty minutes of whole-room argument on the four or five snaps where pairs disagreed. For a 90-minute block (the analyst syllabus), double the charting and add a ten-minute board segment where disagreements get drawn.
3. The method: the Chapter 40 checklist
Every lab, from Lab 1 to the final practical, uses the same order. The order matters more than the content; it's what keeps learners from watching the ball.
Before the snap: seven items, in order
| # | Item | What learners count or name |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Situation | Down, distance, field position, score, clock, timeouts. Which box of the call sheet is the coordinator in? |
| 1 | Personnel | Backs and tight ends (11, 12, 21, 13…), and the defense's answer (base, nickel, dime) |
| 2 | Formation and strength | 2x2, 3x1, empty, bunch; the tight end attached or detached; receivers numbered #1, #2, #3 outside-in on each side |
| 3 | Shell | Two high (MOFO), one high (MOFC), or zero. The shell is not the coverage. |
| 4 | Box | Light, neutral, or loaded; an apex nickel counts as half |
| 5 | Leverage | Corners pressed or off; inside or outside on the slot; safety depth |
| 6 | Motion and reaction | Who moved, and who went with him: traveled, slid, rotated, or froze |
Insist on shell before box (Chapter 40 §40.2): the number of deep safeties tells you how many defenders can be in the box, and counting the box first is how learners miss the safety creeping from ten yards to eight.
At the snap: four things in two seconds
- The line's first step, which tells you the family: all five stepping the same way is zone; down blocks and a puller is gap; high hats is dropback; firing out but staying at the line is play-action; setting and then releasing is screen; firing out and climbing is a run or RPO (and watch the ineligible-downfield rule).
- The read defender: the man the play puts in conflict or leaves unblocked on purpose.
- The decision: the handoff, pull, throw, or cut.
- The block or route that decided it.
After the snap: "why this call, now?"
Chapter 40 §40.4's five context questions, asked of every snap in a sequence: What does the down and distance demand? Where is the ball? What do the score and clock want? What did the last three snaps buy? Who is being attacked? Question 4 is the one fans skip and coordinators live on.
4. Charting sheets
Two sheets. The simplified tagging sheet charts a defense, the way Teo breaks down an opponent for the scouting report. The twelve-field chart charts an offense, the way Lyle tells a reader to chart one game. Early labs use one or the other; Lab 8 uses both.
Sheet A: simplified tagging sheet (charting a defense)
Teo's real breakdown has eighteen fields and takes him five to seven hours a game across three passes (Chapter 23 §23.3). This classroom version keeps the eleven that matter most and fits on one landscape page with fifteen rows.
| Field | What goes in it | Example (Week 6, Sentinels snap) |
|---|---|---|
| Clip # | Running number | 141 |
| Q / time / score | Score from the defense's view (+3 = they lead by 3) | Q2, 6:12, −4 |
| Down & distance, yard line, hash | As called; hash L / M / R | 1-10, own 38, L |
| Offense: personnel and formation | In your own words | 11, Gun Doubles Right |
| Offense: play family | Run, RPO, PA, dropback, screen | Run: inside zone right |
| Defense: personnel | Base, nickel, big nickel, dime | Nickel |
| Box | Light / neutral / loaded (apex nickel = half) | 6 (light) |
| Shell before | 2H / 1H / 0 | 2H |
| Shell after | 2H / 1H / 0, filled from the All-22, at least a second after the snap | 2H (Quarters) |
| Rushers | Number, and who came | 4 |
| Key defender's eyes and first step | For the second-level defender the offense is attacking | W: eyes on the back, first step downhill |
Three rules come with the sheet, all from Chapter 23. Write "?" when you didn't see it; if a column has a "?" on more than about one snap in ten, don't put a percentage on it. Two shell columns, always. Counts, not percentages, until the sample is big enough to deserve one.
Sheet B: the twelve-field chart (charting an offense)
From Chapter 40 §40.6, built the same way as Teo's QC hiring test:
| # | Field | Example entry |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Quarter and clock | Q2 9:14 |
| 2 | Down and distance | 2-8 |
| 3 | Field position (and hash) | STL 44 |
| 4 | Score (offense first) | 7–7 |
| 5 | Personnel (offense / defense) | 11 / nickel |
| 6 | Formation and strength | Doubles R, Y attached |
| 7 | Motion and the reaction | Z zip; nobody traveled |
| 8 | Box count | 7 |
| 9 | Shell: before → after | 1H → 1H (Cover 3) |
| 10 | Family and concept | Dropback, Smash L |
| 11 | Key defender and what he did | Left corner bailed to the deep third |
| 12 | Result (yards; success Y/N) | Hitch +7; Y |
Write the success-rate rule at the top of the sheet: a play succeeds if it gains 40 percent of the yards to go on first down, 60 percent on second, and all of it on third or fourth (Chapter 28 §28.3). Learners get the second-down line wrong constantly. Require three passes: fields 1–9 stopping at the snap; fields 10–12 watching through the whistle; then a third pass for "why this call, now?" and the process and result grades.
5. The whose-fault protocol
The most common film error is blaming the player nearest the ball: the quarterback for the sack, the receiver for the interception, the back for the tackle for loss. The book calls this out repeatedly, and the Game 2 sack is the proof: six blockers, five rushers, everybody blocked somebody, and Bell came free anyway because two of Austin's six were assigned to men who dropped (Chapter 5 §5.8, Chapter 22 §22.1).
The five steps.
- Write the call and the purpose before you watch the result (the 34-second fence, Chapter 40 §40.7).
- Count. Blockers vs. defenders in the box, or protectors vs. rushers. Name the free man, if any.
- Find the first moment the play left its design. Not the moment it failed: the moment it stopped being the play that was called.
- Assign the first cause with the book's marks: C (the call didn't fit the look), R (the rule sent a player to the wrong job), or X (a player didn't execute a correct assignment).
- Write the fix at the level of the cause. A call fix goes on the call sheet; a rule fix goes in Wednesday's install; an execution fix goes to the position room.
Running the argument. Have pairs commit to a mark before the room discusses. When pairs disagree, the burden is on the X: anyone who blames a player must show that the player's assignment was correct and possible. Most "X" answers on sacks turn into "R" answers under that test. Lorusso's "I blocked air, Coach" and Gus's "You blocked a guy who left" are the model exchange.
The Mills demonstration. Run the protocol once on the Game 3 interception, slowly, and let the room discover that the fault sits upstream of the throw: a box with no branch on Tuesday, a scout team that never showed the rotation on Thursday, and a quarterback who threw a good ball to the right spot against the picture the whole week told him he'd get. Then show the two fixes: the middle-read tag (Chapter 38 §38.8) and Vance's spring rule, "Show me the spin on Thursday, or don't call it on Sunday" (Chapter 35).
6. Eight lab sessions
Each lab lists its chapters, the cutup to build, the sheet to use, and what to grade. In the 15-week syllabus they fall in Weeks 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, 11, and 14; in the analyst syllabus they anchor the film blocks.
Lab 1 — Seeing the whole field
Chapters: 3, 4, 40 §40.2 and §40.5. Cutup: twenty snaps, each shown on broadcast and then All-22. Task: checklist items 0–2 only: situation, personnel (both sides), formation, strength, and receiver numbers. Mark every eligible receiver and check the end man on each side. Grade: accuracy of personnel and numbering; at least one correct "?" where the broadcast hid something. Debrief question: what did the broadcast hide that the All-22 showed?
Lab 2 — Shell, box, and leverage
Chapters: 7 (the threshold concept), 23 §23.3. Cutup: thirty snaps against two or three defenses, including at least six where the shell changes at the snap. Task: Sheet A's defensive columns: box, shell before, shell after, leverage. Then one sentence per snap: "The structure can't defend ___." Grade: two shell columns on every snap; box counted after the shell; the apex nickel as half. Debrief question: on which snaps would a pre-snap read have sent the ball to the wrong place?
Lab 3 — The first step tells you the family
Chapters: 5, 9, 10, 11. Cutup: twenty-four snaps from the end zone: six each of zone, gap, dropback, and play-action, shuffled. Task: name the family from the first step alone, then confirm. On zone snaps, mark covered and uncovered linemen and the combo that climbed; on gap snaps, the puller, the kick, and the wrap. Grade: family correct; one zone snap drawn on the board with "hands before climb" judged. Debrief question: on which zone snap did the hole end up somewhere other than the aiming point, and why?
Lab 4 — The read defender: option and RPOs
Chapters: 12, 13, 40 §40.3. Cutup: fifteen option and RPO snaps, plus three plain runs with an unblocked backside end. Task: find the unblocked or read defender, write his two jobs, say what he did, and say whether the decision matched him. For the three plain runs: bust or design? Grade: the read defender named on every snap; the "unblocked defender is a question" standard applied. Check linemen's depth on every RPO throw that crossed the line. Debrief question: where would Anchor A's Ames have to stand for Inside Slant to be the wrong call?
Lab 5 — Reading a defender in the pass game
Chapters: 15, 16, 17. Cutup: smash, flood, and levels against two-high and single-high (four snaps each if you can find them), plus six man-beater snaps (mesh, shallow, a rub). Task: Sheet B fields 9–12; field 11 must name the stressed defender before the result is written. On the painter's-tape freeze, say where the ball should go with the receivers covered. Grade: the key defender, not the target, drives the answer. On rubs, the learner describes spacing, not a block. Debrief question: which of these concepts was called into the coverage it wasn't built for, and what did the quarterback do about it?
Lab 6 — Protection arithmetic on film
Chapters: 21, 22, 5 §5.8. Cutup: twelve pressure snaps from the end zone, including at least two simulated pressures (a lineman dropping) and two sacks. Task: count rushers and blockers at the snap and again a second later; name the free man; find the hot or sight adjust and say whether the ball could get there. Then run the whose-fault protocol on the sacks. Grade: counts correct; the free man named; C / R / X assigned with evidence. Debrief question: where on these snaps was the ball the extra blocker, and where was the hot window taken away?
Lab 7 — Sequences and motion
Chapters: 19, 27, 40 §40.4. Cutup: two complete drives in order, from one game, with at least one play-action and several motion snaps. Task: Sheet B for every snap, plus "why this call, now?" question 4 (what did the last three snaps buy?). On motion snaps, write the reaction (traveled, slid, rotated, froze) and the coverage after the snap in separate fields. Grade: the learner identifies at least one sequence (a run that set up a pass, or a pass that set up a run) and names the defender it was aimed at. Motion reactions are never treated as proof. Debrief question: if you were the defensive coordinator, which snap of these drives would you change your call on, and what would the offense have done next?
Lab 8 — Charting a game and grading it honestly
Chapters: 23, 25, 28, 40 §40.6–§40.7. Cutup: one team's offense for one full half, in order. Task: Sheet B in three passes; then a one-page summary with counts and "since" dates, three tendencies labeled tell, lean, or story, and a process grade and a result grade on the five most important calls, with each failure marked C, R, or X. Grade: use Rubric 3 in rubrics. This lab is the dress rehearsal for the final practical. Debrief question: which call did you grade differently on process than on result, and what would you need to know (that the film can't show) to be sure?
7. Using footage responsibly
- Copyright. Game footage is copyrighted. Use it in class under your institution's guidance on educational use, keep cutups inside the course, and don't post them publicly. Your own program's film is the cleanest material you have.
- Real players, real careers. When you use NFL or college film, grade decisions and structures, not people. "The rule sent the back to the wrong man" teaches; "this guy can't block" doesn't, and it is usually wrong besides. Don't attribute statistics to real players that you can't source.
- High school film. Your players are minors. Use your own team's film for staff development only, never in a public setting, and keep opponent film inside the staff.
- Injury snaps. Skip them. If a snap in a cutup ends with a player down, cut before the injury; the lesson is never worth replaying someone getting hurt. If an injury snap is relevant to a safety lesson (a quarterback hit after a late pull, for example), discuss the mechanism on the whiteboard, not on the replay loop. See the rules and player-safety teaching guide.
- The fictional season. The Outlaws–Sentinels games exist only in the book. Use the book's diagrams and the case studies when you want to teach those snaps; use real film to practice the method.