Case Study 2 — Thirty-Two Letters: Getting From a High-School Sideline to a College Film Room
A high-school case from Lyle's Ohio years: a first attempt that failed, a second that worked, and what changed. All people and programs are fictional and unnamed where the chapter leaves them unnamed.
Setup
Who and where. I'd just finished my fifth season as offensive coordinator at a consolidated high school half an hour from Youngstown, under head coach Ray Kessler, a retired shop teacher who'd coached defense for thirty years. I taught social studies during the day. Across my fourth and fifth seasons, we'd lost one game. I was twenty-nine, married to Dana, a nurse, and we had no children yet.
The goal. I wanted to coach college football, and the realistic door was a graduate assistant (GA) spot at a big program: a graduate student who coaches, usually for tuition plus a modest stipend. GA spots are few, they're usually filled by former players or by someone a staff member vouches for, and they tend to go to people in their early twenties. I was none of those things.
What the "scouting" said. Not much, and that was the problem. I didn't know a single college coach well. My only connection to big-time football was a head coach who'd been in Ohio high-school football longer than I'd been alive and who didn't talk about his own past much.
What Happens
Attempt 1: December — eighteen letters, zero answers
That December I did what I thought you were supposed to do. I wrote a letter that said I was a hard worker and a student of the game. I cut a highlight reel of our best plays from two seasons: long runs, touchdown passes, and a goal-line stand our defense made that had nothing to do with me. I mailed the letter and a disc to eighteen big programs, addressed to their offensive coordinators.
I got four form letters back. The other fourteen never answered.
I was angry about it for about two weeks, and then I did what Ray had taught me to do with a loss: I watched my own film. I put the reel on in my classroom during my free period and watched it as if I were a college coordinator with a stack of fifty of these on his desk.
It was terrible. Not the plays. Our kids were good. The reel was terrible, because it answered a question nobody had asked. A college coordinator doesn't need to know that a high-school team scored touchdowns. He needs to know how the person who sent it thinks. My reel had no thinking on it at all.
The diner conversation
I showed the reel to Ray at my parents' diner on a Saturday morning in January, in the back booth, on a laptop between the coffee cups.
Ray: Who's this for?
Lyle: College coordinators.
Ray: Then why is half of it our defense?
Lyle: Because they're good plays.
Ray: They're my plays. What did you do?
Lyle: I called the offense.
Ray: Show me a play where you were smarter than the other guy. Then tell me why. Then show me the next one.
Lyle: That's going to be a long tape.
Ray: Then it'll be a short list of colleges that watch it. Fix it by Friday.
He also asked me where I'd sent the first batch, and when I told him, he was quiet for a second and wrote something on a napkin. It was the name of a big-conference program two states away, and under it, the name of its offensive line coach. "I played with him," Ray said. "Long time ago. Send that one last, so it's your best one."
Attempt 2: January — fourteen letters, two answers
The second batch was different in every way that mattered.
The letter was one page and opened with what I believed. It was the earliest version of the philosophy page I'd later write on a napkin for Wade Harmon, and much worse, but it was mine.
The film was a twelve-minute teaching cut-up: eighteen clips, each with a title card stating the rule behind the call. "Week 5, first season: we've lost two straight, 14–7 and 21–6, in a four-wide spread our quarterback can't throw, so we switch to two-tight-end wing Power and win 20–13. Rule: the scheme serves the players." "Second season, playoffs: a slanting fifty front held us to 41 rushing yards on 28 carries the first time we played them. We switched from man blocking rules to zone area rules. Rule: block the area the slant goes to, not the man who started there." Every clip said what I saw, what I did, and why. Two of them showed calls that failed and what I changed the next week.
I sent fourteen. Ray's friend's program was last.
TWO ATTEMPTS, SAME COACH (fictional)
ATTEMPT 1 (December) ATTEMPT 2 (January)
"hard worker" letter one-page "what I believe"
highlight reel, 2 seasons 12-minute teaching cut-up,
18 clips, a rule on each
18 programs 14 programs
| |
v v
4 form letters 2 real answers
| | (1 "no, but call
v | us next year")
0 conversations v
1 visit (Ray's phone call)
|
v
1 GA offer
📊 Diagram (described): Two side-by-side funnels compare Lyle's two attempts. On the left, the December attempt used a "hard worker" letter and a two-season highlight reel. It went to eighteen programs, produced four form letters, and led to no conversations. On the right, the January attempt used a one-page "what I believe" letter and a twelve-minute teaching cut-up of eighteen clips, each with a rule. It went to fourteen programs and drew two real answers: one was "no, but call us next year," and the other became a visit, made possible by Ray Kessler's phone call, which led to one graduate-assistant offer.
The visit
Two programs answered. One said no, but told me to call again in a year. That alone told me the new tape worked. The other was Ray's friend's program, and it answered because Ray had picked up the phone the day the letter went out. I found that out later. Ray never mentioned it.
The visit was one long day. The offensive line coach took me to lunch and talked about Ray for forty minutes. Then the co-offensive coordinator sat me in a film room with twenty snaps of an opponent's defense and a legal pad, and left for an hour.
When he came back, I'd found one thing. On third-and-medium, the opponent's weak-side linebacker cheated two steps toward the boundary whenever the ball was on the near hash. That happened on six of the seven snaps where both were true. I said six of seven was small, but that I'd check it on the next opponent game before I'd believe it. He asked me how I'd attack it. I drew it on the board.
He offered me the job that week. Two years later, when he picked up the phone and recommended me to Dale Brockway for a receivers job, he told me the hour in the film room had gotten me the GA spot, and the sentence about checking the next game was most of it. "Every kid who comes through here finds a tell," he said. "You were the first one who didn't believe yours yet."
The cost
The GA spot was a two-year commitment that paid tuition and a stipend closer to a part-time wage than a salary. Dana and I had saved for a year with the specific goal of affording two bad years, and she found a nursing job in the new town within a month. Sophia was born during my second season there.
I called Ray from the diner, on the phone cord stretched to the back booth, to tell him I was leaving the best high-school job I'd ever have. He said, "Don't embarrass us." Then he said, "Fix it by Friday," and hung up.
Analysis
Why attempt 1 failed. It answered the wrong question. A highlight reel shows that a team was good. It can't show how the person who sent it thinks, and that's the only thing a college coordinator is evaluating when he hires a GA. Half the reel even showed someone else's work. Eighteen programs, zero conversations, and the market was right.
Why attempt 2 worked: the mechanism.
- It made the thinking visible. A rule on every clip let a stranger evaluate my reasoning in twelve minutes. That's the same principle as the interview binder in Section 37.6 and the twenty-clip cut-up in Case Study 1, at a different rung.
- It showed failure and correction. Two clips of calls that failed, with the fix, told a reader I'd learn on his staff. Coaches hire people who can be coached.
- It used the network I didn't know I had. Ray's playing days with an offensive line coach were the only reason one of the fourteen letters got a visit. The tape got me through the door, but Ray's phone call opened it. Both were necessary.
- The film-room test measured the right skill. The co-coordinator didn't ask about my record. He gave me raw film and an hour. Notice how close that is to the QC hiring test Teo drafted in Section 37.8. A test like that measures the work directly, and the part that impressed him was the habit of not trusting a small sample. Seventeen years later, that's still the habit I'm trying to keep. "Never let a tendency outlive its evidence" is on my whiteboard in red for a reason.
The honest part. I was hired partly because a man I'd coached under for five years had once played football with a man on that staff. A coach just as good as I was, with a better tape and no Ray Kessler, might have gotten two "no, but call us next year" letters and quit. Section 37.7 is about that coach.
High school vs. the NFL (compare Case Study 1). In the NFL case, I was inside the network and my work was already known, so the problem was speed. In this case, I was outside it, so the problem was visibility. The same tool solved both, a short piece of film where every clip teaches a rule, but it had to do far more work from the outside.
Discussion Questions
- Ray asked, "What did you do?" Why is that the most important question for anyone building a film résumé, and how did the answer change the second tape?
- The co-coordinator valued "six of seven, but I'd check the next game" more than the tell itself. Connect this to Chapter 23's idea of the "since" date. Why would a staff value that habit in a GA?
- Lyle admits that Ray's phone call was necessary. Does that make the second attempt a success of merit or of connections? Can it be both? What would you change in the process, as the program doing the hiring, to find the coach without a Ray Kessler?
- Lyle was twenty-nine and married when he applied for a GA spot. Using the four questions from Section 37.9, would you have advised him to go? What would have changed your advice?
- Compare the two case studies. What is the common tool, and why did it have to do "far more work from the outside"?
Your Turn
Rebuild attempt 2 for yourself. Write (a) a one-page letter that opens with what you believe about offense in no more than four lines, and (b) the title cards for a twelve-clip teaching cut-up from any level of football you've coached, charted, or studied. Each card states what the defense did, what was called, and the rule behind it. At least two clips must show a call that failed and what you changed. If you can't find two failures, you haven't watched enough of your own film yet.