Part IV — Game Planning and Play Calling

Chapters 23–28


The whistle blows on Jalen Ruffin at the Sacramento 39. Game 1, fourth quarter, Sentinels up 27–20. He's just gained seven on inside zone, the second straight time we've handed it to him from the same look, and the play clock in the far end zone flips to 40.

From 40 to 34, I listen. Teo Arriaga is in the booth, and between the whistle and my call he's the only voice allowed on my headset. Shell, box, one thing.

"Two high. Six. Thirty-one came down again."

Thirty-one is Tre Holloway, the Sentinels' strong safety. He has filled the alley hard on both runs, harder on the second than the first. Teo has been charting his first step all half in a column on his sheet that says nothing but down.

From 34 to 28, I make the call. That's six seconds, and I don't need all of them, because the call was already made. I made it the Tuesday before at about one in the morning. It's on a card clipped to the right edge of my call sheet, in a box Teo labeled "Holloway." The card says, in my handwriting: Same look. Run until he pays twice. Then cash it. Under that is one call, "Inside PA, Gaines Post," and under that a number: 15 of 21. That's how many times Teo counted Holloway triggering downhill on the run in the Sentinels' film before the game. The count didn't tell me he would bite. It told me where to look.

He'd paid twice. From 28 to 20, I say it into Darius Vance's helmet. Darius says it once in the huddle. Holloway comes downhill a third time, Trey Gaines runs the post through the grass he left, and it's thirty-five yards to the Sacramento 4.

People who watched that play on television saw a great throw and a safety who guessed wrong. Here's what I saw. A late-night film session where Teo started counting a safety's first steps. A Tuesday whiteboard where a count became a card. A Wednesday practice where the scout safety in a red pinny wore 31. A halftime when the booth started charting Holloway's first step. Two runs we called partly for the yards and mostly to teach him something. And six seconds at the end, which are the part everyone thinks of as play calling.

The call takes six seconds. The week behind it takes about eighty-seven hours. This part is the eighty-seven hours.


What this part teaches

Parts I through III built an offense. Part IV teaches you to aim it at one opponent, one week, one snap at a time.

Chapter 23 is the scouting report, film turned into decisions. You'll learn what film to pick, how to tag every snap the same way, why every count carries its denominator ("9 of 14," never "64 percent"), and why the exceptions are often the most valuable part of the report. Chapter 24 builds the game plan: what you'll take away, what you'll attack, the fifteen-play opening script written to learn rather than to win, and series cards like Holloway's that put sequence on paper. It also covers the box nobody wants to build, the branch for when a tendency stops being true.

Chapter 25 is play calling itself, the forty-second decision. It carries the part's threshold concept: a play call is a bet on a distribution, not a promise of an outcome. Judge it by what the caller knew and the alternatives he had, not by the single result. Chapter 26 takes the situations where the numbers get loud: four kinds of third down, the red zone, two-minute, four-minute, backed up, and the end of a half. Chapter 27 is motion and shifts, which are pre-snap movement with a job, whether that job is information, advantage, or constraint. Chapter 28 closes the part with analytics. Marisol Vega's expected points, success rate, the fourth-down break-even, and the honest limits of all of it come with one rule: analytics informs; it doesn't decide.

Why it sits here

You can't plan against a defense with plays you don't have, and you can't call a play you haven't planned. Part IV comes after the whole offense is built because a game plan is a selection. It chooses part of what you own for one opponent and can't fix a hole in the system in one week. If you've skipped ahead to this part, everything in it will feel like a list of good habits. If you've built Parts I through III, it will feel like the reason you built them.

It also comes before Part V's modern systems on purpose. The Shanahan tree, the Air Raid, and the tempo offenses are easier to understand once you know how a week works. Each one is partly a different answer to the problem of preparing for a defense in six days.

The week, in one picture

THE WEEK BEHIND ONE SUNDAY (in season)

  MON          TUE          WED-FRI          SAT          SUN
  scouting --> game   -->   practice    -->  call    -->  40-second
  report       plan +       the              sheet +      calls
               script       situations       bands
  Ch 23        Ch 24        Ch 26, 27        Ch 25        Ch 25
    ^                                                       |
    |_________ next Monday: grade every call twice ________|
                    (result and process, Ch 28)

📊 Diagram (described): Five stages of an in-season week run left to right. Monday is the scouting report (Chapter 23). Tuesday is the game plan and opening script (Chapter 24). Wednesday through Friday the offense practices its situations, with first and second down, then third down, then red zone, two-minute, and four-minute, and the motion menu inside each (Chapters 26 and 27). Saturday is the call sheet and wristbands, and Sunday is the forty-second calls themselves (both Chapter 25). An arrow loops from Sunday back to the next Monday, labeled "grade every call twice, result and process," which is Chapter 28's job.

The chapters

Ch Title The question it answers
23 The Scouting Report: Film Study, Tendency Analysis, and Knowing the Enemy What do they do, what can't they do, and what do they do when we do X?
24 Building the Game Plan: The 15-Play Script, Run/Pass Mix, and Designing an Attack What will they leave, and is my guy better than theirs there?
25 Play Calling: Art, Science, and the 40-Second Decision Under Pressure Which bet is best right now, with what I know at 34 seconds?
26 Situational Football: Third Down, Red Zone, Two-Minute What is each result worth on this snap?
27 Motion and Shifts: Pre-Snap Movement to Diagnose, Mismatch, and Gain Advantage What job is this motion doing, and what did the defense just tell me?
28 Analytics and Offensive Decision-Making When should the numbers override my gut, and when shouldn't they?

The four anchors in Part IV

Anchor C, the third-and-seven decision, lives in Chapter 25. It's Game 3, the opening drive of the third quarter, third-and-7 at our 41, down 10–7. Two earlier games of film, a sack in the same situation in Game 2, Teo's page, and Vance's numbers against pressure all go into one call. Chapter 25 lays out at least three defensible calls before it tells you which one we made and why every rusher Sacramento sent had a name. Chapters 26 and 28 come back to it as a third-down problem and a pricing problem.

The same chapters hold the other side of that game. Ninety minutes later we called the same concept from almost the same picture, with no branch for a safety rotation, and it was intercepted. Part IV doesn't hide that. It shows you where in the week the mistake was made.

Anchor A's scouting origin is the hook of Chapter 23. It's a Friday night when Teo noticed that Jordan Ames triggered downhill on 14 of 18 zone flows, and that the four exceptions told us what he'd do after he got burned. Anchor D's series card is in Chapter 24, and Chapter 25 grades it as an investment rather than as four separate calls. Anchor B's cornerback count, seventeen of twenty-one, was built with the same method Chapter 23 teaches.

Your Playbook Project in Part IV

Up to now your playbook has described your offense. Part IV turns it against an opponent, the Sacramento Sentinels, whose scouting packet is in Appendix G. Every deliverable here is built for that game.

Ch Deliverable
23 Scouting Template + Sentinels Defensive Tendency Report
24 Game Plan v1 + 15-Play Opening Script against the Sentinels
25 Call Sheet v1 + Play-Caller's Pregame Checklist
26 Situational Package: third down (short, medium, long), red zone, two-minute, four-minute
27 Motion & Shift Menu: diagnostic motions and mismatch motions, with what each tells you
28 Offensive Metrics Dashboard + Fourth-Down / Two-Point Decision Chart

By the end of Part IV you'll have everything you need to call a game against Russ Kimbrough's defense except the experience of calling one. Chapter 39 puts it all together.

Before you start

  1. A defense has shown two-high on a situation twenty-nine straight times. What should your plan do with that number, and what shouldn't it do?
  2. Why would a coordinator script his first fifteen plays to learn rather than to score?
  3. Your third-down call failed. Name two questions you'd ask before deciding it was a bad call.
  4. A receiver motions across the formation and nobody follows him. What do you know now, and what don't you know?
  5. On fourth-and-1 near midfield, who in your building should make the decision, and who should make the call?

If you only read one chapter in this part

Read Chapter 25. Learning to judge a call by its process instead of its result will change how you watch every game for the rest of your life.

Chapters in This Part